South Africa in Australia 2012-13

Harris pushes Robin Peterson's Test case

Firdose Moonda

November 17, 2012

Comments: 18 | Text size: A | A

Robin Peterson finished with superb figures of 4-1-15-2, Pakistan v South Africa, World Twenty 20 2012, Super Eights, Colombo, September 28, 2012
Robin Peterson has largely been used a limited-overs player in recent years © Getty Images
Enlarge
Related Links
Players/Officials: Paul Harris | Imran Tahir | Robin Peterson
Series/Tournaments: South Africa tour of Australia

A frontline spinner is likely be included in South Africa's starting XI for the second Test against Australia next week after the dalliance with an all-pace attack proved unsuccessful in Brisbane. While Imran Tahir is the obvious choice, being the incumbent, former Test player Paul Harris had some other advice for the national selectors.

Speaking to ESPNcricinfo before the series, Harris said he would "love to see Robin Peterson get a go in Test cricket". Peterson may always be remembered as the man Brian Lara took 28 runs off in a single over at the Wanderers in 2003, still the most expensive over in Test history, but he has made massive strides since then.

While Peterson has only played six Tests, his last more than four years ago against Bangladesh, he has become and ODI and T20 regular. He was South Africa's top wicket-taker at the 2011 World Cup and was preferred to Johan Botha in the home series which followed that summer. Botha has since relocated to Australia, which has created more opportunity for Peterson, and he has made the most of it. He also finished the August one-day series in England with the most scalps and has been involved in the past three touring Test squads.

"He has always been a good bowler and has had a chance to show that now," Harris said. "What I've been impressed with is the way he flights the ball, he is not scared at all." Having a more permanent place in the side is something that has helped Peterson shed the fear, according to both Peterson himself and Harris. "It's a massive thing to know you are backed," Harris said. And he would know.

Harris played 37 Tests for South Africa between 2007 and 2011, during which he was often criticised from the outside but praised from within for his ability to dry up an end. He formed an important part of South Africa's building to the No.1 ranking and was part of the squads that won in England and Australia in 2008. During Harris' time, South Africa did not lose a series on the road and although he was not given much credit for that run, he did have something to do with it.

"I knew I had a job to do and a lot of the time my job was to hold up an end," he said. "With the attack we had at the time, it wasn't part of my role to be attacking. And maybe it would have been nice at time to be able to be more aggressive and take wickets but that wasn't the strategy then and I was happy with that."

Harris thinks Peterson is in a position where he may be able to do both. "Robbie has got the ability to take wickets and we've seen that but he is also capable of doing the holding role," he said. "That is an important job too, even if it's not very glamorous."

The South African attack's inability to keep Ed Cowan, Michael Clarke and Michael Hussey quiet during the Brisbane Test was proof that a so-called boring bowler is not surplus to requirements. Debutant Rory Kleinveldt and Graeme Smith both admitted that the unit did not bowl well "in partnerships," and even where one bowler strung a few quiet periods together, the others could not back him up.

Tahir could easily fall into that category too and has been expensive in the past. Harris believes the selectors should take note of Peterson's ability to be miserly. Peterson is also a competent lower-middle order batsman and, with South Africa having lost JP Duminy, may fit better into Andrew Hudson's preferred "like-for-like replacement" category than Dean Elgar, a top-order batsman who joined the squad yesterday.

Harris said it would also be novel to see both Peterson and Tahir in the same XI, as South Africa's attitude to spin has changed enough to accommodate two. Spin went from being a defensive must-have to a genuine attacking option when Tahir made his debut in November last against Australia. Tahir has played 10 Tests since, although his return has been a modest 26 wickets at an average of 40.19, but much has been invested in him.

Not since Paul Adams has South Africa had a wrist-spinner. Both captain Graeme Smith and coach Gary Kirsten have said they are excited by the option Tahir provides and have suggested they will continue to back him in future. So far, they have reneged on that twice, both times for tactical reasons.

An all-pace attack was fielded in Wellington in March this year when Jacques Kallis had a stiff neck overnight and South Africa had to make last-minute adjustments to their XI. In that match, Duminy made his comeback and bowled 10 overs and was due to perform a similar role in Brisbane. If Harris has his way, Peterson could take over in the near future.

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

RSS Feeds: Firdose Moonda

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by TommytuckerSaffa on (November 19, 2012, 17:28 GMT)

I have to agree with JamesTHEwalldravid. SA selectors really dropped the ball by not playing Tahir in the First Test instead going for the OLD South Africa way of 4 front line seamers. Kleinveld was the worst bowling debutant ive seen and incredibly unfit - embarrasing. As a Saffa fan through and through, I have watched so many games (more in the past) where we played with this defensive outlook on Test cricket and I hated it. We have recently turned the corner and Tahir offers us that attacking variation. Lets not take a step backward and move forward. We just got a draw against Oz in Oz with 10 men and a brilliant clarke batting performance - that is an achievement in itself. Lets get the bowling combinations and diciplines right and go for the kill !!! Bring on Test 2.

Posted by Unomaas on (November 19, 2012, 5:15 GMT)

@JamesTHEwalldravid - very much agree with you. This is not a debate of Peterson vs Tahir. This is a debate about the Saffa team as a whole. Tahir represents the new attacking SA that I so much want us to be. Peterson and Harris represent the old safe, boring SA. There is nothing wrong with the old safe SA if you are happy with the status quo but I want this team to aspire to greatness hence we need to have an attacking mindset.

@Proteas-13thman - that is a strong team. I suppose that strong emphasis would have to be placed on Robbie P's batting skills to make the tail wag. I would endorse that team for the sub-continent. I would first have to see Faf in action as a part time spinner before we could make judgement on fielding 3 spinners? And I do agree, Rudolph is proving surplus to requirement.

Posted by Meety on (November 19, 2012, 3:22 GMT)

@Proteas-13thman - that would be a team I would consider IF your mob lost the Gabba Test. I think the comfort zone would require 4 specialist bowlers + Kallis. So the question is Tahir or Peterson. In Oz - leg spin is historically the more effective. Oz have had 4 of the greatest spinners of all time & they were all Leggies (Warne, MacGill, Grimmett & O'Reilly), yet our best offies & you'd have to go to players like May, Mallet & Yardley (hell Nathan Lyon is not far off our best offie ever based on stats)! Ultimately though, I think Smith would be more comfortable with Peterson & I mean that purely on tactical reasons.

Posted by satish619chandar on (November 19, 2012, 2:48 GMT)

Can bat a bit too. Why not have Tahir as the main spinner and Robbie at 7? The no.7 slot now is a choice between Robbie, Faf and Tsolekile in my preference order. Somewhere down, i feel they might have done waway with Albie there in the squad.

Posted by   on (November 18, 2012, 20:01 GMT)

If tahir is not in Pak team that means he is not of international standard....South Africa are making a huge mistake with tahir, they should concentrate on their strength.

Posted by   on (November 18, 2012, 16:33 GMT)

Dear SA Cricket Fans,, I am a Srilankan and really interested in current "Momentum One Day Cup" serious. And also i love to Cricket South Africa too. I believe giving some chance to left-arm spinner " AM Phangiso" would be strengthen the SA Balling attack.

Posted by Spelele on (November 18, 2012, 13:35 GMT)

@Proteas-13thman, I totally agree with that line-up, especially considering the Adelaide pitch. Bring the 2nd test on!

Posted by JamesTHEwalldravid on (November 18, 2012, 10:21 GMT)

After reading all of these comments it is clear that South Africa do not deserve an attacking legspinner such as Tahir. In fact they do not deserve to be number 1 anymore. I have supported them and their rise to number 1 in the world, but now all I see is a very defensive and scared team, who just want to play safe and never take any risks. The Saffers of old have returned, filled with talent and potential, but lacking the killer instinct (excuse the term) to push on and dominate. South Africa were lucky enough to find a good legspinner, who although still has a lot to prove offered them a chance not just to change their team composition, but also their mindset. Alas it seems that will not happen. I started this series excited and fully supporting the Saffers and now I'm wondering if I should support the aussies instead. At least as Clarke showed in the last test that they try to play positively and go for the win. AB as Keeper is also defensive btw. Why do you need 7 specialist bats?

Posted by   on (November 17, 2012, 19:33 GMT)

If Tahir is not going to take wickets and going to be expensive, might as well throw the ball to Peterson - at least if he doesn't take wickets he will dry up an end. And he BATS! Elgar is a good replacement, but Faf deserves his chance (there's your leggie option should one be needed).

Posted by cricfan17 on (November 17, 2012, 18:33 GMT)

I have always been a Robbie Peterson fan. He has really developed as a cricketer especially with the bat, which is what I think really sets him apart from Tahir. I wish I could have seen the two of them in warm ups to know who was more dangerous on pace-welcome Aussie pitches. The quota argument posed by Shongololo below is erroneous. Cricket in SA is developing to a point where the quotas don't play a massive role anymore, particularly with bowlers. Botha's stint with S. Australia now is not helping any re-selection hopes. On Dean Elgar, he isn't a good choice either. In England he was a mediocre all-rounder at best. Kleinveldt was not mentally prepared for Test cricket. They should have started him against a weaker team to build confidence. In my opinion, Tsolekile should replace Rudolph giving AB a rest, Kleinveldt out for Peterson/Tahir (that's a given), and since they seem heartset, Elgar in for Duminy. Phangiso should be groomed 4 national selection with an ODI callup.

Posted by Proteas-13thman on (November 17, 2012, 16:27 GMT)

LOL~!! If the selectors are smart this would be the team : Smith , Peitersen , Amla , Kallis , AB devilliers(keeper) , Faf du plessis , Robin Petersen , Philander , Steyn, Morkel and Imran Tahir. Thats gives us 4 main strike bowlers , 6 batsmen and 3 part time bowlers (Kallis , Robin petersen and FAF)

That's one hell of a strong side~!! It is time to drop rudolf for youth and time to give the inform petersen a second chance due to the unfortunate incident that duminy got injured. AND NEVER EVER SELECT THAT IDIOT KLIENVELD AGAIN...

I would love to read other opinions?

Posted by IPSY on (November 17, 2012, 15:32 GMT)

Robin is just as good a left arm bowler as anyone around now. His only problem is that he is not getting the chance to prove himself in the purest form of the game. I don't think his little encounter against Lara should be bothering him now. The Gt Brian Lara is second only to the Gt Don Bradman as far as batting is concerned. I am sure that every bowler who encountered him had one or two of those night mare moments against him. What should even make Robin not to feel in anyway belittled by that record, when he looks at the record books, he would see that the most runs in an over is only one of the many records that Lara holds. In fact, as far as the different types of batting records are concerned, he holds more records than any including Don Bradman. And those which he does not still hold in retirement (except for the best ave) he held them all before he retired. He also needed one more 100 to hold the the record for the most 100s but like Bradman that didn't stop him from quitting.

Posted by SurlyCynic on (November 17, 2012, 13:36 GMT)

I agree with Seether in that Petersen has improved over the years and is a decent player, probably more of a one day player though. But I doubt any sensible selector would drop Morkel given that he's often been the most dangerous bowler this year. If I was going to complain about 'transformation selections' I'd probably be more likely to query whether Kleinveldt is really a better bowler than Morris (although I would probably choose Parnell ahead of both for left arm variation) or whether Tsolekile is really a better keeping option than Kuhn / Vilas / De Kock.

Posted by Toxicbite on (November 17, 2012, 11:48 GMT)

@Seether, couldn't agree with you more.

Posted by Seether1 on (November 17, 2012, 8:35 GMT)

@Shongololo: Your argument actually holds no water whatsoever! Both Botha and Peterson have almost identical test records. So there is no way that you can say Botha is a better bet at Test level. Peterson has improved a lot over the last 2-3 years, so if the selectors feel he deserves a run, then why not? All this talk of window dressing and "transformation selections" are nonsense. If that was the case they would have dropped a clearly inept Rudolph a long time ago in favour of a player of colour. Morne Morkel would have been dropped for his erratic performances in favour of someone like Tsotsobe. Please, the next time you comment, at least do the bare minimum research.

Posted by TommytuckerSaffa on (November 17, 2012, 7:05 GMT)

No thanks. Tahir offers far more 'mystery' being a leg spinner than an average offspinner. Aussies will easily be able to attack Petersen.

Posted by Shongololo on (November 17, 2012, 5:48 GMT)

I've been wonderign for a while now when this article would flow from Firdose's pen as it's right in her gendre. And here it is, in typical fashion. The truth - backed by Test stats - is that Robin Peterson is, at very best, an okay limited overs cricketer where batsmen, in chazsing quick runs, inevitably offer chances. He is nowhere near Test standard - another Kleinveldt - and Johan Botha, treated so poorly by Cricket SA that he now plies his trade with South Australia, is and always has been a far better option than Robin Peterson. The turth is, Peterson is the epitome of a quota selection in the Test squad. He makes people like you and the politicians feel good that their crude skin-colour-count suggests 'transformation' when it's little more than social engineering. No, Robin Peterson is SA Test cricket's crash test dummy, perennial summer tourist. Never good enough to be there on merit but ideal for the window-dressers.

Posted by Meety on (November 17, 2012, 4:07 GMT)

It will be interesting. Before the tour started - the Saffa management were full of bravado about how they have a new attacking mindset & Tahir was a part of the new Saffaland. One Test in, & they are increasingly likely to go with the defensive Peterson. I would NOT be surprised if they went him over Tahir. Peterson's batting ability will be what will probably sway them over Tahir - which would follow a historic trend with Saffa management in cricket. When in doubt (over selecting a bowler) - pick the better batsmen!

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Firdose MoondaClose
Tour Results
Australia v South Africa at Perth - Nov 30-Dec 3, 2012
South Africa won by 309 runs
Australia v South Africa at Adelaide - Nov 22-26, 2012
Match drawn
Australia v South Africa at Brisbane - Nov 9-13, 2012
Match drawn
Australia A v Sth Africans at Sydney - Nov 2-4, 2012
Match drawn
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days