South Africa in Australia 2012-13 November 11, 2012

Elgar named Duminy's replacement

10

Dean Elgar, the Knights' left-hander who has played five ODIs for South Africa, has been called up to replace JP Duminy in the Test squad. Duminy was ruled out of cricket for six months with a ruptured Achilles' tendon and while Faf du Plessis remains the favourite to take his place in the starting XI, Elgar has been called a "like-for-like replacement."

Although a top-order batsman rather than a lower middle-order one, Elgar also bowls left-arm spin and could be seen to offer the same part-time bowling option as Duminy. Du Plessis, though, bowls legspin and is regarded as next in line, given his inclusion as replacement batsman over the last two tours.

Elgar, a former South Africa Under-19 captain, made his case for a place in the national squad soon after debuting in first-class cricket. In 2006-07, he averaged 55.06 and scored 881 runs in the first-class competition. But two lean patches followed and he only really caught the eye again two seasons later. Elgar's 2009-10 summer resulted in 1193 runs at an average of 62.78 and 2010-11 one saw him score 816 runs at 54.49.

With a reputation for being able to play all around the wicket, a strong square cut and proven form, he was named captain of South Africa's Invitation side to play Sri Lanka in December last year. Elgar top scored with 78. Although always seen as a longer format player, he was named in the squad to play in the ODIs against them later in the tour. He tore knee ligaments on the eve of the series and was ruled out of most of the remainder of the season but continued to feature in South Africa's plans.

Elgar played in the A series against Sri Lanka A in June, where he scored 177 in South Africa's innings victory. He also travelled to Ireland in August to shadow the men's senior side in England and made his debut in the ODIs. Although he did not score a single half-century, scores of 15, 42, 35 and 1 were enough to have national convenor of selector Andrew Hudson labelling it a "good debut series."

Elgar will only travel to Australia once his visa requirements have been processed but with the second Test 11 days away that is not a worry. He will play for the Knights in their domestic one-day cup match on Sunday.

While Elgar will celebrate his maiden call-up to the Test squad, some of the other players in contention may be aggrieved at being overlooked, especially as there are lower-order players who could be in line. Justin Ontong is the closest as an exact replacement for Duminy. He was the top-scoring middle-order batsman last season. In nine matches, he scored 658 runs at an average of 59.81, with two hundreds and four fifties.

Ashwell Prince may not have fancied sitting on the bench but would have been keen on a recall. Since he was dropped after the Boxing Day Test against Sri Lanka in Durban last December, he has done well for Lancashire and started this season with 213 runs in three matches for the Warriors. He remains a nationally contracted player and Hudson said at the time of Prince's exit that he would remain in their thoughts.

Colin Ingram was another candidate. He fell out of favour after the ODI series against Sri Lanka in January but has been churning out the runs at franchise level. His 270 runs in three matches this season have come at an average of 54.00.

None of that has any bearing on the current Test squad, with Elgar due to arrive in Australia soon.

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on November 12, 2012, 21:27 GMT

    I would have voted for Quinton de Kock as a keeper-batsman and let AB play exclusively as a batsman.

  • bonobo on November 11, 2012, 23:01 GMT

    I think if Mckenzie played again, it would be for Rudolph. It is a cliche, but although I dont think Du Plessis, is anything like a test batsmen, he is worth 20 in the field. I was sat behind him at a Test in England in the summer, really it was brilliant. If South Africa have the luxury of a Top 5 keeper, and can carry him at 7, then I think he is definately worth it.

  • suraj71 on November 11, 2012, 18:11 GMT

    i was wishing to see Neil McKenzie for one last time but unfortunately thats not happening :(

  • Lighttrap on November 11, 2012, 17:20 GMT

    @MWaqqar I think that based on the fact that Elgar is replacing Duminy invalidates your statement.

  • InsideHedge on November 11, 2012, 16:38 GMT

    Dean Elgar is a very lucky man indeed.

    It's not just Rudolph who'll be sweating but Imran Tahir too. I'd get that Phangiso in quickly, he looks the real deal. Just looked up the Lions' latest match, and he was amongst the wickets again. I know these are limited overs games but he was very impressive against world class batters in the recent Champions League T20s.

  • Robster1 on November 11, 2012, 15:08 GMT

    If Ingram keeps scoring heavily he must be the next line.

  • MWaqqar on November 11, 2012, 14:18 GMT

    @ Buckers410 cant you understand people like Heino Kuhn are at a disadvantage in SA. No wonder so many SA born cricketers are seeking future elsewhere.

  • djdrastic on November 11, 2012, 11:16 GMT

    Lower middle order does not suit Deans style . He is a nr 3 or 4 , with a style similar to Justin Langer. Riley Russouw , Faf or Ingram are better picks so far down the order. Rudolph needs to start sweating , as there are young pups out there that want his place in the team.

  • on November 11, 2012, 7:53 GMT

    Its perfect time to try out a new keeper batsman.

  • Buckers410 on November 11, 2012, 7:51 GMT

    Why was Heino Kuhn not considered as Mark Boucher's replacement in test cricket. Good FC record and looks a tidy wk

  • on November 12, 2012, 21:27 GMT

    I would have voted for Quinton de Kock as a keeper-batsman and let AB play exclusively as a batsman.

  • bonobo on November 11, 2012, 23:01 GMT

    I think if Mckenzie played again, it would be for Rudolph. It is a cliche, but although I dont think Du Plessis, is anything like a test batsmen, he is worth 20 in the field. I was sat behind him at a Test in England in the summer, really it was brilliant. If South Africa have the luxury of a Top 5 keeper, and can carry him at 7, then I think he is definately worth it.

  • suraj71 on November 11, 2012, 18:11 GMT

    i was wishing to see Neil McKenzie for one last time but unfortunately thats not happening :(

  • Lighttrap on November 11, 2012, 17:20 GMT

    @MWaqqar I think that based on the fact that Elgar is replacing Duminy invalidates your statement.

  • InsideHedge on November 11, 2012, 16:38 GMT

    Dean Elgar is a very lucky man indeed.

    It's not just Rudolph who'll be sweating but Imran Tahir too. I'd get that Phangiso in quickly, he looks the real deal. Just looked up the Lions' latest match, and he was amongst the wickets again. I know these are limited overs games but he was very impressive against world class batters in the recent Champions League T20s.

  • Robster1 on November 11, 2012, 15:08 GMT

    If Ingram keeps scoring heavily he must be the next line.

  • MWaqqar on November 11, 2012, 14:18 GMT

    @ Buckers410 cant you understand people like Heino Kuhn are at a disadvantage in SA. No wonder so many SA born cricketers are seeking future elsewhere.

  • djdrastic on November 11, 2012, 11:16 GMT

    Lower middle order does not suit Deans style . He is a nr 3 or 4 , with a style similar to Justin Langer. Riley Russouw , Faf or Ingram are better picks so far down the order. Rudolph needs to start sweating , as there are young pups out there that want his place in the team.

  • on November 11, 2012, 7:53 GMT

    Its perfect time to try out a new keeper batsman.

  • Buckers410 on November 11, 2012, 7:51 GMT

    Why was Heino Kuhn not considered as Mark Boucher's replacement in test cricket. Good FC record and looks a tidy wk

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Buckers410 on November 11, 2012, 7:51 GMT

    Why was Heino Kuhn not considered as Mark Boucher's replacement in test cricket. Good FC record and looks a tidy wk

  • on November 11, 2012, 7:53 GMT

    Its perfect time to try out a new keeper batsman.

  • djdrastic on November 11, 2012, 11:16 GMT

    Lower middle order does not suit Deans style . He is a nr 3 or 4 , with a style similar to Justin Langer. Riley Russouw , Faf or Ingram are better picks so far down the order. Rudolph needs to start sweating , as there are young pups out there that want his place in the team.

  • MWaqqar on November 11, 2012, 14:18 GMT

    @ Buckers410 cant you understand people like Heino Kuhn are at a disadvantage in SA. No wonder so many SA born cricketers are seeking future elsewhere.

  • Robster1 on November 11, 2012, 15:08 GMT

    If Ingram keeps scoring heavily he must be the next line.

  • InsideHedge on November 11, 2012, 16:38 GMT

    Dean Elgar is a very lucky man indeed.

    It's not just Rudolph who'll be sweating but Imran Tahir too. I'd get that Phangiso in quickly, he looks the real deal. Just looked up the Lions' latest match, and he was amongst the wickets again. I know these are limited overs games but he was very impressive against world class batters in the recent Champions League T20s.

  • Lighttrap on November 11, 2012, 17:20 GMT

    @MWaqqar I think that based on the fact that Elgar is replacing Duminy invalidates your statement.

  • suraj71 on November 11, 2012, 18:11 GMT

    i was wishing to see Neil McKenzie for one last time but unfortunately thats not happening :(

  • bonobo on November 11, 2012, 23:01 GMT

    I think if Mckenzie played again, it would be for Rudolph. It is a cliche, but although I dont think Du Plessis, is anything like a test batsmen, he is worth 20 in the field. I was sat behind him at a Test in England in the summer, really it was brilliant. If South Africa have the luxury of a Top 5 keeper, and can carry him at 7, then I think he is definately worth it.

  • on November 12, 2012, 21:27 GMT

    I would have voted for Quinton de Kock as a keeper-batsman and let AB play exclusively as a batsman.