Australia news May 2, 2014

Clarke selection call a turning point - Marsh

14

Play 06:34
Brettig: Mark Waugh a well-regarded voice

Australia's new chairman of selectors Rod Marsh has pointed to Michael Clarke's resignation from the selection panel following the dire 2013 tour of India as a pivotal moment in the team's resurgence to their current perch at the top of the world rankings for Test and ODI matches.

The 2011 Argus review that helped install Marsh as part of a new panel also appointed Clarke as one of the selectors, an arrangement that became fraught as early as December of the same year when the chairman John Inverarity conceded the dual role was creating "extra difficulty" for Clarke in his interactions with the team.

By the end of the 4-0 hiding on the subcontinent a little more than a year later, Clarke decided that he needed to devote less time to selection teleconferences and more to a side that was fracturing in the absence of the retired Ricky Ponting and Michael Hussey, as exemplified by the suspension of four players in Mohali for failing to follow instructions. While Darren Lehmann's appointment to replace Mickey Arthur as coach has been commonly noted, Marsh said Clarke's call was equally significant.

"Quite a few things have occurred, but I think one of them, which seems to probably get overlooked a little is that Michael gave away his selection duties, which I think freed him up a lot to be able to interact with the team a lot more at training sessions, and off the field," Marsh said. "Michael we all know is an outstanding on the field captain, but I think his off-field captaincy has flourished since he stepped down as a selector, and you can understand that. It's very difficult for him to operate off the field when he's both captain and selector.

"That's freed him up a lot, Darren has brought a no fear feeling to the boys, he's encouraged them to go out and play with freedom and of course getting Mitchell Johnson back into the team and bowling well has just been an absolute bonus because if you remember we had very good, young fit fast bowlers a couple of years ago who've all had injuries and as a consequence it was nice to have one of the old timers, for lack of a better word, back and bowling like the wind."

Marsh spoke frankly about his selection philosophy ahead of a period in which Australia will not only seek to retain their ranking but also lift the World Cup at home in 2015 and hang onto the Ashes in England later in the year. The age of the squad is not a major concern to him, though he hopes to see more young batsmen pushing for inclusion in coming summers. Until then, however, the likes of Chris Rogers will remain verymuch a part of his plans.

"I don't think you can read too much into blokes' ages these days," Marsh said. "The game has changed so dramatically from 20 or 30 years ago whereby it's become a profession, and these guys are professionals, they work very hard on their fitness etc. They play cricket almost every day of the year and if they're not playing they're training or travelling. A 35-year-old today is certainly not like a 35-year-old 20 years ago cricket-wise, it's completely different. In an ideal world it would be nice to have a lot of young blokes in the side and we can't wait for that to happen - if you had three or four 19 or 20-year-old champion batsmen making 1500 runs in Shield cricket that would be fantastic, we would all want that.

"David Warner and Steve Smith have both held up very well over the last couple of series. Obviously Chris Rogers will not be around forever, he's like all of us getting older by the day. However the same guy has just made 241-odd not out in a run chase for 472 earlier this week [for Middlesex], so he wants to keep playing cricket for Australia, and while he's still in really good form it'd be very difficult to leave him out. We do have to plan ahead and we're just waiting for young players to step up and get a truckload of runs, that's what we need and want."

In the case of Smith, Marsh said the panel had chosen to have him concentrate on Test matches while he was still developing his game, but expected the 24-year-old to move into the team across all formats in coming months. Though Marsh did not name him as such, the tactically astute and mentally strong Smith is the man in line to become Australia's next long-term captain.

"Steve Smith is a hell of a good cricketer," Marsh said. "When we get to sit down and choose the side for the next World Cup I'd be very surprised if his name doesn't come up. He's also a very good T20 cricketer, but at the moment our policy has been he's just starting to establish himself in the Test arena, we've perhaps robbed Peter to pay Paul to a degree by saying 'well just keep him out of that for the moment. But we think Steve Smith will be a fine cricketer in all forms for Australia."

In addition to his selection duties, Marsh has also overseen the development of a unified coaching philosophy around Australia over the past two years. He reiterated his belief in the rigorous teaching of technical basics and their grounding in plenty of match-play, as no coach can help a cricketer to tweak a failing in the middle of an innings or a bowling spell.

"Within the game there are basics of technique in whatever you do. If you are taught the basics well early and learn them well, you've always got something to fall back on, because whenever you make a mistake I can promise the answer lies in the basics," he said. "The good cricketers are the ones who can correct things on the run - when they're out there in the middle you haven't got the coach to tell you to do this or that, you've got to work it out for yourself. If you've made mistakes you've got to be able to identify how to correct those mistakes on the move.

"I don't think our batting is as good as it should be for a nation of our strength. With the facilities we've got, with the coaching staff we've got in all states, with the talent we've got I don't think our batting is good enough. Technically I don't think it's good enough, and I think there's been a period where technique hasn't been taught as well as it could've been and I think we've got to get back tot he basics. All our coaching through Australia has got to get back to the basics of the game, and we don't want people to make their mark as a coach unless their mantra is first of all you teach the basics. It's the only way forward as far as I'm concerned."

Daniel Brettig is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo. @danbrettig

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on May 4, 2014, 3:41 GMT

    @Ozcricketw, While Lyon has been no great standout bowler for Australia the past 8-10 tests. He has contributed and chipped in at getting crucial wickets at important times. Okeefe is a very tight accurate spin bowler. But he doesn't offer any more ATM skill wise than what Lyon already does. If Lyon does not contribute the next few Tests the same way he has been the last 8-10. Then I believe Okeefe will get his chance.

  • IndianInnerEdge on May 4, 2014, 1:25 GMT

    Michael Clarke surely is the best captain going around nowadays, he does come across as a good tactician and his awareness of the game is just about the best nwadays. Aus always had a strong FC structure to produce the cricketers to progres to the next level. But the telling factor is the comeback of Mitcheel Johnson and the complete different dimension he lends to the bowling attack. Take him out, and am not saying that OZ will loose every match they play, but am saying that it will be more evenly matched. The main factor for OZ if they are to hang on to the no 1 spot like the teams of the 90's and early 2000's will be their support bowlers, and how they come through....all in all exciting times ahead

  • Ozcricketwriter on May 3, 2014, 13:48 GMT

    This is my test XI:

    Chris Rogers, David Warner, Steve Smith (vc), Michael Clarke, Alex Doolan, Glenn Maxwell, Brad Haddin, James Faulkner, Steve O'Keefe, Mitchell Johnson, Ryan Harris

    It might seem harsh on Shane Watson but I think he needs some time on the sidelines. Once he comes back with some good returns, he should be the next cap off the rank, probably to replace Chris Rogers as Warner's partner opening the innings. Nathan Lyon is okay but Steve O'Keefe is much, much better and it defies belief to pick Lyon ahead of O'Keefe still. As for Faulkner coming in ahead of Siddle, in many ways it is harsh but history has shown that having both Harris and Siddle in the same lineup is surplus to requirements. If Harris is out injured, then Siddle comes in as his back up. Simple as that. Both Faulkner and Maxwell are in incredible form, too good to be ignored.

  • steve48 on May 3, 2014, 9:30 GMT

    @landl47, as an Englishman, admittedly I don't know the full details of Smith, except that he was probably introduced before he was technically ready! I was reacting to Marsh comments about his recent handling. Selecting a young, raw talent is always problematic, and I will take your word on previous mistakes made with the lad, and other young Aussie talent, again it is the sentiments in this article, and the recent work done with Smith I was praising, and contrasting with our treatment of Root and Stokes. Certainly Smith looks to be a vastly improved cricketer, and if you watch the IPL, his intelligence and commitment is outstanding now. If he could land more than 2 of his leggies on the strip per over, what a player you would have, he can certainly bowl the odd peach now, amongst the pies! Ask Ian Bell!

  • on May 3, 2014, 8:06 GMT

    Mitchell Johnson made all the difference...then the new coach...it is a massive coincidence that Aus started winning the moment Johnson was selected. Brutal pace will always win games.

  • popcorn on May 3, 2014, 6:28 GMT

    In my opinion,the turning point was John Inverarity.

  • JJJake on May 3, 2014, 3:50 GMT

    The turn around in this side since boof took over is remarkable. Batsman have scored 17 test centuries in 8 tests Bowlers have taken 20 wickets 7 times out of the past 8 tests. Superb captaincy from Clarke

  • landl47 on May 3, 2014, 3:24 GMT

    Sound thinking as always from Marsh.

    @steve48: if you think Steve Smith has been well-treated and not messed about by Australia, you haven't been paying attention.

  • xtrafalgarx on May 2, 2014, 13:18 GMT

    Yes, there are a few young batsmen around in the shield now, now for performances. The stage is set and there are opportunities galore.

  • on May 2, 2014, 11:51 GMT

    @Steve48, even more bizarre, Root is now captaining Yorkshire! Yes, he is a talent but frankly they are placing way too big of a burden on him.

  • on May 4, 2014, 3:41 GMT

    @Ozcricketw, While Lyon has been no great standout bowler for Australia the past 8-10 tests. He has contributed and chipped in at getting crucial wickets at important times. Okeefe is a very tight accurate spin bowler. But he doesn't offer any more ATM skill wise than what Lyon already does. If Lyon does not contribute the next few Tests the same way he has been the last 8-10. Then I believe Okeefe will get his chance.

  • IndianInnerEdge on May 4, 2014, 1:25 GMT

    Michael Clarke surely is the best captain going around nowadays, he does come across as a good tactician and his awareness of the game is just about the best nwadays. Aus always had a strong FC structure to produce the cricketers to progres to the next level. But the telling factor is the comeback of Mitcheel Johnson and the complete different dimension he lends to the bowling attack. Take him out, and am not saying that OZ will loose every match they play, but am saying that it will be more evenly matched. The main factor for OZ if they are to hang on to the no 1 spot like the teams of the 90's and early 2000's will be their support bowlers, and how they come through....all in all exciting times ahead

  • Ozcricketwriter on May 3, 2014, 13:48 GMT

    This is my test XI:

    Chris Rogers, David Warner, Steve Smith (vc), Michael Clarke, Alex Doolan, Glenn Maxwell, Brad Haddin, James Faulkner, Steve O'Keefe, Mitchell Johnson, Ryan Harris

    It might seem harsh on Shane Watson but I think he needs some time on the sidelines. Once he comes back with some good returns, he should be the next cap off the rank, probably to replace Chris Rogers as Warner's partner opening the innings. Nathan Lyon is okay but Steve O'Keefe is much, much better and it defies belief to pick Lyon ahead of O'Keefe still. As for Faulkner coming in ahead of Siddle, in many ways it is harsh but history has shown that having both Harris and Siddle in the same lineup is surplus to requirements. If Harris is out injured, then Siddle comes in as his back up. Simple as that. Both Faulkner and Maxwell are in incredible form, too good to be ignored.

  • steve48 on May 3, 2014, 9:30 GMT

    @landl47, as an Englishman, admittedly I don't know the full details of Smith, except that he was probably introduced before he was technically ready! I was reacting to Marsh comments about his recent handling. Selecting a young, raw talent is always problematic, and I will take your word on previous mistakes made with the lad, and other young Aussie talent, again it is the sentiments in this article, and the recent work done with Smith I was praising, and contrasting with our treatment of Root and Stokes. Certainly Smith looks to be a vastly improved cricketer, and if you watch the IPL, his intelligence and commitment is outstanding now. If he could land more than 2 of his leggies on the strip per over, what a player you would have, he can certainly bowl the odd peach now, amongst the pies! Ask Ian Bell!

  • on May 3, 2014, 8:06 GMT

    Mitchell Johnson made all the difference...then the new coach...it is a massive coincidence that Aus started winning the moment Johnson was selected. Brutal pace will always win games.

  • popcorn on May 3, 2014, 6:28 GMT

    In my opinion,the turning point was John Inverarity.

  • JJJake on May 3, 2014, 3:50 GMT

    The turn around in this side since boof took over is remarkable. Batsman have scored 17 test centuries in 8 tests Bowlers have taken 20 wickets 7 times out of the past 8 tests. Superb captaincy from Clarke

  • landl47 on May 3, 2014, 3:24 GMT

    Sound thinking as always from Marsh.

    @steve48: if you think Steve Smith has been well-treated and not messed about by Australia, you haven't been paying attention.

  • xtrafalgarx on May 2, 2014, 13:18 GMT

    Yes, there are a few young batsmen around in the shield now, now for performances. The stage is set and there are opportunities galore.

  • on May 2, 2014, 11:51 GMT

    @Steve48, even more bizarre, Root is now captaining Yorkshire! Yes, he is a talent but frankly they are placing way too big of a burden on him.

  • on May 2, 2014, 10:57 GMT

    Exciting times for Australian cricket! Hopefully the likes of Travis Head, Kurtis Patterson, Sam Whiteman etc. have seen what Marsh has said about young batsmen making 1000+ runs in a Shield season and really push their cases. Marsh has said all the right things, can he back them up?

  • dunger.bob on May 2, 2014, 10:50 GMT

    I'm not sure what it is, but Marshy makes me feel as though everythings going to be all right. There's something soothing about having a hard bitten old pro like him in charge of selections. I liked everything he had to say. He said what I've been feeling for a long time. We need a few young batsmen to put their hats in the ring. The bowling is pretty strong with lots of young blokes putting pressure on the likes of Siddle and even Harris but the batting is a different story. .. Now is the time for one or two of the whelps to stand up and make a name for themselves. There hasn't been a better opportunity in years.

    @steve48 : The last few months from your guys have been bizarre frankly. The ECB seems to be hell bent on cutting it's own toes off for some reason. Don't worry though, we've been known to do similar things in times of stress. They'll settle down eventually and get back to the business of building a good cricket team. At least I assume that's what will happen.

  • Big-Dog on May 2, 2014, 8:24 GMT

    As long as Marsh dumps the rotation policy he will do ok. I'm not so sure about Waugh. I suspect we will be seeing a lot more fringe NSW players in the test squad.

  • steve48 on May 2, 2014, 8:21 GMT

    Great stuff from Marsh, just contrast it with ECB and England management at the moment. I have long believed that selection should never be with the skipper, because of the reasons Marsh describes, but I would rather focus here on our treatment of Root and Stokes compared to the Australian handling of Smith. Both should have been rested and invested in following our traumatic ashes campaign, as key players to our future, not yet fully developed. Instead they are prematurely made key players across all 3 formats, then because they are not yet ready, shifted about in their roles. Result, for different reasons end up at home with broken hands! Memo to Downtown et al, PLEASE read this interview. As for Cook , he needs MORE help to develop his captaincy, not fewer senior players and influential staff. We now have a captain with a lot to learn coached by 2 guys with no international playing experience, and either little or failed coaching pedigree at international level..

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • steve48 on May 2, 2014, 8:21 GMT

    Great stuff from Marsh, just contrast it with ECB and England management at the moment. I have long believed that selection should never be with the skipper, because of the reasons Marsh describes, but I would rather focus here on our treatment of Root and Stokes compared to the Australian handling of Smith. Both should have been rested and invested in following our traumatic ashes campaign, as key players to our future, not yet fully developed. Instead they are prematurely made key players across all 3 formats, then because they are not yet ready, shifted about in their roles. Result, for different reasons end up at home with broken hands! Memo to Downtown et al, PLEASE read this interview. As for Cook , he needs MORE help to develop his captaincy, not fewer senior players and influential staff. We now have a captain with a lot to learn coached by 2 guys with no international playing experience, and either little or failed coaching pedigree at international level..

  • Big-Dog on May 2, 2014, 8:24 GMT

    As long as Marsh dumps the rotation policy he will do ok. I'm not so sure about Waugh. I suspect we will be seeing a lot more fringe NSW players in the test squad.

  • dunger.bob on May 2, 2014, 10:50 GMT

    I'm not sure what it is, but Marshy makes me feel as though everythings going to be all right. There's something soothing about having a hard bitten old pro like him in charge of selections. I liked everything he had to say. He said what I've been feeling for a long time. We need a few young batsmen to put their hats in the ring. The bowling is pretty strong with lots of young blokes putting pressure on the likes of Siddle and even Harris but the batting is a different story. .. Now is the time for one or two of the whelps to stand up and make a name for themselves. There hasn't been a better opportunity in years.

    @steve48 : The last few months from your guys have been bizarre frankly. The ECB seems to be hell bent on cutting it's own toes off for some reason. Don't worry though, we've been known to do similar things in times of stress. They'll settle down eventually and get back to the business of building a good cricket team. At least I assume that's what will happen.

  • on May 2, 2014, 10:57 GMT

    Exciting times for Australian cricket! Hopefully the likes of Travis Head, Kurtis Patterson, Sam Whiteman etc. have seen what Marsh has said about young batsmen making 1000+ runs in a Shield season and really push their cases. Marsh has said all the right things, can he back them up?

  • on May 2, 2014, 11:51 GMT

    @Steve48, even more bizarre, Root is now captaining Yorkshire! Yes, he is a talent but frankly they are placing way too big of a burden on him.

  • xtrafalgarx on May 2, 2014, 13:18 GMT

    Yes, there are a few young batsmen around in the shield now, now for performances. The stage is set and there are opportunities galore.

  • landl47 on May 3, 2014, 3:24 GMT

    Sound thinking as always from Marsh.

    @steve48: if you think Steve Smith has been well-treated and not messed about by Australia, you haven't been paying attention.

  • JJJake on May 3, 2014, 3:50 GMT

    The turn around in this side since boof took over is remarkable. Batsman have scored 17 test centuries in 8 tests Bowlers have taken 20 wickets 7 times out of the past 8 tests. Superb captaincy from Clarke

  • popcorn on May 3, 2014, 6:28 GMT

    In my opinion,the turning point was John Inverarity.

  • on May 3, 2014, 8:06 GMT

    Mitchell Johnson made all the difference...then the new coach...it is a massive coincidence that Aus started winning the moment Johnson was selected. Brutal pace will always win games.