Bangladesh v New Zealand, 2nd Test, Mirpur, 1st day October 21, 2013

Tamim fails to learn his lessons

Tamim Iqbal, Mominul Haque and Shakib Al Hasan were happy to play away from their body whenever the bowlers offered any width, and it proved their undoing
20

There is usually a predictable winner in the battle between a left-hand batsman playing with an angled bat and a fielding captain persisting with attacking fields behind point. Despite the number of runs Bangladesh scored in that region on the first day of the second Test, the New Zealand captain Brendon McCullum came out on top.

Tamim Iqbal, Mominul Haque and Shakib Al Hasan were happy to play away from their body whenever the bowlers offered width. Nearly half of Tamim's 17 boundaries came between the wicketkeeper and point. Three of Mominul's eight boundaries, and all three of Shakib's fours came in that region.

When the ball was too short outside off stump from New Zealand's three left-arm quicks, they were deservedly punished. When it was fuller but still wide, Mominul's used his wrists to send the ball to the boundary. And even when it was much fuller, Tamim wasn't letting scoring opportunities go. The ball would hit the edge and find its way through the slips.

During this period, McCullum moved his slip fielders around: sometimes four were standing close together, sometimes they were spread wider, and at others there was only a slip and a gully. There was a yawning gap between the wicketkeeper and gully at times too, while McCullum dabbled with pairs of gullys, short covers and short midwickets.

Tamim might have been encouraged by the two lives he got early in his innings. BJ Watling and Ross Taylor let him off behind the wicket on 5 and 10. Other batsmen may have played more cautiously after those reprieves, but not Tamim. To go from 70 to 86, Tamim drove airily past point, bludgeoned a cover drive and twice edged the ball past the lone slip and gully.

It was his highest Test score since his last century in June 2010, and another ton was approaching. His first boundary in the nineties was a dab past the slip fielder, but off the next ball, McCullum finally had his man.

Tamim was cramped for room by the bustling Neil Wagner, but he had managed to squeeze the ball out by using his bat like a ramp. Kane Williamson leaped and took the catch. It was heart-breaking for Tamim, but there was no one else responsible but the batsman himself. His game is one of high stakes: survive and thrive, or fail.

Tamim's shot wasn't as bad as the one played by a well-set Mominul. Tamim had nearly got the ball past Williamson, who had to cover some distance to take the catch. Mominul, on the other hand, gifted his wicket away to Corey Anderson, who bowled a delivery that was short and wide.

Mominul is the calmest batsmen among the hot heads in the Bangladesh line-up. The best treatment for Anderson's delivery would have been to leave it alone but rather than bat his way, Mominul decided to cash in, but perished.

While it is a new lesson for Mominul, Tamim hasn't learned from several similar lessons over a Test career that has spanned nearly six years. He has managed five half-centuries in 22 innings since his 108 in Manchester in 2010. Against West Indies in 2011, it was a slog sweep on 52 and a wild charge on 83 that led to his dismissals. Against the same team the following year, it was an absurd pull to mid-on. Against Sri Lanka earlier this year, Tamim tried to chop a length ball that was not there to be cut. On most of those occasions, his dismissal hindered Bangladesh's progress.

Playing it his way has been Tamim's mantra. He has had moderate success in international cricket so far, but his method has stopped him from scoring a Test hundred for over three years now. He has only one more Test innings in 2013. For someone like Mominul, Tamim's stunted growth in Test cricket should be a strong message not to take anything for granted. Be it talent or a wide, short ball way outside off stump.

Mohammad Isam is ESPNcricinfo's Bangladesh correspondent. He tweets here

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on October 21, 2013, 20:05 GMT

    You know Tamim's stats suggest that his that he is a better test batsmen than ODI batsmen. In 29 test matches, he's made 2056 runs, with an average of 36.71 and a strike rate of 60.22 4 centuries 12 half centuries. In 122 ODI matches, hes made 3639 runs, with an average of 30.07 and a strike rate of 78.61 4 centuries 24 half centuries. I know its hard to compare between different format, but Tamim's stats do seem partial to Tests and admittedly those are some decent stats for a test Batsmen.

  • asiacricket1234 on October 21, 2013, 16:11 GMT

    Its same old story for Tamim. He has been doing this since our England tour. He always throw his wicket away. He is considered as one of our main batsman so the expectation from him is that he'll take responsibility but he never does it and it seems he doesn't care either. Some people may say that he scored 95 today so he has done alright but we should also consider that he had two lives today and a good batsman will make the most of it but Tamim failed to Utilize it and this is not the first time. He needs to grow up & be responsible. His crazy fans will keep him as one of the best in Bangladesh but with this temperament and irresponsible attitude on field he is not going to achieve anything great. he will end his career as mediocre player if he doesn't change.

  • Bang_La on October 22, 2013, 5:48 GMT

    Absolutely correct title.

  • Joamiq on October 22, 2013, 4:58 GMT

    Frankly focusing on the century itself is missing the point, and perhaps compounding the problem. Had he reached 100, I would have bet a large sum on him falling without reaching 110. Bangladesh batsmen are too focused on these milestones - hence such a disproportionate number of them falling between 40-60 and 90-110. Even on his double century, Mushfiq reached 200 and promptly fell without scoring another run. Fans and analysts often jest when this happens, but really it says a lot about the Bangladeshi batsmen's mentality, and partially explains their inconsistency. A batman's approach may have to change based on the situation, but it should be about the overall situation of the game, not one's individual figures. Tamim, and many other players in the side, lack this perspective.

  • ReverseSweepIndia on October 22, 2013, 4:11 GMT

    this comes to attitude & temperament I think. Tamim is a brilliant batsman. But in international cricket no run is easy. Bowlers comes hard at you, no matter what the surface is. And most of the times they will try to get you early, doesn't matter that you are a Cook, a Dravid, a Chandrapal or Amla or Ponting, Kallis and many alike. But what makes them different is, once you are out of initial phase of your inning, make it count. If you see youngster like Root or Pujara, being an Indian he is where I find solace, he has long way to go, same is true for Root , but fact is once these guys dig in, dig in deep and they score big 100s or doubles. No, surface does not matter, that matter only for ur initial slug of say first 50 balls. Whether you are playing in Mirpur, Perth or Lords, once you get your eye in, make it count. Thats what Tamim seems to be missing. And this time around he don't even have any excuse of carrying the team on his shoulders, I c good batters around him in BD team

  • on October 22, 2013, 3:24 GMT

    The key to Bangladesh's recent success in test cricket is they have found more batsman with sound technique who can score quickly but they are yet to find players with test cricket mentality except Mushfiq

  • regofpicton on October 22, 2013, 1:11 GMT

    Something like 2000 cricket tests have been played so far, and no previous skipper has felt the need to carry on in the field like McCullum has in this game. He is obviously hoping to get very very lucky, and for his stupidity then to be mistaken for genius.

    And for heavens sake, can SOMEONE organise some slip catching practice, which should focus on not dropping catches meant for someone else. The performance of this team, and especially its "captain" is become worse than any mere joke.

  • on October 21, 2013, 21:42 GMT

    I think Tamim was simply trying to reach his 100 after a long time (3 years). He is gifted and has the tenacity to work on his weaknesses. I guess instead of technique heneedsto work on endurance, stamina and fitness so that he can concentrate for 3-4 sessions instead of tiring out or losing it after 150 balls. Only then will we see him converting 50s to 100s and 200s like Shewag,Lara or Ponting. His technique is good enough its just endurance that he needs to put a hell of an effort in if he wants to reach greatness.

  • TheRisingTeam on October 21, 2013, 21:30 GMT

    Tamim needs to watch how Alastair Cook bats. Cook is an opener and this guy is averaging more than 10 runs than Tamim's career average in both ODIs and Tests. Why? because Cook uses his brain and knows how to approach an innings. Tamim at the moment cannot do that.

  • corzaNZ on October 21, 2013, 21:04 GMT

    Man Bangladesh fans are a bit harsh on Tamim. The difference of 5 runs if he got to that century. I bet the comments would be a lot different. Theres not much praise of what an awesome innings it was, yeah he gave a couple of chances early but he definitely made us pay for those drops catches. From a NZer well done Tamim, that was a great attacking innings, and the harsh comments should not be directed at him it should be towards the other batsmen who got starts and got out. Marshall, Mominul and Shakib for making what could of been Bangladesh's day more even or slightly in favor of NZ. Lets hope the rain stays away for what is going to be an important first session on day 2

  • on October 21, 2013, 20:05 GMT

    You know Tamim's stats suggest that his that he is a better test batsmen than ODI batsmen. In 29 test matches, he's made 2056 runs, with an average of 36.71 and a strike rate of 60.22 4 centuries 12 half centuries. In 122 ODI matches, hes made 3639 runs, with an average of 30.07 and a strike rate of 78.61 4 centuries 24 half centuries. I know its hard to compare between different format, but Tamim's stats do seem partial to Tests and admittedly those are some decent stats for a test Batsmen.

  • asiacricket1234 on October 21, 2013, 16:11 GMT

    Its same old story for Tamim. He has been doing this since our England tour. He always throw his wicket away. He is considered as one of our main batsman so the expectation from him is that he'll take responsibility but he never does it and it seems he doesn't care either. Some people may say that he scored 95 today so he has done alright but we should also consider that he had two lives today and a good batsman will make the most of it but Tamim failed to Utilize it and this is not the first time. He needs to grow up & be responsible. His crazy fans will keep him as one of the best in Bangladesh but with this temperament and irresponsible attitude on field he is not going to achieve anything great. he will end his career as mediocre player if he doesn't change.

  • Bang_La on October 22, 2013, 5:48 GMT

    Absolutely correct title.

  • Joamiq on October 22, 2013, 4:58 GMT

    Frankly focusing on the century itself is missing the point, and perhaps compounding the problem. Had he reached 100, I would have bet a large sum on him falling without reaching 110. Bangladesh batsmen are too focused on these milestones - hence such a disproportionate number of them falling between 40-60 and 90-110. Even on his double century, Mushfiq reached 200 and promptly fell without scoring another run. Fans and analysts often jest when this happens, but really it says a lot about the Bangladeshi batsmen's mentality, and partially explains their inconsistency. A batman's approach may have to change based on the situation, but it should be about the overall situation of the game, not one's individual figures. Tamim, and many other players in the side, lack this perspective.

  • ReverseSweepIndia on October 22, 2013, 4:11 GMT

    this comes to attitude & temperament I think. Tamim is a brilliant batsman. But in international cricket no run is easy. Bowlers comes hard at you, no matter what the surface is. And most of the times they will try to get you early, doesn't matter that you are a Cook, a Dravid, a Chandrapal or Amla or Ponting, Kallis and many alike. But what makes them different is, once you are out of initial phase of your inning, make it count. If you see youngster like Root or Pujara, being an Indian he is where I find solace, he has long way to go, same is true for Root , but fact is once these guys dig in, dig in deep and they score big 100s or doubles. No, surface does not matter, that matter only for ur initial slug of say first 50 balls. Whether you are playing in Mirpur, Perth or Lords, once you get your eye in, make it count. Thats what Tamim seems to be missing. And this time around he don't even have any excuse of carrying the team on his shoulders, I c good batters around him in BD team

  • on October 22, 2013, 3:24 GMT

    The key to Bangladesh's recent success in test cricket is they have found more batsman with sound technique who can score quickly but they are yet to find players with test cricket mentality except Mushfiq

  • regofpicton on October 22, 2013, 1:11 GMT

    Something like 2000 cricket tests have been played so far, and no previous skipper has felt the need to carry on in the field like McCullum has in this game. He is obviously hoping to get very very lucky, and for his stupidity then to be mistaken for genius.

    And for heavens sake, can SOMEONE organise some slip catching practice, which should focus on not dropping catches meant for someone else. The performance of this team, and especially its "captain" is become worse than any mere joke.

  • on October 21, 2013, 21:42 GMT

    I think Tamim was simply trying to reach his 100 after a long time (3 years). He is gifted and has the tenacity to work on his weaknesses. I guess instead of technique heneedsto work on endurance, stamina and fitness so that he can concentrate for 3-4 sessions instead of tiring out or losing it after 150 balls. Only then will we see him converting 50s to 100s and 200s like Shewag,Lara or Ponting. His technique is good enough its just endurance that he needs to put a hell of an effort in if he wants to reach greatness.

  • TheRisingTeam on October 21, 2013, 21:30 GMT

    Tamim needs to watch how Alastair Cook bats. Cook is an opener and this guy is averaging more than 10 runs than Tamim's career average in both ODIs and Tests. Why? because Cook uses his brain and knows how to approach an innings. Tamim at the moment cannot do that.

  • corzaNZ on October 21, 2013, 21:04 GMT

    Man Bangladesh fans are a bit harsh on Tamim. The difference of 5 runs if he got to that century. I bet the comments would be a lot different. Theres not much praise of what an awesome innings it was, yeah he gave a couple of chances early but he definitely made us pay for those drops catches. From a NZer well done Tamim, that was a great attacking innings, and the harsh comments should not be directed at him it should be towards the other batsmen who got starts and got out. Marshall, Mominul and Shakib for making what could of been Bangladesh's day more even or slightly in favor of NZ. Lets hope the rain stays away for what is going to be an important first session on day 2

  • SyedAreYouDumb on October 21, 2013, 20:35 GMT

    His scores are undermining his immense talent, like shakib and Ashraful they all should have had more centuries. Looks like the new boys Mominul and Marshall Ayub look good to get more centuries. However if Nasir was to play in the top order he would get plenty of centuries as he is a guy you would expect to get a huge score since he is very reliable.

  • AzAb12754 on October 21, 2013, 20:02 GMT

    Good batsman scores 50s but the top ones scores 100s and sadly our team don't have any world class batsman. Too early to say for Mominul, Nasir and Anamul but hopefully one day.

  • on October 21, 2013, 19:34 GMT

    Frankly, Tamim is their best player regardless of this. Bangladesh need to respect this and appreciate what they have. Since when have they had another opener capable of taking the attack to the opposition and averaging nearly 40?

  • on October 21, 2013, 18:50 GMT

    Bangladesh need a rock. They should not be thinking along the lines of sparkling 50s. A Trott, a Kalliss, a Chanderpaul. This is what they need. Given the nature of the tracks in Bangla, it should be easy to produce batsmen who can bat for 5 sessions if necessary.

  • on October 21, 2013, 18:31 GMT

    whats the problem you guys i don't know. Tamim get 95 this is a fantastic achievement. We have played a few test in a year only 4/5 test where as others played more than 10 test in a year that not enough for cricketer. I think we have to get chance to play more test in a calendar year. Then a player can continue his form and learn from mistake of his recent match.

  • on October 21, 2013, 18:31 GMT

    I agree with Shariar. Tamim is seriously lacking in common sense. He has little regard for his team and goes about his merry way at will. These days Bangladesh's final score rarely rests on his and Sakib's performance. Thank Allah that we have groomed others who can get the job done. Tamim knows his place in the team is safe. There isn't any serious challenger for his place and so he can afford to be so cavalier. His score though high was too full of chances. He could be out before reaching double figures. Mr. Tamim, don't forget, India has done away with the great Sehwag and your record is no where near Sehwag's. One never knows what new star tomorrow might bring.

  • Captainman on October 21, 2013, 17:23 GMT

    Don't forget both Tamim and Shakib strike rates in tests is also high. Both have strike rates of 60 runs per 100 balls whereas the best batsman today that usually scores 100 have strike rates well below 50 in tests. If Tamim can take it easy for a bit and take the cautious approach then he can score numerous 100. But like the article says "Tamim just doesn't learn".

    Tamim needs to understand that he's playing for Bangladesh not England and he's vital in the Bangladesh team.

  • TigerRoars on October 21, 2013, 17:05 GMT

    It will be a pleasant surprise if Tamim learns any lesson from this. He has not shown a tendency in the past. I hope Mominul is an exception in this regard.

  • TheRisingTeam on October 21, 2013, 16:41 GMT

    I don't know what to say. Clearly Bangladesh batsman have the worst temperament of all test playing nations. Tamim and Shakib have now played 30 or more tests and still they cannot score many 100s. Tamim has 13 test 50s but only 4 of them into 100s. Shakib conversion rate is even worse currently has 14 test 50s but only a mere 2 have been converted into 3 figures and that's just unacceptable considering the amount of experience they have in their International careers. No wonder either of them are not averaging in the 40s yet which is basically the benchmark for good test batsman. I feel bad for the good crowd that came up today because they enjoyed Tamim's stroke-play today and wanted him to get to his 100 but Tamim let them down. I really hope he does justice to his talent and prove everyone wrong.

  • on October 21, 2013, 16:10 GMT

    To succeed you need skills. one. who does not have the common sense makes the same mistake again and again

  • on October 21, 2013, 16:10 GMT

    To succeed you need skills. one. who does not have the common sense makes the same mistake again and again

  • TheRisingTeam on October 21, 2013, 16:41 GMT

    I don't know what to say. Clearly Bangladesh batsman have the worst temperament of all test playing nations. Tamim and Shakib have now played 30 or more tests and still they cannot score many 100s. Tamim has 13 test 50s but only 4 of them into 100s. Shakib conversion rate is even worse currently has 14 test 50s but only a mere 2 have been converted into 3 figures and that's just unacceptable considering the amount of experience they have in their International careers. No wonder either of them are not averaging in the 40s yet which is basically the benchmark for good test batsman. I feel bad for the good crowd that came up today because they enjoyed Tamim's stroke-play today and wanted him to get to his 100 but Tamim let them down. I really hope he does justice to his talent and prove everyone wrong.

  • TigerRoars on October 21, 2013, 17:05 GMT

    It will be a pleasant surprise if Tamim learns any lesson from this. He has not shown a tendency in the past. I hope Mominul is an exception in this regard.

  • Captainman on October 21, 2013, 17:23 GMT

    Don't forget both Tamim and Shakib strike rates in tests is also high. Both have strike rates of 60 runs per 100 balls whereas the best batsman today that usually scores 100 have strike rates well below 50 in tests. If Tamim can take it easy for a bit and take the cautious approach then he can score numerous 100. But like the article says "Tamim just doesn't learn".

    Tamim needs to understand that he's playing for Bangladesh not England and he's vital in the Bangladesh team.

  • on October 21, 2013, 18:31 GMT

    I agree with Shariar. Tamim is seriously lacking in common sense. He has little regard for his team and goes about his merry way at will. These days Bangladesh's final score rarely rests on his and Sakib's performance. Thank Allah that we have groomed others who can get the job done. Tamim knows his place in the team is safe. There isn't any serious challenger for his place and so he can afford to be so cavalier. His score though high was too full of chances. He could be out before reaching double figures. Mr. Tamim, don't forget, India has done away with the great Sehwag and your record is no where near Sehwag's. One never knows what new star tomorrow might bring.

  • on October 21, 2013, 18:31 GMT

    whats the problem you guys i don't know. Tamim get 95 this is a fantastic achievement. We have played a few test in a year only 4/5 test where as others played more than 10 test in a year that not enough for cricketer. I think we have to get chance to play more test in a calendar year. Then a player can continue his form and learn from mistake of his recent match.

  • on October 21, 2013, 18:50 GMT

    Bangladesh need a rock. They should not be thinking along the lines of sparkling 50s. A Trott, a Kalliss, a Chanderpaul. This is what they need. Given the nature of the tracks in Bangla, it should be easy to produce batsmen who can bat for 5 sessions if necessary.

  • on October 21, 2013, 19:34 GMT

    Frankly, Tamim is their best player regardless of this. Bangladesh need to respect this and appreciate what they have. Since when have they had another opener capable of taking the attack to the opposition and averaging nearly 40?

  • AzAb12754 on October 21, 2013, 20:02 GMT

    Good batsman scores 50s but the top ones scores 100s and sadly our team don't have any world class batsman. Too early to say for Mominul, Nasir and Anamul but hopefully one day.

  • SyedAreYouDumb on October 21, 2013, 20:35 GMT

    His scores are undermining his immense talent, like shakib and Ashraful they all should have had more centuries. Looks like the new boys Mominul and Marshall Ayub look good to get more centuries. However if Nasir was to play in the top order he would get plenty of centuries as he is a guy you would expect to get a huge score since he is very reliable.