The experts review the action

Katich has worked out his game

A tremendous batting display by both Katich and Ponting, on a day when England looked a bit flat on the field (04:41)

July 9, 2009

View comments (3)


England v Australia, 1st Test, Cardiff, 2nd day

Katich has worked out his game

July 9, 2009

Ian Chappell: "Apart from that period when Flintoff got them going, he bowled a terrific spell straight after lunch, England looked pretty flat." © Getty Images

Andrew Miller: On the second day of the first Ashes Test, the bat dominated and in particular Australia's second pairing of Simon Kaitch and Ricky Ponting. Ian, they have taken Australia to a strong position?

Ian Chappell: Very good position, it was excellent batting. Ricky Ponting, I thought, started very positively, played aggressively. Katich did what he always does. He is a classic batsman who knows his game and sticks to those rules. And as he went on, he got more positive and started to score a bit more quickly.

I think Australia achieved their objective of grinding the England bowlers into the turf. It was a very good effort, because there is enough turn there in the pitch. If England had got a break through, there would have been a new batsman in and they might have got a double breakthrough. So I thought it was a tremendous partnership between Ponting and Katich.

AM: Well, Katich has had a tough time in the Ashes series, 2001 and 2005, both were traumatic series for him. But he has started this one as if he means to really make a mark this time.

IC: I think he is much more confident and relaxed player now than he was before. He has had some down periods, got left out of the team and actually felt that he would never get back into the team. I was reading the other day, and he said that from now on every game is a bonus. And I think, because he is thinking that way he is much more relaxed. I think he has perhaps sorted out couple of things in his batting as well. He scored a pile of runs playing first-class cricket for New South Wales, and that has obviously done a lot for his confidence.

I think the most important thing with Simon Katich is that he has worked out his game, and that's what he sticks to. He doesn't try and go out of those boundaries and that suits him very well.

AM: As for Ponting, everyone knows how crucial his form is for Australia, particularly at this time when they have a really young and changing side. What did you make of his performance today?

IC: Well, I think because Ricky works so hard on his captaincy and sorting out the young and inexperienced guys, he probably took an edge off his own batting in South Africa. But I think he has probably worked that out as a captain, and realised that he has to contribute more as a captain because he doesn't have all those experienced players around him. But, he can't do that so much that it detracts from his batting. So I think he has worked out the balance and he looked really positive today from ball one, he looks good and that is good news for Australia.

AM: What do we make of England's bowling? I mean they went in with two spinners, there have been signs that it is going to turn, but it looks pretty slow turn so far.

IC: It does look slow. Couple of times when both [Monty] Panesar and [Graeme] Swann have bowled a good delivery, the batsmen had to hurry their shot a little bit but they just had enough time to make the adjustment that they had to make.

I though that James Anderson got bit carried away with [Phil] Hughes. I think he fell into that trap of bowling to Hughes' weakness than bowling to his own strength. To me Anderson's great strength is not banging the ball into the pitch, his strength is to bowl it on the good length with a little bit of swing and bowl an occasional bouncer to push the batsman back. So he fell into that trap a bit. Really, apart from that period when [Andrew] Flintoff got them going, he bowled a terrific spell straight after lunch, they looked pretty flat.

I think Andrew Strauss also has to work out on his field placing a bit. At times when nothing much is happening, your fallback position is to stop them from scoring singles and rotating the strike regularly and just see if you can make something happen that way. I think he needs to work on placing a field that will keep the batsman on strike for a while.

AM: And prospects for the next three days of the game, there was a lot of talk about the Cardiff pitch, but it looks like that they have prepared a pitch that is going to go five days?

IC: I don't think there is any problem with the pitch going five days. The game is moving along at pretty good speed at the moment. So I would think that a result is well and truly possible unless we get some interruptions with weather.

Posted by onics on (July 10, 2009, 9:27 GMT)

I personally feel that the match is still balanced. As days go the pitch will turn more. On the second day Australia ended with 249/1 trailing by 186 runs. if swann and panesar get some turn as expected, then England can get a lead of about 50 runs. I think England needs ponting and katich before lunch. if England can get a good lead i would go with the English. Whereas if Australia can bat up to day 4 just after lunch certainly i would go with the Aussies. I think it all depends on the 3rd innings. if England can cross 350 then England can will win this test match.if Australia can bowl out England below 200 then Aussies will win. To get England all out before 200 i think huaritz , Clarke,katich,north play an important role. if they can get some turn it could cause real problems to England. I conclude that this test match is a result.

Posted by dsig3 on (July 10, 2009, 8:02 GMT)

I always find it strange why no-one turns up to watch test matches in India when such thrilling tactics are on display. People from Aus and Eng actually support their test sides and enjoy watching cricket. When Aus and Eng want to destroy all interest in the ashes we will let the indian coaching staff know.

Posted by aditya87 on (July 9, 2009, 20:20 GMT)

In light of the position England are in this Test match, the English coaching staff and think tank would do well to look at the recent India v Australia Test match at Nagpur -- because India won that Test match from a similar position as England are now, and finished a 2-0 drubbing of the Aussies.

India had scored 400-odd in their first innings, and Australia had raced to 189-2 at the end of the second day's play. Katich and Hussey were the men batting overnight. On Day 3, MS Dhoni cleverly decided to employ an 8-1 offside field and had his bowlers aim well outside off stump (although not so much that they would be wided) for the first session-and-a-half. Result: the Aussie momentum was stopped dead in its tracks, the batsmen frustrating themselves out before the Indian spinners ate the rest of the Aussie order up on a similar flat wicket as is this one. India gained a vital first innings lead and went on to win the game convincingly.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Play Video
Moonda: It was an intense chase for SA

Oct 21, 2014 ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent Firdose Moonda talks about South Africa's victory against New Zealand in the first ODI (02:13)

Play Video
Agarkar: West Indies just didn't turn up

Oct 17, 2014 Ajit Agarkar reviews the fourth ODI between India and West Indies in Dharamsala, played in the backdrop of the WICB cancelling the ongoing tour (05:26)

Play Video
Amla ton seals New Zealand's fate

Video Report: ESPNCricinfo's Alexis Nunes reports on the second ODI between New Zealand and South Africa, in Mount Maunganui. (01:20) | Oct 24, 2014

Play Video
Moonda: Amla read conditions perfectly

Video Report: Firdose Moonda says New Zealand allowed the match to slip away by dropping Hashim Amla twice, and they need to sort out their top-order problems to come back in the series (02:11) | Oct 24, 2014

Play Video
'A near perfect performance' - de Villiers

Press Conference: AB de Villers and Hashim Amla were both happy with the improvements shown by South Africa after they secured the ODI series against New Zealand (03:38) | Oct 24, 2014