A talk show on English cricket

Should England make changes ahead of Melbourne?

Will England stick with Finn and Colly? Plus, Tendulkar breaks more records and takes the spotlight off a second-rate Indian performance (40:03)

December 22, 2010

View comments (3)
Posted by dibble on (December 23, 2010, 1:23 GMT)

I think England should stick with the same personnel. Australia won't play as well at MCG - the pitch won't be as bouncy. Also the pressure is back on them as the team supposedly with momentum and they are basically fragile - especially at the top order of their batting. So England just need to remember Adelaide. As an Englishman, I'm banking on Swann coming good at some point and Collingwood coming back with a fighting knock. I would move Bell up to 5. Every great team must have a b 'blip' to realize what they must do to get back on top.

Posted by   on (December 22, 2010, 23:36 GMT)

England's attack looks tired and Finn would be my fall guy. I would pick Ajmal Shahzad as he gives the attack a more aggressive look in the absence of Broad. Colly is a gutsy batter and arguably England's best fielder, but has looked woefully out of touch - Morgan deserves his chance and he is a left hander which changes the dynamic of the middle order. We could always play 5 bowlers and pick Finn or Bresnan - and ask the batters to stand up and be counted. Test matches are won by bowlers after all - the batters decide by how much.

Posted by slartibartfast on (December 22, 2010, 14:00 GMT)

Yes, of course. They should drop Finn, the highest wicket in the team. Poor english players. One loss and suddenly chop and change galore. With nary a rationale.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Play Audio
England's Spaghetti Bolognese

Jul 22, 2014 Dan Norcross is joined by Hoppsy, Gnasher, Butch and George to discuss the future of English cricket after the debacle at Lord's (45:46)

Play Audio
Fever Pitch

Jul 16, 2014 JHB is joined by Jarrod, Butch, George and Arya to discuss English pitches, Anderson and Root's partnership and Dhoni's conservative tactics. (34:38)

Play Video
Cricket Brain 2014: Charlie Dagnall

Features: Charlie 'Daggers' Dagnall is the latest contestant to take on the Cricket Brain challenge. Can the Test Match Special commentator challenge Key and Shantry at the top of the table? (03:26) | Jul 31, 2014

Play Video
'Series is a test of character' - Dhoni

Press Conference: MS Dhoni admitted there were lots of areas for improvement and believes that the next two Tests against England will be a good test of India's character (01:27) | Jul 31, 2014

Play Video
Chappell: Ashwin should be brought in for Jadeja

Match Point: Ian Chappell feels that MS Dhoni's negative tactics led to India's undoing in the third Investec Test at Ageas Bowl (01:56) | Jul 31, 2014