The experts review the action

'The collapse cost India'

Sanjay Manjrekar, speaking to Sharda Ugra, says India played really well, but for the astonishing collapse in the batting Powerplay and at the end of their innings (02:55)

March 12, 2011

Posted by niceguy1977 on (March 13, 2011, 7:35 GMT)

There is nothing new in thier collapse, when tendulkar and gambhir started playing such an defensive game clearly it let SA to come on top. Also one of the worst tail india do have. in the middle order dhoni is out of form for the last 15 innings scoring just 311 runs out of 501 balls and he looks like not going to score at all, kohli is unable to score coming late down the order, Yuvi is just coming to form, so out of Indians 7 batsmen theory only 4 or 5 is performing leaving indians both a batsmen short and a bowler short

Posted by KrishRavi on (March 13, 2011, 6:29 GMT)

Dear Sanjay

From what has happened so far in the tournament - India as yet do not seem to have the 4 bowlers necessary to win the World Cup with the seven batsmen theory . And where do we find them now . We might find a 3rd in R Ashwin ? if that happens - then perforce a 2 medium fast and 2 spinner bowling option may be needed with the kind of bowling we have . Never has P Kumar absence been felt so much . India are yet to qualify for the q finals and if ENG Beat WI , Bang BEAT SA and NETH , and WI beat India - we may lose out on a qf spot .

Ravi Krishnan

Posted by   on (March 12, 2011, 22:22 GMT)

Collapse was one of the reasons for loss but the last over by Nehra was not the right choice by captain Dhoni I think Bhajji would have been much better choice but Dhoni has his own way of thinking which worked for a while but he is running out of luck and his choices of players are not good anymore , Someone got to tell him to stop experimenting and favoring certain players and play the game with the deserving squad next time

Comments have now been closed for this article

Play Video
Arnold: An awesome victory for Sri Lanka

Jun 24, 2014 Russel Arnold speaks to Andrew Fernando at the end of a pulsating Test match at Headingley to review the significance of the Sri Lanka series victory in England. (06:05)

Play Video
Arnold: Sri Lanka have shown a lot of heart

Jun 23, 2014 Russel Arnold assesses Sri Lanka's performance over the opening three days at Headingley and says there is much they can be proud of (05:41)

Play Video
Wonderful working with Muralitharan - Lyon

Press Conference: Nathan Lyon talks about training with Muttiah Muralitharan and on the upcoming Test between India A and Australia A (02:34) | Jul 11, 2014

Play Video
#politeenquiries: Is India's last-wicket partnership more humiliating than the Ashes?

Features: Jarrod Kimber and George Dobell are joined by special guest Rahul Dravid to answer your tweets at the end of the second day of the first Test between England and India. (05:38) | Jul 10, 2014

Play Video
'We've got to bat big' - Broad

Press Conference: Stuart Broad said that England will need to bat big in their first innings against India at Trent Bridge but has confidence in his team-mates after bowling on a slow wicket for two days (02:15) | Jul 10, 2014