The experts review the action

'West Indies don't know how to win'

Ian Bishop, speaking to Sharda Ugra, says that India weren't quite at their best and the West Indies were worse (04:38)

March 20, 2011

Posted by   on (March 20, 2011, 22:50 GMT)

Windies were strategic. They must think that they have a better chance of getting to the semi-finals against Pakistan than a wounded Australia. I honestly hoped they would not have won.

Posted by Nampally on (March 20, 2011, 18:48 GMT)

WI should have played Chanderpal instead of Thomas. Chander is a good reliable bat who can keep one end going, albeit his strike rate is not high. In the next game 2 changes are needed. Chanderpal for Thomas and Gayle for Edwards. If WI bat well with determination, they have the potential to beat Pakistan. Disciplined batting is lacking in the team which is causing their failure.Gayle, Smith 3. Sammy 4. Bravo 5. Pollard 6. Sarwan 7. Chanderpal 8. Russel will provide a strong line up. But they must stay and not throw away their wkts. Good Luck in Q/F.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Play Video
Butcher: Batting with freedom helps India

Sep 2, 2014 Mark Butcher dissects India's batsmen after the visitors took the ODI series with a nine-wicket win in Edgbaston (04:15)

Play Video
Butcher: England's attitude to ODIs wrong

Sep 2, 2014 Mark Butcher analyses England's problems in ODIs after the team surrendered meekly by nine wickets against India in Edgbaston (03:51)

Play Video
'Marsh demolished us' - du Plessis

Press Conference: Following their loss to Australia in the tri-series match, Faf du Plessis said South Africa had bowled well but the game was taken away by Mitchell Marsh's belligerent fifty (05:48) | Sep 3, 2014

Play Video
'Gave myself a chance on that wicket' - Mitchell Marsh

Press Conference: Following his 51-ball 86, which helped set up Australia's win over South Africa, Mitchell Marsh said the team played with the right attitude and were eager to compete against South Africa (03:57) | Sep 3, 2014

Play Video
Raina dazzles in the field at Edgbaston

Highlights: Suresh Raina showed his value with his catching and throwing prowess, taking two sharp catches and firing a direct hit at the stumps to run out Chris Woakes in India's nine-wicket win in the 4th ODI at Edgbaston (01:20) | Sep 3, 2014