A fortnightly talk show hosted by one of India's most popular cricket commentators

'Dhoni made the difference for India'

Harsha Bhogle, Sanjay Manjrekar and Ian Chappell discuss India's World Cup triumph, its implications for Indian cricket and what went wrong for some of the other teams (46:04)

Producers: Siddhartha Talya and Ranjit Shinde

April 6, 2011

Posted by   on (April 8, 2011, 5:25 GMT)

Dear Harsha/Sanjay/Chap.. you touched almost all the teams who came to knockout.. but forgot to mention newzeland.. it would have been nice if there are ffew words for newzeland too.. overall it was good.

Posted by Jayar84 on (April 7, 2011, 13:25 GMT)

This is one of the best Commentary post world cup. Thanks to Espn cricinfo

Posted by TheUparcut on (April 7, 2011, 6:09 GMT)

There were mainly three weaknesses for Indian cricket right from the dat India started playing the game-1.Fast bowling 2.Lack of all-rounders 3.Fielding.It is good that we are improving on our fielding.But fast bowling and producing all-rounders is still something we are lacking in.It is high time that we filtered the fast bowlers and give the best opportunity to the most deserving one which would in deed help in raising the bar and would see an improvement in quality,something similar to what Australia did.The Indian cap should me made difficult to get.That is what Australia did.Most of the debutants were aged 25+.They had enough of first class experience and were good enough to stay for a long while at international level and they turned out to be great stars.Something similar needs to be implemented soon.

Posted by   on (April 6, 2011, 15:58 GMT)

spot on captain cool.....the best captain India has ever produced ....

Posted by cric_mk on (April 6, 2011, 9:34 GMT)

Writing about Sourav Ganguly - probably the most ill-treated cricketer in the history of cricket, Arjuna Ranatunga once said Indians do not know how to respect their real heroes. Unfortunately that's the bare truth! Now after winning the WC all the media beating drums for Sachin and Dhoni in their headlines and conveniently sidelined the real-performer Yuvi!!

Posted by   on (April 6, 2011, 7:34 GMT)

he always has been an influential leader........

Posted by xylo on (April 6, 2011, 5:32 GMT)

On the South African fiasco, my personal opinion is this: When you have very good bowlers, play only 4 of them. I personally feel that when you play five of them, the captain sends a message to each one of them that he does not trust them to finish the job for him. Especially when considering the fact that each of their opponents played 3-4 bowlers. To play Steyn/Morkel/Botha/Peterson/Tahir versus say India's Zaheer/Munaf/Nehra/Harbhajan, the South African class was so superior, yet the sum of the parts was lesser.

Posted by xylo on (April 6, 2011, 5:27 GMT)

I would love to see cricketers in a televised match, and not cine stars/politicians. You know, I tuned into ESPN/Star Cricket, not Star Gold or DD Parliament. I would love to see the reaction of Anil Kumble when Dhoni hit the winning runs, not Aamir Khan/Preity Zinta/Sonia Gandhi. Also, I would really like you cricket experts begin talking about post-World Cup Sachin's future. How should he phase himself out so that his replacement gets enough exposure to be ready for WC 2015. Would he have to be nudged out like Kapil Dev? Or, would he sign off like Saurav Ganguly not letting his emotions get the better of him?

Comments have now been closed for this article


Play Audio
'Australia will kill to be in India's situation'

Mar 29, 2013 Harsha Bhogle, Ian Chappell, and Sharda Ugra look into the implications of India's 4-0 defeat of Australia (37:39)

Play Audio
'Australia's batting order is in a mess'

Mar 12, 2013 Harsha Bhogle, Ian Chappell, and Tom Moody discuss the mid-to-long-term concerns for Australia, some of which have appeared glaringly in the defeats against India (29:32)


Play Video
'Expunge from records if found guilty' - Chopra

News and Analysis: Former India international, IPL player, and current first-class batsman Aakash Chopra discusses his views on the IPL spot-fixing scandal with Jayaditya Gupta and Nitin Sundar (27:53) | May 20, 2013

Play Video
Opening spell as good as I have ever seen - Cook

Press Conference: England captain Alastair Cook talks to the media after his team beat New Zealand in the first Test at Lord's (01:40) | May 19, 2013

Play Video
'One hour of madness the difference' - McCullum

Press Conference: New Zealand captain Brendon McCullum talks to the media after his team's loss to England in the first Test at Lord's (01:04) | May 19, 2013