A talk show on English cricket

'A serious shortage of nous'

England fail on the subcontinent again as India complete a spinning whitewash in the ODIs. Is it time for wholesale changes? Plus the latest on Pakistan v Sri Lanka, South Africa v Australia and the spot-fixing trial (56:59)

Producer: Tom Kingham

October 27, 2011

Posted by   on (October 29, 2011, 5:18 GMT)

Why not accept that England is nowhere near the side that was made out to be by you guys (the English media)? When India was no 1 for nearly 2 years, it was 'pretty competitive at the top' with 'no clear leader'. Once England got to the top spot (it's been a grand two months now) they become the 'successors to Steve Waugh/Ricky Ponting's Australian teams'!! Also, why say India is strong in India rather than saying England is strong only in England. While India has always been competitive in England (barring this one series) England have almost always been abysmal in ODIs in India. Hence 5-0 in an ODI series in India is pretty routine stuff while the 4-0 trouncing in England was an upset. Hoping this gets published...

Posted by couchpundit on (October 28, 2011, 13:43 GMT)

Gven that a second string of indian team was selected and how full strength English ODI team failed has lots to say about the difference in the team.

LOL @ Andrew Miller...

Posted by 12kris on (October 28, 2011, 10:59 GMT)

It was a whitewash alright. But calling it a 'spinning whitewash' is far from correct as the pacers took 45% of the wickets that fell to the bowlers!

Posted by   on (October 28, 2011, 10:23 GMT)

The title seems to suggest that "nous" is synonymous with "talent". England cannot bowl quality spin or play quality spin on spinning pitches. That is a fact. Swann's type of bowling suits wickets in England/SA/Australia. His style is easily nullified by the ease with which Indian's play spin.

Posted by dr.jha on (October 27, 2011, 17:07 GMT)

guys... just a correction... cricket is NOT the NATIONAL SPORT in india its HOCKEY.. none the less..its the unofficial one for sure

Comments have now been closed for this article


Play Audio
A book that would never have a happy ending

Oct 9, 2014 Mark Butcher, George Dobell and Andrew McGlashan join JHB to discuss the fallout from KP's autobiography (36:38)

Play Audio
Catches, Moeen, and more

Sep 30, 2014 Daniel Norcross is joined by Mark Butcher, Andrew McGlashan and George Dobell to review the 2014 English county season (50:40)


Play Video
Ronchi combats collapse with 99

Highlights: New Zealand wicketkeeper-batsman Luke Ronchi rescued New Zealand by scoring 99 from 83 balls, including a 74-run 10th-wicket stand with Trent Boult, to take his side to 230 against South Africa in the first ODI at Mount Maunganui. (01:42) | Oct 21, 2014

Play Video
Highlights: Ronchi's rearguard takes NZ to 230

Highlights: Action from the first innings of the first ODI between New Zealand and South Africa, in Mount Maunganui. (03:30) | Oct 21, 2014

Play Video
de Kock's leg-side screamer

Highlights: South Africa wicketkeeper Quinton de Kock dives to his left for a one-handed catch to dismiss New Zealand batsman Nathan McCullum during the 1st ODI in Mount Maunganui. (00:21) | Oct 21, 2014