The experts review the action

Chappell: Australia lack confidence in second spinner

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell analyses Australia's eight-wicket loss to India in the first Test in Chennai and also paves a way ahead for both teams (00:00)

Interviewer: Daniel Bretting

February 28, 2013

Posted by gregjones on (March 1, 2013, 16:29 GMT)

The problem is not about not having 'World class' spinners.One does not need to be a Shane Warne to pick wickets. Panesar was not known to be world class but he did the job required of him of winning the series in India. What more does one need from a bowler.Australia have very many such fine players who are neglected for average ones.Lyon has been given too many matches for him to become a regular in the team.He might be the only spinner in the world today who struggles to pick wickets during the fourth and fifth days of a test match which he has been achieving quite regularly in the last 6 to 7 test matches. Lyon was the main reason why Australia could not win the first 2 test matches against South Africa being the lone spinner, where he could not take wickets in the final days of both tests. If such a spinner cannot be replaced then I suppose that there might not be another spinner playing in the Australian domestic circuit.

Posted by gregjones on (March 1, 2013, 16:23 GMT)

@ Matty82A First thing is, I would never had picked Lyon in the first place to endure his average bowling which, as Geoff Boycott says, would have been played with ease by his Grand mother.That is why I said that tactics count more than machoism.Almost everybody should have known by now that Indian batters are not comfortable at all against left arm spin.The perception that Indians play spin comfortably is nonsense.Just have a look at the last series of England & India.Swann was negotiated easily in the 1st test and the Poms lost badly.Next test Panesar takes 10 wickets and England win easily and was instrumental for England winning the series.Only after Panesar's entry did Swann started bowling with confidence.If you do not have fine spinners then select the next one.No use continuing with Lyon who has no variation and hardly spins the ball.Keefe or even Doherty would have been handful on that Chennai pitch.

Posted by VivGilchrist on (March 1, 2013, 7:48 GMT)

The problem is Australia's best spinner was not selected. If he was, they would have faith in playing 2 spinners. Doherty isn't even Tasmanias best spinner, that why there's no confidence. OKeefe should be there. His bowling would be perfect for India.

Posted by Klgn on (March 1, 2013, 4:42 GMT)

Whether India goes to Australia or Australia comes to India, situation is similar for both. It's all about temperament of the team. Indian have feeling bouncy tracks, and swing story at aussie wicket, difficult conditions for Indians. Weather is also cold and breezy in auss. Other hand, Aus team feeling spin and humid, hot environment. Are you really cricketers?? Look the Army of any country going for battle in any field, how they are mentally strong with the conditions. Sometimes, thinking that if I could be the cricketer i could make a difference rather than the current ones!! You should just go and performed no matter what is the situation. Be a sportsMAN!

Posted by   on (March 1, 2013, 2:51 GMT)

Bhujo, you do realise they have a squad over in India, half the players you name arnt in the squad so how do you expect them to get selected. Smith hardly bowls so how can you pick him as your main allrounder. How you could consider hilfenhaus and mckay better bowlers then whats over there is beyond me, they could play the next 3 tests and they would be lucky to get a wicket between them.

Posted by Matty82A on (February 28, 2013, 22:53 GMT)

@gregjones, it's all well and good for you to criticise Clarke in regards to his handling of Lyon.Would you hazard to offer any suggestions as to how you would have handled the situation or who you would have selected?

The problem for Australia is that we do not have any world class spinners. In my opinion the main oversight made by the selectors was not taking Steve O'Keefe on the tour, but in saying that I am by no means suggesting that O'Keefe is a world class option.

Posted by   on (February 28, 2013, 22:08 GMT)

That Australia didnt want a 2nd spinner would definetely hurt the confidence Xavier Doherty. Remember Michael Beer was selected but he got injured, hes a fairly decent spinner.

Posted by Klgn on (February 28, 2013, 21:51 GMT)

Agree with the legend Ian Chappel,that Aussies has good chance to bounce back and win from second test. Just a few changes I am looking for, Include one more spinner, doherty or somebody. Include, George Bailey batman, Clint Mckay, Michelll Johnson,Ben Hilfenhaus,and Smith-Allrouder!! Aus is good for pace attack but still require some mix of spin, pace and medium pace, part time spinners!! Batsman should work on straight bat practice like Alasteir cook. Need to get advice from the players who already played in India whether it is IPL or other format. These players are the key in India. Australia should seek advice from great Shane Warne as he can give best advice as he knew/read the condition than any body else!!!

Posted by Hardy1 on (February 28, 2013, 19:14 GMT)

I think Gambhir will come in for Sehwag but I'd be surprised to see any other changes. I really think Ojha should come back for Harbhajan though, why he was even dropped is beyond me. Jadeja & Vijay both need to be given the entire series before judgement can be passed (even though I'm hesitant about both players to be honest) but otherwise the team is well settled.

Australia really need to bring in another spinner along with Lyon who's probably low on confidence & can't be expected to take the burden of all of the overs of spin that should be bowled in somewhere like Hyderabad. There were certainly positives, including Henriques, Clarke & Pattinson obviously but most of the Australian batsmen got starts at least so that bodes well for them.

Posted by gregjones on (February 28, 2013, 18:25 GMT)

Clarke's bravado of revealing the Aussie side 2 days before the test has fallen flat on his face. It is one thing being brave and another thing being clever in selecting your team.You see a dustbowl at Chennai and you go gloating that Aussies will not copy the English by selecting 2 spinners.If you are not going to pick 2 or 3 spinners on an obvious turner or you have no confidence in your second spinner (Anyway how can one be even 10% confident with what Lyon is bowling), then why take 4 spinners on the tour? England have proved to be more skillful and intelligent than Australia by playing to win unlike Australia who want to show to the world that they play their own brand of cricket. Whole load of rubbish!!

Comments have now been closed for this article

Play Video
Agarkar: Shami's bowling a gain for India

Sep 5, 2014 Ajit Agarkar analyses India's 41-run loss to England in the fifth ODI in Headingley and says that although the batsmen struggled, Mohammed Shami's performance could give MS Dhoni a reliable death bowler (05:49)

Play Video
Butcher: Batting with freedom helps India

Sep 2, 2014 Mark Butcher dissects India's batsmen after the visitors took the ODI series with a nine-wicket win in Edgbaston (04:15)

Play Video
Sixes, yorkers and relay catches

Highlights: Who made the number one play of the Champions League T20 so far? (01:28) | Sep 15, 2014

Play Video
Butcher: Yorkshire were streets ahead

News and Analysis: Mark Butcher looks back at Yorkshire's Championship-clinching victory and how they have dominated the tournament this year (01:26) | Sep 15, 2014

Play Video
Moonda: A strong message to the doubters

News and Analysis: Russell Domingo's contract extension is a big gesture of support from CSA to a coach who had his critics after an uneasy start to his tenure last year (01:56) | Sep 15, 2014