Middlesex v Lancashire, Division 1, Lord's, 2nd day May 12, 2014

Morgan shows signs of life

Middlesex 275 for 3 (Malan 92, Morgan 72*, Robson 51) lead Lancashire 266 (Smith 59, Buttler 59, Dexter 6-63) by nine runs
Scorecard

It has been a strange old early season for Middlesex's batsmen. Funny things can happen in April and May, but there leaps from the sublime to ridiculous are a notch above.

From the highs of 472 for 3 and 439 to the lows of 105 and being 66 for 8, it has been a case of all or almost nothing. So in many ways, reaching 275 for 3 on the second day against Lancashire was a little bit vanilla; solid, efficient, workmanlike. In all seriousness, though, it was just what they needed and a good day's work to secure a strong position in the match when rain cut off the last 10 overs.

Three half-centuries moulded Middlesex's strong reply with Eoin Morgan reaching the close unbeaten on 76 and eyeing his first Championship hundred since 2009 (he has only had three first-class hundreds since then, two of them in his Test career).

With the T20 and ODIs against Sri Lanka beginning shortly, where Morgan will feature, it may be too late for a run to the Test team at the start of the season, largely due to Gary Ballance's fine form, but very little about new England is yet set in stone.

There is also a sense that the selectors will not need to be overly persuaded to bring Morgan back into the Test side. After his nudge and a wink to skip the IPL he is earmarked as not only that 'something a little different' in the middle order but also one of few viable candidates to lead the side if the team's fortunes do not improve under Alastair Cook.

With a view to the longer format, this innings was watchful and, largely, restrained although there were two shots which summed him up as a red-ball cricketer: a thick edge through gully as he drove away from his body and a reverse sweep against Simon Kerrigan. There will always be an element of edge-of-the-seat about him, which should be applauded not nullified.

The one black mark on Morgan's innings was the involvement in the run out of Dawid Malan, eight short of what would have been his first Championship hundred since August 2012 against Warwickshire. He was caught out by Morgan's push and run into the leg side. It was always a tight call from Morgan, but Malan hesitated for a fraction of a second as well.

Malan was dropped on 34 at first slip by Paul Horton - he was diving to his right which suggested it should have been Jos Buttler's catch - but otherwise had few alarms against an honest, but limited Lancashire attack.

Perhaps Malan's dismissal was a hint of karma after he had earlier been involved in ending Robson's innings. Robson was sold down the river and beaten by a direct hit from cover, having played an innings low on standout shots but high on the watchfulness and judgement that has put him on the brink of a Test debut.

Two run-outs from three wickets to fall was careless on a day where the sun shone for the most part which so often makes batting easier here. The only Lancashire bowler to strike was Kyle Hogg when he had Chris Rogers caught down the leg side with his second ball of the Championship season. It was a neat, low catch by Buttler and though the umpires briefly conferred over whether it carried Rogers was content to walk off.

It was a curious day for Kerrigan, who was used a disappointingly stereotypical way by Glen Chapple: one over before lunch, one over before the second new ball and just five in between. There were some mitigating circumstances for Chapple - often two left handers at the crease and a short Tavern boundary - but the seamers did not gain vast amounts of help.

Young English spinners will only develop if they are allowed to bowl, and in challenging circumstances. Morgan was clearly keen to attack Kerrigan, as the reverse-swept four showed, but it is only what he will encounter if he returns to the top level.

Andrew McGlashan is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on May 14, 2014, 4:05 GMT

    Morgan is a gud player but he is not get enough support & believe from ecb

  • jackiethepen on May 13, 2014, 10:19 GMT

    It gets a bit crazy when someone is being judged as a possible Test player among others but is already considered as a possible replacement Test captain. He has to learn how to play Test cricket first, never mind captain a side. We have a current captain who has performed over 100 Tests and still is regarded as 'learning' the complicated process of five day cricket.

  • CricketingStargazer on May 13, 2014, 9:55 GMT

    I was at Lords ion Sunday and was talking to people around the team. There seems to be a feeling around the Middlesex set-up that if England do not pick him Morgan may not even end the season in the Middlesex team. Strange, but true. There is a feeling that he does not deliver enough in Championship cricket and that he place may come under real pressure.

  • zoot364 on May 13, 2014, 8:25 GMT

    I was at Lord's yesterday. Some observations on the England contenders: Robson: looks really secure on the back foot but I wonder if his slightly unusual stance hints at a vulnerability to the fuller length delivery. Buttler: the ball bounces out of his gloves too frequently to inspire confidence Morgan: perky at the crease as usual but we need to see some really long innings from him. Kerrigan: didn't see much of him but his rather apologetic run-up does make me wonder

  • hhillbumper on May 12, 2014, 20:28 GMT

    Morgan is not a test class player.Coming off once in a blue moon might make him a mythical danger player in ODI but never ever should he play test cricket.Maybe we could play one of those interesting English players.

  • Harvey on May 12, 2014, 19:20 GMT

    Every time Eoin Morgan makes a few County Championship runs for Middlesex, something that by the way doesn't happen nearly often enough for most Middlesex supporters, journalists immediately start pushing his case for an England Test recall. The truth of the matter is that despite being a quality limited overs player, he averages less than 35 in first class cricket. He isn't even a stand-out player in a middle order that is currently widely regarded as Middlesex's achilles heel, so how anyone can think he's even worthy of consideration for an England Test place is beyond me. I would love to see him go on and make a big hundred in this game, but he will need to start playing a lot better in County Championship matches than he has done so far to warrant inclusion in the Test side.

  • CodandChips on May 12, 2014, 19:12 GMT

    I wouldn't have Morgan in my team but I can certainly see England picking him, and if so, good luck to him. Robson as well continues to score though I'm not a massive fan, perhaps due to his background (despite having a British passport since youth and coming to England as a bowler).

    Kerrigan may have struggled but I still think he is the best front-line spinner. He is also the leading spinner in division 1 this season for wickets, and has done so with good economy.

    I certainly wouldn't pick Buttler yet. He has barely established himself in white-ball international cricket. Why risk ruining him in a test match that he clearly isn't ready to play? Mind with Prior's injury, and Bairstow's lack of ability with bat and gloves, who else is there? I like Davies but his batting has been poor this season, so perhaps a specialist keeper would be better. The best glovemen in the country are Bates, Foster and Read, but I can't see them getting picked. Perhaps they'll pick Buttler or Bairstow.

  • on May 14, 2014, 4:05 GMT

    Morgan is a gud player but he is not get enough support & believe from ecb

  • jackiethepen on May 13, 2014, 10:19 GMT

    It gets a bit crazy when someone is being judged as a possible Test player among others but is already considered as a possible replacement Test captain. He has to learn how to play Test cricket first, never mind captain a side. We have a current captain who has performed over 100 Tests and still is regarded as 'learning' the complicated process of five day cricket.

  • CricketingStargazer on May 13, 2014, 9:55 GMT

    I was at Lords ion Sunday and was talking to people around the team. There seems to be a feeling around the Middlesex set-up that if England do not pick him Morgan may not even end the season in the Middlesex team. Strange, but true. There is a feeling that he does not deliver enough in Championship cricket and that he place may come under real pressure.

  • zoot364 on May 13, 2014, 8:25 GMT

    I was at Lord's yesterday. Some observations on the England contenders: Robson: looks really secure on the back foot but I wonder if his slightly unusual stance hints at a vulnerability to the fuller length delivery. Buttler: the ball bounces out of his gloves too frequently to inspire confidence Morgan: perky at the crease as usual but we need to see some really long innings from him. Kerrigan: didn't see much of him but his rather apologetic run-up does make me wonder

  • hhillbumper on May 12, 2014, 20:28 GMT

    Morgan is not a test class player.Coming off once in a blue moon might make him a mythical danger player in ODI but never ever should he play test cricket.Maybe we could play one of those interesting English players.

  • Harvey on May 12, 2014, 19:20 GMT

    Every time Eoin Morgan makes a few County Championship runs for Middlesex, something that by the way doesn't happen nearly often enough for most Middlesex supporters, journalists immediately start pushing his case for an England Test recall. The truth of the matter is that despite being a quality limited overs player, he averages less than 35 in first class cricket. He isn't even a stand-out player in a middle order that is currently widely regarded as Middlesex's achilles heel, so how anyone can think he's even worthy of consideration for an England Test place is beyond me. I would love to see him go on and make a big hundred in this game, but he will need to start playing a lot better in County Championship matches than he has done so far to warrant inclusion in the Test side.

  • CodandChips on May 12, 2014, 19:12 GMT

    I wouldn't have Morgan in my team but I can certainly see England picking him, and if so, good luck to him. Robson as well continues to score though I'm not a massive fan, perhaps due to his background (despite having a British passport since youth and coming to England as a bowler).

    Kerrigan may have struggled but I still think he is the best front-line spinner. He is also the leading spinner in division 1 this season for wickets, and has done so with good economy.

    I certainly wouldn't pick Buttler yet. He has barely established himself in white-ball international cricket. Why risk ruining him in a test match that he clearly isn't ready to play? Mind with Prior's injury, and Bairstow's lack of ability with bat and gloves, who else is there? I like Davies but his batting has been poor this season, so perhaps a specialist keeper would be better. The best glovemen in the country are Bates, Foster and Read, but I can't see them getting picked. Perhaps they'll pick Buttler or Bairstow.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • CodandChips on May 12, 2014, 19:12 GMT

    I wouldn't have Morgan in my team but I can certainly see England picking him, and if so, good luck to him. Robson as well continues to score though I'm not a massive fan, perhaps due to his background (despite having a British passport since youth and coming to England as a bowler).

    Kerrigan may have struggled but I still think he is the best front-line spinner. He is also the leading spinner in division 1 this season for wickets, and has done so with good economy.

    I certainly wouldn't pick Buttler yet. He has barely established himself in white-ball international cricket. Why risk ruining him in a test match that he clearly isn't ready to play? Mind with Prior's injury, and Bairstow's lack of ability with bat and gloves, who else is there? I like Davies but his batting has been poor this season, so perhaps a specialist keeper would be better. The best glovemen in the country are Bates, Foster and Read, but I can't see them getting picked. Perhaps they'll pick Buttler or Bairstow.

  • Harvey on May 12, 2014, 19:20 GMT

    Every time Eoin Morgan makes a few County Championship runs for Middlesex, something that by the way doesn't happen nearly often enough for most Middlesex supporters, journalists immediately start pushing his case for an England Test recall. The truth of the matter is that despite being a quality limited overs player, he averages less than 35 in first class cricket. He isn't even a stand-out player in a middle order that is currently widely regarded as Middlesex's achilles heel, so how anyone can think he's even worthy of consideration for an England Test place is beyond me. I would love to see him go on and make a big hundred in this game, but he will need to start playing a lot better in County Championship matches than he has done so far to warrant inclusion in the Test side.

  • hhillbumper on May 12, 2014, 20:28 GMT

    Morgan is not a test class player.Coming off once in a blue moon might make him a mythical danger player in ODI but never ever should he play test cricket.Maybe we could play one of those interesting English players.

  • zoot364 on May 13, 2014, 8:25 GMT

    I was at Lord's yesterday. Some observations on the England contenders: Robson: looks really secure on the back foot but I wonder if his slightly unusual stance hints at a vulnerability to the fuller length delivery. Buttler: the ball bounces out of his gloves too frequently to inspire confidence Morgan: perky at the crease as usual but we need to see some really long innings from him. Kerrigan: didn't see much of him but his rather apologetic run-up does make me wonder

  • CricketingStargazer on May 13, 2014, 9:55 GMT

    I was at Lords ion Sunday and was talking to people around the team. There seems to be a feeling around the Middlesex set-up that if England do not pick him Morgan may not even end the season in the Middlesex team. Strange, but true. There is a feeling that he does not deliver enough in Championship cricket and that he place may come under real pressure.

  • jackiethepen on May 13, 2014, 10:19 GMT

    It gets a bit crazy when someone is being judged as a possible Test player among others but is already considered as a possible replacement Test captain. He has to learn how to play Test cricket first, never mind captain a side. We have a current captain who has performed over 100 Tests and still is regarded as 'learning' the complicated process of five day cricket.

  • on May 14, 2014, 4:05 GMT

    Morgan is a gud player but he is not get enough support & believe from ecb