Duleep Trophy, 2013 October 21, 2013

Is Duleep Trophy no longer relevant?

With tournaments like Champions League T20 nudging Duleep Trophy towards the margins of India's domestic calendar, the once-popular event is facing an identity crisis
22

The last time the Duleep Trophy was shared, before this year's edition, was 16 years ago when the 1997-98 final between West Zone and Central Zone in Chennai lost three days of play due to rain. The common strands between then and now are the weather and the four-match format of the tournament.

However, the significance of the tournament to India's domestic calendar has changed. Sixteen years ago, the Duleep Trophy was the last hurdle on the domestic circuit to earning a national call-up. In 2013, the tournament is struggling to find a slot in the domestic calendar that allows at least the zonal stars to participate. The tournament has clashed with the Champions League T20 for the last few years, and had the status of the Duleep Trophy not devalued, it would have seen domestic stars in whites rather than the coloured clothing of their franchise.

In such a scenario, one of the semi-finals this year was decided by a coin toss, followed by a final that saw just 10 overs played over five days - the last thing the tournament, already in the midst of an identity crisis, needed.

Amay Khurasiya, who led Central Zone in that final 16 years ago, feels it's time to realise the declining worth of the Duleep Trophy.

"If there are so many avenues for a person to get selected for India, then some avenues are going to dip in terms of significance," Khurasiya, who is now the director of Madhya Pradesh Cricket Association's academy, told ESPNcricinfo.

The Champions League matches were mostly held in cities that were unaffected by rain. A match scheduled to be held in Ahmedabad was moved to Jaipur following heavy rain. Yet that facility was not extended to the Duleep Trophy final that was held at the same venue where, 72 hours earlier, the semi-final had been washed out.

Ratnakar Shetty, the BCCI's general manager - game development, told Mumbai Mirror that October was the only slot available and the tournament could only be held in the southern part of India because other venues around the country were involved with the Champions League or the India-Australia series.

TC Mathew, the Kerala Cricket Association president who is also a member of the BCCI's senior tournament committee, also cited the same reasons.

"First and foremost, we must understand that the rains were expected to subside in October," Mathew said. "And it wasn't raining every day, so the question of informing the Board of our (KCA) inability to host the final after the semi-final disaster didn't arise.

"At the same time, I don't think the Board was in a position to shift the final at the eleventh hour because of the volume of cricket played around the country. At the end of the day, when Kerala has seen rains more than 180% of the average annual rainfall, despite putting in all the possible human effort, we couldn't have more than 10 overs in the game."

The BCCI finds itself in a conundrum of scheduling too many tournaments in limited span of time, with recent additions such as the Corporate Trophy, IPL, Champions League and the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy. With a prolonged Ranji trophy, which now assures each team of at least eight games per season, there are questions over whether the BCCI should let go of the Duleep Trophy that, until recently, used to be a marquee event. Khurasiya isn't averse to the idea.

"In an era when a four-over spell or an eight- or ten-over burst with the bat can catapult a youngster into the national team, Duleep Trophy has almost lost its value," Khurasiya said. "Nothing lasts forever. With times everything changes.

"You need to have vision. If something's not worth it, you better not continue with it. No doubt plenty of avenues have been created for cricketers to get noticed. At the same time, too much of cricket is also not good if it's affecting the quality. And I suppose the quality is being affected these days."

Amol Karhadkar is a correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • CricketMaan on October 24, 2013, 13:10 GMT

    Duleep, Ranji, Vijay Hazare, Syed Mustaq Ali, IPL, Corporate tourneys..do we really need so many to identify talent? No is my answer. However a lot these tours gives so many players, staff an oppurtunity to also earn when they can never go and make money at the highest level. The missing point is no matter whether Dupleep or Ranji, if we keep producing sub-standard pitches our cricket is no way going to improve neither our winning ways! You will still find Kholi, Samson, Chand or a Aparajith no matter which trophy we play, but how do we unearth another Kumble, Srinath, Kapil or will we ever produce a McGrath or Steyn!!

  • on October 23, 2013, 18:44 GMT

    Duleep Trophy, like in the earlier decades shud be played after a long Ranji season. The zone's best players are capable of plying their trades in the months of May-June post IPL. This is a great tournament. Shud not be scrapped.

  • balajik1968 on October 23, 2013, 14:21 GMT

    Abhishek, I know. But it is still 27 teams competing for one trophy. When was the last time a rank outsider won the Ranji? Don't say Rajasthan. When has a player last been selected on the basis of his Duleep exploits. Honestly I can't think of anyone. Maybe one, maybe two in the last 20 years.

  • Abhishek.2626 on October 23, 2013, 13:33 GMT

    Mr Balaji. Ranji Trophy has two tiers. "Elite" and "Plate". All the teams do not compete in one. The Plate trophy is for the weaker half. They can enter the Elite competition by reaching the final in the Plate competition.

  • balajik1968 on October 23, 2013, 6:10 GMT

    Gopalakrishna, I did not say Ranji Trophy is irrelevant. What I am saying is that with so many teams playing for one trophy, motivation will not be high among the weaker teams. Teams like Andhra, Goa, Tripura do not have a realistic chance, and will not even try. Put them among teams with equal strength; they may try. A trophy will be a great motivator to improve.

    I do not recall the last player who got called up to India after being picked for Duleep. It has been a long time. At one time, if the zonal selectors picked someone for Duleep, he was seen as an India prospect. No longer.

    What I am trying to say is Duleep Trophy has lost its context. Same for the Irani. Ranji is right now unwieldy. Why not a revamp?

  • jimbond on October 22, 2013, 17:56 GMT

    For Duleep trophy to be meaningful, it should feature five day games, it should not clash with other international matches involving India, it should be telecast on television- including DD, and finally the performers here should be given chances in the national team and in A teams.

  • on October 22, 2013, 13:38 GMT

    Duleep trophy is still important as its a one of a kind tournament. the most meaningless tournament is Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy. When you already have the IPL to pick the best players of T20 format then why have a state level t20 tournament which nobody follows! most of the reasonable standard domestic players play in the IPL also & it wouldnt matter if a couple of 20 somethings donot get a chance to swing their bats in another T20 competition if they didnot get to play the IPL. moreover all other countries after the launch of their permier franchise t20 leagues (like big bash, BPL, CPL, SLPL) have discontinued their old t20 statelevel tournaments.

  • buntyj on October 22, 2013, 11:54 GMT

    unfortunately true that no longer relevant. unfortunate since the 5 team tournament if played on a home and away league basis with participation by test players for each team in at least two matches and played on pitches with just a little bounce would be the best prep for our test selection

  • Gopalakrishna on October 22, 2013, 10:46 GMT

    balajik should say that even the Ranji Trophy is irrevelent!!! HRG

  • Gopalakrishna on October 22, 2013, 10:45 GMT

    balajik should say that even the Ranji Trophy is irrevelent!!! HRG

  • CricketMaan on October 24, 2013, 13:10 GMT

    Duleep, Ranji, Vijay Hazare, Syed Mustaq Ali, IPL, Corporate tourneys..do we really need so many to identify talent? No is my answer. However a lot these tours gives so many players, staff an oppurtunity to also earn when they can never go and make money at the highest level. The missing point is no matter whether Dupleep or Ranji, if we keep producing sub-standard pitches our cricket is no way going to improve neither our winning ways! You will still find Kholi, Samson, Chand or a Aparajith no matter which trophy we play, but how do we unearth another Kumble, Srinath, Kapil or will we ever produce a McGrath or Steyn!!

  • on October 23, 2013, 18:44 GMT

    Duleep Trophy, like in the earlier decades shud be played after a long Ranji season. The zone's best players are capable of plying their trades in the months of May-June post IPL. This is a great tournament. Shud not be scrapped.

  • balajik1968 on October 23, 2013, 14:21 GMT

    Abhishek, I know. But it is still 27 teams competing for one trophy. When was the last time a rank outsider won the Ranji? Don't say Rajasthan. When has a player last been selected on the basis of his Duleep exploits. Honestly I can't think of anyone. Maybe one, maybe two in the last 20 years.

  • Abhishek.2626 on October 23, 2013, 13:33 GMT

    Mr Balaji. Ranji Trophy has two tiers. "Elite" and "Plate". All the teams do not compete in one. The Plate trophy is for the weaker half. They can enter the Elite competition by reaching the final in the Plate competition.

  • balajik1968 on October 23, 2013, 6:10 GMT

    Gopalakrishna, I did not say Ranji Trophy is irrelevant. What I am saying is that with so many teams playing for one trophy, motivation will not be high among the weaker teams. Teams like Andhra, Goa, Tripura do not have a realistic chance, and will not even try. Put them among teams with equal strength; they may try. A trophy will be a great motivator to improve.

    I do not recall the last player who got called up to India after being picked for Duleep. It has been a long time. At one time, if the zonal selectors picked someone for Duleep, he was seen as an India prospect. No longer.

    What I am trying to say is Duleep Trophy has lost its context. Same for the Irani. Ranji is right now unwieldy. Why not a revamp?

  • jimbond on October 22, 2013, 17:56 GMT

    For Duleep trophy to be meaningful, it should feature five day games, it should not clash with other international matches involving India, it should be telecast on television- including DD, and finally the performers here should be given chances in the national team and in A teams.

  • on October 22, 2013, 13:38 GMT

    Duleep trophy is still important as its a one of a kind tournament. the most meaningless tournament is Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy. When you already have the IPL to pick the best players of T20 format then why have a state level t20 tournament which nobody follows! most of the reasonable standard domestic players play in the IPL also & it wouldnt matter if a couple of 20 somethings donot get a chance to swing their bats in another T20 competition if they didnot get to play the IPL. moreover all other countries after the launch of their permier franchise t20 leagues (like big bash, BPL, CPL, SLPL) have discontinued their old t20 statelevel tournaments.

  • buntyj on October 22, 2013, 11:54 GMT

    unfortunately true that no longer relevant. unfortunate since the 5 team tournament if played on a home and away league basis with participation by test players for each team in at least two matches and played on pitches with just a little bounce would be the best prep for our test selection

  • Gopalakrishna on October 22, 2013, 10:46 GMT

    balajik should say that even the Ranji Trophy is irrevelent!!! HRG

  • Gopalakrishna on October 22, 2013, 10:45 GMT

    balajik should say that even the Ranji Trophy is irrevelent!!! HRG

  • Gopalakrishna on October 22, 2013, 10:43 GMT

    It's unfortunate that the tournament was washed out due to rain in South India. Nature has played the spoilsport. It is unfair to scrap such a wonderful tournament which was the trial for selection for the national team. Duleep Trophy tournament has given the nation a long list of cricketers - its too long to mention it. Whoever has represented India in test was a product from Duleep Trophy - Let us not forget this. HR Gopala Krishna - Cricket Statistician - Bangalore

  • on October 22, 2013, 10:32 GMT

    The Duleep Trophy should be continued and better organized. The Team India players do not play most of their state's Ranji games, make them play the Zonal tournament, getter better croud attention, strengthen the competition and play in a league format. The association based T-20 tournament could be done away with, or converted into an age group tournament. But the Duleep Trophy should be given greater importance.

  • on October 22, 2013, 9:15 GMT

    I dont think the tournament is irrelevant, I follow the tournament quite closely. I was thrilled to see the performance of an unknown kid Anustup Majumder 2 years back in Duleep trophy. The knocks earned him India A call up and IPL and he played very well there. He lost out next year in Ranji but thats a different story.

  • balajik1968 on October 22, 2013, 6:59 GMT

    Not just Duleep Trophy, even Irani Trophy in its current format is irrelevant. There are 27 teams competing in Ranji. That is too much. Have a 3 tier structure. Ranji for the top 9, Duleep for the next 9 and Irani for the next.

  • Sharath274 on October 22, 2013, 5:49 GMT

    I think we can do away with Duleep and Deodhar trophy for now. When there is a well formatted Ranji trophy, having a duleep trophy is not going to give any additional opportunities to the aspirants. and also considering the no. of A series the fringe players get to play in different conditions, that would add more value than playing zonal matches on Indian pitches.

  • JohnnyRook on October 22, 2013, 5:39 GMT

    I agree that it has lost its relevance and I completely understand the reasons. But I think should stay the premier first class ournament in India. Cut Ranji Trophy short but keep Duleep Trophy intact. Simply because Duleep Trophy has less number of teams and a lot stronger competetion. Best Players from 5-6 Ranji Trophy teams get in the squad for North Zone. It has to stay the final hurdle before India or India A selection. It is Indian cricket's loss if BCCI ignores Duleep Trophy...

  • sray23 on October 22, 2013, 3:52 GMT

    Duleep trophy is no longer relevant. Once long flagship 4-5 day tournament is enough (Ranji). It is clogging up the calendar, best to let it go.

  • PratUSA on October 22, 2013, 1:23 GMT

    I used to like Duleep trophy as it was a higher level competition than Ranji Trophy. It was also used to bring in a 6th foreign team occasionally. But if it's not given due respect then it's better to let it go. Deodhar Trophy really needs to go to if politics doesn't stop it again from being scrapped. Challenger trophy has also lost meaning. Ranji, Vijay Hazare, Syed Mushtaq Ali, Irani, and IPL are more than enough for senior domestic calendar. I wouldn't even mind cutting off Syed Mushtaq Ali trophy. One tournament in each format sounds about right, with Irani trophy to be converted into a marquee event, by ensuring national squad players are available to play in it.

  • RogerC on October 22, 2013, 0:40 GMT

    All domestic tournaments other than IPL have become irrelevant in India. If you see recent times, all newcomers to Indian team are selected based on IPL performances.

  • on October 21, 2013, 21:38 GMT

    The Duleep trophy should be the premier domestic tourno and should be in a league format like it used to be at the end of a Ranji season. There is no need for the S Mushtaq Ali tourno with IPL also running. Similarly the Challenger series is a waste of time.

    The reason this tourno has seen fortunes decline is because it is treated with contempt. The boards scheduling has been farcical-having an A team series vs WI and the CLT20 with the Challengers -it is clear they dont know hot to handle the A team. Then the ODIs vs Australia all around the same time as Duleep is not right. Frankly this tourno should have had all the senior India players playing to warm up for upcoming tests and to give the tourno the status it deserves

  • RG88 on October 21, 2013, 19:44 GMT

    I think we should identify the hierarchy of domestic tournaments.The new format of Ranji is very exciting. An additional day rest between each back to back games would enhance the quality of the competition. 5 Days knock is cool too. Vijay Hazare Trophy and Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy should be played on same lines.This would be the whole season. Duleep Trophy and Deodhar Trophy should be U25 competitions. CK Nayudu U25 championship likewise should not be played zonal wise but should have 4 groups. Ranji Trophy should be the main competition and CK Nayudu the feeder line for the Ranji teams. Irani Trophy is rightly placed.

  • Harmony111 on October 21, 2013, 18:18 GMT

    We will see how relevant the Duleep Trophy is by the no of comments this article itself shall receive.

    My own opinion is that the Duleep Trophy suffers from viewer fatigue as well as player fatigue. Viewers are tired and confused as there are way too many matches, often running parallel. The players are fatigued after playing a long season + they don't see Duleep Trophy as any sort of gateway to the national team cos it comes at the end of the season and the team for the near-future series is not picked for a few more weeks/months by which time their Duleep Trophy performance is not exactly remembered.

    However, if and when special performances are produced Duleep Trophy does mean a lot. In 2010, we saw Yusuf Pathan & Dinesh Karthik producing big 100s in each innings of the final and a world record chase, as that match went on ppl started to enter the stadium and turned on their tv sets. I was keenly following the final when it was in its final stages.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Harmony111 on October 21, 2013, 18:18 GMT

    We will see how relevant the Duleep Trophy is by the no of comments this article itself shall receive.

    My own opinion is that the Duleep Trophy suffers from viewer fatigue as well as player fatigue. Viewers are tired and confused as there are way too many matches, often running parallel. The players are fatigued after playing a long season + they don't see Duleep Trophy as any sort of gateway to the national team cos it comes at the end of the season and the team for the near-future series is not picked for a few more weeks/months by which time their Duleep Trophy performance is not exactly remembered.

    However, if and when special performances are produced Duleep Trophy does mean a lot. In 2010, we saw Yusuf Pathan & Dinesh Karthik producing big 100s in each innings of the final and a world record chase, as that match went on ppl started to enter the stadium and turned on their tv sets. I was keenly following the final when it was in its final stages.

  • RG88 on October 21, 2013, 19:44 GMT

    I think we should identify the hierarchy of domestic tournaments.The new format of Ranji is very exciting. An additional day rest between each back to back games would enhance the quality of the competition. 5 Days knock is cool too. Vijay Hazare Trophy and Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy should be played on same lines.This would be the whole season. Duleep Trophy and Deodhar Trophy should be U25 competitions. CK Nayudu U25 championship likewise should not be played zonal wise but should have 4 groups. Ranji Trophy should be the main competition and CK Nayudu the feeder line for the Ranji teams. Irani Trophy is rightly placed.

  • on October 21, 2013, 21:38 GMT

    The Duleep trophy should be the premier domestic tourno and should be in a league format like it used to be at the end of a Ranji season. There is no need for the S Mushtaq Ali tourno with IPL also running. Similarly the Challenger series is a waste of time.

    The reason this tourno has seen fortunes decline is because it is treated with contempt. The boards scheduling has been farcical-having an A team series vs WI and the CLT20 with the Challengers -it is clear they dont know hot to handle the A team. Then the ODIs vs Australia all around the same time as Duleep is not right. Frankly this tourno should have had all the senior India players playing to warm up for upcoming tests and to give the tourno the status it deserves

  • RogerC on October 22, 2013, 0:40 GMT

    All domestic tournaments other than IPL have become irrelevant in India. If you see recent times, all newcomers to Indian team are selected based on IPL performances.

  • PratUSA on October 22, 2013, 1:23 GMT

    I used to like Duleep trophy as it was a higher level competition than Ranji Trophy. It was also used to bring in a 6th foreign team occasionally. But if it's not given due respect then it's better to let it go. Deodhar Trophy really needs to go to if politics doesn't stop it again from being scrapped. Challenger trophy has also lost meaning. Ranji, Vijay Hazare, Syed Mushtaq Ali, Irani, and IPL are more than enough for senior domestic calendar. I wouldn't even mind cutting off Syed Mushtaq Ali trophy. One tournament in each format sounds about right, with Irani trophy to be converted into a marquee event, by ensuring national squad players are available to play in it.

  • sray23 on October 22, 2013, 3:52 GMT

    Duleep trophy is no longer relevant. Once long flagship 4-5 day tournament is enough (Ranji). It is clogging up the calendar, best to let it go.

  • JohnnyRook on October 22, 2013, 5:39 GMT

    I agree that it has lost its relevance and I completely understand the reasons. But I think should stay the premier first class ournament in India. Cut Ranji Trophy short but keep Duleep Trophy intact. Simply because Duleep Trophy has less number of teams and a lot stronger competetion. Best Players from 5-6 Ranji Trophy teams get in the squad for North Zone. It has to stay the final hurdle before India or India A selection. It is Indian cricket's loss if BCCI ignores Duleep Trophy...

  • Sharath274 on October 22, 2013, 5:49 GMT

    I think we can do away with Duleep and Deodhar trophy for now. When there is a well formatted Ranji trophy, having a duleep trophy is not going to give any additional opportunities to the aspirants. and also considering the no. of A series the fringe players get to play in different conditions, that would add more value than playing zonal matches on Indian pitches.

  • balajik1968 on October 22, 2013, 6:59 GMT

    Not just Duleep Trophy, even Irani Trophy in its current format is irrelevant. There are 27 teams competing in Ranji. That is too much. Have a 3 tier structure. Ranji for the top 9, Duleep for the next 9 and Irani for the next.

  • on October 22, 2013, 9:15 GMT

    I dont think the tournament is irrelevant, I follow the tournament quite closely. I was thrilled to see the performance of an unknown kid Anustup Majumder 2 years back in Duleep trophy. The knocks earned him India A call up and IPL and he played very well there. He lost out next year in Ranji but thats a different story.