England v India, 1st Investec Test, Trent Bridge, 3rd day July 11, 2014

Seamers star, but India kept waiting


England 352 for 9 (Root 78*, Ballance 71, Robson 59, Bhuvneshwar 4-61) trail India 457 by 105 runs
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

Play 01:02
Kimber: This year's worst decision

It was just like the second day. England's batsmen dominated the first session, India's bowlers took a clump of wickets in the second session, and England's lower order frustrated the bowlers after tea. India were on the verge of taking a massive lead and possibly bowling England out short of the follow-on mark before Joe Root averted the danger along with the lower order to end the day unbeaten on 78. Root put on 78 with Stuart Broad, and an unbroken 54 with No. 11 James Anderson as England ended the day trailing by 105.

The pitch remained slow and unresponsive through the third day, but India's seamers got more out of it by bowling a much straighter line. Where India's batsmen defended 288 balls from England's seamers and left 257 balls alone, England's batsmen, by stumps, had defended 175 balls and only left 87 alone. It took until the 33rd over of the day, and the second over of the post-lunch session, for India to taste any success.

It came from Ishant Sharma, who got the ball to duck back in from a good length to make Robson pay for staying stuck in his crease. The ball hit his front pad before cannoning onto his back pad and umpire Bruce Oxenford had little hesitation in giving him out, even if Hotspot picked up what might have been a faint inside edge.

The umpires changed the ball two overs later, after it looked to have gone out of shape. And the replacement, much to India's delight, showed itself far more responsive to the clouds that had gathered overhead, after two clear days. Ishant immediately got it to curl late into the left-handed Gary Ballance and ping him on the front pad - this time, there was absolutely no doubt about the decision. Only two Indian batsmen had been dismissed bowled or lbw. All of England's top three had been dismissed with no help from fielders.

Ian Bell caressed his way to 25 before he fell victim to indecision, bottom-edging Ishant to the keeper while trying to withdraw his bat from a short, rising ball outside off. Indifferent bounce consumed Moeen Ali ten overs later, when he took his eyes of a Mohammed Shami bouncer that didn't quite rise as expected and ended up gloving the ball to slip.

Bhuvneshwar Kumar came to the party with ten minutes to go for tea, swinging the ball away from the right-handed Matt Prior and then the left-handed Ben Stokes to have both caught behind. Prior had reason to feel aggrieved by his dismissal, with replays showing a fair sliver of daylight between ball and outside edge.

After tea, Broad went after the bowling, driving and slashing on the up through the off side. Despite the old ball doing a bit, India took the new ball two overs after it was due, and the runs came even quicker, Broad striking five fours in the first two new-ball overs. The mood rubbed off on Root as well, and he got in an uncharacteristically big front-foot stride to drive Bhuvneshwar sweetly through the off side.

Just when the partnership was assuming dangerous proportions, Bhuvneshwar got one to straighten from leg stump and hit Broad's front pad in front of leg stump. He had his fourth wicket seven overs later, when he nipped one back to bowl Liam Plunkett.

India still had Anderson to get past, though. In his last Test match against Sri Lanka, he had blocked out 54 balls before being dismissed two balls short of saving the match and the series. Here, he came out with a different approach. Root initially farmed the strike, placing the ball adroitly into the outfield to take the singles that India gifted him with their deep fields.

Given the strike, Anderson went for his shots, punching Bhuvneshwar through the covers, reverse-sweeping Jadeja, and only looking uncomfortable when the fast bowlers dug it in. Root and Anderson batted for 14.3 overs, and could yet overhaul the 111 runs that Bhuvneshwar and Shami, India's last-wicket pair, had put on on the second day.

In the morning session, Robson and Ballance had looked largely untroubled, and had seemed by lunch to have won the contest of patience against India's seamers. Ballance took guard outside the crease to negate the effect of his extravagant back-and-across trigger movement and get relatively close to the pitch of the ball when the bowlers drew him forward. Robson got nicely on top of the ball when he defended off the front foot, and even Bhuvneshwar's inswing, by and large, didn't cause his head to fall over.

The only chance in the session came when Robson, on 43, inside-edged Ravindra Jadeja as he tried to work the ball around the corner. Virat Kohli dived to his left from leg slip and got his fingers under the ball but couldn't hold on.

The bowlers lost some of their discipline late in the session, and Ballance capitalised to beat Robson to fifty. There had been no fours for 12 overs before Ballance took three off one Ishant over, two clipped off his legs and one slapped past backward point.

Stuart Binny, who replaced Ishant from that end, released a little more of the pressure, leaking four boundaries in his first three overs, and both batsmen reached their 50s with steered fours down to third man off him. Binny didn't bowl in the second session, and only sent down one over after tea, and with Jadeja threatening to play a bigger role in England's second innings, India may come to wonder if they should have gone with an extra spinner.

Karthik Krishnaswamy is a senior sub-editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Ravishankar on July 14, 2014, 7:56 GMT

    Ishant, though took wickets was most inconsistent bowler. He bowled too many no balls and thinks speed is only thing in a bowling and not accuracy!. He should learn from Making a regarding fast bowling on accuracy and Johnson on Speed. If he does not improve should be fired. Bhuvi is an example for accurate bowler.

  • sri on July 12, 2014, 12:59 GMT

    Now pressure is on dhoni . Draw seems to be the safest bet. Eng bowlers will probably try hard for a win now . No DRS and hope for minimal umpiring mistakes.

  • Hamish on July 12, 2014, 12:59 GMT

    @YorkshirePudding: As you admit that you hadn't seen any of the play, I simply don't understand your logic here. Who would you suggest should do the reporting? I suggest you watch the interview with Kapil Dev and Wasim Akram, both of whom said it was a wicket just like you'd get on the subcontinent. Does that mean by your logic that every subcontinental wicket should be reported?

  • Dummy4 on July 12, 2014, 12:53 GMT

    It.s about captaincy...not the pitch....cuz the same pitch was good enough to take the first 7 wickets.

  • Ashok on July 12, 2014, 12:51 GMT

    Dhoni must be regretting his XI selection in which he dropped Ashwin with 6 LH batsmen in he England side. The result is even 2 LH bats who are the pace bowlers, Broad & Anderson, could pummel the Indian bowling. I do not understand why Dhoni made such drastic changes with o back ups either. Rohit Sharma is an excellent off spinner too. Bringing in Rehane + dropping Ashwin for Bunny were the 2 moves which any captain with little bit f common sense would not have done. At least when Ashwin is dropped, by keeping Rohit in XI, there was a back up offspinner to help him out if needed. Now Anderson is on his way to century mostly Sweeping/pulling the ball for 4's. Broad also had a field day with 47. Dravid as the team Mentor could first advise Dhoni how to select a balanced XI. This is where Dhoni has failed very badly as a captain consistently. With England in Lead which was unimaginable when they were 202 for 7.What a turn of fate from Winning position to fighting to eke out a draw!

  • brai on July 12, 2014, 12:50 GMT

    dhoni is cool & stuff like that is alright ,it works in odis & t20s .just because there is always pressure on scoring runs you just can run through motions and hope for the results to come for you just like he does in odis taking the game to the last ball etc ,but here in test cricket there is no last ball , if dhoni tries something new , think fast change fields ,insoire bowlers show some intent etc the match would look interesting even if you loose .

  • Dummy4 on July 12, 2014, 12:45 GMT

    The pitch seems so dry without any pace. The ball is not seaming straight allowing Root and Anderson to get bat on ball. Dhoni has tried everything, the short ball, spinner nothing seems to be working.

    I dont know why everyone here is blaming Dhoni when the pitch is lifeless and the bowlers can't make any movement. This match is definitely going to end in a draw unless india post a big total in quick time and teak quick wickets in england's 2nd innings.

  • Jason on July 12, 2014, 12:44 GMT

    I've Just got in after a morning out in the sun, dropped onto ESPN to check the score, thinking I'd see India with a 150-200 run lead, and frankly I cant believe what I'm seeing. I really think the pitch needs reporting if you can have a 181 run Last wicket Partnership, especially when viewed with the Indian Last wicket partnership of 111, thats nearly 300 runs scored by the last wicket out of 900+ runs.

  • Ishaan on July 12, 2014, 12:43 GMT

    I see many people criticising dhoni, he did everything he could, but not to any effect. Even after such a big stand, he had attacking fields for anderson. There was also a point of time when litrally everyone was around anderson. I mean, on a such a flat and slow pitch, it is very difficult to get someone out when he is set. Though i hope anderson gets a century, he deserves it fully.

  • Hamish on July 12, 2014, 12:41 GMT

    England outplaying India on a subcontinental wicket under a sunny sky; interesting, to say the least. I do wish Dhoni wouldn't appeal for caught behinds when the camera shot from behind the wicket clearly shows the ball to be missing the bat by inches. It's not as if he can claim his bowlers are delivering the ball so fast that he hasn't time to get a good look.

  • No featured comments at the moment.