England v India, 4th Investec Test, Old Trafford, 1st day August 7, 2014

England let their bowling talk

England refrained from verbal aggression. And their performance did not dip as a consequence. Indeed, you might argue that the added discipline, control and focus actually rendered them more effective
  shares 20

Play 02:02
Highlights: Broad wreaks havoc on India with 6 for 25

Ronan Keating almost certainly was not thinking about the England seam attack when he sang "You say it best when you say nothing at all." But, as India collapsed against some high quality swing bowling at Emirates Old Trafford, it seemed an apposite description nevertheless.

Despite all the swearing and snarling unleashed at Trent Bridge, in particular, James Anderson and co. expressed themselves so much more effectively here. Allowing their bowling to do the talking, they exploited some helpful conditions and, perhaps, some helpful batting, to strike a blow that may well define this series.

That does not mean England's cricket lacked aggression or intent. A packed slip cordon and fuller length spoke far more eloquently than any poor language or playground posturing that we might have seen earlier in the series.

And, while Anderson did not actually speak after taking the wicket of Ravi Jadeja, it seems safe to assume that a body language expert would have interpreted him with a handful of asterisks: something along the lines of "You *** **** *** you ******* **** **** with a cucumber."

The point is, Anderson did not say anything. And his performance did not dip as a consequence. Indeed, you might argue that the added discipline, the added control of his temper and the added focus upon the job that matters - harnessing the conditions and dismissing batsman - actually rendered him more effective. It is not simply that he does not need the overt aggression he allegedly showed towards Jadeja in Nottingham, it is that it might actually distract him from the job in hand.

Conditions here were probably no more helpful than they had been on the first morning at Lord's. But, while on that occasion England squandered the potential advantage by bowling too short and being seemingly more interested in intimidating the batsmen than dismissing them, here Anderson and Stuart Broad bowled with the skill and maturity required to damage a fragile India top-order. No side has suffered more ducks in a Test innings and the decline from 8 for 0 to 8 for 4 just 13 deliveries later was, Broad said later, one of the more dramatic passages of play he had witnessed.

While Broad finished with the eye-catching figures - his 6 for 25 were the best figures for an England bowler against India in England since Fred Trueman claimed 8 for 31 on this ground in 1952 - it was Anderson who was most impressive. The delivery that dismissed Murali Vijay, a full ball delivered from wide of the crease that demanded a stroke but swung away sharply to take the edge, was a long way along the spectrum towards unplayable. And if the ball that dismissed Virat Kohli, an outswinger that might just have been left, was slightly less impressive, it was still a fine delivery to a man with an obvious frailty outside off stump and who had been set-up by inswingers. Anderson has now dismissed Kohli three times in the series at a cost of only two runs in total.

Later Anderson beat Jadeja with one that swung back, and produced a beauty to take Ashwin's edge, but saw Jos Buttler put down the chance. They were exactly the sort of conditions - and exactly the sort of bowling - that touring sides fear when they play in England. England, at last, benefited from home conditions.

Broad lent excellent support and afterwards accepted that the key to England's success had not been to get carried away by the extra pace in the wicket.

"They were pretty much as good bowling conditions as you can get," Broad said. "I was actually a bit disappointed when we lost the toss as I thought it would prove to be a big toss to win. Australia scored 500 last year and then the pitch was a bit up and down on the final day. We don't want to bat last on that wicket, because there are already little signs of uneven bounce.

"But we got a bit lucky with the overhead conditions. It clouded over and the ball was swinging nicely. There was bounce in the wicket as well. It's hard batting against swing when you know you can be hit on the head.

"But it wasn't just about the conditions. We bowled well and we hit a good length. We knew we could not be too encouraged by the bounce. It felt hard to get people bowled or leg before because of the bounce, but we still challenged the front feet of the batsmen and we took our catches. It's easy on bouncier wickets to fall into the trap of bowling too short.

"It's not like the Indian batsmen will be kicking themselves for playing poor shots. The all received decent balls. They certainly had to play at those deliveries. But it was a pretty good Test wicket and very different when the sun came out. It seemed to take all the zip out of the wicket."

Perhaps Broad enjoyed a little luck. He saw Ashwin pull to deep square leg and MS Dhoni slog to the same area. And if he earned the wicket of Cheteshwar Pujara with one that drew a stroke but nipped away, then he might consider the wicket of Gautam Gambhir, unable to deal with the bounce of the new ball, surprisingly soft. Bhuvneshwar Kumar, meanwhile, left a straight one and Pankaj Singh might be considered one of the least impressive batsman in world cricket.

But this was not a perfect performance by England. The two younger seamers, Chris Woakes and Chris Jordan, were far less threatening than their senior colleagues, while Buttler endured an uncomfortable day with the gloves and, as well as conceding 10 byes - the fourth highest contribution in the India innings - and put down that chance offered by Ashwin when he had scored 25.

But such flaws can be tolerated so long as the senior players deliver. And, to some extent, they must be expected as young and inexperienced players come into the side and learn their trade at the highest level. Jordan, at least, showed signs of improvement, though Woakes - as good as he was luckless in Southampton - looked a little anxious as his wait for another Test wicket went on. His current bowling average - 222 - is monstrously harsh, but his line was not quite tight enough to exploit the conditions.

But he might reflect that both Anderson and Broad endured such days early in their careers. In terms of learning from mistakes and harnessing conditions, he could hardly want for better role models.

George Dobell is a senior correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • POSTED BY SpaMaster on | August 9, 2014, 7:14 GMT

    A more appropriate title would be: England's bowling talks too

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 10:31 GMT

    I am amused. Stuart Broad takes six wickets and he is considered lucky? What impresses me is that he doesn't dish up balls to score off and even though he bowled two Tail enders (one really considering Kumar's earlier exploits) on both occasions the ball clipped the top of the wicket which indicates the perfect length. Give the lad some credit!

  • POSTED BY Naresh28 on | August 8, 2014, 10:07 GMT

    Anderson, Steyn and Johnson - these three are the best in the world - no doubt. All have different skills. I think Anderson takes it when it comes to seam and wrist position. The other two are speed.

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 9:54 GMT

    I wonder the reasoning behnid India choosing to bat early on this track. The pitch and English bowling was made to look devastating by spineless Indian batting.

  • POSTED BY shane-oh on | August 8, 2014, 9:54 GMT

    @Calvin Palmer Warbah - classic! As soon as it looks like you might lose, you suddenly don't care about this series. Thanks mate, gave me a good laugh!

  • POSTED BY fozzilla on | August 8, 2014, 9:48 GMT

    a lot of bitter Indian fans on here. Its funny that IPL is becoming a bit like the premiership in the UK. Fans don't really care about our International football team anymore and are more interested in their club side to the detriment of both. Its a slippery slope! On another note, this Indian outfit is really dire...

  • POSTED BY Absolutelycricket on | August 8, 2014, 9:11 GMT

    my gut feeling is India will win this test if it last for 5 days, pitch looks a bit turning on day one, obviously india will bat sensibly on 2nd innings with 300 plus to win and with jadeja and ashwin will be into england batting

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 9:04 GMT

    India should consider itself lucky that Cook made a blunder by not choosing Finn for this match. It would have been even more difficult. Probably Cook will repent that decision Of not picking Finn. If only India can Bowl England out fir 225 or less and set a 4th inning target of 220 for England there is still life in this match for India. Only if the Indians believe in themselves. Not otherwise.

  • POSTED BY dunger.bob on | August 8, 2014, 8:37 GMT

    @ Nutcutlet: Yes, well, you haven't actually won this Test either. Obviously you're in the box seat but disaster is always just a decent collapse away. I happen to agree with you though. I have a feeling that the team you have on the park today would have acquitted itself better in Aus. than the one you actually sent. That's unproven and unknowable of course, but that's what my spidey sense tells me.

    @ the f dude : Honestly mate, no worries at all. I enjoy the IPL as well. It's a bit of good old fashioned fun and there are some incredible skills on show at times. There's absolutely nothing wrong with giving the fan's what they want so if that's your thing in India, go for it.

  • POSTED BY ZainE111 on | August 8, 2014, 8:11 GMT

    Wow - lots of sour grapes in the comments below.

    In my opinion, aside from Pujara and Rahane, no Indian batsman in their current setup has shown an ability to make a solid test-match quality innings against decent seam bowling unless the pitch is flat and lifeless.

  • POSTED BY SpaMaster on | August 9, 2014, 7:14 GMT

    A more appropriate title would be: England's bowling talks too

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 10:31 GMT

    I am amused. Stuart Broad takes six wickets and he is considered lucky? What impresses me is that he doesn't dish up balls to score off and even though he bowled two Tail enders (one really considering Kumar's earlier exploits) on both occasions the ball clipped the top of the wicket which indicates the perfect length. Give the lad some credit!

  • POSTED BY Naresh28 on | August 8, 2014, 10:07 GMT

    Anderson, Steyn and Johnson - these three are the best in the world - no doubt. All have different skills. I think Anderson takes it when it comes to seam and wrist position. The other two are speed.

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 9:54 GMT

    I wonder the reasoning behnid India choosing to bat early on this track. The pitch and English bowling was made to look devastating by spineless Indian batting.

  • POSTED BY shane-oh on | August 8, 2014, 9:54 GMT

    @Calvin Palmer Warbah - classic! As soon as it looks like you might lose, you suddenly don't care about this series. Thanks mate, gave me a good laugh!

  • POSTED BY fozzilla on | August 8, 2014, 9:48 GMT

    a lot of bitter Indian fans on here. Its funny that IPL is becoming a bit like the premiership in the UK. Fans don't really care about our International football team anymore and are more interested in their club side to the detriment of both. Its a slippery slope! On another note, this Indian outfit is really dire...

  • POSTED BY Absolutelycricket on | August 8, 2014, 9:11 GMT

    my gut feeling is India will win this test if it last for 5 days, pitch looks a bit turning on day one, obviously india will bat sensibly on 2nd innings with 300 plus to win and with jadeja and ashwin will be into england batting

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 9:04 GMT

    India should consider itself lucky that Cook made a blunder by not choosing Finn for this match. It would have been even more difficult. Probably Cook will repent that decision Of not picking Finn. If only India can Bowl England out fir 225 or less and set a 4th inning target of 220 for England there is still life in this match for India. Only if the Indians believe in themselves. Not otherwise.

  • POSTED BY dunger.bob on | August 8, 2014, 8:37 GMT

    @ Nutcutlet: Yes, well, you haven't actually won this Test either. Obviously you're in the box seat but disaster is always just a decent collapse away. I happen to agree with you though. I have a feeling that the team you have on the park today would have acquitted itself better in Aus. than the one you actually sent. That's unproven and unknowable of course, but that's what my spidey sense tells me.

    @ the f dude : Honestly mate, no worries at all. I enjoy the IPL as well. It's a bit of good old fashioned fun and there are some incredible skills on show at times. There's absolutely nothing wrong with giving the fan's what they want so if that's your thing in India, go for it.

  • POSTED BY ZainE111 on | August 8, 2014, 8:11 GMT

    Wow - lots of sour grapes in the comments below.

    In my opinion, aside from Pujara and Rahane, no Indian batsman in their current setup has shown an ability to make a solid test-match quality innings against decent seam bowling unless the pitch is flat and lifeless.

  • POSTED BY Veeru_SRT on | August 8, 2014, 7:59 GMT

    I feel !_INDIA_! going to register their 2nd victory at Old Trafford...!!!

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | August 8, 2014, 7:04 GMT

    England is beginning to put together a decent side once more. I always thought that an Indian summer would be ideal rehab after the trauma of last winter, and after an uncertain start, that's the way it's looking. Not every box is ticked & there's no room for complacency. First, there is an obvious over-reliance on Jimmy & Stuart. The gulf between England's premier pair and the rest is vast. Jordan may make the grade, but he's likely to get injured with an action that looks as if it's placing enormous stresses on his frame. Woakes is better than he was last year, but he needs to move up two more bowling notches to be Test quality. Sam Robson doesn't look the part (think Mitch J v SR to realise how far away he is!); Ali has done well, but does that mean the search for a specialist spinner is now off? Buttler is fine as a bat, but does he have to keep as well? Why not play him as a specialist bat? I hope Eng. selectors do not go into self-congrat mode. This is not the finished article.

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 6:38 GMT

    'Letting their bowling talk', does not make much sense as England was not the team aggrieved by the decision of the disciplinary committee.

  • POSTED BY subcontinent-expert on | August 8, 2014, 6:13 GMT

    Yeah so what if England have not won a 50-50 world cup at all.. So what if they loose CT finals at HOME.. May be the same reason for English fan to come and support in ODIs for them....

  • POSTED BY St.John on | August 8, 2014, 6:13 GMT

    George Dobell has a great ability to hit the nail on its head; come directly to the point in a wonderful journalistic way. Quoting Ronan Keating's "You say it best when you say nothing at all." really says it all. I guess Andersson has heeded Boycott & countless others. If he continues...He will after all be remembered as England's best quickie

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 6:10 GMT

    The comment about India not caring about anything except IPL Is true but naive. It is saying that "India has no nationalistic pride" which I sure India DOES have.

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 4:38 GMT

    So what if India lose the series! CLT20 is coming up, Indian crowds are getting excited and IPL 2015 is not far either. On whole of Indian fans behalf especially Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Bangalore etc international cricket doesn't matter to us, it's ipl that counts. If you don't believe it....have a look at our packed ipl stadiums just after the 0-8 drubbing in England and Australia last tour.p

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 4:23 GMT

    Don't send your young players to play in English counties and then don't worry...

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 2:33 GMT

    Anderson becoming Kohlis biggest Nightmare I see

  • POSTED BY here2rock on | August 8, 2014, 1:50 GMT

    England bowled well under very helpful conditions, India once again misread the conditions and did not show fight at all till Dhoni came to the crease, with his limited technique he showed what was required, application at the crease and willingness to fight. Dhoni's India made even bigger mistake by picking Gambhir and Jadeja in the side. I would have played Naman Ojha and Rohit Sharma in the side. This would have given Dhoni a break from keeping and better depth in batting.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • POSTED BY here2rock on | August 8, 2014, 1:50 GMT

    England bowled well under very helpful conditions, India once again misread the conditions and did not show fight at all till Dhoni came to the crease, with his limited technique he showed what was required, application at the crease and willingness to fight. Dhoni's India made even bigger mistake by picking Gambhir and Jadeja in the side. I would have played Naman Ojha and Rohit Sharma in the side. This would have given Dhoni a break from keeping and better depth in batting.

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 2:33 GMT

    Anderson becoming Kohlis biggest Nightmare I see

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 4:23 GMT

    Don't send your young players to play in English counties and then don't worry...

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 4:38 GMT

    So what if India lose the series! CLT20 is coming up, Indian crowds are getting excited and IPL 2015 is not far either. On whole of Indian fans behalf especially Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Bangalore etc international cricket doesn't matter to us, it's ipl that counts. If you don't believe it....have a look at our packed ipl stadiums just after the 0-8 drubbing in England and Australia last tour.p

  • POSTED BY android_user on | August 8, 2014, 6:10 GMT

    The comment about India not caring about anything except IPL Is true but naive. It is saying that "India has no nationalistic pride" which I sure India DOES have.

  • POSTED BY St.John on | August 8, 2014, 6:13 GMT

    George Dobell has a great ability to hit the nail on its head; come directly to the point in a wonderful journalistic way. Quoting Ronan Keating's "You say it best when you say nothing at all." really says it all. I guess Andersson has heeded Boycott & countless others. If he continues...He will after all be remembered as England's best quickie

  • POSTED BY subcontinent-expert on | August 8, 2014, 6:13 GMT

    Yeah so what if England have not won a 50-50 world cup at all.. So what if they loose CT finals at HOME.. May be the same reason for English fan to come and support in ODIs for them....

  • POSTED BY on | August 8, 2014, 6:38 GMT

    'Letting their bowling talk', does not make much sense as England was not the team aggrieved by the decision of the disciplinary committee.

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | August 8, 2014, 7:04 GMT

    England is beginning to put together a decent side once more. I always thought that an Indian summer would be ideal rehab after the trauma of last winter, and after an uncertain start, that's the way it's looking. Not every box is ticked & there's no room for complacency. First, there is an obvious over-reliance on Jimmy & Stuart. The gulf between England's premier pair and the rest is vast. Jordan may make the grade, but he's likely to get injured with an action that looks as if it's placing enormous stresses on his frame. Woakes is better than he was last year, but he needs to move up two more bowling notches to be Test quality. Sam Robson doesn't look the part (think Mitch J v SR to realise how far away he is!); Ali has done well, but does that mean the search for a specialist spinner is now off? Buttler is fine as a bat, but does he have to keep as well? Why not play him as a specialist bat? I hope Eng. selectors do not go into self-congrat mode. This is not the finished article.

  • POSTED BY Veeru_SRT on | August 8, 2014, 7:59 GMT

    I feel !_INDIA_! going to register their 2nd victory at Old Trafford...!!!