England Lions v New Zealanders, Tour match, Grace Road May 7, 2013

Root begins captaincy examination

His young features bely a grown-up temperament and steely focus that prompted England to test Joe Root's leadership credentials
  shares 23

Sometimes the best captains never actively seek the job. They are invited to lead because others perceive qualities that they themselves regard as second nature and therefore nothing out of the ordinary. Joe Root could be one of those captains.

Root has had scant experience of leadership in his formative years, yet his elevation to the Lions captaincy against New Zealand at Grace Road on Wednesday, the final warm-up before the Lord's Test, is the latest accolade in a quite remarkable year.

Long innings of intense fortitude after his breakthrough to England's Test side have been followed by the most abundant, free-flowing form of his life - 467 runs in three first-class innings for Yorkshire, a batting talent suddenly flowering - with the excitement of the Champions Trophy and back-to-back Ashes series ahead.

But there has been so much emphasis on Root's slip-of-a-lad countenance, the impression that he is a boy amongst men, that his captaincy credentials have gained little attention. When he broke into the England team you could sense people looking at him in wonder and exclaiming: "You ain't nothing but a child." Now the child is in charge.

The official view, as expounded by Geoff Miller, the national selector, is that he had been given the role "in order to assist his development as a cricketer and provide him with valuable experience of captaincy against quality opposition". Andy Flower, England's director of cricket, is uncomfortable about the hype. But the Sun has pitched it higher, pronouncing only four Tests into his England career that he is the likely successor to Alastair Cook.

England do nothing without analysing its impact so it is fair to conclude that something is afoot. The selectors wanted Root to lead the Lions on a one-day tour of Australia last winter only to pass the job on to James Taylor when Root was called up for the full tour in New Zealand. They are grateful for a second chance. Fast-tracking young players into the England set up means that captaincy opportunities come rarely.

Root has the sort of maturity that takes time to be recognised, a serious intent which was not always noticed by his peers during his teenage years when more fast-talking, outgoing characters held sway. His strength of character emerges subtly but it is apparent to all those who deal with his cricket on a daily basis.

At Yorkshire, they were wise to his gifts. He was the youngest player ever to be awarded a scholarship to the Yorkshire Academy, at only 13. Ian Dews, Yorkshire's academy director, who has known the Root family since his playing days in the Yorkshire League, still remembers a young man who found himself pushed forward when it came to the crunch.

"He was often the youngest in the group but he never took a backward step," Dews said. "In any group of players he was the one who would lead. We would do classroom presentations on dealing with the media or time management and it would often be, 'go on Rooty, you have a go'.

"He'd have battles when he was not strong enough to hit it off the square but you knew that when he did develop as a cricketer they would struggle to get him out. When he practices, he does so to the finest detail."

Andrew Gale, Yorkshire's captain, can expect to see little of Root for the rest of the season, but he recognises his influence on and off the field. His unbeaten 182 against Durham, followed by 236 against Derbyshire, fashioned two victories that have stabilised Yorkshire's start to their Championship campaign, but Gale knows that his value goes deeper than that. "He's 22 and he's a big voice in our dressing room," Gale said. "He speaks like a 35-year-old."

Paul Farbrace arrived at Yorkshire as second XI coach, after more high-profile spells as Sri Lanka's assistant coach and Kent's director of cricket, eager to concentrate on player development again. He has grown to admire Root's qualities. "He is so committed to learning and understanding the game he will make an excellent captain," Farbrace said. "Underneath that exterior is a very hard-working, steely, gutsy character.

"He speaks his mind more than some might imagine. He has always had strong opinions and is foremost in speaking up and expressing his views. He has a great desire for knowledge; he is an absolute sponge.

"The toughness you see when he is batting goes through is always apparent. He is up there with Kumar Sangakkara when it comes to working hard on his technique. He is the absolute benchmark for any kid. He is full of hard work and dedication."

Cricket has fascinated Root since childhood and his immersion in it gives him many of the qualities inherent in a good captain. He is a natural believer in setting goals, both individually and for the team. His dedication and, latterly, his achievements work in his favour when it comes to commanding respect. So too does a belief in his even-handedness and equilibrium. If he can find the same mental stimulation in captaincy he does in batting, he can make a success of the job.

In choosing captains, England no longer place much store by charisma. Ted Dexter had charisma in the 1960s but if the game drifted, Dexter could drift too, practising his golf swing at square leg. What some people saw as charisma in David Gower was condemned by the Yorkshire sage Geoffrey Boycott as flippancy. Mike Brearley, who was briefly replaced by a superficially more charismatic captain in Ian Botham, later observed: "Charisma seems to me to be a most limited asset for a captain."

When it comes to it, what England require from a captain is somebody steadfast, patient and analytical; somebody who can develop naturally from knowing his game to knowing the game. On Thursday, they will begin to discover whether Joe Root is that man.

David Hopps is the UK editor of ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | May 8, 2013, 10:11 GMT

    'England do nothing without analysing its impact so it is fair to assume that something is afoot'. Absolutely, David! To date, what do we know from observation about JR? He has a sound & developing technique & temperament to match; isn't fased by stepping onto the bigger stage; plays in context; seems not to possess an outsize ego; conducts himself with quiet self-confidence; is happy to bowl tidily when required, & fields very well indeed. What do we learn from articles such as this? That he is a serious student of the game in practice & in theory; keen to learn more & has a mind that challenges & a social confidence that demands that he speaks up & expresses his views. Captaincy material? No brainer. He ticks all the boxes. England is very lucky to have such a young man & with some years ahead under Cook's captaincy, JR will only get better, more complete. It is, IMO, highly unlikely that he will not be England's captain when Cook calls it a day (but that may not be this decade!).

  • POSTED BY landl47 on | May 7, 2013, 20:32 GMT

    It's way too soon to know if he will even be a good test player, let alone a captain of England. However, he has shown both good technique and good temperament up to now. The real test will come when he has a bad run. If he reacts like Alastair Cook, never gives up, works hard and comes out the other side a better player, then he'll be a bona fide star.

  • POSTED BY AKS286 on | May 10, 2013, 19:21 GMT

    @ Jadejafan on (May 8, 2013, 7:44 GMT) Every Individual is different fella. Unfair to compare one individual to another. Umar Akmal is dropped by PCB in all format. Nasir Hussain , M.Taylor, Sherwin Campbell are the worst player of ODI (No Shame to tell). I don't understand how these players played for soo many years. Talent & leadership skills are different things. Root is for future so Eng has to groom from today. remember Ponting groom PuP and CA is looking for smith. @RandyOz Australia win or loss it does't matter the matter is where is khawaja.

  • POSTED BY HatsforBats on | May 9, 2013, 11:05 GMT

    @ Selassie-I, I saw a bit of Root in India and NZ. He looked composed and correct but his scoring was quite restricted each time. Temperament and technique are critical so hopefully he continues to improve. Cook was always pencilled in as captain, not sure Flower can take credit for that. And to be honest, the options were fairly limited. I was inquisitive about Cook's tactical acumen and I think his odi performances have been very positive.

  • POSTED BY jackiethepen on | May 8, 2013, 18:16 GMT

    I watched Joe Root bat at Durham when he put together a very good stubborn innings. You wouldn't say he stands out if you didn't know his England connections. Quite a few County players have played some good innings this season so far. But they are completely ignored. He is a quiet player, patient, and has already benefitted from batting with England stars. He is obviously more confident. But greater tests will come. Not quite sure why he has been given the captaincy of the Lions nor why Hopps and the Sun see him as a future captain of England. He has shown no flair for it so far. Cook is an excellent player - the best - but he is a lousy captain unfortunately and he was exposed in New Zealand when he just ran out of ideas and put everyone back on the boundary. We are stuck with Cook because of the infantile idea that captaincy has no special skills of its own. Nasser and Brearley have been our best captains so far.

  • POSTED BY Selassie-I on | May 8, 2013, 17:44 GMT

    @Posted by HatsforBats on (May 8, 2013, 12:48 GMT) I don't know if you have ever seen him bat, but he certainly looks like he has the test temprament and technique, and the ability to improvise when needed for OD cricket.

    I shoudl think that this is what Andy Flower and co have looked at, rather than stats. I don't know about you, but I'm not arguing, he's made some pretty decent selectorial decisions, overall. Not sure if you were one of these guys complaining when he made Cook captain, if so then we thought you might have learned from that.

  • POSTED BY HatsforBats on | May 8, 2013, 13:48 GMT

    You can't help but feel they are rushing the kid. Sure, he looks promising with good technique, maturity and it sounds like he's a hard worker, but he has hardly set the world alight. His short test career is distinctly mediocre and prior to this year his FC career average was about 32, hardly beating the door down demanding selection. Was there no one else? No other seasoned journeyman (26-29) averaging 40+ who'd put in the years of dedication and deserved the reward of a test cap? I would actually like to hear some opinions on his selection from those in the know.

  • POSTED BY CricketMaan on | May 8, 2013, 10:28 GMT

    Clarke debuted against India with a debut 100, went on to captain Aussies. Kane Williamson did it, might captain Kiwis one day, Root came close to a 100 and will now lead Lions. India surely knows how to make debutants a champion stuff albiet its from the opposition camp!!

  • POSTED BY Cyril_Knight on | May 8, 2013, 8:48 GMT

    I haven't seen Root live yet, only on TV, so reserve some judgement until then, but he looks special.

    Like the best Test batsmen he has an unassuming style, he blocks and leaves well and puts the bad ball away. But two things set him apart from the other young talents; he has all the shots (back foot, front foot, drives, pulls) and crucially has the ability to change the tempo of his innings to suit the situation.

    I'm pretty sure he will be slowly promoted up the batting order for England to become the regular opener with Cook, hopefully by this time next year.

  • POSTED BY Mattzo12 on | May 8, 2013, 8:46 GMT

    @deep6321. Of Root's 6 FC hundreds 3 of them have been 186, 222* and 236. If that's not converting starts what is?

    He has the potential to be an England great. Let's hope he realizes that potential.

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | May 8, 2013, 10:11 GMT

    'England do nothing without analysing its impact so it is fair to assume that something is afoot'. Absolutely, David! To date, what do we know from observation about JR? He has a sound & developing technique & temperament to match; isn't fased by stepping onto the bigger stage; plays in context; seems not to possess an outsize ego; conducts himself with quiet self-confidence; is happy to bowl tidily when required, & fields very well indeed. What do we learn from articles such as this? That he is a serious student of the game in practice & in theory; keen to learn more & has a mind that challenges & a social confidence that demands that he speaks up & expresses his views. Captaincy material? No brainer. He ticks all the boxes. England is very lucky to have such a young man & with some years ahead under Cook's captaincy, JR will only get better, more complete. It is, IMO, highly unlikely that he will not be England's captain when Cook calls it a day (but that may not be this decade!).

  • POSTED BY landl47 on | May 7, 2013, 20:32 GMT

    It's way too soon to know if he will even be a good test player, let alone a captain of England. However, he has shown both good technique and good temperament up to now. The real test will come when he has a bad run. If he reacts like Alastair Cook, never gives up, works hard and comes out the other side a better player, then he'll be a bona fide star.

  • POSTED BY AKS286 on | May 10, 2013, 19:21 GMT

    @ Jadejafan on (May 8, 2013, 7:44 GMT) Every Individual is different fella. Unfair to compare one individual to another. Umar Akmal is dropped by PCB in all format. Nasir Hussain , M.Taylor, Sherwin Campbell are the worst player of ODI (No Shame to tell). I don't understand how these players played for soo many years. Talent & leadership skills are different things. Root is for future so Eng has to groom from today. remember Ponting groom PuP and CA is looking for smith. @RandyOz Australia win or loss it does't matter the matter is where is khawaja.

  • POSTED BY HatsforBats on | May 9, 2013, 11:05 GMT

    @ Selassie-I, I saw a bit of Root in India and NZ. He looked composed and correct but his scoring was quite restricted each time. Temperament and technique are critical so hopefully he continues to improve. Cook was always pencilled in as captain, not sure Flower can take credit for that. And to be honest, the options were fairly limited. I was inquisitive about Cook's tactical acumen and I think his odi performances have been very positive.

  • POSTED BY jackiethepen on | May 8, 2013, 18:16 GMT

    I watched Joe Root bat at Durham when he put together a very good stubborn innings. You wouldn't say he stands out if you didn't know his England connections. Quite a few County players have played some good innings this season so far. But they are completely ignored. He is a quiet player, patient, and has already benefitted from batting with England stars. He is obviously more confident. But greater tests will come. Not quite sure why he has been given the captaincy of the Lions nor why Hopps and the Sun see him as a future captain of England. He has shown no flair for it so far. Cook is an excellent player - the best - but he is a lousy captain unfortunately and he was exposed in New Zealand when he just ran out of ideas and put everyone back on the boundary. We are stuck with Cook because of the infantile idea that captaincy has no special skills of its own. Nasser and Brearley have been our best captains so far.

  • POSTED BY Selassie-I on | May 8, 2013, 17:44 GMT

    @Posted by HatsforBats on (May 8, 2013, 12:48 GMT) I don't know if you have ever seen him bat, but he certainly looks like he has the test temprament and technique, and the ability to improvise when needed for OD cricket.

    I shoudl think that this is what Andy Flower and co have looked at, rather than stats. I don't know about you, but I'm not arguing, he's made some pretty decent selectorial decisions, overall. Not sure if you were one of these guys complaining when he made Cook captain, if so then we thought you might have learned from that.

  • POSTED BY HatsforBats on | May 8, 2013, 13:48 GMT

    You can't help but feel they are rushing the kid. Sure, he looks promising with good technique, maturity and it sounds like he's a hard worker, but he has hardly set the world alight. His short test career is distinctly mediocre and prior to this year his FC career average was about 32, hardly beating the door down demanding selection. Was there no one else? No other seasoned journeyman (26-29) averaging 40+ who'd put in the years of dedication and deserved the reward of a test cap? I would actually like to hear some opinions on his selection from those in the know.

  • POSTED BY CricketMaan on | May 8, 2013, 10:28 GMT

    Clarke debuted against India with a debut 100, went on to captain Aussies. Kane Williamson did it, might captain Kiwis one day, Root came close to a 100 and will now lead Lions. India surely knows how to make debutants a champion stuff albiet its from the opposition camp!!

  • POSTED BY Cyril_Knight on | May 8, 2013, 8:48 GMT

    I haven't seen Root live yet, only on TV, so reserve some judgement until then, but he looks special.

    Like the best Test batsmen he has an unassuming style, he blocks and leaves well and puts the bad ball away. But two things set him apart from the other young talents; he has all the shots (back foot, front foot, drives, pulls) and crucially has the ability to change the tempo of his innings to suit the situation.

    I'm pretty sure he will be slowly promoted up the batting order for England to become the regular opener with Cook, hopefully by this time next year.

  • POSTED BY Mattzo12 on | May 8, 2013, 8:46 GMT

    @deep6321. Of Root's 6 FC hundreds 3 of them have been 186, 222* and 236. If that's not converting starts what is?

    He has the potential to be an England great. Let's hope he realizes that potential.

  • POSTED BY Jadejafan on | May 8, 2013, 8:44 GMT

    He is very promising but so overrated especially by the English. Umar Akmal, Kane Williamson and Nasir Hossain is more talented than him.

  • POSTED BY Harlequin. on | May 8, 2013, 8:26 GMT

    @deep6321 - he looks like a player who won't convert good starts? I couldn't disagree more with that! Regularly getting out after you have got in is usually a sign that you have switched off, and everything I have seen/read/heard about Joe Root is that his mental attitude is second to none. But you're right, it should be a good series coming up, the NZ and Aus attacks should give him a chance to prove his mettle more than the Indians did.

  • POSTED BY on | May 8, 2013, 7:27 GMT

    Deep 3621 - he's had the County (I know it's' only county) starts and converted them to huge doubles.

  • POSTED BY deep6321 on | May 8, 2013, 6:49 GMT

    I have been waiting for this series.I am waiting to see If NZ can continue their good form earlier at home.Some good players coming in NZ side.looks a perfectly balanced side to me.Surely they will deliver..

  • POSTED BY deep6321 on | May 8, 2013, 6:16 GMT

    Joe Root is good player.But I dont think he will be good test player.He looks like a player who always gets starts and fails to get big scores.

  • POSTED BY deep6321 on | May 8, 2013, 6:10 GMT

    England are going to be rooted by boult and bracewell and wagner. NewZealand will have a great series victory

  • POSTED BY SirBobJones on | May 8, 2013, 1:36 GMT

    New Zealand are going to be rooted.

  • POSTED BY on | May 8, 2013, 0:00 GMT

    Trust the Press to put so much weight on this young man's shoulders! Good luck to him, but give him a chance to learn and grow strong through failure. There's one thing on his side: he's a Yorkshireman, where they breed them tough!

  • POSTED BY on | May 7, 2013, 22:47 GMT

    You've got to feel sorry for young English players, the English media hypes them up ridiculously and then tears them down when they don't live up to the hype. I wish all the best for him, but so far haven't seen any amazing test match skills.

  • POSTED BY R_U_4_REAL_NICK on | May 7, 2013, 22:34 GMT

    Oh come now RandyOZ, you were just saying on other threads what a great prospect Bopara is and how Australia badly need players with his talent...

    "England do nothing without analysing its impact so it is fair to conclude that something is afoot..." - Really? Anyone believe that? I can think of a few selection blunders over the last few years that dispel that wishful thinking.

  • POSTED BY RandyOZ on | May 7, 2013, 22:05 GMT

    Sadly he is the only half decent looking prospect for England, the rest are either South African or non-existent. The inevitable slide continues.

  • POSTED BY 2.14istherunrate on | May 7, 2013, 20:34 GMT

    There is tendency to not let people develop at a sane pace. Root has been fast tracked into Tests and ODI's at a very young age. There are other ways in which a 21 yr old needs to develope regardless of cricket-eg life, and giving him the Lions' captaincy already may just be a step too far. He just needs to Joe Root for a bit and develope in away that is natural.

  • POSTED BY ozziespirit on | May 7, 2013, 19:12 GMT

    He looks like a very good English captain in the making.

  • POSTED BY ozziespirit on | May 7, 2013, 19:12 GMT

    He looks like a very good English captain in the making.

  • POSTED BY 2.14istherunrate on | May 7, 2013, 20:34 GMT

    There is tendency to not let people develop at a sane pace. Root has been fast tracked into Tests and ODI's at a very young age. There are other ways in which a 21 yr old needs to develope regardless of cricket-eg life, and giving him the Lions' captaincy already may just be a step too far. He just needs to Joe Root for a bit and develope in away that is natural.

  • POSTED BY RandyOZ on | May 7, 2013, 22:05 GMT

    Sadly he is the only half decent looking prospect for England, the rest are either South African or non-existent. The inevitable slide continues.

  • POSTED BY R_U_4_REAL_NICK on | May 7, 2013, 22:34 GMT

    Oh come now RandyOZ, you were just saying on other threads what a great prospect Bopara is and how Australia badly need players with his talent...

    "England do nothing without analysing its impact so it is fair to conclude that something is afoot..." - Really? Anyone believe that? I can think of a few selection blunders over the last few years that dispel that wishful thinking.

  • POSTED BY on | May 7, 2013, 22:47 GMT

    You've got to feel sorry for young English players, the English media hypes them up ridiculously and then tears them down when they don't live up to the hype. I wish all the best for him, but so far haven't seen any amazing test match skills.

  • POSTED BY on | May 8, 2013, 0:00 GMT

    Trust the Press to put so much weight on this young man's shoulders! Good luck to him, but give him a chance to learn and grow strong through failure. There's one thing on his side: he's a Yorkshireman, where they breed them tough!

  • POSTED BY SirBobJones on | May 8, 2013, 1:36 GMT

    New Zealand are going to be rooted.

  • POSTED BY deep6321 on | May 8, 2013, 6:10 GMT

    England are going to be rooted by boult and bracewell and wagner. NewZealand will have a great series victory

  • POSTED BY deep6321 on | May 8, 2013, 6:16 GMT

    Joe Root is good player.But I dont think he will be good test player.He looks like a player who always gets starts and fails to get big scores.

  • POSTED BY deep6321 on | May 8, 2013, 6:49 GMT

    I have been waiting for this series.I am waiting to see If NZ can continue their good form earlier at home.Some good players coming in NZ side.looks a perfectly balanced side to me.Surely they will deliver..