England v NZ, 1st Investec Test, Lord's, 3rd day

Baby-faced Root shows maturity

The youngest player on either team, Joe Root appeared the senior man during a potentially match-defining partnership with Jonathan Trott

George Dobell at Lord's

May 18, 2013

Comments: 6 | Text size: A | A

Joe Root and Jonathan Trott put together a solid stand as England built a lead on the third afternoon, England v New Zealand, 1st Investec Test, Lord's, 3rd day, May 18, 2013
Joe Root and Jonathan Trott put on the highest partnership of the match so far © PA Photos
Enlarge

There must be something disconcerting about being thwarted by Joe Root. Like being held at gun point by a toddler, there is something incongruous about the baby-faced batsman providing such mature resistance.

Root, the youngest player on either side, has not just produced the highest innings of this match to date but may well have struck the defining blow. His stand of 123 with Jonathan Trott is the single century partnership of the game so far and England's only half-century stand. The lead is still only 205 but, on a pitch that is providing substantial assistance for the offspin of Kane Williamson, England may well hold the trump card with Graeme Swann to bowl in the fourth innings. He will rarely have conditions more in his favour.

The true value of the partnership between Root and Trott was put into context by what preceded and followed it. Just as New Zealand lost their last seven wickets for just 60 runs (including six for 52 in the morning session) so England lost four wickets for 12 runs in 39 balls once Root was dismissed by Tim Southee's well-disguised offcutter. Such evidence would suggest that this slow pitch remains desperately demanding for batsmen. Scoring the highest total of the match in the fourth-innings - which New Zealand may well have to do - will not be easy.

The notable feature of Root's innings was how few of his runs came from drives. All eight of his boundaries came square, or just backward of square, of the wicket and only one run came in the V between mid-on and mid-off. He pulled or hooked the fast bowlers particularly well, cut the spinner nicely and, despite one or two misunderstandings with Trott, maximised their scoring opportunities with some swift running between the wickets.

Perhaps England had some fortune. Root and Trott batted through the only period of sustained sunshine in the game and New Zealand struggled to obtain the swing they had generated in the first innings. On the face of things, the loss of Bruce Martin, the left-arm spinner, to a calf strain in the evening session might have been a body blow to New Zealand as well, though it actually brought Williamson into the attack. Bowling his offspin quicker and a little straighter than Martin, he immediately proved more demanding. Swann will have observed with interest.

Trott's suitability for such situations needs little reiteration. Suffice it to say, his sound defence and determined temperament render him an ideal player to negate a striving attack in match-defining situations and he has now scored a half-century at least in all seven of his Tests at Lord's. But, so impressive was Root that he looked the more assured of the pair for much of their partnership. It was a remarkably calm display from a man not just in his fifth Test but playing his first game at any level at Lord's. Both his younger brother and father have played at this ground before him.

 
 
Trott's suitability for such situations needs little reiteration but so impressive was Root that he looked the more assured of the pair for much of their partnership
 

Perhaps he was helped by that family influence. His younger brother, Billy, is in the England dressing room for this game, fulfilling 12th man duties, while his parents and grandfather were among the spectators at the ground. But such aids are peripheral: when it comes down to facing international bowlers such as Neil Wagner - a man who surely looked older than Root even in his prenatal scans - he is all on his own. He coped admirably.

It may prove relevant that Root's best performances to date - this game and his debut match against India in Nagpur - have taken place on unusually slow wickets. Perhaps, when international teams have had a chance to analyse his technique, he will undergo a fallow period and certainly the Australia pace attack will provide a different test. But whatever happens, Root has underlined the impression that he is a young man with a long future at this level.

Such is his apparently unflappable temperament and his ability to adapt his game to the differing demands he has faced - he has also impressed in his ODI opportunities - that few would bet against him finding a way to overcome whatever obstacles life presents. Forget the boyish exterior - really, he might struggle to be served in one of the bars on this ground - where it matters, in his head, he is as cool and calm as anyone.

His success is also testament to the system that helped produce him. Root had not enjoyed an especially outstanding season in 2012 but, such was the good impression he had made while involved in the England Lions set-up, he won selection on the Test tour to India. It has proved an inspired decision and one for which the England selectors and staff - particularly Graham Thorpe, who pinpointed his attributes - deserve much praise. It might also prove a timely reminder of the worth of the Lions system, imperfect and inconvenient to the domestic game though it may sometimes appear.

"We played exceptionally well for the majority of the day and hopefully we can take that confidence into tomorrow and get a good partnership in early," Root said afterwards. "It's very disappointing not to finish as strongly as we would have liked, so the first hour tomorrow will be crucial.

"The rough outside the right-handers' off stump is encouraging and Graeme Swann will look at that and enjoy it. The pitch is quite slow and is obviously deteriorating. The longer we can stay out there the harder it will for them."

Some will suggest that his most recent success again poses a threat to Nick Compton. It is true that Root, coming in at No. 4 due to Ian Bell's incapacitation with "flu-like symptoms", has played as an opener for Yorkshire and that, in time, he may well move up to perform the same role for England. And it is true, too, that Compton, late on a pleasing inswinger from Wagner, has done his case few favours in this game.

But England's success in recent years was not built on cut-throat selection and it is not so long since Compton contributed back-to-back centuries in New Zealand. It is encouraging to have options and the likes of Varun Chopra, James Taylor and Ben Stokes ensure that a healthy competition for places remains.

George Dobell is a senior correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: George Dobell

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Herbet on (May 19, 2013, 18:58 GMT)

Root is an opener. He looks a far better player than Compton and he and Cook will form a long term partnership. Whether or not it starts this summer depends on how many runs Bairstow gets at Headingley compared to Compton. Roots first class average is comprised from games played entirely in damp English summers (there has not been a dry one since he became professional) against the new ball. It is worth noting how many runs he has scored for the Lions, not only a level up, but also on better batting pitched. That some young Pakistani's average nearly 50 on feather beds is an irrelevance.

Posted by Herbet on (May 19, 2013, 18:53 GMT)

gsingh7 "Hick left cricket altogether". Hick did leave cricket, at the age of 41, proud owner of over 130 fc centuries. Root is not overhyped, just like Strauss, Cook, Trott, Bell, Pietersen and Prior weren't.

Posted by gsingh7 on (May 19, 2013, 13:42 GMT)

root is overated by english press. previously ravi bopara and graeme hick were overrated by the same press and look where they are nowadays. hick left cricket altogether. young talents these days are kohli, pattinson, pujara or miller who have better skills to succeed at highest level. root have to improve leaps and bounds to reach these players level let alone legends like sachin , kallis or ganguly

Posted by   on (May 19, 2013, 9:53 GMT)

Jadeja fan:

Yes, both those players have impressive records and have a lot of potential - but that doesn't been Joe Root is overrated. Statistics are only relevant in context, and scoring while 40 odd, and 70 odd won't give him an amazing batting average, in the context of a low scoring game on a tough wicket they're absolutely crucial. For a young player to be the one who steps up in difficult conditions while senior players struggle is impressive. And I think that is why people are getting excited - not because they've read he averages 35 on his cricinfo profile.

Posted by Jadejafan on (May 19, 2013, 8:05 GMT)

Joe Root is promising but really overrated youngster by the English. There are 2 players his age who are a bit younger and better than him - Umar Akmal and Nasir Hossain. We all know the talent Umar Akmal possesses but Nasir Hossain averages 45 in both ODIs and Tests after playing 20 innings in both forms while Joe Root is not even close yet people making a big deal out of it.

Posted by jmcilhinney on (May 19, 2013, 2:22 GMT)

It will be interesting to see where Root eventually settles into the England batting order. He's given the impression so far that he would be fairly comfortable pretty much anywhere. Given his performance here and for the Lions, he looks a possibility at #3 as well. It certainly depends how Compton performs longer-term and who else is coming through as an opener, whether Root ends up opening.

It certainly is an important point worth noting that most of Roots boundaries came square of the wicket. The England bowlers looked better on day 3 when bowling a fuller length and they need to ensure that that continues come NZ's second innings. Taylor also looked strong square and we know that McCullum is likely to murder anything short, so England need to make sure that those two in particular don't get easy pickings.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
George DobellClose
Tour Results
England v New Zealand at The Oval - Jun 27, 2013
No result
England v New Zealand at The Oval - Jun 25, 2013
New Zealand won by 5 runs
Kent v N Zealanders at Canterbury - Jun 22, 2013
N Zealanders won by 42 runs
England v New Zealand at Cardiff - Jun 16, 2013
England won by 10 runs
Australia v New Zealand at Birmingham - Jun 12, 2013
No result
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days