England v Pakistan, 2nd npower Test, Edgbaston

Sorry Pakistan crumble for new low

The Report by Andrew McGlashan

August 6, 2010

Comments: 92 | Text size: A | A

England 112 for 2 (Trott 31*, Pietersen 36*) lead Pakistan 72 (Anderson 4-20, Broad 4-38) by 40 runs
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details


Stuart Broad successfully appeals for the wicket of Azhar Ali, England v Pakistan, 2nd Test, Edgbaston, August 6, 2010
Stuart Broad took four wickets as Pakistan found themselves in another huge hole at Edgbaston © PA Photos
Enlarge

Pakistan were poor in the first Test, but were even worse at Edgbaston as they crashed for 72 on the opening day - a new low against England five days after setting the previous record - with their threadbare batting skittled by the hosts' three quicks. Stuart Broad and James Anderson took four wickets apiece while Steven Finn collected two against some feeble resistance before England moved to 112 for 2 by the close, already a lead of 40, with Pakistan's woes compounded by another shoddy fielding display.

It was a desperate effort from the visitors and made Salman Butt's decision to bat first in ideal bowling conditions look foolish. Butt insisted he was making a positive move - and signs of uneven bounce suggested he wasn't entirely wrong - but he wasn't backed up by the mindset of the batsmen who, after twice collapsing at Trent Bridge, were purely focused on survival and showed virtually no intent. Nine runs came in the first hour - and four of those off one shot from Butt - and when wickets fell the scoreboard hadn't gone anywhere.

Better batting line-ups than Pakistan would have struggled, but Imran Farhat and Azhar Ali combined to face 56 balls between them without making a run and England were never forced to move away from Plan A. The highest partnership was 27 for the seventh wicket between Umar Amin and Mohammad Amir before Anderson made it 15 wickets in his last three Test innings to deny Broad a five-wicket haul after he'd made the top-order inroads.

England's progress in reply wasn't without problems as conditions remained helpful. Alastair Cook, who was reprieved by the UDRS after being given lbw to Mohammad Asif, continued his poor form when he managed to deflect a loopy bouncer to second slip off the back of the bat when he was far too early on a pull. Andrew Strauss then departed as the review system benefited Pakistan after umpire Steve Davis failed to spot an inside edge.

Pakistan's zero-sum game

  • Pakistan's first-innings total of 72 is their joint fourth-lowest in Tests, and their worst against England. It's Pakistan's 12th sub-100 total in Tests, of which six have come since 2002.
  • Pakistan's innings contained five ducks, which is only the third instance of five or more zeroes in a Pakistan innings.
  • Only three Pakistan batsmen have faced more deliveries in an innings of zero than Azhar Ali's 32. Imran Farhat, who made a 24-ball duck, is in joint sixth place.
  • Collectively, Pakistan's five batsmen who failed to score faced 70 deliveries, which is second-highest for a single innings, next only to Geoff Allott's famous 77-ball effort for New Zealand against South Africa in 1999.
  • It's also the first time in Test history that two of the top three batsmen have scored ducks in an innings, and consumed more than 50 deliveries in doing so.
  • The last time Pakistan played more than 30 overs in an innings and scored at a slower rate was more than 20 years ago, in January 1990, when Australia bowled them out for 107 in 65.5 overs (1.62 runs per over).

However, Pakistan had another dreadful time with dropped catches. Jonathan Trott was shelled at first slip by Farhat when he had 8 - a regulation chance - and Kevin Pietersen, on 9, was put down at mid-on by Umar Gul as he charged Saeed Ajmal. Gul had to stretch, but it wasn't much of an effort. Pietersen was then dropped a second time on 20 by Zulqarnain Haider, the debutant keeper who earlier collected a first-ball duck, when he couldn't hold an inside edge.

Pietersen also flashed an edge between keeper and slip off the luckless Ajmal but by the time bad light ended play he was beginning to look far more settled at the crease with a sign of a strut returning. Trott, as has been his style this season, moved along in unobtrusive but effective style, which was no mean feat in testing conditions.

It was immediately clear that England's bowlers would find plenty of help and the demise started in the eighth over when Farhat feathered an edge off Broad, who was back on the ground where he took 8 for 52 for Nottinghamshire a couple of weeks ago. Anderson, in his 50th Test, again made the ball do what he wanted with swing both ways as he left Butt playing at fresh air.

However, it was Finn who removed the Pakistan captain when an uncertain push outside off resulted in a regulation edge to Graeme Swann at second slip. The best grab of the morning, though, came from Matt Prior when he flung himself across in front of first slip to snaffle Shoaib Malik's outside edge and hand Anderson a deserved wicket. The nick would have carried to Strauss so Prior took a gamble, but committed himself fully to the dive and, like the slip cordon, is very safe these days.

Compared to what had come before, Umar Akmal launched his innings with a blaze of strokeplay with six runs off his first two balls before he whipped Broad over the deep square-leg boundary. It was a different story for Azhar, who couldn't even score off half volleys before being trapped lbw by one that nipped back from Broad. Azhar considered using a review but after some advice from Umar trudged off and replays confirmed the appeal would have been upheld - if only just - with the impact marginally inside the line of off stump.

Umar, who at least was playing a few shots, could have saved himself with a review but opted not to ask after Finn trapped him lbw with one that scooted through. Umar had moved so far across his stumps that he was struck outside the line and the third umpire would have been able to overturn the on-field decision.

Zulqarnain couldn't have made his debut in tougher conditions and received a lovely first delivery from Broad that grazed the outside edge. After lunch, Amin and Amir at least tried to show some aggression and Amin was given a life when Swann spilled a rare chance at second slip.

Amir, meanwhile, was reprieved by the UDRS when HotSpot showed an inside edge after he was given lbw to Anderson, although there was a suggestion the mark was made by bat hitting pad. However, it was only going to be a matter of time before England completed the job and Broad's fourth ended Amin's fighting effort and Broad was eyeing his fourth five-wicket haul until Anderson cut through the long tail.

It really was a sorry state of affairs for Pakistan as Mohammad Yousuf, who ruled himself out yesterday after his long-haul flight, watched their latest embarrassing demise from the dressing room.

Andrew McGlashan is an assistant editor at Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: Andrew McGlashan

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by   on (August 7, 2010, 11:42 GMT)

I wonder what form of lubrication Pakistan are using on their hands before taking the field - the ball just doesn't stick - from a marketing point may be one of the major oil companies can sponsor the Pakistan for their slippery efforts!

Posted by satanswish on (August 7, 2010, 11:20 GMT)

If Pakistani fielders can hold their catches, they can still give England better fight. Bowling is exceptionally good, but their fielders & batsmen are just pathetic.

Posted by pakistaniblood on (August 7, 2010, 10:51 GMT)

My question is why was Yasir Hameed sent in 16 if he was not to be played. Anyone else could be sent but why him who is not to be considered while Pakistan has collapsed miserably for 2nd time and will continue to do that again and again. I will say very much as expected because with averages of 30 you cannot expect better from them. And with continuously failing Imran Amin and Azhar and team still persisting with them, no one can understand why. What is so special with them and is there any reprimand. One reason is that Salman himself has alkways been a failed undeserving batsman/captain and will never improve for sure because he does not have the qualities and skills (he is not saeed anwar) and obviously a failed batsman will not like to have better players than him in side. This is very true although Salman will never be comfortable. Secondly which country has lowest test batting averages. It is Pakistan and Bangladesh. Now it is a tie between these two. This is all because of PCB.

Posted by   on (August 7, 2010, 10:27 GMT)

wrong decision to drop kamran, he iis and forever be the greatest wicketkeeper batsman pakistan has ever produced...

Posted by   on (August 7, 2010, 10:23 GMT)

India should stop playing matches against newbie teams and should have the guts to play with teams like england ,aussie and south africa....or they are scared?

Posted by   on (August 7, 2010, 10:21 GMT)

This is disspointing,I am an Indian and I am very happy that my team won today,fighting it out when everyone wrote them off in this series,the much lampooned bowling attack bowled there heart out and set up the game which then batsmen fought to win,but I am very sad to see Pakistan crumble like dis,I wanted all the Asian teams to play and dominate world cricket.Whatever is wrong with Pakistan cricket need to be adressed or its going to be determental for test cricket in general.I think Pakistan need dedicated and sincere players,the reason India is no1 in tests because you have players like Laxman,Dravid,Sachin,Sehwag,Dhoni who have impeccable behaviour in the dressing room,that automatically rubs on the younger players.Unless u have role models to look uo to,how come youngsters going toget inspired and perform.

Posted by ashraja on (August 7, 2010, 9:11 GMT)

What a Disgrace! Since Ijaz Butt has been in charge, we have been a laughing stock in cricket. What was the whole point in rushing MoYo to the UK when he was not going to even play the 2nd Test!!! They should have said they will try to sort out his visa and send him to the UK but he will not be available until the 3rd Test.

Imran Farhat is useless. He should not be selected to play Tests anymore. Yasir Hameed needs to be given a chance. He has a great temperament and is a great fielder.

Pakistan cricket will not be successful until players start getting picked on merit. I have said it before. Azher Ali can be a good Test batsman and we should continue with it but exposing him like this will damage his cricketing career.

What the hell was Butt thinking when he won the toss and decided to bat 1st?!? IT WAS CLOUDY AND PERFECT FOR SWING/SEAM BOWLING!!!

Ijaz Butt, do us all a favour and jump off a cliff..........

Posted by   on (August 7, 2010, 8:06 GMT)

I think Pakistan must relinquish its test status and stick with ODI's and Twenty20's. They can't play test cricket anymore. Ijaz Butt should be fired and Imran Khan should be the new man in-charge.

Posted by sawarsi on (August 7, 2010, 8:05 GMT)

they dont hav patience !!!!! where are all the karachiites??????? they are better fielders and better batsmen then these guyz!!!!!!!!

Posted by sha720 on (August 7, 2010, 8:04 GMT)

i thing only Pakistan team has debut players in test matches ,just see the Raina debut test after the 98 ODI matches than see his performance in test matches this is good decisions this want Pakistan team as well as pls getup PCB see want happen for the around the world and make decision quickly. don't practice WC this way preparation is surly Pakistan out for the first round on the WC.PLS ask Former Players idea And doing best pls.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Andrew McGlashanClose
Andrew McGlashan Assistant Editor Andrew arrived at ESPNcricinfo via Manchester and Cape Town, after finding the assistant editor at a weak moment as he watched England's batting collapse in the Newlands Test. Andrew began his cricket writing as a freelance covering Lancashire during 2004 when they were relegated in the County Championship. In fact, they were top of the table when he began reporting on them but things went dramatically downhill. He likes to let people know that he is a supporter of county cricket, a fact his colleagues will testify to and bemoan in equal quantities.
Tour Results
England v Pakistan at Southampton - Sep 22, 2010
England won by 121 runs
England v Pakistan at Lord's - Sep 20, 2010
Pakistan won by 38 runs
England v Pakistan at The Oval - Sep 17, 2010
Pakistan won by 23 runs
England v Pakistan at Leeds - Sep 12, 2010
England won by 4 wickets (with 3 balls remaining)
England v Pakistan at Chester-le-Street - Sep 10, 2010
England won by 24 runs
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days