England v Pakistan, 2nd npower Test, Edgbaston, 1st day August 6, 2010

Battered Pakistan fold on day one

12

Review of the day
Andrew Strauss laughed knowingly on the eve of the Test when asked if he was learning whose judgment he could trust in matters of UDRS referrals, and whose he could not. On the evidence of the day's first over, Strauss had presumably bracketed James Anderson in the former category, seeing as he agreed to take a second view of a somewhat speculative lbw appeal from only the second ball of the day. In fairness, it pitched in line and only just skimmed over the top of middle stump, but given that the onfield decision would have stood in the event of a borderline verdict, it was still a bit of a waste.

Review of the day Mk 2
Talking of which, Strauss himself had an unfortunate brush with the big screen when his own turn came to bat later in the day. He had moved along to 25, the highest score at the time on another crazy day, when Amir zipped a full-length delivery back towards his body and through to the keeper amid a blur of deflections. England's captain stood his ground, albeit somewhat sheepishly, as Zulqarnain Haider - showing impressive judgment for a debutant with a first-ball duck to his name - insisted on using a review. Sure enough, the ball had clearly jagged off Strauss's gloves on its way past his body, and he was sent on his way to a mild ripple of admonition.

Debutant of the day
That moment aside, the most memorable day of Zulqarnain's life soon ended up as one he'd prefer to forget. Shortly before lunch he snicked an off-stump delivery from Broad to become the 55th batsman to make a golden duck in their first Test innings, and in the evening session he dropped a leg-side catch off Kevin Pietersen that was the exact replica of the only thing that his predecessor behind the stumps, Kamran Akmal, had got right in the course of his shocking match at Trent Bridge. Then as now, the bowler was Umar Gul, who zipped one off the seam to find the inside edge. But where Kamran clung on, Haider made a hash.

Comeuppance of the day
After a flawless performance from the cordon at Trent Bridge, Graeme Swann - aka Mr Second Slip - had a premonition of events to come. "It was the worst possible start we could have done," he said during the build-up to the second Test, "because now everyone thinks were are going to catch everything!" Lo and behold, who should bring an end to their 100% series record than Swann, who was fooled by a Stuart Broad delivery that squared up Umar Amin and squirted off a leading edge straight into his midriff ... and out again. One ball later, Amin edged once again, but this time for four as the ball looped clear over the cordon's head.

Clanger of the day
At least Swann could say that his let-off wasn't costly, as Pakistan were already six-down at the time, and the reprieved Amin was dismissed four overs later. Imran Farhat, on the other hand, had fewer reasons to be exonerated. Not only were his bowlers busting a gut to keep their team in the game, having extracted both openers on 44, and created this next opportunity 10 runs later, but he had committed a near-identical sin at Trent Bridge last week, when he dropped England's centurion, Eoin Morgan, early on the second day. This time the sinned-against bowler was Asif, who did well not to lamp his team-mate in his follow-through, as a regulation nick went to ground at first slip.

Shot of the day
Umar Akmal does not believe in waiting for the ball. He believes there is no ball that is unplayable. Already he had picked off six runs including a clipped four off the first two balls he faced. So when Broad pitched full but on an unthreatening length slightly outside leg stump, Umar used his strong and supple wrists to flick it over deep square-leg for a surprising six, half an hour before the lunch break. It was an aberration in an otherwise perfect nose-dive of an innings, as he soon ended up as part of Pakistan's lunchtime scoreline of 37 for 6.

Run-rate of the day
Until Akmal arrived to apply a relative measure of humpty to the innings, Pakistan had limped along to 12 runs for three wickets in 14.2 overs. England, by contrast had no such agonies when their chance came soon after lunch. By the time Andrew Strauss and Alastair Cook had picked off a boundary apiece in the first over of Mohammad Amir's reply, they had scored more runs, 9, in four deliveries than Pakistan had managed in 10 overs. Their eventual total of 72 was their joint fourth-lowest total in Tests, and the second time in a week that they had improved on their worst effort against England.

Andrew Miller is UK editor of Cricinfo.

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Acton49 on August 7, 2010, 10:38 GMT

    masood69, how can you not blame Salman for this happinings, he won the toss and with the bowlers at his disposal elected to bat. What! did Waqar had any input? He was a bowler and with the overcast condition even a novice would have opted to field. This was the chance of a lifetime to repeat the Aussie magic of 88 all out. But no! We (Salman, Waqar, Aqib and Ijaz) has a better idea of your fragile looking batting! You are doing your utmost to reduce your world class attack to dispair... do you think that Younis in the slips would have spilt the chance. Please read the review.... it makes a mockery of test match cricket. After a long time we get a four test series and what do we do! send out most inexperience team ever! Who should take the blame!

  • on August 7, 2010, 10:27 GMT

    wrong decision to drop kamran, he iis and forever be the greatest wicketkeeper batsman pakistan has ever produced...

  • masood69 on August 7, 2010, 6:03 GMT

    You can not blame salman butt for all these happening. The toss was very vital and after wining toss they should go for fileding becuase the wicket had moisture and cloudy condition. I m pretty sure that in the morning, Waqar, Aijaz and Salman must have check the pitch condition and decided what to do if u win the toss. Waqar is very senior and experience and he can guide to the captain. if Pakistan would have taken fielding then the situation could be apposite like australia at leads. I m pretty sure if pakistan would have done fielding first then england would have 80 all out and pakistan would have been on driving seat. but unfortunately pakistan is looser now. i dont understand whats the role of waqar and aijaz what they are doing as senior men. they should guide to salman otherwise!!!!!!! 4-0 is the result.

  • on August 7, 2010, 4:04 GMT

    Get Farhat and Amin removed from the team.they nedd some time

  • Sajeesh.M.S on August 7, 2010, 2:48 GMT

    I think it is better to bring Younis into the side not only because of his batting abilities but also due to his fielding. He is a very good ground fielder, better than anyone in the current pakistan team. Only the Y's combination can rescue pakistan,not sure of Yusuf's fielding abilities though.

  • simon_w on August 7, 2010, 2:28 GMT

    Re. Review of the day Mk 2 - the ball came off the bat and then onto the hip, which is why it didn't immediately look out to the umpire. It didn't go anywhere near the gloves "on the way past his body" - were you watching a different ball?

  • Zohaib.R.Q. on August 6, 2010, 21:37 GMT

    pakistani batting line-up makes it very difficult for fans like us to like them. winnig the toss, even a five year-old would have bowled on this wicket:P

  • Acton49 on August 6, 2010, 20:16 GMT

    If it takes a person to speak good English to be Pakistan team captain then PCB has got their man! At what cost to Team Pakistan! If to say that if we had held on to our chances then we would have done this or that... What is then the difference between Yusuf's captaincy in Australia, where we lost due to dropped catches and Salman's captaincy in the two test against England but Salman's insistence in not accepting that the youngster are out of the depth. Why then elect to bat in an overcast, cloudy morning with the bowlers in your armoury; the only reason why Salman chose to bat was to put down Yusuf's arrival and to say to the world that look we can do without the Younis and Yousef. How many years do the two great batsmen left, two - three years, then by all means draft youngster. Get Younis and Yousuf, push Azhar / Umar Amin or Malik to open with Salman, you have youth and experience. Now go and get Younis for the 3rd and 4th Test.

  • on August 6, 2010, 19:45 GMT

    Akmaljr. has hit breaks on his performance....there is a long way to go for him before to be considered a frontline batsmen. Maybe he needs to be dropped to develop some patience

  • on August 6, 2010, 19:42 GMT

    4-0 white wash is evident, these 11 stupids dont know how to bat and take catches.

  • Acton49 on August 7, 2010, 10:38 GMT

    masood69, how can you not blame Salman for this happinings, he won the toss and with the bowlers at his disposal elected to bat. What! did Waqar had any input? He was a bowler and with the overcast condition even a novice would have opted to field. This was the chance of a lifetime to repeat the Aussie magic of 88 all out. But no! We (Salman, Waqar, Aqib and Ijaz) has a better idea of your fragile looking batting! You are doing your utmost to reduce your world class attack to dispair... do you think that Younis in the slips would have spilt the chance. Please read the review.... it makes a mockery of test match cricket. After a long time we get a four test series and what do we do! send out most inexperience team ever! Who should take the blame!

  • on August 7, 2010, 10:27 GMT

    wrong decision to drop kamran, he iis and forever be the greatest wicketkeeper batsman pakistan has ever produced...

  • masood69 on August 7, 2010, 6:03 GMT

    You can not blame salman butt for all these happening. The toss was very vital and after wining toss they should go for fileding becuase the wicket had moisture and cloudy condition. I m pretty sure that in the morning, Waqar, Aijaz and Salman must have check the pitch condition and decided what to do if u win the toss. Waqar is very senior and experience and he can guide to the captain. if Pakistan would have taken fielding then the situation could be apposite like australia at leads. I m pretty sure if pakistan would have done fielding first then england would have 80 all out and pakistan would have been on driving seat. but unfortunately pakistan is looser now. i dont understand whats the role of waqar and aijaz what they are doing as senior men. they should guide to salman otherwise!!!!!!! 4-0 is the result.

  • on August 7, 2010, 4:04 GMT

    Get Farhat and Amin removed from the team.they nedd some time

  • Sajeesh.M.S on August 7, 2010, 2:48 GMT

    I think it is better to bring Younis into the side not only because of his batting abilities but also due to his fielding. He is a very good ground fielder, better than anyone in the current pakistan team. Only the Y's combination can rescue pakistan,not sure of Yusuf's fielding abilities though.

  • simon_w on August 7, 2010, 2:28 GMT

    Re. Review of the day Mk 2 - the ball came off the bat and then onto the hip, which is why it didn't immediately look out to the umpire. It didn't go anywhere near the gloves "on the way past his body" - were you watching a different ball?

  • Zohaib.R.Q. on August 6, 2010, 21:37 GMT

    pakistani batting line-up makes it very difficult for fans like us to like them. winnig the toss, even a five year-old would have bowled on this wicket:P

  • Acton49 on August 6, 2010, 20:16 GMT

    If it takes a person to speak good English to be Pakistan team captain then PCB has got their man! At what cost to Team Pakistan! If to say that if we had held on to our chances then we would have done this or that... What is then the difference between Yusuf's captaincy in Australia, where we lost due to dropped catches and Salman's captaincy in the two test against England but Salman's insistence in not accepting that the youngster are out of the depth. Why then elect to bat in an overcast, cloudy morning with the bowlers in your armoury; the only reason why Salman chose to bat was to put down Yusuf's arrival and to say to the world that look we can do without the Younis and Yousef. How many years do the two great batsmen left, two - three years, then by all means draft youngster. Get Younis and Yousuf, push Azhar / Umar Amin or Malik to open with Salman, you have youth and experience. Now go and get Younis for the 3rd and 4th Test.

  • on August 6, 2010, 19:45 GMT

    Akmaljr. has hit breaks on his performance....there is a long way to go for him before to be considered a frontline batsmen. Maybe he needs to be dropped to develop some patience

  • on August 6, 2010, 19:42 GMT

    4-0 white wash is evident, these 11 stupids dont know how to bat and take catches.

  • on August 6, 2010, 18:14 GMT

    im tired of this batting line up. im pak fan but they hurt to much.

  • sharprider on August 6, 2010, 17:32 GMT

    An outrageous decision (to bat first under overcast conditions) and lousy approach to batting, knowing full well that a lot was depending on him, Salman is the main culprit who seems to have no shame at all as he was seen smiling away as he led his team off the field at tea-time. It seems that no amount of criticism can sway him or his coach in terms of team-selection, proper judgement on winning the toss or organising the batting order, etc. Now, I think, it is time for the Pakistani management to take a closer look, in consensus with the experts available on hand, at the pathetic situation in which the team finds itself at this stage of the series. In order to achieve reasonable, if not super, results in the Tests, a comprehensive reorganisation is immediately required, starting with replacing the skipper followed by restructing of the batting order and subjecting all the players to rigorous catching practice.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • sharprider on August 6, 2010, 17:32 GMT

    An outrageous decision (to bat first under overcast conditions) and lousy approach to batting, knowing full well that a lot was depending on him, Salman is the main culprit who seems to have no shame at all as he was seen smiling away as he led his team off the field at tea-time. It seems that no amount of criticism can sway him or his coach in terms of team-selection, proper judgement on winning the toss or organising the batting order, etc. Now, I think, it is time for the Pakistani management to take a closer look, in consensus with the experts available on hand, at the pathetic situation in which the team finds itself at this stage of the series. In order to achieve reasonable, if not super, results in the Tests, a comprehensive reorganisation is immediately required, starting with replacing the skipper followed by restructing of the batting order and subjecting all the players to rigorous catching practice.

  • on August 6, 2010, 18:14 GMT

    im tired of this batting line up. im pak fan but they hurt to much.

  • on August 6, 2010, 19:42 GMT

    4-0 white wash is evident, these 11 stupids dont know how to bat and take catches.

  • on August 6, 2010, 19:45 GMT

    Akmaljr. has hit breaks on his performance....there is a long way to go for him before to be considered a frontline batsmen. Maybe he needs to be dropped to develop some patience

  • Acton49 on August 6, 2010, 20:16 GMT

    If it takes a person to speak good English to be Pakistan team captain then PCB has got their man! At what cost to Team Pakistan! If to say that if we had held on to our chances then we would have done this or that... What is then the difference between Yusuf's captaincy in Australia, where we lost due to dropped catches and Salman's captaincy in the two test against England but Salman's insistence in not accepting that the youngster are out of the depth. Why then elect to bat in an overcast, cloudy morning with the bowlers in your armoury; the only reason why Salman chose to bat was to put down Yusuf's arrival and to say to the world that look we can do without the Younis and Yousef. How many years do the two great batsmen left, two - three years, then by all means draft youngster. Get Younis and Yousuf, push Azhar / Umar Amin or Malik to open with Salman, you have youth and experience. Now go and get Younis for the 3rd and 4th Test.

  • Zohaib.R.Q. on August 6, 2010, 21:37 GMT

    pakistani batting line-up makes it very difficult for fans like us to like them. winnig the toss, even a five year-old would have bowled on this wicket:P

  • simon_w on August 7, 2010, 2:28 GMT

    Re. Review of the day Mk 2 - the ball came off the bat and then onto the hip, which is why it didn't immediately look out to the umpire. It didn't go anywhere near the gloves "on the way past his body" - were you watching a different ball?

  • Sajeesh.M.S on August 7, 2010, 2:48 GMT

    I think it is better to bring Younis into the side not only because of his batting abilities but also due to his fielding. He is a very good ground fielder, better than anyone in the current pakistan team. Only the Y's combination can rescue pakistan,not sure of Yusuf's fielding abilities though.

  • on August 7, 2010, 4:04 GMT

    Get Farhat and Amin removed from the team.they nedd some time

  • masood69 on August 7, 2010, 6:03 GMT

    You can not blame salman butt for all these happening. The toss was very vital and after wining toss they should go for fileding becuase the wicket had moisture and cloudy condition. I m pretty sure that in the morning, Waqar, Aijaz and Salman must have check the pitch condition and decided what to do if u win the toss. Waqar is very senior and experience and he can guide to the captain. if Pakistan would have taken fielding then the situation could be apposite like australia at leads. I m pretty sure if pakistan would have done fielding first then england would have 80 all out and pakistan would have been on driving seat. but unfortunately pakistan is looser now. i dont understand whats the role of waqar and aijaz what they are doing as senior men. they should guide to salman otherwise!!!!!!! 4-0 is the result.