ICC Cricket World Cup 2011 / News

Ireland v West Indies, World Cup 2011, Mohali

Ireland slip at crucial moments

Nagraj Gollapudi in Mohali

March 11, 2011

Comments: 19 | Text size: A | A

The Ireland story: they held kept their grip on the game both while fielding to begin with and later while chasing the target, before control slipped away at the most crucial moments. In the morning, for 35 overs, Ireland had put West Indies under house arrest till the pirate from Trinidad - Kieron Pollard - walked in, imposed himself and forced a jailbreak.

Then, even with half their batsmen back in the dressing room with nine overs and 79 runs to go and a batting Powerplay in hand, Gary Wilson raised hopes of a victory having compiled an impressive fifty. Suddenly, he was ruled out in dubious fashion. Ireland got distracted and the Shamrock was crushed.

It was a case of so near yet so far. Even the absence of Trent Johnson, who failed to recover from a knee injury, had not deterred the Irish. Boyd Rankin had a new companion with which to share the new ball in Alex Cusack. With an agile field providing ample support both men bowled a tight line and a perfect length.

Surprisingly the West Indies opening pair of Devon Smith and Shivnaraine Chanderpaul seemed like they were carrying putters instead of bats in hand as they carefully avoided playing any big strokes. Their circumspection only helped Ireland who cashed in. After 15 overs West Indies had not lost a wicket but a score of just 50 seemed a tad too slow.

Surprisingly the greenish tinge on the pitch had predicted a lot of seam movement and some early wickets for the fast bowlers. The perceived dawn raid by the fast men never came. Far from being dejected, the Ireland bowlers kept on leveraging the advantage. After 24 overs West Indies were on a far from promising 89. Next over Kevin O'Brien picked up two wickets. By the time the ball was replaced Ireland seemed in a dominant position at 138 for 3.

To get out of the hole they had dug themselves in, the pair of Smith and Kieron Pollard opted for the batting Powerplay immediately. And that is where Ireland faltered for the first time. George Dockrell, the left-arm spinner, had been introduced past the 30-over mark, but he had already stamped his authority by dismissing Ramnaresh Sarwan in his second over. In the following over he kept Pollard under check, giving only five runs.

Gary Wilson got to a fifty off 52 balls, Ireland v West Indies, Group B, World Cup, Mohali, March 11, 2011
Gary Wilson kept Ireland afloat but departed at a crucial time © Getty Images

But for some unknown and unexplained reason he was removed. Thereafter Pollard established himself and snatched the game away from Ireland - 57 runs came in those five overs when the field was in. West Indies smacked 133 runs off the final 15 overs. Dockrell remained busy on the ropes, fetching the ball instead of delivering it.

"I have no complaints for the boys. They bowled pretty well. Coming out in the first 15 overs I know we did not pick up any wickets but they were going at less than three [an over]. That was a great effort. We picked up momentum there. We picked wickets at crucial times. But Kieron Pollard came in and played a great knock and it is hard to defend when he plays like that. We knew what power they had in the middle order and just had to try and contain them. You also have to give credit to Devon Smith the way he played. He did not find it easy to start with but he caught up coming forward in the middle overs," William Porterfield, the Ireland captain said.

He reckoned Ireland were still in the contest while they discussed the gameplan for the chase. "When we came out at half-time we it was a par score and very, very chaseable," he said. At the halfway stage Ed Joyce and Wilson had just started their union. Joyce, who had a sum of 52 runs in the previous three matches, had got off to the most fluent starts with two graceful cover drives as soon as he walked in. He continued to regale the senses with his wristy drives. Wilson was an able partner and both men steadily built a platform. Their settled minds caused distress for Darren Sammy, who was busy changing fields and swapping bowlers.

Even when Joyce left, bowled round the legs by Andre Russell, Wilson had immediately moved into a commanding position to take control. But just like he had taken the pressure off Joyce, he needed a man to stand by him. Kevin O'Brien disappointed and went for the big shots straightway and vanished quickly. Ireland could not bring the spirit of their Bangalore evenings to Mohali. Luck deserted the Irish today as Wilson perished to a questionable umpiring decision.

"We got ourselves into a pretty good position going into the last ten overs. The wicket changed a lot more than we maybe expected. It kept low and got slightly harder. We lost a few wickets at pretty crucial times. Niall and Ed partnership started the rebuilding and then Gary came and along with Ed they were going going pretty strongly till we lost a couple of wickets in the 40th over which delayed the batting Powerplay slightly which kind of set us back," was Porterfield's analysis.

Nagraj Gollapudi is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Nagraj Gollapudi


Comments: 19 
. Your ESPN name '' will be used to display your comments. Please click here to edit this.
Comments have now been closed for this article

Posted by Brendan on (March 12, 2011, 18:47 GMT)

It was obvious to EVERYONE (besides da Silva and Paul Forde) that he was trying to run the ball down to 3rd man; under those circumstances, even if it wasn't as obvious SURELY the situation of absolutely needing runs should mean the batsman gets the benefit of the doubt? Of course, this WAS obvious, so yeah; absolutely disgusting decision. And it has nothing to do with the DRS, it put the correct info there; hitting outside the line. The umpire stuffed up, that's it.

Posted by Dummy4 on (March 12, 2011, 17:25 GMT)

Stop complaining about asoka de silva he did absoulety nothing wrong. When a player ask for review it goes to the third unpire if its not absolutely clear for example two reds and 1 yellow it goes back to the unfield umpire, now tell me how many onfield umpires in this world cup change their decision. If it is was clear wilson wasnt out the third unpire would have ask asoka to change his decision he didnt so asoka was right. To many times in the past players have hiden bats behind pad and make it look like they were playing a shot well no more. Ireland played well but they loose 5 wickets for 44 runs just not good enough if u want to win a compition plus they didnt have a pollard so it would have always been difficult in the end getting to the runs. Also they were not bowling to badly at the start i just felt chanderpaul was very very poor gayle would have caused some serious concerns. I still think they are a decent competitive team just need more experience.

Posted by Dummy4 on (March 12, 2011, 8:02 GMT)

chakde irish....this team is not a minnow......hop that soon this team will b with test status!!!

Posted by Dummy4 on (March 12, 2011, 6:23 GMT)

I don't blame umpire De Silva for sticking into his original decision, UDRS has given it back to infield umpire and so he hasn't changed his original & stuck into it. We have seen so many such decisions like this in this WC. UDRS throw the decision back to infield. So the final say is with the umpire.

Posted by Prbath on (March 12, 2011, 5:17 GMT)

I am a sri lanken, but i would say Asoka De Silva is the worst umpire going around, ICC should axe him,

Posted by Dummy4 on (March 12, 2011, 4:49 GMT)

@Rakesh_Sharma- Tough luck on the Irish! However, West indies were arguably the better team. Asoka De Silva was at his controversial best, I hope he umpires all of India's matches going forward!

Posted by Dummy4 on (March 12, 2011, 4:10 GMT)

In the ICC rules and regulation what wilson did wasn't technically a shot....he just put the bat there....and any thing behind the pad is not consider a shot (check it out many ppl are given out when playing the bat behind the pad to make it look like they are playing a forward defensive stroke so that is where it came from) so u guys must also look at it from the umpires side ......although i'm west indian it was a tough one tho

Posted by Abhimanyu on (March 12, 2011, 3:58 GMT)

Irish are out of this World Cup already. Had they won this game today, They had great chance of getting to the Quarter Finals. Irish messed up both in late bowling and lower middle order batting.

Posted by Dummy4 on (March 12, 2011, 3:45 GMT)

Please check your stats. 55 runs were scored in batting PP by WI and not 57. It was wrongly written in your commentary as well.

Posted by Amit on (March 12, 2011, 3:17 GMT)

Irish didn't slip on their own. Asoka pushed them. This is the second time umpire has played spoilsport. Erasmus blatantly disregarded the 2.5 meter rule to give Chigumbura out in NZ-Zim. game. ICC needs to train these umpires to rely and use the technology.

Email Feedback Print
Nagraj GollapudiClose
News | Features Last 3 days
  • No stories yet
News | Features Last 3 days
  • No stories yet

World Cup Videos