ICC Cricket World Cup 2011 / Features

Canada v New Zealand, World Cup 2011, Group A, Mumbai

Davison woes and DRS questions

ESPNcricinfo presents the plays of the day from another one-sided Group A match, between New Zealand and Canada

Nagraj Gollapudi at the Wankhede Stadium

March 13, 2011

Comments: 3 | Text size: A | A

Hiral Patel played a brief, but attacking, innings, Canada v New Zealand, World Cup 2011, Group A, Mumbai, March 13 2011
Hiral Patel became yet another victim to the poor use of the DRS © AFP
Enlarge
Related Links

Drop of the day
Kane Williamson had just made his first run of the World Cup when he faced a simple off-break, delivered wide of the crease from around the stumps by John Davison. Erroneously, Williamson spooned a simple return catch to the bowler. But Davison, on the follow-through, messed up an easy chance as he tried catching it with upright hands. The habit of doing fielding drill with the baseball mitts at times can be a deterrent as Davison proved today. It was a schoolboy error going for the unorthodox technique when he could have taken the offering with straight hands.

If-only moment
Rizwan Cheema lined himself up at wide long-on trying to deflect Ross Taylor's third six in the most expensive over in the day by Harvir Baidwan (Taylor took 28 runs hitting four sixes and one four) . Cheema rubbed his palms at the back of his trousers in anticipation as the ball was on the descent. Suddenly he realised the ball could fly over the ropes. So in a last-minute improvisation he arched back, took the catch, but unfortunately lost his balance as he skipped over the ropes. He did jerk the ball back, but his feet had already touched the ropes. Taylor was on 47, eventually making 74. Matches turn on moments like that. New Zealand were 210 for 4. The story might have had a different narrative, but then...

The DRS moment
Hiral Patel went for a wild pull against a short-pitched delivery from Jacob Oram on the off stump. At a distance it seemed it was a hit-and-a-miss shot. But Brendon McCullum, standing behind the stumps, and Oram appealed. The umpire disagreed. New Zealand asked for a review as they were confident they heard a noise. In the absence of Hot Spot or a Snickometer, the question was how could Steve Davies (the third umpire) ascertain if the noise heard was actually ball hitting bat. Davies went on to rule Patel out. One wonders how.

Catch of the day
Ross Taylor's ridiculous one-handed effort to interrupt a thick edge from Ruvindu Gunasekera, which was flying towards the third man, until the New Zealand captain decided to raise his hand.

Can-you-believe-it moment
Clearly time has come for Davison to call it a day. That is no exaggeration if you consider the way Davison ran himself out, deciding to walk back casually once he had deflected a Jacob Oram yorker, which had trickled down to the short-fine leg. Showing no urgency to finish the run Davison started ambling initially before deciding to walk the final ten yards. Reacting to the batsman's lethargy an alert Brendon McCullum lobbed a perfect throw to knock the stumps off. It was a shocking display by the tournament's oldest cricketer, who showed little respect towards the opponent and the game.

Innings Dot balls 4s 6s PP1 PP2 PP3 Last 10 overs NB/Wides
New Zealand 153 35 12 53/1 42/0(11-15) 74/2(37-41) 122/3 1/7
Canada 167 25 3 40/2 21/1(11-15) 37/2(41-45) 77/4 1/9

Nagraj Gollapudi is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Nagraj Gollapudi

© ESPN EMEA Ltd.

Comments: 3 
. Your ESPN name '' will be used to display your comments. Please click here to edit this.
Comments have now been closed for this article

Posted by dummy4fb on (March 13, 2011, 22:31 GMT)

Pretty certain Steve Davis was the TV umpire, rather than Steve Davies...

Posted by squizdog on (March 13, 2011, 19:12 GMT)

Im not sure which game you were watching Nagraj, but the DRS should not have been used for the Hiral Patel dismissal. There was a huge noise which could be heard live!! Then slowing it down just made the noise even more prominent. No need for snicko or hot spot. It was pretty clear cut and should not have gone to the DRS anyway!!

Posted by Ellis on (March 13, 2011, 17:18 GMT)

It is long past the time for the Canadian selectors to drop Davison. His body language during this World Cup tournament has been disgraceful and matched by his bowling, batting and fielding. He cannot be a positive influence on the side from Canada. He is trading on one innings played a few years back. A younger player could not have performed worse and would have gained invaluable experience. Davison's attitude is in marked contrast to the other members of the Canadian team. Even though outgunned, they have given of their best. Nobody can ask for more.Bagai has led from the front by example and performance. He and the others deserve better than a churlish and under-performing Davison.

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Nagraj GollapudiClose

    England's limitless future

Mark Nicholas: In ODIs they have a line-up packed with power hitters down to the lower order; the 444 was not as much of a surprise as it might at first seem

Dhoni struggles to bring method to T20's madness

A refusal to play low-percentage cricket is a major ingredient in his success as an ODI finisher, but that approach is no longer fetching results in T20

Why the 444 v Pakistan was inevitable

Ahmer Naqvi: Is it surprising that a team famed for its bowling attack conceded the highest ODI total? Not if you have followed their fortunes closely

In sheep's clothing

Our photo blog looks at sweaters in cricket

News | Features Last 3 days

Dhoni struggles to bring method to T20's madness

A refusal to play low-percentage cricket is a major ingredient in MS Dhoni's success as an ODI finisher, but that approach is no longer fetching results in T20

ODI records smashed at Trent Bridge

England set a new record for the highest team total in ODIs as the runs flowed

'I don't think the selectors handled my exit properly'

Shivnarine Chanderpaul, now preparing for a second career in coaching, on not getting the farewell he thought he deserved

Lauderhill prepares for cricket's big boys

This is the first time India are officially visiting the USA, and the excitement among their local fans is tangible - even if match tickets are stiffly priced

Catch-less Amir, and the Florida biggie

Also: playing for three countries, winning from 26 for 5, and players born in the Middle East

News | Features Last 3 days

World Cup Videos