| Series | Countries | Live Scores | Fixtures | Results | News |
Features
|
Photos | Video & Audio | Blogs | Statistics | Archive | Games | Mobile | ||||||||||||||||||||
|
February 12, 2013
|
Selection dilemma awaits Clarke
|
|
|
Related Links
Ian Chappell : Spin could be Australia's Achilles heel in India
News : Clarke ruled out of final ODI Players/Officials:
Michael Clarke
Series/Tournaments:
Australia tour of India
|
|
Haywire scheduling, key retirements and a stubbornly stiff right hamstring. Even before the vagaries of the subcontinent could be considered, Michael Clarke departed for India with the palpable sense that he is embarking upon the most difficult task of his captaincy so far.
Clarke was at pains to keep his selection options as open as possible before setting off to join the squad assembling in Chennai. The loss of Michael Hussey so soon after Ricky Ponting and the redefinition of Shane Watson have left the batting in particular with a whiff of the uncertain.
Add to this Clarke's hamstring trouble, which may yet rule him out of the full squad's only warm-up match, and there was every reason to believe the captain's pronouncement that he has not stared down a greater challenge than those to come over the four Tests.
For a reminder of the difficulty, Clarke needed only to look back at the 2010 visit, a tour hurriedly upgraded from ODIs to Tests by the BCCI and finishing in a 2-0 defeat for the team then captained by Ponting. Clarke cobbled 35 runs in four innings, his torpor summed up by a Bangalore stumping in which he did not realise his foot had dragged beyond the crease line.
"Touring India is as tough a challenge as I've had in my career," Clarke said in Sydney. "Every time I've been there on a Test tour it's been extremely difficult, hence the Australian team hasn't won that much over there. So it's a huge challenge, the players know that.
"That's partly why we're trying to prepare as well as we can by sending players early to get them used to conditions, to give ourselves the best chance. We know it's going to be tough, we know how good India is, but we look forward to it."
The Australian team's calendar for 2013 is so congested that this tour is the first to start before the home international program had finished. While Clarke is somewhere in the air between Sydney and Chennai, 11 members of his squad will be commencing a two-day warm-up match.
After Clarke has arrived, the coach Mickey Arthur will still be minding a severely weakened Twenty20 team in a match against the West Indies in Brisbane. Given the jarring adjustment from Australian climes and surfaces to those that may be found in India, it is hardly the ideal way to prepare. And preparation has always been one of Clarke's favourite buzzwords.
"What I've learned in the past is how important preparation is for my personal performance," Clarke said when asked about his dire 2010 tour. "I need to make sure I've done all my training to give myself the best chance of scoring runs.
"That's what I'm looking forward to over the next few days. Getting into the Indian conditions, batting on those wickets, facing a lot of reverse swing, a lot of spin bowling, and making sure when that first ball's bowled in that first Test that I'll be as well prepared as I was for this summer.
"I'd really like to play that three-dayer. I'll be advised by Alex [Kountouris] the physio once I land in India but at this stage my plan is to play that three-dayer. There is so much time I don't think there is any doubt I'll be fit for the first Test.
"In my mind cricket-wise I feel like I need that game to spend some time in the middle in Indian conditions both batting and bowling, but also with my captaincy as well because India is such a different place to Australia. But I'll listen to the expert and see what he has to say."
Among the players who have a headstart on Clarke by way of acclimatisation time are the allrounders Glenn Maxwell and Moises Henriques, plus the young batsman and sometime legspinner Steve Smith. One of the trio is likely to be chosen in the Tests as No. 6 or 7 batsman and fifth bowling option, now Watson can no longer provide it.
"It's very open, hence we've sent 17 players in three different stages to get over there as soon as possible to prepare and get used to conditions," Clarke said. "Runs and wickets will certainly play a big part in these practice games leading up to the first Test but for a lot of guys it's more about preparation and seeing conditions."
Those conditions will vary, as will the range of questions posed by an Indian side stung by recent defeats and intent on demonstrating, in the words of Harbhajan Singh, "how we play cricket here". Clarke's leadership, as both batsman and captain, is about to face its sternest examination yet.
Daniel Brettig is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo. He tweets here
© ESPN EMEA Ltd.
| ||||||
| Comments have now been closed for this article |
||||||
Assistant editor Daniel Brettig had been a journalist for eight years when he joined ESPNcricinfo, but his fascination with cricket dates back to the early 1990s, when his dad helped him sneak into the family lounge room to watch the end of day-night World Series matches well past bedtime. Unapologetically passionate about indie music and the South Australian Redbacks, Daniel's chief cricketing achievement was to dismiss Wisden Almanack editor Lawrence Booth in the 2010 Ashes press match in Perth - a rare Australian victory that summer.
ICICI Bank M2I. Register Now and Get A Gift Offer.
Safe & simple online money transfer. Apply Now!
Buy Wisden 2013 & get a FREE Playfair
Available now at Cricshop
Clarke deserves immense credit for both the runs he's scored, and the positive way he's led a side very much in transition. With respect to Sri Lanka and West Indies, away series in India and England will provide far sterner challenges. The batting line-up is alarmingly thin on experience and proven quality, and the one thing the Aussie selectors have to do is identify the players to take them forward, and stick with them through thick and thin. Australia need to realise their pool of talent is far more modest than it was a decade ago, and they're not going to magically find great players by rotating. With Ponting and (even more importantly) Hussey gone, Watson playing just as a batsman, and a starting line-up that'll have a lot of questions to answer - whoever they pick, they may need to accept that things will get worse before they get better.
Any tour of India is demanding in any event ... Especially for those used to the hard bouncy pitches of South Africa and Australia ... where the ball tends to hit the deck and take off ... To get that in the pitches in India requires a fast bowler to put more effort in ... The pitches tend to be more suited to turners and at the same time batsmen that can play the game ... with patience ... That is why Amla and Kallis have achieved on the Indian pitches ... Australia will have a rather untested line-up in India ... with no Ponting ... No Hussey ... but then hopefully with Watson slotting in in the middle of the inninngs may give Australia some stability in the middle ... But then India are without the Wall and VVS ... So their line-up too is far from stable at England showed ... I expect a hard-fought battle between the Indians with the pace of Australia and Australia with the spin of India ... Maybe Nathan can show his true colours ... like Swann and Panesar ...
Michael is spot on and his starting line up will grace the field in the first test. It may not end that way through the series. Cowan is the key. He must and will play in the first test, but 2 failures will see his demise with Watson returning to opening. Having said that, Cowan is really suited to English conditions and must open the innings for at least 2 tests in England. Secondly, Khawaja, is also in the hot seat. No doubt very comfortable in seam conditions, but not sure with a spin friendly environment.
I'm a true Indian fan but I have always adored Michael Clarke's batting. He's one of those fluent batsmen who are easy on the eye and graceful in their strokeplay. As a captain I think he's done a great job with a team in transition Indian tour will be tough but I think India's spinners look very weak right now. Bt as article suggests the Indian side really has their back to the wall after the 2-1 defeat at home against England. There's enough talent in Indian batting dept and if they click absence of a quality spinner like Swann will cost Aussies You need good spinners and batsmen who can play spin properly to succeed here. Right now Clarke's the best batsman of the spin bowling in this Aussie side. So I hope he stays fit throughout the series and bats well because I think his wicket will affect the outcome of any match in a major way. One word for Aussie schedule of 2013, Horrific. Injuries are inevitable with this kind of workload. GL to both teams Looking fwd to a great series.
I was thinking Aus might struggle but I have had a re-think as GSinge7 has predicted India 4-0 (who was expecting that); as he as poor a predictor as Paul the Octopus was Nostradamus like I have to go for the Aussie win (2-1).
Posted byClarke comments are safe and secure. I think it must be easier for them but not tougher. They beat WI 5-0 and in good form. But India lost tests with England. We Indians feel, Australia having better bowling attack and also better fielding side. Indians new faces must adjust before giving tough competition. Though Indian batting looks solid they are inexperienced but having good cricket averages for most of the batsmen. Any time India vs Australia is best cricket to watch. We are ready for the game. Sorry guys you kangaroos do not have TV rights this time to enjoy one of the best sides play.
Posted by AKS286 on (February 14, 2013, 9:29 GMT)about 2 players first clarke- he will do nothing while batting on number 5 with tailenders. secondly Bhuvaneswar kumar he only strike with new ball. MSD hided him on pak series with old ball, no one knows how he bowl with old ball no yorkers, bouncers we have seen. after 5 overs of B.Kumar MSD is on the stumps. bowling 5 days with no pace, no yorker and bouncer with old ball IMO B.Kumar is not an ideal choice. Oz need S.Marsh & Haddin in india. Cowan, Hughes, S.marsh, clarke, Voges, haddin, watson, MJ, Pattinsn, siddle, Beer/Starc.
Posted by JoieDeVivre on (February 14, 2013, 3:31 GMT)As an Indian fan, I'm hoping India wins the series but the reality is Australia have an excellent chance of repeating the 2004 series win and that is simply because India is going through one of the most toughest phases in it's history. While the Australian top order looks a bit unsettled the biggest strengths of this Aussie line up are their fast bowlers, lower order batsmen and ever impressive skipper Michael Clarke. Fair to say Australia start as favorites to win the series despite being the guests. For India to make any impression in this series batsmen have to find form, R Ashwin needs to bowl with truck loads of patience something that was clearly missing in the series against England and finally the selectors and MS Dhoni have to be a bit bold in their selection. The series has all the qualities of being an excellent one but like I mentioned Australia clearly start as favorites and Michael Clarke can take a lot from this series specially with back to back Ashes this year.
Posted by Al_Bundy1 on (February 14, 2013, 3:18 GMT)Agree with @mzm149 - Although I would give 2-1 in favor of Australia. Kohli, Tendulkar and Sehwag will be exposed once again. Pujara will score a few runs here and there. Bhuvaneshwar performs once in a while even when conditions support him. Ishant Sharma and Dinda are quite useless bowlers. Inning defeats are awaiting India and double centuries are awaiting Clarke. Things could get better for India if our Selectors do their job and select in-form players like Jaffer, Rayudu, Rasool, Ahmed, etc. but they prefer washed out players like Tendulkar, Sehwag, Ishant and Bhajji
Posted by IndianInnerEdge on (February 14, 2013, 0:47 GMT)Clarke is right in saying this will be a tough test of his captaincy, a tour of India is always demanding. Firstly, look at the scheduling-the oz players fresh off the plane will go headlong into the test, could have done with one more practice match. I predict a close series 2-1 to Australia. India's stocks have plummetted dramatically, the pace bowling is a joke with Ishant becoming an average county trundley(think of the missed potential here) - B kuimar is a new comer-predominantly swing bowler who due to lack of pace would struggle to swing in tests, the spinners are pathetic, the batting slightly better, the fielding-the usual. all in all, good chance for Aus to walk away with the series and test out their young pace quartert