Corruption in the IPL July 28, 2013

Investigation finds 'no wrongdoing' by IPL owners

ESPNcricinfo staff
  shares 23

A two-member panel has found "no evidence of any wrongdoing" against Raj Kundra, co-owner of Rajasthan Royals, the Rajasthan Royals franchise, and India Cements, the owner of Chennai Super Kings. The panel, comprising former high-court judges, was formed to look into the involvement of the owners of two IPL franchises in corruption during the tournament.

The BCCI working committee met in Kolkata on Sunday and Niranjan Shah, a BCCI vice-president, said that the report submitted by the two retired judges, T Jayaram Chouta and R Balasubramanian, will now be forwarded to the IPL governing council.

"There is no evidence of any wrongdoing found by the judges against Raj Kundra, India Cements and Rajasthan Royals," Shah said. "The report will now be forwarded to the IPL governing council which will take a final decision when it meets on August 2 in New Delhi."

Meanwhile, Joint commissioner of police (crime) Himanshu Roy said, "The BCCI had written to us asking for the investigating officer to depose before the board. We wrote back a month ago, seeking clarification on the legal provisions of their request. But they have not replied."

The investigation into Gurunath Meiyappan, a top Super Kings official and BCCI president N Srinivasan's son-in-law, India Cements, Kundra and Rajasthan Royals' owner Jaipur IPL Pvt Ltd was sanctioned after Meiyappan was arrested by Mumbai Police and Kundra reportedly confessed to betting in IPL matches.

When asked if India Cements - the company of which Srinivasan is managing director and vice-president - has been given a clean chit in the report, Jagmohan Dalmiya, the interim BCCI chief, said: "The final call will be taken in the IPL governing council meeting. The governing council will examine the report and accordingly will take a decision. The copy of the report will be made public in due course."

Dalmiya also said that Srinivasan, who stepped aside from his duties till the investigation was complete as it included the probing of his son-in-law, will decide who will chair the governing council's meeting on August 2. The question arose because Rajiv Shukla had resigned as the IPL governing council's chairman on June 1. However, Dalmiya said he had not accepted that resignation. "I have requested him to continue," he said. "I have not accepted Shukla's resignation."

He conceded that BCCI Anti-Corruption and Security Unit chief Ravi Sawani's findings on the Rajasthan Royals players accused of spot-fixing was discussed on Sunday, but since one of the three players involved - Ajit Chandila - was still in police custody, he could not be spoken to and so the probe is as yet incomplete.

"We will wait for some time and then proceed accordingly," Dalmiya said. "Sawani is currently on leave because of his son's marriage. Let him come back."

Regarding the controversy over MS Dhoni's conflict of interest because of his involvement with player management company Rhiti Sports, Dalmiya said "nothing will be swept under the carpet".

"I had said nothing will be swept under the carpet, many were asking what happened to that," he said. "We have changed our mode of working. The players will have to declare their interest in sports management companies."

By Sharda Ugra

The BCCI's working committee meeting in Kolkata has turned an important step of "Operation Clean-Up" into something resembling "Operation Cover-Up".

BCCI vice-president Niranjan Shah said the two-member probe panel had found "no evidence of wrongdoing" against Raj Kundra, co-owner of Rajasthan Royals, and India Cements, the owner of Chennai Super Kings. Interim chief Jagmohan Dalmiya announced that the panel's report would be formally tabled at another meeting five days later in Delhi.

These facts spin out a series of questions.

Does "no evidence of wrongdoing" erase the fact that Gurunath Meiyappan, who went from being "team principal" of Chennai Super Kings to an "enthusiast" and happens to be the son-in-law of BCCI president N Srinivasan, was arrested and questioned by Mumbai Police, and that Kundra was called in for questioning by Delhi Police?

The arrest of a top-ranking team official and the questioning of a team owner about his association with bookmakers are not routine for any self-respecting sporting league. The damage caused to the IPL's credibility by these events is as much of a "wrongdoing" as the arrest of and allegations against the three Rajasthan Royals players. Both Gurunath and Kundra were in positions of authority, with access to inside information.

The next question that arises is with regards to the still-amorphous nature of the two-member probe panel that was set up to investigate the Rajasthan and Chennai honchos. To begin with, its appointment took place without a formal meeting of the IPL governing council. After the resignation of BCCI secretary Sanjay Jagdale, who was originally named on the panel, it was neither disbanded nor was there a third member chosen to replace him. It is not known whether either Gurunath or Kundra deposed before the panel and who else was questioned. Had help been sought from the Mumbai or Delhi Police, whose investigations had a two-month head-start over BCCI's own probe panel? The bazaar says the panel did approach Mumbai Police, but were refused help. Mumbai Police says that it had asked the panel a question, but nobody replied. So, what were the panel's questions and where did their answers come from?

Two conclusions emerged from Kolkata: Rajasthan Royals will benefit from the fact that they share the dock with Chennai Super Kings, the IPL's best-connected and most powerful team. If Super Kings owners are to be spared, regardless of the arrest of a key official, so will Royals'. Even though the Delhi Police chief said that Kundra had confessed to betting in the IPL. Secondly, the probe panel's report is now in the hands of the BCCI's one-man disciplinary committee, Arun Jaitley. The other two members are Srinivasan, whose company India Cements is under investigation, and Shah.

The report will then pass on to the IPL's governing council, which will meet on August 2 in Delhi, home turf for Jaitley and Rajiv Shukla, whose resignation as IPL chairman, Dalmiya said, has not been accepted.

With the IPL's standing eroded, the ground beneath the BCCI's feet is merely becoming shifting sand.

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • POSTED BY hhillbumper on | July 30, 2013, 9:53 GMT

    If the IPL is clean then unsure what it says for Indian sport. It will continue to be badly run money fest that will eventually sink the national team because India will believe its own hype. IPL should be bought under control but won't be because people are too afraid to take it on.While we are at it can one of you tell me who will win next years IPL.It must be known by someone or can you still bid for what team will win?

  • POSTED BY on | July 30, 2013, 4:18 GMT

    It is a foregone conclusion. Like Kirti Azad said, BCCI should be brought under the purview of RTI.

  • POSTED BY chetanphanse on | July 30, 2013, 3:28 GMT

    Pathetic display by BCCI. 2 judges from TN. What do we expect!!!!

  • POSTED BY maa9009 on | July 30, 2013, 3:25 GMT

    Ha Ha Ha! I have just registered to post this comment.

  • POSTED BY paapam on | July 30, 2013, 1:37 GMT

    Why is one not surprised?! Fortunately the courts have ruled that RTI is applicable to federations selecting national teams. That should set the cat amongst the pigeons!

  • POSTED BY xylo on | July 29, 2013, 22:47 GMT

    I hope nobody was surprised by this decision. That would have been very funny.

  • POSTED BY usernames on | July 29, 2013, 16:04 GMT

    I don't know what people expect. Do you folk expect the outcome to go against an organisation, even if the concerned org has done nothing wrong? I don't see why we are *this* skeptic about everything. We don't know pretty much anything about the people involved here. Yes, they run a big organisation, and yes, they make a lot of money. But what else?

    I could be wrong, of course, and they could be pulling wool over our eyes but I don't see why we're this skeptic although nothing drastic has happened in Indian cricket in a long, long time. We have some great brand ambassadors who I'd expect would come clean if something shady were going on.

  • POSTED BY IndiaNeedsBowlers on | July 29, 2013, 10:40 GMT

    Well I don't know the truth and I don't expect to get the truth. Firstly we have the Indian media (news channels, newspapers etc.) who convice the accused as quickly as blinking the eyes. Then we have probe panels which do not have any investigative/prosecuting power (so in other words complete joke) coming out and giving clean chits. Anyways my only concern is that how this harms young cricketers who are caught is the mess of Spot Fixing. Not all of them can make it big, and so quick money is seems good. But what if it is not just money, but pressure from Team owners / agents. Afterall the owners are the Employers and agents are the ones who get contracts for most of the domestic (unknown) players. Unless BCCI and IPL function transparently (and maybe I am hoping for the impossible) the only possible outcome for this controversy is "swept under the carpet".

  • POSTED BY Mumraiz on | July 29, 2013, 10:11 GMT

    Might is Right...very much expected outcome..!!

  • POSTED BY kishorekr on | July 29, 2013, 9:54 GMT

    ssrini - you may be the ex (and immediate future?) BCCI President himself, right? Please understand, the BCCI probe holds no water whatsoever. It is an eyewash/hogwash/trash all rolled into one.

  • POSTED BY hhillbumper on | July 30, 2013, 9:53 GMT

    If the IPL is clean then unsure what it says for Indian sport. It will continue to be badly run money fest that will eventually sink the national team because India will believe its own hype. IPL should be bought under control but won't be because people are too afraid to take it on.While we are at it can one of you tell me who will win next years IPL.It must be known by someone or can you still bid for what team will win?

  • POSTED BY on | July 30, 2013, 4:18 GMT

    It is a foregone conclusion. Like Kirti Azad said, BCCI should be brought under the purview of RTI.

  • POSTED BY chetanphanse on | July 30, 2013, 3:28 GMT

    Pathetic display by BCCI. 2 judges from TN. What do we expect!!!!

  • POSTED BY maa9009 on | July 30, 2013, 3:25 GMT

    Ha Ha Ha! I have just registered to post this comment.

  • POSTED BY paapam on | July 30, 2013, 1:37 GMT

    Why is one not surprised?! Fortunately the courts have ruled that RTI is applicable to federations selecting national teams. That should set the cat amongst the pigeons!

  • POSTED BY xylo on | July 29, 2013, 22:47 GMT

    I hope nobody was surprised by this decision. That would have been very funny.

  • POSTED BY usernames on | July 29, 2013, 16:04 GMT

    I don't know what people expect. Do you folk expect the outcome to go against an organisation, even if the concerned org has done nothing wrong? I don't see why we are *this* skeptic about everything. We don't know pretty much anything about the people involved here. Yes, they run a big organisation, and yes, they make a lot of money. But what else?

    I could be wrong, of course, and they could be pulling wool over our eyes but I don't see why we're this skeptic although nothing drastic has happened in Indian cricket in a long, long time. We have some great brand ambassadors who I'd expect would come clean if something shady were going on.

  • POSTED BY IndiaNeedsBowlers on | July 29, 2013, 10:40 GMT

    Well I don't know the truth and I don't expect to get the truth. Firstly we have the Indian media (news channels, newspapers etc.) who convice the accused as quickly as blinking the eyes. Then we have probe panels which do not have any investigative/prosecuting power (so in other words complete joke) coming out and giving clean chits. Anyways my only concern is that how this harms young cricketers who are caught is the mess of Spot Fixing. Not all of them can make it big, and so quick money is seems good. But what if it is not just money, but pressure from Team owners / agents. Afterall the owners are the Employers and agents are the ones who get contracts for most of the domestic (unknown) players. Unless BCCI and IPL function transparently (and maybe I am hoping for the impossible) the only possible outcome for this controversy is "swept under the carpet".

  • POSTED BY Mumraiz on | July 29, 2013, 10:11 GMT

    Might is Right...very much expected outcome..!!

  • POSTED BY kishorekr on | July 29, 2013, 9:54 GMT

    ssrini - you may be the ex (and immediate future?) BCCI President himself, right? Please understand, the BCCI probe holds no water whatsoever. It is an eyewash/hogwash/trash all rolled into one.

  • POSTED BY hayagriva on | July 29, 2013, 9:48 GMT

    This is a win for the team owners... a loss for cricket. The ills of betting still continue and will probably continue in the future. Fans give so much to the game. They deserve to be given a clean game. Always.

  • POSTED BY ssrrini on | July 29, 2013, 8:33 GMT

    Every one getting confused with two different case here. One is betting and the other spot fixing. The clean chit being given to owners on "Spot Fixing" not betting. Spot fixing case is handled by Delhi Police, while betting is handled by Mumbai Police. Media for its convenience doing a mix and match of the two different cases. I have not seen a single article in print or electronic media to differentiate the two.

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | July 29, 2013, 8:17 GMT

    I'm always suspicious of negative statements or assertions ( 'no evidence of wrong-doing' is subtly differerent from stating 'everything is legal, above board & transparent'). Remember that this report was the work a couple of retired judges (with a third seat left vacant) appointed by the BCCI to investigate an agenda set by them! What else would you expect appointees to come up with? That is not a forensic investigation, as indeed, the speed of their adjudication would suggest. It has the look of a rubber-stamp about it to me. Furthermore, the retired judges' summation doesn't seem to chime with ongoing criminal investigations which are going to be forensic in approach as they (& not this report) will be subject to due process. Thank you, Sharda, for staying on this case. It can't be easy as you'll be blanked or sent round in circles by those who really, really, don't want the truth to see the light of day. Your operaton should be called Operation Exposure! Bon courage.

  • POSTED BY Naresh28 on | July 29, 2013, 8:07 GMT

    OK so lets move on now. BCCI could be stronger if both Dalmiya and Srinivasan run it.Spot fixing cases still need sorting out. The IPL can breath again.

  • POSTED BY CricPuli on | July 29, 2013, 0:34 GMT

    Does it need to be three people in the panel? I'd say that even one is enough if he does the job cleanly. There is no spot fixing from what I have heard so far. So, let us move on for the sake of the game.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 20:34 GMT

    I am a CSK fan.But I am appalled at this outcome. Thankfully only BCCI probe is over and not the Delhi police and Mumbai police probe.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 16:47 GMT

    While it takes decades for people to be convicted or come out clean. I am amazed, how quickly these owners have got the judgement.

  • POSTED BY VJGS on | July 28, 2013, 15:53 GMT

    Thank God that CSK is clean and safe. The good thing about the panel was that it was made of High Court Judges and not some dirty politicians, so we can know for certain that there is nothing suspicious that happened behind the scenes.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 15:01 GMT

    There is no Spot-Fixing by the owners.. So no harm done to IPL. But owners should avoid betting.

  • POSTED BY indianpunter on | July 28, 2013, 14:37 GMT

    Clean chit to everyone. Did anyone think otherwise? All is well in the IPL. 3 more years to Srini ! Bring it on !!

  • POSTED BY IndianEagle on | July 28, 2013, 14:16 GMT

    One thing that comes to my mind on reading this is "if you keep arresting the people who place betting on sports you have to arrest lakhs of people" -judges during ipl spot fixing. We all know betting is not big offense in india. May be judges panel felt that betting has nothing to do with spot fixing, may be their finding reveals that they had no role in spot fixing. With all these and above statement by the court is clearly more than enough to give clean certificate to them. finally some relieve.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 14:02 GMT

    It is fair enough to believe two judges panel than the media, which literally convicted RR and CSK at their own whims and fancies. Now BCCI should appoint a panel to investigate the behavior of the media over the entire episode!

  • POSTED BY ODI_BestFormOfCricket on | July 28, 2013, 13:36 GMT

    This is expected one.Clearly guruntath's arrest was motivational, under the influence by some powerful factors. Why i reiterates this from very start is bcz he was neither owner and not the share holder. Even honuorable high court too said 'dont arrest people who puts money on betting' bcz betting simply not the big offense. Unlike kundra, Gurunath didnot even get a enough time to explain his position. The timing of the arrest was most notable, day ahead of ipl final causes moral blow to CSK and eventually lost the match.

    Some may ask, probe by Delhi and Mumbai police is still under way how could ret.judges manage to submit their report? Police investigating all aspects, judges panel only investigated whether gurunath and kundra had any role in spot fixing.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • POSTED BY ODI_BestFormOfCricket on | July 28, 2013, 13:36 GMT

    This is expected one.Clearly guruntath's arrest was motivational, under the influence by some powerful factors. Why i reiterates this from very start is bcz he was neither owner and not the share holder. Even honuorable high court too said 'dont arrest people who puts money on betting' bcz betting simply not the big offense. Unlike kundra, Gurunath didnot even get a enough time to explain his position. The timing of the arrest was most notable, day ahead of ipl final causes moral blow to CSK and eventually lost the match.

    Some may ask, probe by Delhi and Mumbai police is still under way how could ret.judges manage to submit their report? Police investigating all aspects, judges panel only investigated whether gurunath and kundra had any role in spot fixing.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 14:02 GMT

    It is fair enough to believe two judges panel than the media, which literally convicted RR and CSK at their own whims and fancies. Now BCCI should appoint a panel to investigate the behavior of the media over the entire episode!

  • POSTED BY IndianEagle on | July 28, 2013, 14:16 GMT

    One thing that comes to my mind on reading this is "if you keep arresting the people who place betting on sports you have to arrest lakhs of people" -judges during ipl spot fixing. We all know betting is not big offense in india. May be judges panel felt that betting has nothing to do with spot fixing, may be their finding reveals that they had no role in spot fixing. With all these and above statement by the court is clearly more than enough to give clean certificate to them. finally some relieve.

  • POSTED BY indianpunter on | July 28, 2013, 14:37 GMT

    Clean chit to everyone. Did anyone think otherwise? All is well in the IPL. 3 more years to Srini ! Bring it on !!

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 15:01 GMT

    There is no Spot-Fixing by the owners.. So no harm done to IPL. But owners should avoid betting.

  • POSTED BY VJGS on | July 28, 2013, 15:53 GMT

    Thank God that CSK is clean and safe. The good thing about the panel was that it was made of High Court Judges and not some dirty politicians, so we can know for certain that there is nothing suspicious that happened behind the scenes.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 16:47 GMT

    While it takes decades for people to be convicted or come out clean. I am amazed, how quickly these owners have got the judgement.

  • POSTED BY on | July 28, 2013, 20:34 GMT

    I am a CSK fan.But I am appalled at this outcome. Thankfully only BCCI probe is over and not the Delhi police and Mumbai police probe.

  • POSTED BY CricPuli on | July 29, 2013, 0:34 GMT

    Does it need to be three people in the panel? I'd say that even one is enough if he does the job cleanly. There is no spot fixing from what I have heard so far. So, let us move on for the sake of the game.

  • POSTED BY Naresh28 on | July 29, 2013, 8:07 GMT

    OK so lets move on now. BCCI could be stronger if both Dalmiya and Srinivasan run it.Spot fixing cases still need sorting out. The IPL can breath again.