India A v WI A, 3rd unofficial ODI, Bangalore

Edwards states comeback case with ton

The Report by Kanishkaa Balachandran

September 19, 2013

Comments: 30 | Text size: A | A

West Indies A 312 for 9 (Edwards 104, Johnson 54, Unadkat 5-55) beat India A 267 for 8 (Aparajith 78, Yuvraj 61) by 45 runs
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

Kirk Edwards celebrates his century , 3rd unofficial ODI, Bangalore, September 19, 2013
Kirk Edwards' knock was a typical one-day innings - steady building followed by acceleration © WICB Media
Related Links

After West Indies A were hammered in the opening one-dayer, they had just one day to regroup against an India A side high on confidence and a captain who made a stirring comeback ton. For the second game in succession, West Indies lost the toss, but it wasn't a bad thing as their batsmen batted the hosts out of the game to take the series 2-1. 'A' tours are essentially auditions for the national side and West Indies ended the series with two gains. The relatively unknown Jonathan Carter sent a message to the selectors with a century in the second match and in the third, Kirk Edwards sent them a reminder with a comeback ton.

The tour had a lot of context for Edwards, who said ahead of the series that he was looking to build on this opportunity to make a comeback. He last played for West Indies in May 2012 and his previous ODI appearance was a year earlier. Though he has played an equal number of Tests and ODIs, indications have been that the selectors see a bigger role for him as a Test batsman. Having juggled both one-day and four-day captaincies so far, Edwards was relieved of the duty in the shorter format to allow him to focus on his own batting and give Kieran Powell experience at leading a side.

Edwards was guilty of not converting his starts in the first two matches. On Sunday, he edged to the keeper after making a brisk 19; on Tuesday he moved to 36 after smashing a six over square leg but was stumped down the leg side the following ball while trying to repeat the stroke. Today, he held back, initially preferring to play from the crease. Three boundaries off Yuvraj Singh, through the off side and over midwicket, got him going.

What would have helped settle Edwards early was the start provided by the openers. Kieran Powell, who had struggled to push on in the earlier matches, made a conscious effort to force his way into form, risking his wicket with a few top edges. When Edwards walked in at No. 3, he had the cushion of 74 runs made in just over 13 overs.

The start rubbed off on Jonathan Carter and Leon Johnson as well, who shared stands of 66 and 93 with Edwards. Edwards' knock was a typical one-day innings - steady building followed by acceleration. He focused on taking singles, and as his fifty approached, had the confidence to waltz down the track to the offspinner Yusuf Pathan and loft over deep midwicket. He reached the mark with a massive six over long-on that was headed perilously close to the press box windows.

Edwards took apart the part-timers, cutting the offspin of B Aparajith past the wicketkeeper and short third man for boundaries. Johnson's more aggressive knock at the other end put West Indies on the path to a big score and after he was dismissed, caught at cover, Edwards took control.

He was helped by questionable field placements by Yuvraj after the 40th over. With no Powerplay restrictions, India had as many as five fielders in the ring on the off side, with three in the deep on the leg side. It worked against India as the bowlers repeatedly used length deliveries against the set Edwards, who picked the gaps past point and cover with ease and bludgeoned a six over the clubhouse roof to hasten his progress towards a century.

Siddarth Kaul was punished for 23 in an over, and without any protection in the deep on the offside, Edwards picked him for three consecutive boundaries. He acknowledged his century with a simple raise of the bat and the knock was a confidence-booster ahead of the three unofficial Tests, which he will captain. He was bowled for a run-a-ball 104 off a yorker from Jaydev Unadkat, who took his first List A five-for, though the left-arm seamer was gifted his wickets as the batsmen looked for quick runs. West Indies made 100 runs off the last ten overs and that was enough to shut the hosts out.

The only passage that kept India in the hunt was the third-wicket stand of 112, off 117 balls, between Aparajith and Yuvraj. An estimated 11,000 filled the seats at the Chinnaswamy - the best turnout of the series - expecting another masterclass from Yuvraj. Yuvraj powered along at more than a run-a-ball, slogging the spinners several rows back. Aparajith, who replaced the out-of-sorts Unmukt Chand, made good use of the opportunity with some positive drives. A worried Powell summoned his troops for a quick chat after the stand grew. When Yuvraj played back to a straight delivery by Ashley Nurse and lost his stumps, India's resistance receded. India needed another big partnership to wrest the initiative but Yuvraj's departure proved untimely.

Kanishkaa Balachandran is a senior sub-editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Kanishkaa Balachandran

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by   on (September 20, 2013, 16:17 GMT)

@ Ravi Shankar on (September 20, 2013, 4:45 GMT)

What you predicted may come true: Veeru & Zak in tests ; and Yuvi in ODI's. But it is NOT the most desirable option. We have to develop younger players. We have to move forward, Fortunately, many options available,. Though, they may not be of the oldies' standards yet, I see enough potential in them to match or even outshine the predecessors, when their time come. They are pretty close, though. Invest in them.

Posted by SNIFFLEATHER on (September 20, 2013, 12:28 GMT)

Roach, Best, Cummins and there's a thought...

Posted by   on (September 20, 2013, 12:16 GMT)

@ Ravi Shankar on (September 20, 2013, 4:45 GMT)

Both Jadeja & Maneria are ideal replacement for Yuvi. They are better bowlers too. Even Mandeep can be an excellent replacement for batting & fielding. There are many more. They are all better fielders too. Even at the improved fitness level, Yuvi is still gasping for breath after taking a fast run or two. He is not getting younger either.

Zak is the best swing bowler we have had in years. I ahd made several posts in recent yeras saying that he should be roped in to develop "Zaks forthe future" Pleanty of 'raw stock is available for him to work with. Iswar Pandey. Mohit Sharma. Jaidev unadkat, Umesh Yadav and many more.

In both cases, I mentioned a few names at random, nameswhich came to my mind immediately. The key point is that we haveto build towards the future.

I didn't understand,why you were making a reference to CSK players, though!

Posted by Naresh28 on (September 20, 2013, 8:41 GMT)

Indian pace/seam bowlers with wicket taking instinct have been missing of late. ZAKS fitted this bill and was probably instrumental in taking India to number 1. On the horizon I only see Pandey and maybe Sandeep Sharma. Bhuvi is ok but looks fragile. Sreesanth looked like a good bowler - but what a messed up career.If India wants to get to number 1 and stay there, a greater effort needs to be done in this department. Right now the spin department is probably compensating for the other lack. CONGRATS TO WI on winning this series and India need barking up with bowling. For India the selectors are still experimenting with the bowling unit to see who's who.

Posted by jimbond on (September 20, 2013, 6:09 GMT)

@Nampally: if part timers bowl 21 overs (42% of the overs) and give 50% of the runs, its not a bad deal, especially if its on a day when the part timers were not being effective. On other days Yuvraj is certainly a wicket taker- though he was never considered much of a bowler even at the peak of his career. Kaul is certainly no part-timer, clearly he had an off day, and anyone can have an off day. In the previous matches, Unadkat was as bad- even here he was lucky. Yes, Yusuf Pathan does not perform even in local matches anymore.

Posted by KishoreMalladi on (September 20, 2013, 6:00 GMT)

Yet again familiar woes for India. Thump the opposition and tend to go over the board and lose the next ones. Of course not taking any credit away from WI for some splendid performance in all three departments of the game. The batsmen scored when it mattered, bowlers took wickets at the right time and in the end the WI prevailed. The bowling looked handicapped without any streamline impact bowler. It is also sad to note that the 3 main front line bowlers did not have that adequate experience too to handle tough situations and the other part-timers like Yusuf or Kaul were too expensive. In all an allround performance from WI after match one helped them seal the series. It is high time India learn from these performances and hope many more A tours give the cricketers the required experience and expertise to handle world class teams and competition.

Posted by   on (September 20, 2013, 4:45 GMT)

Mr. Jose puliampatta...if u want yuvi n zak to be only left fr domestic matches only den who do u want in d team ???badrinath,anirudha,n all other players 4m Csk???I agree that gauti n yusuf.doesnt dserve ny yuvi in limited overs n viru-zak in tests should n will cme back...wait n wtch..

Posted by ghostcall on (September 20, 2013, 4:43 GMT)

To all those people against Old guards, Yuvi is the best hitter then any batsman in the current India national squad and much better batting option than Sharma, Raina, Jadega..Does any one has the guts to hit six sixes in a row against Stuart Board? the shots we witnessed were hit with precise timings and skill rather than mere slogs He made us win the World 20 cup and World 50 cup and also made a contribution with decent bowling but it really appalls me that people generally forget his contribution. Yuvi is a big match player and cant be replaced with any Tom, Dick and Harry. Either Jadega, Raina , Ashwin or Sharma, some one has to sit in the dug out if we want to win the 20 WorldCup next year & 50 worldcup down under.. YUVSTRONG

Posted by   on (September 20, 2013, 0:37 GMT)

@BRUTALANALYST Using an earlier analogy of yours of Beaton being a "school kid"; let me state, Aparajit is also a "school kid", belonging to the same batch. Yusuf Pathan, stretching the analogy to the opposite extreme, is a grandpa with no teeth. And you have solid advice to the WI Captain & team management, how to beat the kid and the grandpa! Ha ha! I am just 'brutally' joking! 'Analysis', I am leaving it you, since you are good at it.

Posted by   on (September 20, 2013, 0:28 GMT)

@Abhinav Verma . Yususf had been like this for a very very long time... even for his IPL team. He is NOT a horse for the long race. He is no spring chicken either. Selectors were decent enough to give him yet another chance.(as they are doing for a few more). He doesn't have the mettle to take it. We all have to reconcile to that reality. A shame though. Let him be just an occasional entertainer for any franchise who can & is willing to spend money on him. Period.

Posted by BRUTALANALYST on (September 19, 2013, 18:34 GMT)

My only slight criticism of Powell's captaincy and the bowlers tactics today would firstly be knowing that the openers will be bowling the odd bouncer you must at least have a fine leg otherwise you allow a pressure free hook into the gap without risk. Secondly when Yuvraj was batting v Miller having mid on back for the last ball after he has hit boundaries allowed him to take simplest single to keep strike, if he had brought man up he wouldn't be able to do this and it could've baited him to go big before the last ball is even bowled potentially forcing an error(just somethings to think about if any of the setup is reading this) As mentioned before he shows great qualities as a captain especially on first outing of course Kirk also played a roll it was really great seeing their passion and fight throughout.

Posted by aclarity on (September 19, 2013, 17:53 GMT)

I hope the next time the WI Selectors sit to pick a test squad they remember Pace Matters and Pace and Movement are devastating. The current WI pace bowlers are Roach, Best, Rampaul, Sammy and Edwards. Historically, Rampaul and Edwards need a full week rest between test matches otherwise they are ineffective and prone to injury. Sammy lacks pace and does not move the ball much anymore. Our young pacers knocking at the door are Cottereal, Cummins, Beaton, Holder, Gabriel and Johnson. Isn't it time to integrate 3 or 4 of these young bowlers? At the test level, you need wickets and I don't see Sammy in the test squad. Additionally, Holder and Sammy cannot be on the same 16 man squad. These are hard choices but will it be personality over reality. I remember Holding for V. Holder and Andy Roberts dropped at the ARG. Both were correct so now we await this turning point.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 17:51 GMT)

yusuf pathan has really disappointed me. The stage was set for him to perform and show hours mettle. Instead we saw his degradation as a cricketer

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 17:17 GMT)

One more clinical performance by WI. Kirk Edwards seems to be a man on mission. Used his feats well against spinners . Carter brief stay was impressive & coupled with his bowling, won`t be surprised to see him in senior squad this Nov. Cummings very impressive with old ball,constantly hitting 140K & with intelligent use of short ball, made scoring difficult. Player to watch for future. Biggest let down was Russel, short of fitness, form & attitude. India A suffered most due to scantly bowling resources. S Kaul was overwhelmed by the situation. Baba played well ,so Yuvi. Rest of the squad not focused & gave away situations. Lot of be desired of Yuvi`s captaincy too.

Posted by Temuzin on (September 19, 2013, 17:06 GMT)

Agree with Jose Puliampatta. All seniors mentioned by him shopuld only play in A games. They are tried tested and failed/old guards. Keep them away from national side which is young vibrant and winning combo.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 16:53 GMT)

@Deepesh Mathur: Menaria is with Rajasthan Royals, practicing for CLT20.

Posted by BRUTALANALYST on (September 19, 2013, 16:07 GMT)

Cummins was again a highlight with ball altho a lil straight early on strayin onto pads. I loved the way Powell brought him back to get important wkt of Jadhav & then later totally set up Pathan with 2short balls followed by a perfect length top of off delivery cleaning him up ! Nurse was good, after the Yuvraj LBW decision that somehow wasn't given he kept his head up and carried on pluggin away before getting his man for the 2nd time clean bowled, his best game with the ball along with Permaul who also bowled great. Carter again showed he can cause a few problems, his unorthodox action in similar vain as Kevon Kooper causes batsman issues and he was unlucky twice first havin Aparajith caught behind not given & then had Russell been on the rope where he was supposed to be he would have been able to take the simple catch of Yuvraj instead he was stuck in no mans land letting him off the hook. I also thought the Indian Unadkat showed good heart right down to the last over !

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 15:52 GMT)

Ashok menaria deserved a spot, he played exceptionally well against Newzelands

Posted by ReverseSweepIndia on (September 19, 2013, 14:59 GMT)

well played WI A. They really have some good candidates knocking on selections doors provided wise men handle them properly. And to Indian selectors, if they think that they just have to turn up and they will win, they are in for big trouble. Yuvi as batsman is still class apart but he could not captain IPL franchise, not one but twice, then why make him captain? WI played better, they still would have won, but why give easy runs to opposition, let them earn it.

Posted by Paddy789 on (September 19, 2013, 14:49 GMT)

The only positive is that Yuvi is back in form, should be considered for selection at least against the home series agaisnt Australia.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:49 GMT)

Well if aparajit played aggressive then score would be 240 below with yuvi in he did right thing ,he played the rohit sharma role in here ,if rohit scores slow its tactics and if any other player scores slow its bad atitude ah?

Posted by BRUTALANALYST on (September 19, 2013, 14:47 GMT)

Another comprehensive thoroughly professional victory, had the umpires given correct decisions it would have been a thrashing as Aparajith 78 was clearly caught behind off Carter before he made 20 and Yuvraj was shown to be plumb LBW v Nurse in the 30's. However they got there chances and put W.I A under pressure, I was really impressed with Powell who mid way through this partnership called the team together and gave them a real talking too! he shows all characteristics of a great leader, calm, intelligent yet full of passion. These 4 Powell, Edwards, Cartr an Johnson r all very classy players it has been a real joy 2watch the previous 2 games much more so than the recent W.I 1st11 as they rotated strike well and put all the bad balls away. Carter like Edwards last game was a lil unlucky with his wicket but again showed intent form ball1. I believe Edwards who looks solid will find himself back in the first 11 an if Carter an Johnson keep pluggin away a call will also come there way.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:35 GMT)

congrats Windies. You are simply great.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:14 GMT)

Selfish cricket by Aparajith, I know it was his first chance in this series he might have wanted to score some runs in front of the national selectors but he played way too slow chasing 312. Such attitude might prove fatal!

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:10 GMT)

I am repeating it again; let the gesture to the old guards like Veeru, Zak, Gouti, Yuvi , Yusuf et al remain just that ; gestures, nothing more than that. We have to move FORWARD!

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:09 GMT)

The experiments with the old steam engines failed. The two "Y" - class express engines, let up the steam, cranked up the wheels and did the first trial run well. Then, it started bucking and sputtering in the next two rounds. Either failed to get on to the track, or halted with a "Thud", on the tracks before reaching the destination. Let them be shunted back to the domestic track, or be sent to the show-piece IPL tracks to entertain the crowd, who are still so fond of those past wonders.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:08 GMT)

Very happy that the West Indian cricket is picking up again. All cricket lovers will be delighted to see such young talents coming up. West Indies always had and still have a soft corner in the Indian hearts.

Posted by   on (September 19, 2013, 14:03 GMT)

Yuvi was never captaincy material. For one he is not a people person. Even when he was captaining Pune Warriors, you could see him standing aloof of the proceedings. I am glad he at least got some runs under his belt and should be a prime candidate for selection.

Posted by spant on (September 19, 2013, 13:40 GMT)

Those who believe that captain-ship has not much role to play in winning and loosing of match, must analyze the bowling changes and field placement in last 2 matches. It is a type case of using wrong bowlers at wrong time!!!

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Kanishkaa BalachandranClose
Country Fixtures Country Results
2nd ODI: India Women v SA Women at Bangalore - Nov 26
SA Women 98/4 (31/50 ov)
CA XI v Indians at Adelaide
Nov 28-29, 2014 (10:30 local | 00:00 GMT | 19:00 EST | 18:00 CST | 16:00 PST)
3rd ODI: India Women v SA Women at Bangalore
Nov 28, 2014 (15:00 local | 09:30 GMT | 04:30 EST | 03:30 CST | 01:30 PST)
Quarter-final: Central Zone v South Zone at Mumbai
Nov 29, 2014 (09:00 local | 03:30 GMT | 22:30 EST | 21:30 CST | 19:30 PST)
1st Semi-final: East Zone v North Zone at Mumbai
Nov 30, 2014 (09:00 local | 03:30 GMT | 22:30 EST | 21:30 CST | 19:30 PST)
Only T20I: India Women v SA Women at Bangalore
Nov 30, 2014 (10:00 local | 04:30 GMT | 23:30 EST | 22:30 CST | 20:30 PST)
Complete fixtures » | Download Fixtures »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days