India v England, 3rd Test, Mumbai, 4th day

Epidemic of dropped catches

Yuvraj Singh's failure to hold James Anderson at short leg right at the end of England's second innings took the missed chance count for this Test to 15 - and we've still 90 overs to play.

John Stern in Mumbai

March 21, 2006

Text size: A | A



Mahendra Singh Dhoni's horrible missed stumping of Andrew Flintoff - fatal error? © Getty Images
Enlarge

The Ashes was such a frenetic series in which no one involved had time to stop and think that the rash of dropped catches (42 in all) seemed a strangely appropriate theme.

But a change down the gears in this series (the Nagpur madness aside) has not done anything for the fielders' handling skills.

Yuvraj Singh's failure to hold James Anderson at short leg right at the end of England's second innings took the missed chance count for this Test to 15 - and we've still 90 overs to play.

India have spilled ten of those catches, including a missed stumping by Mahendra Singh Dhoni, and their total spillages for the series is approaching 20.

Assessing the damage is easily done on a bald statistical basis: India's drops cost them about 21 runs a time, England's just under 14. But in real terms, only hindsight and the final result can pass proper judgement on these aberrations.

If England win, then Dhoni's horrible missed stumping of Andrew Flintoff today - when the England captain had given Harbhajan Singh the charge - will be viewed as a seminal moment. Flintoff, who was also dropped by Yuvraj before he had scored, was on 14 at the time and finished on 50.

It could not be said that Flintoff took the game away from India as England supporters kept hoping he would. His dash at Harbhajan was the only rush of blood in a 146-ball half-century that was an exercise in self-restraint. Such abstinence would have been inconceivable two years ago but we've come to expect it from the new mature Fred, Captain Sensible and father of two.

Was he too sensible? Almost certainly but you can be sure that if Flintoff is becalmed then runs cannot be easy to come by for anyone. Paul Collingwood matched Flintoff's scoring rate while he was in which again shows that the tortoise beats the hare in these conditions.

If India draw or win, then it will be Dhoni's own reprieve by Monty Panesar that history may regard as the turning point. Dhoni had 23 at the time and hit Anderson to Panesar's left at mid-off. He certainly picked the right fielder. Panesar never looked like taking it. It wasn't a sitter but you would expect it to be taken at this level.

When Rahul Dravid was dropped by Matt Prior three balls later you sensed a momentum shift which didn't materialise. Dravid did not add to his score but Dhoni scored a further 41 and was also dropped again on 40 by Shaun Udal off his own bowling. The time-versus-runs equation is so delicate in a match like this and Dhoni was in for a further 30 overs.

Why so many drops? The Wankhede Stadium is considered by many to be a bad ground for seeing the ball, possibly because it is a relatively steep arena, the crowd is close to the field and there are no gaps between the stands.

The heat is severe too and maybe lapses in concentration might be a factor though whether that explains India missing ten chances on home soil is a moot point.

Geraint Jones, a culprit in the Ashes, has been flawless here. Yuvraj, by contrast, has put down four, three at bat-pad and one at third slip. He'll probably hit the winning runs, just to make up for them.

John Stern is editor of The Wisden Cricketer

RSS Feeds: John Stern

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
John SternClose
John Stern John Stern is editor of the Wisden Cricketer, the world's largest selling cricket magazine. Having cut his journalistic teeth at the legendary Reg Hayter's sports-writing academy in Fleet Street, he spent four years on the county treadmill for the London Times. He joined Wisden in 2001 and was deputy editor of Wisden Cricket Monthly at the time of its merger with the Cricketer in 2003 to form TWC.
Related Links

    Dhoni wins the first round in the captaincy battle

Ian Chappell: Both Dhoni and Cook have made some inexplicable blunders, but India's captain pulls ahead slightly

    TV contracts dictate daytime scheduling of Caribbean matches

Tony Cozier: It's unlikely that fans in West Indies will ever get to enjoy five-day cricket in the evening

    Why isn't Ashwin playing?

Martin Crowe: It's hard to understand how India's best spinner is being left out in favour of bits-and-pieces players

    Gower savours life in the last chance saloon

Rewind: David Gower was on the verge of being dropped for good in 1990 when he made a charismatic century against India

The Vincent punishment

Paul Ford: What incentive do other players have of confessing their involvement in fixing if a lifetime ban is all that they can expect?

News | Features Last 7 days

India look for their Indian summer

Billboards are calling the series England's Indian Summer, but it is India who are looking for that period of warmth, redemption after the last whitewash, for they have seen how bleak the winter that can follow is

South Africa face the Kallis question

Accommodation for a great player like Jacques Kallis should be made with careful consideration and South Africa cannot get carried away with sentiment

India's bowling leader conundrum

The present Indian bowling line-up will tackle its first five-Test series without the proven guidance of Zaheer Khan, their bowling captain. India had unravelled without him in 2011. Will they do better this time around?

Five key head-to-heads

From two embattled captains to the challenge for India's openers against the new ball, ESPNcricinfo picks five contests that could determine the series

Packed tours, and Shiv's late stumping

Also, best post-war win/loss record, most runs in two calendar years, most ducks in a Test, and brothers with similar numbers

News | Features Last 7 days

    India look for their Indian summer (87)

    Billboards are calling the series England's Indian Summer, but it is India who are looking for that period of warmth, redemption after the last whitewash, for they have seen how bleak the winter that can follow is

    Why isn't Ashwin playing? (69)

    It's close to inexplicable how India's best spinner is being left out in favour of bits-and-pieces players

    South Africa face the Kallis question (56)

    Accommodation for a great player like Jacques Kallis should be made with careful consideration and South Africa cannot get carried away with sentiment

    India's bowling leader conundrum (44)

    The present Indian bowling line-up will tackle its first five-Test series without the proven guidance of Zaheer Khan, their bowling captain. India had unravelled without him in 2011. Will they do better this time around?

    Five key head-to-heads (33)

    From two embattled captains to the challenge for India's openers against the new ball, ESPNcricinfo picks five contests that could determine the series