Zimbabwe in 2009 December 28, 2009

Hope floats

The return of former players to decision-making roles and the revamp of the domestic structure spell better days ahead for Zimbabwe

For the last five years the end-of-year report on Zimbabwe has grown gloomier and gloomier. Twelve months ago Steve Price wrote that just keeping the game alive against the backdrop of political chaos represented a major achievement.

And yet, a year on there are finally signs that a corner might have been turned. There's a long way to go, especially on the field, where half a decade of neglect cannot be turned around in a few months, but there are glimmers of hope.

The changes have largely been made possible by the improvement in the country's political fortunes. Zimbabwe, so long an international pariah, has started to rebuild, although the situation remains fragile, and if Robert Mugabe has one of his notorious mood swings then the dark days of 2007 and 2008 could return in weeks.

But for now, Zimbabwe Cricket, berated by many, including me, for years, deserves credit for a number of initiatives, the main one being a complete revamping of a tattered and discredited domestic structure. The old system has been swept away and heavily politicised provinces replaced with five new self-contained franchises. Time will tell how independent they are, but it's a start and the early signs are promising.

That change was allied to a decision to embrace the country's players, including those who had been at the heart of the battle with the board, and many returned as either players or coaches. Perhaps the biggest sign of returning normality was the sight of overseas cricketers such as Chris Silverwood and Steve Tikolo turning out for the franchises.

Internationally there was little to write home about. With fixtures hard to come by, the year was spent playing Bangladesh and Kenya. The results highlighted Zimbabwe's status as being too good for Associates and way short of being able to mix it with the big boys. Only four of 14 ODIs against Bangladesh were won, while only one of 10 against Kenya was lost. The three ODIs against Full Members resulted in comprehensive defeats.

Until the on-field results improve, talk of Zimbabwe returning to Test cricket is premature. Unfortunately they were a notable absentee from the ICC World Twenty20 - a competition in which they bloodied Australia's noses in 2007 - because of political tensions between England, the hosts, and the Mugabe regime.

Another reason was that Peter Chingoka, ZC's chairman, who has been in situ for almost two decades, was banned from the European Union as well as Australia and New Zealand. That caused a few dicey situations as the ICC sought a balance between backing one of its own and not risking a major standoff over someone increasingly hard to support. Common sense prevailed and Chingoka appeared to become increasingly marginalised even in his own country, handing over day-to-day control to chief executive Ozias Bvute, who embarked on a largely successful media charm offensive.

The ICC commissioned a fact-finding report from Julian Hunte, the head of the West Indies Cricket Board. The irony of someone whose own board remains a bigger shambles than the one he was supposed to be advising on caused more than a few wry smiles. The end result was the common-sense move to include a Zimbabwe side in the ICC Intercontinental Cup, as well as a number of other supportive moves from Full Members. Sadly, that generosity did not seem to spill over to neighbours South Africa, who insisted on being paid almost $100,000 to host two ODIs against the Zimbabweans in November.

New kid on the block
Twenty-year-old fast bowler Kyle Jarvis, who represented Zimbabwe at the Under-19 World Cup in 2008, was brought straight into the national side and showed enough promise to suggest he could be a feature of the team for some time. Quick if raw, he should benefit from guidance from bowling coach Heath Streak.

Fading star
It's hard not to feel for Tatenda Taibu, who was left keeping Zimbabwe's head above water, often almost single-handed, during the dark days. His talent as a keeper-batsman is not in doubt, but his fortunes off the field have sent his career into reverse. Too often he was missing from the side because of off-field rows. He refused to play in Kenya because his kit had been left in Bangladesh, and was then slapped with a 10-match ban after admitting he lied to a Harare court when accused of assaulting a ZC employee.

High point
Returning from a three-year self-imposed exile, Charles Coventry smashed an unbeaten 194 against Bangladesh in August, equalling the world record for the highest score in an ODI. His previous best in any format had been 106. Perhaps it underlined Zimbabwe's weaknesses that despite his innings boosting his side to a post-300 total they were easily beaten.

Low point
The final ODI of the year, against South Africa, was almost like watching the Zimbabwe team in the dark days of two or three years ago. South Africa eased to 331 for 5 without ever breaking sweat and then Zimbabwe all but waved the white flag as they were bowled out for 119 in under 35 overs. If anyone who matters had been watching - and the banks of empty stands suggested few were - it would have reminded them how far Zimbabwe have to go.

What 2010 holds
A real watershed, both on and off the field. David Coultart, a minister in the power-sharing government, is likely to turn his attention to cricket, but whatever happens, it has to be hoped it won't deflect too much from the advances made in 2009. With experience back on the playing and coaching side, the national team needs to start producing more consistent performances to back the goodwill the international community has for it.

Martin Williamson is executive editor of Cricinfo and managing editor of ESPN Digital Media in Europe, the Middle East and Africa

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • abe on December 31, 2009, 21:08 GMT

    Instead of berating Zimbabwe cricket we should be encouraging it.Where politics are concerned, Western countries are hypocrites.Hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians have been killed by UK/Allies airstrikes in Iraq/Afghan and these hypocrites still boycott Zimbabwe..sheesh!

  • Sachit on December 29, 2009, 22:49 GMT

    With return of players like Taibu, Price and Coventry, Zimbabwe is very near to get playing 11 that could challenge any team of the world. They are pretty good in spin department lead by Ray Price and supported by Greame Cremer and captain Utseya. Elton Chigumbura, Keith Dabengwa and skipper Prosper Utseya are good all rounders. Taibu and Matsikenyari are doing pretty good job in middle order followed by hard hitting Charles Coventry. There weakest area is fast bowling department. They have no option available as per international standards. Hope Heath Streak could groom up youngsters like Kyle Jarvis, Trevor Garwe and Ed Rainsford for the job. Opening and upper middle order also need to improve a lot. Chamu Chibhabha and Mark Vermeulen are not consistent enough and almost same is the case with Hamilton Masakadaza. Sean Williams, Forster Mutizwa, Greg Lamb and Timycen Maruma are few more names that could be tried out for different roles in batting order as well as decent part timers.

  • lucy on December 29, 2009, 19:15 GMT

    It's Coltart, not Coultart, and he's not just some minister in the Zimbabwean government, he's the sports minister.

  • Prince on December 29, 2009, 15:39 GMT

    Zimbabwe needs more games.Simple.

  • Terry on December 28, 2009, 23:28 GMT

    I think regardless of the political situation of the home side, cricket should be played against all 16 international teams for at least 3 ODI's home & 3 ODI's away. If a side has concerns about touring, it needs to be advised to ICC 12 months ahead of time, so that the series can be moved to a neutral country that is suitable to play in (eg: Aust vs Pak in England). Regarding test cricket, as Ive stated previously, there are over 100 countries playing cricket, and yet only 9 countries have chance to play test cricket. Some form of qualifying competition is needed where best of associates play against test nations in test cricket in a rotational basis. This could be as a 2 tier system or as a Test World Cup (similar to ODI world cup, with Group Stage[20], Super Eights[8], Semis[4] and Final[2]). Either way would improve competition gobally and encourage teams to compete to be promoted (instead of being politically aligned to majority of ICC board, such as Bang over Kenya in 1999-2001!)

  • Mark on December 28, 2009, 22:49 GMT

    Yes, Zimbabwe were too good for Kenya, but Kenya are far from the strongest Associate now. We'll see how they go in the Intercontinental Cup but, the fact that Afghanistan gave them a tough game suggests that they are far closer to the top flight in ODIs than in the longer format.

  • No featured comments at the moment.