June 20, 2011

Beware the Caribbean curse

As India kick off their Test series in the West Indies, a look back at a few cautionary tales from the past
18

Many of us are familiar with Jack Sparrow and the Curse of the Black Pearl. But for some Indian cricketers, especially batsmen, heading to the islands that the pirates of the Caribbean once preyed on has brought with it misfortune of another kind. Think woe in the West Indies and your mind goes to Nari Contractor and a career cruelly cut short by a fracture to the skull in Barbados. But as Abhinav Mukund and Virat Kohli prepare for their Test debuts, and Suresh Raina bids to get his career back on course, there are at least three men who could tell them which channels not to sail.

Long before Contractor, there was Madhav Apte, who outperformed even Sir Frank Worrell in scoring 460 runs at 51 on the 1952-53 tour. Opening the batting, his painstaking unbeaten second-innings 163 saved India the Trinidad Test after they had slumped to 10 for 3. But after that tour, he was never selected again, disappearing into a black hole of administrative ineptitude and bias.

On the Contractor tour, where India were hammered 5-0 by one of the all-time great West Indian sides, the Afghanistan-born Salim Durani was one of the consolations, scoring 259 runs and taking 17 wickets. In Port of Spain, where India made a match of it after conceding a big first-innings lead, he scored 104 in the second innings and had match figures of 4 for 118. But though he would represent India another decade, there would only be 19 more games and no more hundreds. The wait for an allrounder would last till 1978.

The Queen's Park Oval saw more Indian heroics in 1976. Most supporters are aware of the third Test, where India chased down 403 with just four wickets down. Brijesh Patel, who would go on to have one of the most celebrated Ranji Trophy careers, was in the middle when the winning runs were hit, but his finest hour had come a fortnight earlier at the same venue.

That forgotten Trinidad Test, saved only by Clive Lloyd's obdurate 70, saw Patel make 115. In 21 Tests, it was the only time this pillager of domestic attacks would get to three figures. As for the big picture, those two Trinidad results and the loss of Andy Roberts to injury pushed Lloyd towards the four-man-pace solution. Wayne Daniel made his debut in Jamaica, and you don't need Fire in Babylon to tell you what happened next.

In the colour-television age, we have the story of Sanjay Manjrekar, who walked in at 68 for 4 in only his third Test, at the abattoir that was the Kensington Oval. Less than 18 months earlier, Winston Benjamin had sent him to a Delhi hospital in his debut Test. Against Malcolm Marshall, Curtly Ambrose, Courtney Walsh and Ian Bishop, he made a marvellous 108, handling both pace and bounce with a veteran's aplomb. There would be two more centuries in Pakistan later that year (1989), but little to celebrate afterwards, as a career that promised so much fizzled out.

The likes of Wes Hall, Charlie Griffith, Michael Holding, Roberts and that 1989 quartet no longer await Kohli and Mukund. But as India head into a series that will reveal much about the bench strength, they can reflect on a one-day campaign where little went according to plan apart from the scoreline.

India know what they have to do in the Caribbean. Victory will be gracefully accepted - they have, after all, won only four of 42 Tests in the West Indies - but they also need to make a statement before heading to England

The standout batsman was Rohit Sharma, who at times resembled the player he was in Australia in 2008, when it seemed that India's batting would one day revolve around him. He remains on the wait list as far as a Test berth is concerned, though, and only Kohli of the other young hopefuls made any sort of impact.

Raina specialised in the Bollywood shots, and will doubtless be put through a short-ball wringer if he plays at Sabina Park. S Badrinath had a golden opportunity to cement a place, but three innings that brought to mind Lot's wife mean that he's again likely to be on the outside looking in.

The bowling, too, offered little by way of encouragement. Amit Mishra and Munaf Patel excelled in patches, but given the welter of absentees, they were likely to play anyway. Praveen Kumar remains a new-ball specialist, while Ishant Sharma's form fluctuates like the wind at Port Royal.

In the season that has seen that cinematic paean to Lloyd's side released, India know what they have to do in the Caribbean. Victory will be gracefully accepted - they have, after all, won only four of 42 Tests in Guyana and the islands - but they also need to make a statement before heading to England.

Once the five missing stalwarts return, this is a very good side, potentially a great one. But it's also a team with more than a touch of grey at the temples. For Kohli, Mukund, and even Raina, these storied venues that once resounded with the footsteps of Headley and Sobers offer a matchless opportunity to be part of the process of renewal that the team will have to go through sooner rather than later. Hopefully they can steer clear of the Caribbean curse.

Dileep Premachandran is an associate editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • arvindnandan on June 23, 2011, 7:08 GMT

    Interestingly, Dileep, you leave out Sunny Gavaskar from the discussion completely, arguably the greatest success story of Indian cricket; but for whom, our glorious ascendancy in international cricket wouldn't have begun. This success story began in Caribbean in 1971 - and its echo rings in till date. Of course, Gavaskar history is a complete antithesis to that of the 'curse'.

  • pradeep_dealwis on June 21, 2011, 9:36 GMT

    India has good bench strength, definitely as far as the batting is concerned...the bowling is average anyways, except for Zaheer, who is one of the top five bowlers in the world now.

  • donda on June 20, 2011, 19:28 GMT

    Wining a series in WI is just like stealing all the gold from pirates, its so difficult and young players from India will have to go through that toughness to become great players. To me it's as difficult to win in WI as in India. To Ian Chapel misery , it will show us how the youngster will perform if we retire all Indian batting legends today.

    Chapel will take his words back after this series. But he is stubborn. he will keep on bugging Indian cricket in Jealousy for ever.

  • on June 20, 2011, 16:34 GMT

    @esarun Abey Kuruvilla was inexplicably not selected for further series even though he fared ok. Nobody knows why he was left out and he faded away. He never had enough chances. I guess the same is going to happen to Badrinath too.

  • on June 20, 2011, 15:09 GMT

    On paper WI and India seem to be on balance. But with WI one can never be sure. They have on many occasions plucked defeat form the jaws of victory. For this Test one would expect Edwards to prove a point but if the spinners can get in India could have an uncomfortable time. Dhoni has a reputation of winning and he won't want to lose to WI because the World Champion status is at stake. So for now it look evens. The end of the first day, barring weather, will give us some indication as to where the Test is heading. WI have the edge, playing at home and the batting and bowling are good too, but don't underestimate India.

  • on June 20, 2011, 14:53 GMT

    @DeveshJinwala: Cheteshwar Pujara is missing because broke his leg in the outfield in the IPL

  • on June 20, 2011, 14:50 GMT

    Nice record of events. It's true that over the years a lot of promising careers came to a screeching halt once faced with the Caribbeans pace machine of the yore. Similarly, such highly regarded was a Caribbean success story that anyone succeeding here just went ahead of themselves as an international cricketer. Wouldn't exactly call Wasim Jaffer or Kuruvilla unfulfilled promise - Jaffer got a fair run, and did produce the riches for a while. Kuruvilla was selected 4 years too late. That's the biggest leeway all these incumbents have got: they are at an age where they can afford some mistakes, and absorb from the veterans. How quickly they learn would be defined by their ambition and set them ahead of the race.

  • MeowCat on June 20, 2011, 14:06 GMT

    England,SAfrica,India,NewZealand are the top teams right now.Ireland will come Number 1 some day aswel!!

  • esarun on June 20, 2011, 13:31 GMT

    Of players who never kept their promise, you can add Abey Kuruvilla too. He made his test debut in the Carribbean and in only his third test took a 5-for that had seemingly set up a famous Indian win in that fortress of West Indian cricket, Barbados. Leave it to our inept batsmen to make a meal of a target of 120 !!

  • KishorKumar25 on June 20, 2011, 9:42 GMT

    I think they should give a chance to mithun, In bouncy pitches of WI he ll be tough to play.

  • arvindnandan on June 23, 2011, 7:08 GMT

    Interestingly, Dileep, you leave out Sunny Gavaskar from the discussion completely, arguably the greatest success story of Indian cricket; but for whom, our glorious ascendancy in international cricket wouldn't have begun. This success story began in Caribbean in 1971 - and its echo rings in till date. Of course, Gavaskar history is a complete antithesis to that of the 'curse'.

  • pradeep_dealwis on June 21, 2011, 9:36 GMT

    India has good bench strength, definitely as far as the batting is concerned...the bowling is average anyways, except for Zaheer, who is one of the top five bowlers in the world now.

  • donda on June 20, 2011, 19:28 GMT

    Wining a series in WI is just like stealing all the gold from pirates, its so difficult and young players from India will have to go through that toughness to become great players. To me it's as difficult to win in WI as in India. To Ian Chapel misery , it will show us how the youngster will perform if we retire all Indian batting legends today.

    Chapel will take his words back after this series. But he is stubborn. he will keep on bugging Indian cricket in Jealousy for ever.

  • on June 20, 2011, 16:34 GMT

    @esarun Abey Kuruvilla was inexplicably not selected for further series even though he fared ok. Nobody knows why he was left out and he faded away. He never had enough chances. I guess the same is going to happen to Badrinath too.

  • on June 20, 2011, 15:09 GMT

    On paper WI and India seem to be on balance. But with WI one can never be sure. They have on many occasions plucked defeat form the jaws of victory. For this Test one would expect Edwards to prove a point but if the spinners can get in India could have an uncomfortable time. Dhoni has a reputation of winning and he won't want to lose to WI because the World Champion status is at stake. So for now it look evens. The end of the first day, barring weather, will give us some indication as to where the Test is heading. WI have the edge, playing at home and the batting and bowling are good too, but don't underestimate India.

  • on June 20, 2011, 14:53 GMT

    @DeveshJinwala: Cheteshwar Pujara is missing because broke his leg in the outfield in the IPL

  • on June 20, 2011, 14:50 GMT

    Nice record of events. It's true that over the years a lot of promising careers came to a screeching halt once faced with the Caribbeans pace machine of the yore. Similarly, such highly regarded was a Caribbean success story that anyone succeeding here just went ahead of themselves as an international cricketer. Wouldn't exactly call Wasim Jaffer or Kuruvilla unfulfilled promise - Jaffer got a fair run, and did produce the riches for a while. Kuruvilla was selected 4 years too late. That's the biggest leeway all these incumbents have got: they are at an age where they can afford some mistakes, and absorb from the veterans. How quickly they learn would be defined by their ambition and set them ahead of the race.

  • MeowCat on June 20, 2011, 14:06 GMT

    England,SAfrica,India,NewZealand are the top teams right now.Ireland will come Number 1 some day aswel!!

  • esarun on June 20, 2011, 13:31 GMT

    Of players who never kept their promise, you can add Abey Kuruvilla too. He made his test debut in the Carribbean and in only his third test took a 5-for that had seemingly set up a famous Indian win in that fortress of West Indian cricket, Barbados. Leave it to our inept batsmen to make a meal of a target of 120 !!

  • KishorKumar25 on June 20, 2011, 9:42 GMT

    I think they should give a chance to mithun, In bouncy pitches of WI he ll be tough to play.

  • DeveshJinwala on June 20, 2011, 8:41 GMT

    Though not part of the team (and that is surprising really), why is there no mention of Cheteshwar Pujara ?

  • nickydude on June 20, 2011, 8:19 GMT

    With due respect to Indian Batsmen, the future for piling up runs by the tons is available!. Just've a look for the countries to visit on the FTP. Aus is in shambles, Pak is as good as finished, WI is also as good as gone, same with NZ pitches, SL is safe pitch, what remains to tackle is just Eng & SA, once in 4 yrs! provided they produce the same assembly of bowlers like Steyn & Co.!

  • Godfather007 on June 20, 2011, 7:47 GMT

    Fantastic opportunity for the likes of Mukund,Kohli and Badrinath to show what they are made up of.I was disappointed with Badrinath after his performance in the One Dayers but hope he can come good in the test series.He can be India's answer to Michael Hussey.Also Ajinkya Rahane should also have got a look in.He is an extremely talented bloke.

  • Percy_Fender on June 20, 2011, 7:39 GMT

    I wish to add that the assessment that Amit Mishra only used his chances partially is absolutely incorrect. I have watched Mishra bowl prior to this ODI series. In fact from when he made his debut against Australia when I think he won a Test match for India. He seems to have practised a lot because now he has a prominent yet suble drift, a beautiful and controlled loop and above all the confidence and control that he lacked earlier. His choice of line of middle and leg was highly consistent and compelling indeed. He also had the scrambled seam variety of spin that reduced his turn before he gave one the original rip. He was in fact the nearest I have seen to the legendary Shane Warne in his latest avtaar. I hope that Dhoni gives him the field for a high quality leg spinner who has great control. He may go for the mad runs like if someone like Pollard or Bravo are batting. But that will be more the exception than the rule. It can happen only when there are fielding restrictions.

  • on June 20, 2011, 6:34 GMT

    U forgot Wasim Jaffer who hit a double during the 2006 series..

  • pvwadekar on June 20, 2011, 5:28 GMT

    Raina has no business in Test matches, he is in there just because he is a CSK player, it would have been better to have Rohit Sharma or Ajinkya Rahane instead of Raina.

  • Percy_Fender on June 20, 2011, 5:05 GMT

    Gavaskar made his debut at the Port of Spain in Trinidad and went on to become one of the greatest batsman of all time against all teams great bowlers and in different conditions. Dilip Sardesai made that epic 212 in the first innings of the 1971 Test match at Kingston Jamaica after India were stuttering at 74 for 6, that I saw in bold print in the morning newspaper. I have given these two instances only to show that a visit to the West Indies in the olden days was at once exciting. Even the prospect of going to the Carribean islands seemed so inviting. Cricket was the great additional magnet. The dropping of Madhav Apte has always baffled me. I do not think it was because of administrative ineptitude. He was from Eliphinston College Bombay I think and remained outside the regional influences. But why he did not play longer is a great mystery because he was really good. His brother Arvind had a brief stinit at the top too. I think some greats will be born in this Test match.

  • karthikvlk on June 20, 2011, 4:25 GMT

    well poor comparisons. THe selection process is much more open now than on 60's-90's. so those who plays well will be rewarded with the place in the side on permanent basis. Not a well written article by dileep premachandran

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • karthikvlk on June 20, 2011, 4:25 GMT

    well poor comparisons. THe selection process is much more open now than on 60's-90's. so those who plays well will be rewarded with the place in the side on permanent basis. Not a well written article by dileep premachandran

  • Percy_Fender on June 20, 2011, 5:05 GMT

    Gavaskar made his debut at the Port of Spain in Trinidad and went on to become one of the greatest batsman of all time against all teams great bowlers and in different conditions. Dilip Sardesai made that epic 212 in the first innings of the 1971 Test match at Kingston Jamaica after India were stuttering at 74 for 6, that I saw in bold print in the morning newspaper. I have given these two instances only to show that a visit to the West Indies in the olden days was at once exciting. Even the prospect of going to the Carribean islands seemed so inviting. Cricket was the great additional magnet. The dropping of Madhav Apte has always baffled me. I do not think it was because of administrative ineptitude. He was from Eliphinston College Bombay I think and remained outside the regional influences. But why he did not play longer is a great mystery because he was really good. His brother Arvind had a brief stinit at the top too. I think some greats will be born in this Test match.

  • pvwadekar on June 20, 2011, 5:28 GMT

    Raina has no business in Test matches, he is in there just because he is a CSK player, it would have been better to have Rohit Sharma or Ajinkya Rahane instead of Raina.

  • on June 20, 2011, 6:34 GMT

    U forgot Wasim Jaffer who hit a double during the 2006 series..

  • Percy_Fender on June 20, 2011, 7:39 GMT

    I wish to add that the assessment that Amit Mishra only used his chances partially is absolutely incorrect. I have watched Mishra bowl prior to this ODI series. In fact from when he made his debut against Australia when I think he won a Test match for India. He seems to have practised a lot because now he has a prominent yet suble drift, a beautiful and controlled loop and above all the confidence and control that he lacked earlier. His choice of line of middle and leg was highly consistent and compelling indeed. He also had the scrambled seam variety of spin that reduced his turn before he gave one the original rip. He was in fact the nearest I have seen to the legendary Shane Warne in his latest avtaar. I hope that Dhoni gives him the field for a high quality leg spinner who has great control. He may go for the mad runs like if someone like Pollard or Bravo are batting. But that will be more the exception than the rule. It can happen only when there are fielding restrictions.

  • Godfather007 on June 20, 2011, 7:47 GMT

    Fantastic opportunity for the likes of Mukund,Kohli and Badrinath to show what they are made up of.I was disappointed with Badrinath after his performance in the One Dayers but hope he can come good in the test series.He can be India's answer to Michael Hussey.Also Ajinkya Rahane should also have got a look in.He is an extremely talented bloke.

  • nickydude on June 20, 2011, 8:19 GMT

    With due respect to Indian Batsmen, the future for piling up runs by the tons is available!. Just've a look for the countries to visit on the FTP. Aus is in shambles, Pak is as good as finished, WI is also as good as gone, same with NZ pitches, SL is safe pitch, what remains to tackle is just Eng & SA, once in 4 yrs! provided they produce the same assembly of bowlers like Steyn & Co.!

  • DeveshJinwala on June 20, 2011, 8:41 GMT

    Though not part of the team (and that is surprising really), why is there no mention of Cheteshwar Pujara ?

  • KishorKumar25 on June 20, 2011, 9:42 GMT

    I think they should give a chance to mithun, In bouncy pitches of WI he ll be tough to play.

  • esarun on June 20, 2011, 13:31 GMT

    Of players who never kept their promise, you can add Abey Kuruvilla too. He made his test debut in the Carribbean and in only his third test took a 5-for that had seemingly set up a famous Indian win in that fortress of West Indian cricket, Barbados. Leave it to our inept batsmen to make a meal of a target of 120 !!