March 30, 2012

Strauss and Smith search for runs

England's captain hasn't scored a Test century in his last 23 innings, while South Africa's has struggled in the first innings in his last 12 Tests
30

They are both left-hand batsmen who lead their teams and their batting line-ups; they are captains who are closing in on their 100th Test matches; and they are players struggling just a bit to perform to levels that they are used to. The first Test of South Africa's tour to England this summer will be Graeme Smith's 100th; the last Test of the same series will be Andrew Strauss' 100th, if he plays all of England's Tests during this period. Both will want their batting to be in a healthier state in their landmark matches and after.

Of the two, Strauss is clearly more desperately in need of Test runs. It has been 23 innings since he last managed a Test hundred - 110 at the Gabba in the Ashes opener in 2010 - and over these 23 innings, he has only managed an average of 28.52, with five fifties and a highest of 87. Over the last 14 of those 23 innings, Strauss has achieved some consistency, but not of the sort you'd want from one of your top-order batsmen: he has been dismissed between 22 and 32 seven times, which shows he has got off to starts often but has failed to make them count. During this period, he has averaged 41.50 in the innings in which he has touched 20; before that, he used to average 66.12 when he avoided the early pitfalls and reached 20. Clearly he isn't doing enough when he gets a start.

Smith's problems are slightly different. His overall numbers are much better than Strauss', though his average is slightly inflated by two unbeaten 50-plus scores, including a 101 not out. Unlike Strauss, he has scored centuries - two in 21 innings - and has made his starts count, averaging 65.30 in the innings in which he has reached 20.

Smith's issue has been his inability to be at his best in the first innings. As opposed to his career average of 50.22 in the first innings of Tests, during this period his first-innings average has slumped to 24.83, with a highest of 62 in 12 innings. On the other hand, Smith has been prolific in the second innings, scoring a couple of centuries in pretty challenging situations: in Cape Town against Australia, his unbeaten 101 and the partnership with Hashim Amla swung a bizarre Test match decisively in South Africa's favour, while his 115 in Dunedin put South Africa in control after they had conceded the first-innings lead to New Zealand. In fact, Smith has always had a superb record in the second innings, and even more so in the fourth innings of Tests, and he has kept that up over the last 15 months; it's just that he has found first-innings runs a lot harder to score.

For Strauss, on the other hand, second-innings runs have been far more difficult: he averages 19.25, with a highest of 32 in eight innings.

Smith and Strauss over the last year and a half
Batsman Tests Innings Runs Average 100s/ 50s
Smith since Nov 20, 2010 12 21 738 41.00 2/ 4
Strauss since Dec 1, 2010 15 23 656 28.52 0/ 5
Smith and Strauss in 1st and 2nd innings during this period
Batsman Innings Runs Average 100s/ 50s
Smith - 1st innings 12 298 24.83 0/ 3
Smith - 2nd innings 9 440 73.33 2/ 1
Strauss - 1st innings 15 502 33.46 0/ 5
Strauss - 2nd innings 8 154 19.25 0/ 0

Both Strauss and Smith have been helped by the fact that other batsmen have taken over the mantle of scoring. (For Smith that's more the case in the first innings, since he has been the star batsman in the second.) South Africa have had AB de Villiers and Jacques Kallis, who have scored mountains of runs in the first innings to set up the game for them. Alviro Petersen has been a useful addition as well, averaging more than 53, while Amla has chipped in with four fluent fifties and a hundred. In the second innings Smith has the highest aggregate and average, but he has been well supported by Amla, de Villiers and Kallis.

South African batsmen in Tests since Nov 20, 2010
Batsman 1st inngs Runs Average 2nd inngs Runs Average Overall ave
AB de Villiers 12 910 91.00 7 310 44.28 71.76
Jacques Kallis 11 792 79.20 7 253 50.60 69.66
Hashim Amla 12 487 40.58 8 396 56.57 46.47
Alviro Petersen 8 429 53.62 7 149 24.83 41.28
Graeme Smith 12 298 24.83 9 440 73.33 41.00
Jacques Rudolph 8 214 30.57 4 165 55.00 37.90
Ashwell Prince 7 192 27.42 5 117 39.00 30.90

Strauss, though, has been overshadowed in both first and second innings by England specialist batsmen, plus Matt Prior, who is among the team's four batsmen to average more than 50 during this period. In the second innings, though, most of the England batsmen have fared quite poorly - Cook and Kevin Pietersen both average in the 20s, and only Prior averages more than 38. Those averages are obviously the result of England's recent problems against Pakistan and Sri Lanka, since in many of their wins last year, they hardly needed to bat a second time.

England batsmen in Tests since Dec 1, 2010
Batsman 1st inngs Runs Average 2nd inngs Runs Average Overall ave
Ian Bell 15 942 78.50 8 262 37.42 63.36
Alastair Cook 15 1175 78.33 8 200 25.00 59.78
Kevin Pietersen 15 924 66.00 8 188 23.50 50.54
Matt Prior 14 549 49.90 8 302 50.33 50.05
Jonathan Trott 13 638 53.16 8 293 36.62 46.55
Andrew Strauss 15 502 33.46 8 154 19.25 28.52

As stated earlier, the problem is clearly more acute for Strauss, and that's also reflected in his struggles against a couple of types of bowling. Strauss has always been susceptible against left-arm fast bowlers - over his entire Test career, he averages 27.29 against them, as opposed to 46.71 against right-arm pace - but more recently he has also been unusually unsteady against left-arm spin. He has fallen three times to Abdur Rehman and twice to Rangana Herath in the last 16 months, and averages 11 against left-arm spin, which is well below his career average of 53.84 against that type of bowling. His problems against left-arm pace have continued too, with six dismissals at an average of 16.33.

Smith's stats are particularly poor against a certain type of bowling, but in the first innings he has come off second-best against both right-arm fast (seven dismissals, average 23.57) and left-arm fast (four dismissals, average 24.50). England's high-quality pace attack will surely fancy their chances against Smith's slightly iffy technique, especially at the start of his innings. England's problem is that their captain looks equally, if not more, susceptible against South Africa's top-class bowling line-up.

Strauss against each type of bowler
Bowler type Runs Balls Dismissals Average
Right-arm pace 389 878 8 48.62
Right-arm spin 114 344 4 28.50
Left-arm pace 98 211 6 16.33
Left-arm spin 55 115 5 11.00

S Rajesh is stats editor of ESPNcricinfo. Follow him on Twitter

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on April 2, 2012, 19:46 GMT

    smith is surely a better batsman than strauss but not by a great difference despite strauss has a better technique than of smith's, I guess smith is mentally strong than strauss

  • SafferBob on April 2, 2012, 7:22 GMT

    And they were both born in Johannesburg

  • lakshitha.jayakody on March 31, 2012, 15:30 GMT

    Every top player will undergo similar situations, where their performance is poor, stagnated or not up to the their caliber. Tendulkar underwent similar situations many times, Kevin Pietersen was century less for 39 months, Murali lost the touch for some period in somewhere of 2001/2002, Mahela Jayawardena only scored 21 runs in entire 2003 world cup, basically all the top players have undergone this kind of bad periods and they all bounced back. These two players will be back to form in future and if things are not getting better, give them some time rest and regain their touch and focus. Anyway a good article.

  • TommytuckerSaffa on March 31, 2012, 10:30 GMT

    @RandyOz

    hahaaaa, quality comment. thumbs up !

  • Selaelo on March 31, 2012, 10:29 GMT

    This is a good article, comparing two players that have several similarities; Captaincy, Test macthes paleyed, Batting style(both left handers) perfomances for the past two years, amongst other things. Its not about who is better than the other. Its gonna be interesting to see two left handed captains that might reach 100 Test matches on the same tour in june/July, both wanting to lead from the front , hoping that the their strong batting line up and dominant bowling attack does well to help their respective team to lift the series trophy.

  • RandyOZ on March 31, 2012, 6:03 GMT

    I feel sorry for Smith that he is compared with Strauss, a third rate grade cricket journeyman. About the only thing they have in common is thy are both South African. Smith is class.

  • AvidCricFan on March 30, 2012, 23:38 GMT

    May be a series against India, BD and Zim may help Strauss come back to form temporarily.

  • Des_65 on March 30, 2012, 21:51 GMT

    Its OK for Strauss & Smith. Tendulkar went for 33 innings w/o a century in all forms of international cricket.

  • on March 30, 2012, 20:30 GMT

    @sadha1972 - Mate, I think that you are mistaken. Smith is both awesome as a batsman and as a captain. SA were unlucky not to win 2-0 or 3-0 against NZ in thier last tour (weather helped NZ out). As of now, I think SA has the right captain in place. I do however see AB DeViellers taking over in a few years.

  • on March 30, 2012, 19:27 GMT

    Smith averages 73 in the second innings. SEVENTY-THREE. Who else has comparable figures?

  • on April 2, 2012, 19:46 GMT

    smith is surely a better batsman than strauss but not by a great difference despite strauss has a better technique than of smith's, I guess smith is mentally strong than strauss

  • SafferBob on April 2, 2012, 7:22 GMT

    And they were both born in Johannesburg

  • lakshitha.jayakody on March 31, 2012, 15:30 GMT

    Every top player will undergo similar situations, where their performance is poor, stagnated or not up to the their caliber. Tendulkar underwent similar situations many times, Kevin Pietersen was century less for 39 months, Murali lost the touch for some period in somewhere of 2001/2002, Mahela Jayawardena only scored 21 runs in entire 2003 world cup, basically all the top players have undergone this kind of bad periods and they all bounced back. These two players will be back to form in future and if things are not getting better, give them some time rest and regain their touch and focus. Anyway a good article.

  • TommytuckerSaffa on March 31, 2012, 10:30 GMT

    @RandyOz

    hahaaaa, quality comment. thumbs up !

  • Selaelo on March 31, 2012, 10:29 GMT

    This is a good article, comparing two players that have several similarities; Captaincy, Test macthes paleyed, Batting style(both left handers) perfomances for the past two years, amongst other things. Its not about who is better than the other. Its gonna be interesting to see two left handed captains that might reach 100 Test matches on the same tour in june/July, both wanting to lead from the front , hoping that the their strong batting line up and dominant bowling attack does well to help their respective team to lift the series trophy.

  • RandyOZ on March 31, 2012, 6:03 GMT

    I feel sorry for Smith that he is compared with Strauss, a third rate grade cricket journeyman. About the only thing they have in common is thy are both South African. Smith is class.

  • AvidCricFan on March 30, 2012, 23:38 GMT

    May be a series against India, BD and Zim may help Strauss come back to form temporarily.

  • Des_65 on March 30, 2012, 21:51 GMT

    Its OK for Strauss & Smith. Tendulkar went for 33 innings w/o a century in all forms of international cricket.

  • on March 30, 2012, 20:30 GMT

    @sadha1972 - Mate, I think that you are mistaken. Smith is both awesome as a batsman and as a captain. SA were unlucky not to win 2-0 or 3-0 against NZ in thier last tour (weather helped NZ out). As of now, I think SA has the right captain in place. I do however see AB DeViellers taking over in a few years.

  • on March 30, 2012, 19:27 GMT

    Smith averages 73 in the second innings. SEVENTY-THREE. Who else has comparable figures?

  • on March 30, 2012, 18:22 GMT

    They are better batsman. But smith is better than strauss. As a captain they are same.

  • on March 30, 2012, 15:37 GMT

    @sadha1972, you say "MOST OF HIS VICTORIES HAVE COME AGAINST THE WEAKER TEST NATIONS" lol! that's ridiculous! As Captain, Smith has achieved series victories against England(away), Austrailia (away), Pakistan(away),New Zealand (away), West Indies (away), AND India (home and drew two series away) and Srilanka(home) !! That's all test playing Nations, And you still think he is " holding SA back"??

  • Salil-Mishra on March 30, 2012, 14:14 GMT

    Here you see the England Captain hasn't scored a century in 23 innings and averages only 28.52 during that period. But the nay sayers in India blame only Tendulkar for not scoring a century in 21 innings. His averages is also far ahead of Strauss. Also, Gambhir took more time in scoring a ton in between his last and the latest. There are so many examples if you really want to see.

  • sadha1972 on March 30, 2012, 9:11 GMT

    AS A BATSMAN SMITH DESERVES HIS PLACE IN THE TEAM BUT HIS CAPTAINCY IS HOLDING SOUTH AFRICA BACK. MOST OF HIS VICTORIES HAVE COME AGAINST THE WEAKER TEST NATIONS. STRAUSS IS A POOR BATSMAN PERIOD BUT HIS CAPTAINCY IS UP THERE WITH BEST.

  • The-love on March 30, 2012, 8:34 GMT

    for sure.....smith is far superior than the present test openers for all teams.

  • Asbah on March 30, 2012, 7:56 GMT

    How can you compare Strauss with Smith? Smith's average is 50, whereas, Strauss averages a little more than 40! Even your analysis shows that since Nov, 2010 Smith has averaged 41 and Strauss could only manage 28. Both of them open the innings and lead their respective side, but, that is where the similarities end. As far as batting skills are concerned Strauss is way out of Smith's League..

  • on March 30, 2012, 7:52 GMT

    Smith just loves going over to England and killing off the career of the incumbent English captain. Ask Nasser and Vaughan.

  • Romanticstud on March 30, 2012, 7:40 GMT

    In the test matches of recent times ... England haven't played to their ashes form in general ... losing to Pakistan and are busy with Sri-Lanka ... South AFrica on the other hand recently beat Sri-Lanka at home and had weather spoil their progress in New Zealand, and won that series ... The main concerns are that Kallis has either made nothing or made plenty ... If you look at 2nd inning figures in general Kallis has made 9 centuries in drawn games where SA would have lost the game if he had not done so. In victories Smith has been prolific and averages 66.2 ... Kallis only 62.91 ... So the addage that if Smith performs so does SA still holds ... but without Kallis we would have lost more tests especially at home ...

  • JustOUT on March 30, 2012, 7:32 GMT

    Previously it was Nasser Hussain and Vaughan, now it will be turn for Strauss to announce his retirement from Cricket after the 2nd or 3rd Test match against SA. And for sure, Smith will display his heroics in 4th innings either in 2nd or 3rd test match as a farewell gift to Strauss.

  • WarVdm on March 30, 2012, 7:32 GMT

    They were also both born in Jo'burg! Having said that, Smith has scored recent centuries against NZ and Australia, plus an ODI century vs SL. He also averages nearly 50 (49,64). Strauss averages 41...

    I respect Strauss as an opener and captain, but Smith is a notch above him. Smith has a few second innings centuries (and fifties) that result in wins too...

  • mabless on March 30, 2012, 7:27 GMT

    i thnk all de criticism dat smith endures has a lot 2 do wit his technique. lets face it, its hardly romantic wen dis guy play. he daz nt endear or charm his way in2 our hearts de way say AB or Amla do wit their sublime stroke-making. Smith is de g8t captain in history,stats wil tel u. he is nt under-rated, any bowler wil tel u dey wuld take smiths wicket anytym, esp if SA r chasing, ppl jst dnt lyk him personaly n dats a shame. he daz nt do himself justice aswell, lyk runing away 2 hyd in sweden afta chockin in de WC.

  • on March 30, 2012, 6:41 GMT

    Smith was the leading run-scorer in the series against New Zealand with 282 runs at an average 56.40, including a century and two fifties and he is now only six wins behind the world-record of most Test wins as captain set by Australia's Ricky Ponting. Why compare him to Strauss, who will be yet another English captain to quit while playing against SA? Reminds me of Whatsisname... starts with an A, I think :)

  • on March 30, 2012, 6:21 GMT

    smith was the series highest scoring batsman form either sa or nz, poor headline!

    gc smith re-writes the history books yet again :

    - now only six wins behind the world-record of most Test wins as captain set by AustraliaÂ's Ricky Ponting.

    - became the 4th youngest player to score his 8 000th Test run, becoming the second South African to pass the figure after Jacques Kallis.

    - 7 811 have been scored as an opener, which makes him one of the most successful openers of the 21st century. Matthew Hayden is the only modern day cricketer ahead of him on the list.

    - The drawn match at the Basin Reserve was his 91st in charge, which makes him certain to pass Allan Borders long-standing record of 93 matches during the tour of England in July.

  • chilled_avenger on March 30, 2012, 6:08 GMT

    @JustOut The last three India-South Africa test series has been drawn 1-1........Also the last England-South Africa series was also drawn 1-1!

  • on March 30, 2012, 5:43 GMT

    England will loose 3-0..................

  • on March 30, 2012, 5:33 GMT

    No disrespect, but what is the point of this debate. OVERALLl, Strauss has been struggling, and Smith has not. All other points are just nit picking really.

  • on March 30, 2012, 5:30 GMT

    Absolutely rubbish analysis on Smith.Smith is by far the best opening batsman in the world today. He is infact the only opening batsman who does well all over the world and that too under pressure and along with that he is the gr8s 4th innings batsman of all time.Smith has a fantastic record in England. He has scored 2 big double hundreds in england n a match winning 150. Its England bowlers who will have trouble to bowl agnst Smith n not vice versa.

  • SICHO on March 30, 2012, 5:19 GMT

    As an SA fan my biggest concern is the batting line-up for both teams, nothing is to be said about the bowling line-up they are both world class. I don't think there will be any high scoring game between England & South Africa not this time

  • JustOUT on March 30, 2012, 3:55 GMT

    I predict SA keeping the Basil D'overia trophy by winning the test series. SA hardly drawn a series. They always hit for either win or lose.

  • Buggsy on March 30, 2012, 3:31 GMT

    Can't wait for this series. England are obviously champs in their own conditions, but the South Africans revel in them just as much. Draw 1-1.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Buggsy on March 30, 2012, 3:31 GMT

    Can't wait for this series. England are obviously champs in their own conditions, but the South Africans revel in them just as much. Draw 1-1.

  • JustOUT on March 30, 2012, 3:55 GMT

    I predict SA keeping the Basil D'overia trophy by winning the test series. SA hardly drawn a series. They always hit for either win or lose.

  • SICHO on March 30, 2012, 5:19 GMT

    As an SA fan my biggest concern is the batting line-up for both teams, nothing is to be said about the bowling line-up they are both world class. I don't think there will be any high scoring game between England & South Africa not this time

  • on March 30, 2012, 5:30 GMT

    Absolutely rubbish analysis on Smith.Smith is by far the best opening batsman in the world today. He is infact the only opening batsman who does well all over the world and that too under pressure and along with that he is the gr8s 4th innings batsman of all time.Smith has a fantastic record in England. He has scored 2 big double hundreds in england n a match winning 150. Its England bowlers who will have trouble to bowl agnst Smith n not vice versa.

  • on March 30, 2012, 5:33 GMT

    No disrespect, but what is the point of this debate. OVERALLl, Strauss has been struggling, and Smith has not. All other points are just nit picking really.

  • on March 30, 2012, 5:43 GMT

    England will loose 3-0..................

  • chilled_avenger on March 30, 2012, 6:08 GMT

    @JustOut The last three India-South Africa test series has been drawn 1-1........Also the last England-South Africa series was also drawn 1-1!

  • on March 30, 2012, 6:21 GMT

    smith was the series highest scoring batsman form either sa or nz, poor headline!

    gc smith re-writes the history books yet again :

    - now only six wins behind the world-record of most Test wins as captain set by AustraliaÂ's Ricky Ponting.

    - became the 4th youngest player to score his 8 000th Test run, becoming the second South African to pass the figure after Jacques Kallis.

    - 7 811 have been scored as an opener, which makes him one of the most successful openers of the 21st century. Matthew Hayden is the only modern day cricketer ahead of him on the list.

    - The drawn match at the Basin Reserve was his 91st in charge, which makes him certain to pass Allan Borders long-standing record of 93 matches during the tour of England in July.

  • on March 30, 2012, 6:41 GMT

    Smith was the leading run-scorer in the series against New Zealand with 282 runs at an average 56.40, including a century and two fifties and he is now only six wins behind the world-record of most Test wins as captain set by Australia's Ricky Ponting. Why compare him to Strauss, who will be yet another English captain to quit while playing against SA? Reminds me of Whatsisname... starts with an A, I think :)

  • mabless on March 30, 2012, 7:27 GMT

    i thnk all de criticism dat smith endures has a lot 2 do wit his technique. lets face it, its hardly romantic wen dis guy play. he daz nt endear or charm his way in2 our hearts de way say AB or Amla do wit their sublime stroke-making. Smith is de g8t captain in history,stats wil tel u. he is nt under-rated, any bowler wil tel u dey wuld take smiths wicket anytym, esp if SA r chasing, ppl jst dnt lyk him personaly n dats a shame. he daz nt do himself justice aswell, lyk runing away 2 hyd in sweden afta chockin in de WC.