England v NZ, 2nd Investec Test, Headingley, 2nd day May 25, 2013

In Root, England have something special to savour

With a mix of David Gower, Graham Thorpe and Michael Vaughan, Joe Root can capture hearts and minds
  shares 25

For those who saw it, the quality and thrill of the stroke with which David Gower announced his Test match career will live forever. The year was 1978, the ground Edgbaston, the opponent Pakistan and the bowler Liaqat Ali. The ball was more long hop than bouncer and with typical, priceless charm the most gifted batsman of a generation swivelled and pulled it to the square-leg boundary. As first balls go, this one did. The gasps of admiration - one huge self-satisfied British drool - were heard in every corner of the Empire.

Twelve months previously, Ian Botham had captured our imagination with his derring-do debut against Australia. Could it really be that England, the England of grim county pros and leaden grey skies had thrown us another diamond? Yes, it darn well could. Botham and Gower sparkled for more than a decade, papering over cracks in the English game that manifested themselves with alarming clarity once they had gone.

Wind the clock on some 35 years. In an over of memorable audacity at Headingley on Saturday, Joe Root drove through midwicket, swept past short fine-leg and then, after the New Zealand captain had rearranged the field to strengthen the leg side, reverse-swept into the off-side space created by the move. Think of it like this, six Tests in and the kid was taking the mickey.

Not for a moment though is this the reason we should celebrate. There is more, masses more to Root than a reverse sweep. Not since Gower has an English-born batsman of such pedigree caught the eye. Graham Thorpe was close but not so clear-headed. Michael Vaughan was every bit as good, but in bursts. Indeed, Vaughan's batting in Australia on the 2002-03 tour was as good as anyone in the modern era. Ask Shane Warne, who saw it from 22 yards away and felt that only Sachin Tendulkar had the Australians so covered. It is too soon to judge Root that good or, conversely, to wonder if his downtime could be so disheartening as that experienced by Vaughan.

What we know is that the basics are spot on, the temperament sound and the appetite insatiable. Like Gower, and like Thorpe and Vaughan, come to think of it, Root's game is set up on the back foot. This is unusual among English batsmen in the age of the covered pitch and unusual full-stop given the modern fondness for a forward press and a thumping drive.

Vaughan had two strokes that made his name: a truly beautiful cover drive, executed with a good stride to the pitch of the ball, a high left elbow, and a straight and free-flowing blade that preceded a lovely break of the wrists in the follow-through. And he had a killer pull stroke, made by the certainty of the cover drive, because bowlers dare not pitch too full.

In Root there is Vaughan's composure and presence, Thorpe's flexibility and accuracy and Gower's sense of magic

Thorpe could cut, pull and deflect with a surgeon's precision. He was a square-of-the-wicket specialist but with a punch drive down the ground that withered an ordinary bowler. But Thorpe fought an inner demon that messed with his belief. This, in turn, compromised his ability to change the course of a match as he might persistently have done. At his best - in Sri Lanka against Muttiah Muralitharan, for example - he could do pretty much anything, but his genius was elusive and frustrating.

Gower was almost unreasonably talented. The options at his disposal, the responses, the range, the variety that was given him, well, one wondered if such riches were a confusion. He could delight and he could infuriate but he emptied bars. No cricketer can have been so driven by the desire to entertain, save Denis Compton perhaps. The flashes and flights of fancy were as much a part of the show as the square drives and late cuts that seemed to have been conceived, never mind played, at the last possible moment. This was an artist with the softest hands, the most delicate touch and the most enviable timing. When he chose to apply it, Gower was the most fluent and enjoyable of English batsmen, a mismatch to the stereotype of the professional game.

There is a bit of all of these fine batsman in Root: the Root of Yorkshire, who made that fabulous hundred at Yorkshire's famous cricketing place on Saturday. There is Vaughan's composure and presence, Thorpe's flexibility and accuracy, and there is Gower's sense of magic, to go with that blond and innocent teenage kick.

Like Thorpe, he is a busy cricketer, stealing runs when they seem not to be there. Like Vaughan, he can drive from a perfect position off the back foot, which forces a bowler to change his length. Like Gower, he can score in a 360-degree radius thus challenging captains to find new solutions to an old problem, that there are only nine fielders with which to defend.

Unlike any of them, he has an awkward, rather crabby stance with his feet positioned wide apart and the bat set between them as it was with Bradman (no bad thing, I hear you cry!). He holds that bat at waist height, not so apparently as Graham Gooch, but a little more obviously than, say, Vaughan. The face is shut in the backlift but the wrists cock perfectly to allow free strokeplay. Better than anyone in the game today, Root uses the depth of the crease, giving himself more time to play than your average Joe. In this way, he is a throwback, rather as Gower was too.

Already he is my favourite current batsman, a position in heart and mind long occupied by Tendulkar. The attention and adulation seems to suit him, after all only Yorkshire luminaries such as FS Jackson, Sir Leonard Hutton, Geoffrey Boycott and Vaughan himself have made hundreds at Headingley and none of them managed it at the first time of asking. English cricket has someone special to savour. Buy a ticket if you can.

Mark Nicholas, the former Hampshire captain, presents the cricket on Channel 9 in Australia and Channel 5 in the UK

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | May 26, 2013, 7:40 GMT

    I've watched enough first class & Test cricket over the years to state without hesitation that Joe Root's batting is truly exceptional. Yesterday he demonstrated more assurance at the crease, more composure, a tighter technique in countering the swinging ball than any other batsman on show. When one realises that means that the quality of his batsmanship was, IMO, superior to that of Cook, Trott & Bell on this showing, I'm left wondering how one so young & inexperienced at the highest level has achieved his level of proficiency. He has the elan of Gower without the carelessness; the application & watchfulness of Thorpe with more strokes mastered & above all these a sense of total enjoyment in doing his work. Indeed, it seems not to be work at all to young Joe, more an unfettered & smiling delight in the mastery of his craft. And this, Heaven help the bowlers, is only the first hour of his cricketing day!

  • POSTED BY jackthelad on | May 26, 2013, 6:10 GMT

    An excellent, composed innings from Root; good to see him crack the century, though it's a shame a lapse of concentration prevented him from going on the make it a big one (the look on his face as he walked off suggests he felt the same). However: let's put the lid on all this media hype, which will help no-one, least of all young Joe (though he seems level-headed enough to dismiss it for the belly-rumbling it is). When he has been at the top for three or four years, when he has played against the best attacks and done well, both home and away - then we can start to think about comparisons with maestros like Gower and Vaughan. At the moment - he's made a very good start, let's hope he carries on and develops the undoubted talent he has - and let's give him a rest from the 'saviour of English batting' drivel til he has a chance to settle in.

  • POSTED BY jmcilhinney on | May 26, 2013, 1:14 GMT

    It certainly is hard not to be excited about Root. It's early days and anything could still happen. Many players have started well and not lived up their promise. He certainly looks to have all the required attributes to succeed though. Ravi Bopara was the last batsman to start with a flurry but his form fell away dramatically and he seems to lack the mental fortitude to be successful at Test level. At this early stage, that seems to be one of Root's strengths.

  • POSTED BY A_Yorkshire_Lad on | May 25, 2013, 22:39 GMT

    England does have something special in Root - I think the most telling part about today's events is that when he was walking off after being dismissed , Root seemed more concerned that he'd got out to a poor shot rather than basking in the applause for his century. Even though he looks like a 12 year old (!) he has - along with the ability - the right temperament , which for an England batsman is , I think , just crucial . Putting him in the England team initially down at 5 or 6 might turn out to be a master stroke.

  • POSTED BY lateswing on | May 27, 2013, 16:37 GMT

    IMHO, a young Mike Atherton is who Root resembles the most, although he probably plays more shots than Athers did

  • POSTED BY YorkshirePudding on | May 27, 2013, 7:24 GMT

    While Root is doing good the test of a batsman is when they get 'found' out and hit a lean patch.

    It was pleasing to see his disappointment at getting out after making his ton, as it looked like he wanted to bat on. I can see him opening the batting within 12 to 18 months.

  • POSTED BY shot274 on | May 26, 2013, 22:00 GMT

    Give us all a break Mark! He has played 6 test matches. 5 against New Zealand and 1 against India!!!Currently these must be the two weakest bowling sides in the world. Nobody in the Empire thought Gower was great because he pulled Liaqat Ali for four!!!

  • POSTED BY WakeyLee on | May 26, 2013, 20:09 GMT

    Above all else Joe has a knack of getting hard fought runs when his team needs them and adapts to the situation brilliantly. The yorkshire public better buy a ticket for tomorrow as they're not going to see much of him at headingley in the future...

  • POSTED BY on | May 26, 2013, 19:06 GMT

    @ Raghu Sharma. Your comments would carry a little more weight if you had a better eye for obvious details "Johhny Bairstow" you don't even know where he is now? Erm he's playing for England - now - and got the second highest score in the match being played so far - just behind Joe Root who he shared a 124 run partnership. While their are examples of English batters who have flattered to deceive (and lets be fair - batters from every other country in roughly equal number as well) Using Bairstow as an example of "Hype to tripe" when he is playing right in front of us - at this precise moment - and playing so well on the test match stage - wasn't your best choice.

  • POSTED BY Herbet on | May 26, 2013, 14:04 GMT

    The shout for Carberry to open in the Ashes is a good one, as at the moment I'd be loathe to move Root up just yet and potentially destroy his growing confidence if the Aussie bowlers end up being good. Not only is Carberry in fantastic form, and Compton out of form, but he is a generally aggressive batsman as opposed to Cook, Compton and Bell who are nudgers and accumulators. England have been starting so slowly later that a quick couple of wickets drops us right in it and piles the pressure on Bell and Root, of whom Root seems better equipped to cope. Carberry is also an athlete and an excellent fielder. As much as I like Bairstow, and as much as it was great to see two young friends having so much fun in a high pressured international sporting event yesterday, it would be he who would make way for Pietersen as I feel he is not quite there.

  • POSTED BY Nutcutlet on | May 26, 2013, 7:40 GMT

    I've watched enough first class & Test cricket over the years to state without hesitation that Joe Root's batting is truly exceptional. Yesterday he demonstrated more assurance at the crease, more composure, a tighter technique in countering the swinging ball than any other batsman on show. When one realises that means that the quality of his batsmanship was, IMO, superior to that of Cook, Trott & Bell on this showing, I'm left wondering how one so young & inexperienced at the highest level has achieved his level of proficiency. He has the elan of Gower without the carelessness; the application & watchfulness of Thorpe with more strokes mastered & above all these a sense of total enjoyment in doing his work. Indeed, it seems not to be work at all to young Joe, more an unfettered & smiling delight in the mastery of his craft. And this, Heaven help the bowlers, is only the first hour of his cricketing day!

  • POSTED BY jackthelad on | May 26, 2013, 6:10 GMT

    An excellent, composed innings from Root; good to see him crack the century, though it's a shame a lapse of concentration prevented him from going on the make it a big one (the look on his face as he walked off suggests he felt the same). However: let's put the lid on all this media hype, which will help no-one, least of all young Joe (though he seems level-headed enough to dismiss it for the belly-rumbling it is). When he has been at the top for three or four years, when he has played against the best attacks and done well, both home and away - then we can start to think about comparisons with maestros like Gower and Vaughan. At the moment - he's made a very good start, let's hope he carries on and develops the undoubted talent he has - and let's give him a rest from the 'saviour of English batting' drivel til he has a chance to settle in.

  • POSTED BY jmcilhinney on | May 26, 2013, 1:14 GMT

    It certainly is hard not to be excited about Root. It's early days and anything could still happen. Many players have started well and not lived up their promise. He certainly looks to have all the required attributes to succeed though. Ravi Bopara was the last batsman to start with a flurry but his form fell away dramatically and he seems to lack the mental fortitude to be successful at Test level. At this early stage, that seems to be one of Root's strengths.

  • POSTED BY A_Yorkshire_Lad on | May 25, 2013, 22:39 GMT

    England does have something special in Root - I think the most telling part about today's events is that when he was walking off after being dismissed , Root seemed more concerned that he'd got out to a poor shot rather than basking in the applause for his century. Even though he looks like a 12 year old (!) he has - along with the ability - the right temperament , which for an England batsman is , I think , just crucial . Putting him in the England team initially down at 5 or 6 might turn out to be a master stroke.

  • POSTED BY lateswing on | May 27, 2013, 16:37 GMT

    IMHO, a young Mike Atherton is who Root resembles the most, although he probably plays more shots than Athers did

  • POSTED BY YorkshirePudding on | May 27, 2013, 7:24 GMT

    While Root is doing good the test of a batsman is when they get 'found' out and hit a lean patch.

    It was pleasing to see his disappointment at getting out after making his ton, as it looked like he wanted to bat on. I can see him opening the batting within 12 to 18 months.

  • POSTED BY shot274 on | May 26, 2013, 22:00 GMT

    Give us all a break Mark! He has played 6 test matches. 5 against New Zealand and 1 against India!!!Currently these must be the two weakest bowling sides in the world. Nobody in the Empire thought Gower was great because he pulled Liaqat Ali for four!!!

  • POSTED BY WakeyLee on | May 26, 2013, 20:09 GMT

    Above all else Joe has a knack of getting hard fought runs when his team needs them and adapts to the situation brilliantly. The yorkshire public better buy a ticket for tomorrow as they're not going to see much of him at headingley in the future...

  • POSTED BY on | May 26, 2013, 19:06 GMT

    @ Raghu Sharma. Your comments would carry a little more weight if you had a better eye for obvious details "Johhny Bairstow" you don't even know where he is now? Erm he's playing for England - now - and got the second highest score in the match being played so far - just behind Joe Root who he shared a 124 run partnership. While their are examples of English batters who have flattered to deceive (and lets be fair - batters from every other country in roughly equal number as well) Using Bairstow as an example of "Hype to tripe" when he is playing right in front of us - at this precise moment - and playing so well on the test match stage - wasn't your best choice.

  • POSTED BY Herbet on | May 26, 2013, 14:04 GMT

    The shout for Carberry to open in the Ashes is a good one, as at the moment I'd be loathe to move Root up just yet and potentially destroy his growing confidence if the Aussie bowlers end up being good. Not only is Carberry in fantastic form, and Compton out of form, but he is a generally aggressive batsman as opposed to Cook, Compton and Bell who are nudgers and accumulators. England have been starting so slowly later that a quick couple of wickets drops us right in it and piles the pressure on Bell and Root, of whom Root seems better equipped to cope. Carberry is also an athlete and an excellent fielder. As much as I like Bairstow, and as much as it was great to see two young friends having so much fun in a high pressured international sporting event yesterday, it would be he who would make way for Pietersen as I feel he is not quite there.

  • POSTED BY on | May 26, 2013, 14:03 GMT

    I have seen so many English Commentators , jumping on the gun , just after one or two good innings by an English player . Always making comparison with Greats only to see them fizzle out after some time . Jonny Bairstow , played one such innings somewhere , and he was then hailed as the next best thing . I don't even know where he is now . Don't know what you guys would had done If the English Team had raw exceptional talents like South Africans have or Pakistan or India Had .

  • POSTED BY Herbet on | May 26, 2013, 13:55 GMT

    I like Root, and he does look like a very good player. But its too early on to compare him to Vaughan, never mind Gower. Lets see how he copes with a genuinely top class spinner (he'll have to wait for one to come along first, unless he plays against Swann for Yorkshire) and genuinely top fast bowling i.e. South Africa. So far we know he can bat for a long time, he can play spin in India and he can cope easily with swing, as you'd expect of anyone from northern England. The player he reminds me of the most, while we are at it, is Michael Atherton, as he plays so late and generally off the back foot. For a Vaughan-a-like you need to watch James Vince for Hampshire.

  • POSTED BY thebatsmansHoldingthebowlersWilley on | May 26, 2013, 12:14 GMT

    Mark Nicholas is so taken to hyberbole it's hard to take anything he says seriously. Yes Joe Root looks a good player, great range of shots and good footwork.... but let's give the guy some time and space before we compare him to the greats of the game

  • POSTED BY on | May 26, 2013, 11:30 GMT

    "Not since Gower has an English-born batsman of such pedigree caught the eye. Graham Thorpe was close but not so clear-headed. Michael Vaughan was every bit as good, but in bursts." Wow, last time I checked, the current England captain, born in England, is well on his way to become one of England's greatest batsmen, and score well over 10000 Test runs, I wonder what he could have done to catch your eye as a batsmen of pedigree on par with Gower, Vaughan and Thorpe?

  • POSTED BY GeoffreysMother on | May 26, 2013, 9:22 GMT

    Root batting at 5 is good. He shows the capacity to defend or accelerate as the situation allows. We should be cautious about moving him up to open too early ; he has been out to a seaming second new ball three times. Whilst Bairstow clearly has more vulnerabilities, he has the ability to take the game away from opponents, very much as Pieterson does. Like Pieterson he has the ability to win games that would otherwise be draws. At the moment I would be loathe to leave either out, or move Root up the order. If Compton doesn't come through this poor period (and it may actually be his ability to play the moving ball at this level) then Chopra or Carberry could be used. Which leaves the question of how to fit Pieterson back in: time for yet another focus on can Ian Bell score runs when his career is on the line?

  • POSTED BY Behind_the_bowlers_arm on | May 26, 2013, 8:23 GMT

    Root looks a talented player with great calmness and no immediately obvious flaws but he doesnt bring any of those players to my mind. In fact in mannerisms and physique he reminds me of Derek RANDALL. Thats meant to be a compliment by the way.

  • POSTED BY gothetaniwha on | May 26, 2013, 8:14 GMT

    One century and he's a world beater up with Gower , way over the top , must be English .

  • POSTED BY VillageBlacksmith on | May 26, 2013, 8:04 GMT

    give the young lad a chance for gawds sake nicholas... he is playing in his first test at his home ground and you go completely overboard like this... i really hope root doesn't read this stuff...

  • POSTED BY on | May 26, 2013, 7:37 GMT

    Typical English Journalism. Going gaga over too early. Hopefully root will prove his substance in Ashes and years to come.

  • POSTED BY ygkd on | May 26, 2013, 7:24 GMT

    I couldn't for the life of me see any resemblance to Gower, Vaughan or Thorpe, until I remembered that Gower was thin, Vaughan was a Yorkshireman and Thorpe debuted in County cricket at nineteen. Yep, Root's a dead-ringer on those terms.

  • POSTED BY Cricket24 on | May 26, 2013, 1:28 GMT

    I hope he doesnt become a Vinod Kambli. He has sparkled and has a great captain in Alastar Cook

  • POSTED BY ham1990 on | May 26, 2013, 1:03 GMT

    What a fantastic article! It truly was refreshing to watch a quality English born and bred batsman almost winding the clock back with strokeplay and temperament uncharacteristic of the modern game (with the hullabaloo of 20/20).

  • POSTED BY 2.14istherunrate on | May 25, 2013, 23:10 GMT

    There is much in what the writer says here. Root seemed to be there to enjoy himself somewhat and wore a broad grin anytime the camera focussed. I felt before this game that there seemed to be no-one questioning his right to a place in the full England side. Yet he had not scored his first century yet. The aura about him had grown quite uniquely as he seemed already in the blood stream of the English public. He had not scored a century on debut like Cook though it was the same venue,India,Nagpur and he scored 74; yet his name kept getting included so that I was left to wonder when I had last felt this thing about a young batsman, feted more than the rest as though the stand out. Maybe it was just my imagination but there were echoes of a young batsman 23 years ago on his first visit to England. I hesitate to mention Root in the same breath as Tendulkar but that's the truth of it for me. Some players just acquire that aura. I wish him good luck anyway!

  • POSTED BY landl47 on | May 25, 2013, 21:53 GMT

    It's a bit early for such extravagant praise, but Root does appear to be developing into a fine cricketer. Mentally he seems to have both confidence and intelligence, a rare combination. He's not the elegant strokeplayer that Gower and Vaughan were, but he looks well-organized and efficient. If we're lucky he will develop into a Rahul Dravid type of player and that would be a great thing for English cricket.

  • POSTED BY ozwriter on | May 25, 2013, 21:24 GMT

    mark nicholas, this article is waaay over the top. one century and he is your favourite players? just shows how fickle journalists are nowadays. score around 20 centuries like cook, jayawardene or ponting, then we can start talking with suche effusive praise.

  • POSTED BY ozwriter on | May 25, 2013, 21:24 GMT

    mark nicholas, this article is waaay over the top. one century and he is your favourite players? just shows how fickle journalists are nowadays. score around 20 centuries like cook, jayawardene or ponting, then we can start talking with suche effusive praise.

  • POSTED BY landl47 on | May 25, 2013, 21:53 GMT

    It's a bit early for such extravagant praise, but Root does appear to be developing into a fine cricketer. Mentally he seems to have both confidence and intelligence, a rare combination. He's not the elegant strokeplayer that Gower and Vaughan were, but he looks well-organized and efficient. If we're lucky he will develop into a Rahul Dravid type of player and that would be a great thing for English cricket.

  • POSTED BY 2.14istherunrate on | May 25, 2013, 23:10 GMT

    There is much in what the writer says here. Root seemed to be there to enjoy himself somewhat and wore a broad grin anytime the camera focussed. I felt before this game that there seemed to be no-one questioning his right to a place in the full England side. Yet he had not scored his first century yet. The aura about him had grown quite uniquely as he seemed already in the blood stream of the English public. He had not scored a century on debut like Cook though it was the same venue,India,Nagpur and he scored 74; yet his name kept getting included so that I was left to wonder when I had last felt this thing about a young batsman, feted more than the rest as though the stand out. Maybe it was just my imagination but there were echoes of a young batsman 23 years ago on his first visit to England. I hesitate to mention Root in the same breath as Tendulkar but that's the truth of it for me. Some players just acquire that aura. I wish him good luck anyway!

  • POSTED BY ham1990 on | May 26, 2013, 1:03 GMT

    What a fantastic article! It truly was refreshing to watch a quality English born and bred batsman almost winding the clock back with strokeplay and temperament uncharacteristic of the modern game (with the hullabaloo of 20/20).

  • POSTED BY Cricket24 on | May 26, 2013, 1:28 GMT

    I hope he doesnt become a Vinod Kambli. He has sparkled and has a great captain in Alastar Cook

  • POSTED BY ygkd on | May 26, 2013, 7:24 GMT

    I couldn't for the life of me see any resemblance to Gower, Vaughan or Thorpe, until I remembered that Gower was thin, Vaughan was a Yorkshireman and Thorpe debuted in County cricket at nineteen. Yep, Root's a dead-ringer on those terms.

  • POSTED BY on | May 26, 2013, 7:37 GMT

    Typical English Journalism. Going gaga over too early. Hopefully root will prove his substance in Ashes and years to come.

  • POSTED BY VillageBlacksmith on | May 26, 2013, 8:04 GMT

    give the young lad a chance for gawds sake nicholas... he is playing in his first test at his home ground and you go completely overboard like this... i really hope root doesn't read this stuff...

  • POSTED BY gothetaniwha on | May 26, 2013, 8:14 GMT

    One century and he's a world beater up with Gower , way over the top , must be English .

  • POSTED BY Behind_the_bowlers_arm on | May 26, 2013, 8:23 GMT

    Root looks a talented player with great calmness and no immediately obvious flaws but he doesnt bring any of those players to my mind. In fact in mannerisms and physique he reminds me of Derek RANDALL. Thats meant to be a compliment by the way.