New Zealand v West Indies, 1st Test, Dunedin, 3rd day December 5, 2013

NZ seamers lay platform for innings win

31

West Indies 213 (Chanderpaul 76, Southee 4-52, Boult 3-40) and 168 for 2 (Bravo 72*, Edwards 59, Boult 1-26) trail New Zealand 609 for 9 dec by 228 runs
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

The only other time this millennium New Zealand asked a side other than Zimbabwe or Bangladesh to follow on, the game ended in a draw after their bowlers could only dismiss four batsmen in 180 overs. The chances of a repeat, New Zealand would believe, were extremely low against a West Indies batting line-up low on confidence in the longer format despite the loss of only two wickets in 49 second-innings overs in Dunedin. West Indies still trail by 228 runs after their first innings folded for 213, with Tim Southee and Trent Boult sharing seven wickets between them.

The pitch at the University Oval had lost its greenish tinge and with the sun out, the conditions seemed best for batting. West Indies, trailing by 542 at the start of the day, couldn't have asked for more.

The New Zealand bowlers, however, showed yet again where West Indies had gone wrong in the first two days, bowling predominantly fuller lengths and using the bouncer sparingly. With Marlon Samuels and Darren Bravo staying rooted to the crease against swinging deliveries, a wicket never seemed too far away.

Southee extracted an outside edge off Samuels' bat in the second over of the day only to see it fall short of first slip. In the next over, Samuels had another reprieve after Nigel Llong had ruled him out lbw as he played outside the line to a Boult delivery that came in. The replays showed the ball just missing off stump and the decision was overturned.

New Zealand's search for a wicket ended in the fourth over of the day as Bravo drove at a full delivery from Southee and got a thick outside edge which was snaffled by Brendon McCullum at gully. Fifteen balls later, Southee took advantage of Samuels' reluctance to come forward and had him caught at first slip off an outswinger delivered from a wider angle as the batsman was sucked in to a loose drive to be dismissed for 14.

Deonarine added 33 for the fifth wicket with Shivnarine Chanderpaul, pushing at fuller deliveries with hard hands. The technique earned him two boundaries, but an attempted wild drive - without moving his feet - off an angled delivery in Southee's seventh over of his spell went straight to first slip where Ross Taylor completed the catch after a brief fumble.

Unfazed by the indiscretion shown by other batsmen, Chanderpaul batted confidently, driving at the full deliveries, pulling the short ones and using his feet to Ish Sodhi. A powerful pull off Neil Wagner took him past 11,000 runs in Test cricket and three fours in the next over bowled by Sodhi brought him his 62nd half-century in Tests.

Ramdin gave Chanderpaul useful support in a 68-run stand but in the third over after lunch, he couldn't get out of the way off a short delivery from Boult and edged it to the keeper. Boult struck in the next over with the big wicket of Chanderpaul, whose indecision proved fatal as he shouldered arms to an incoming delivery and was adjudged lbw after an 87-ball 76.

West Indies could only add 30 more runs as Sodhi, expensive in his spell, picked up two of the last three wickets to fall. Darren Sammy, who was hampered by the hamstring niggle, and was turning down singles, inexplicably called Tino Best for a second, but the latter's late response meant he was caught well short at non-striker's end by a throw from long on.

It seemed West Indies' second innings was headed the same way as the first when Kieran Powell drove at a length delivery outside off from Boult and edged it to second slip, but Kirk Edwards and Bravo curtailed the urge to be flamboyant and showed improved application in the second innings.

That Boult and Southee needed an extended breather after their first spells worked in the batsmen's favour as Neil Wagner and Sodhi failed to exert similar pressure after tea. While Wagner couldn't extract the same movement as the two lead seamers, Sodhi dished out a regular dose of long-hops and full-tosses which allowed the two batsmen to settle into the innings.

By the time Southee came back for his second spell, Bravo had put on the cape of confidence and he moved to 40 with a hat-trick of boundaries through covers. In the next over, though, it seemed as if Bravo had fallen short after yet another start. He took the eyes off a short delivery from Wagner and the ball ballooned to first slip after hitting his forearm. Umpire Llong adjudged it not out, and the replays suggested the ball could have only flicked the glove-straps. The third umpire, however, went with the on-field umpire's call after New Zealand asked for a review. Bravo survived, he rubbed his forearm and wrist immediately after getting hit and that may have worked in his favour.

Bravo did get to his half-century - his ninth in Tests and first in 2013 - and along with Edwards helped West Indies resist New Zealand's charge with a century stand. Edwards, who collected 28 of his 59 runs against Sodhi, was eventually trapped lbw playing back to a slider from the legspinner. Sodhi bowled a much-improved second spell with tighter lines, while slipping in a deceptive googly from time to time that had Samuels in trouble more than once.

With eight West Indies wickets remaining, New Zealand would hope to finish off the match on the fourth day.

Devashish Fuloria is a sub-editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • delboy on December 5, 2013, 23:48 GMT

    One can only hope Darren Bravo with help from Deonarine, Sammy and Ramdin can finish this match on a personal best of 402 not out. Having been forced to follow on this performance would fade that into a mere second..This is your time Darren as you may never again get an opportunity to really build a BIG innings.

  • WILAD on December 5, 2013, 23:41 GMT

    I know WI hasn't look that good but WI supporters over reacting. Roach no.14 test bowler is out. Fidel 29 ranked is injured and Rampaul isn't fit. That's the whole attack right there. Team changes big time with those players. It's just bad luck. Roach has been taking 5fors like crazy and I don't think it would have been that different in India or NZ. Remember these are back up bowlers except Shilli. In recent time it's the bowling that has kept WI in games and the luxury is not there right now. Who has WI lost to recently? India in India. Australia got a drubbing there and playing NZ in NZ where England barely escape with a draw. Yes the batting can improve but WI hasn't done well away(except for bangladesh) for many years now. Take it easy.

  • __PK on December 5, 2013, 20:27 GMT

    Interesting match, that one in 2008/9 when NZ asked India to follow-on. Taylor and McCullum scored centuries in the first innings then, too. Appalling decision from Vettori to put India back in, though. India were 4/240 off 77 overs, so obviously batting conditions were OK, but then they lost 6/50 in 13 overs and Vettori misread the situation. Apart from those crazy 13 overs, India only lost 8 wickets in 250 overs.

  • Riddymon on December 5, 2013, 16:00 GMT

    @vivsobers Delboy is right..he didn't necessarily mean tests. His last two scores in India were 63* and 37*...if you include this last innings...that's 3.

  • Puffin on December 5, 2013, 15:46 GMT

    Many will be wondering what will things will be like once Chanderpaul retires.

  • on December 5, 2013, 15:24 GMT

    Anyone who is recommending Charles / Walton as a test keeper really haven't seen either play . At best 50/50 chances accepted/ dropped . If looking for a keeper , look at young keepers and develop them . Pooran? Under 19 team ?

  • CricketChat on December 5, 2013, 15:04 GMT

    Can WI push the match into 5th day? That would be some improvement given the dismal showing in tests in Ind.

  • abc_akram on December 5, 2013, 14:54 GMT

    I am really surprised by WICB'S selection policy. What's the rationale in not selecting experienced fast bowlers like Ravi Rampaul, Jerome Taylor and Fidel Edwards and Sunil Narine is also not playing, West Indies batsmen should also dig in and apply themselves. Lendl Simmons can be given some more chances. Shannon Gabriel is not bowling well but he is being persisted with, and moreover Tino Best and Gabriel are bowling too many shot pitched deliveries giving easy pickings for the kiwi batsmen. Probably the present Windies fast bowlers should watch more videos of Ambrose,Garner,Marshall,Walsh Holding Roberts.

  • on December 5, 2013, 14:22 GMT

    W.I will draw this match. They will shock us. Lil

  • on December 5, 2013, 12:35 GMT

    Even NZ will be embarrassed by the likely result of this game. The gulf between the 2 teams is palpable.

  • delboy on December 5, 2013, 23:48 GMT

    One can only hope Darren Bravo with help from Deonarine, Sammy and Ramdin can finish this match on a personal best of 402 not out. Having been forced to follow on this performance would fade that into a mere second..This is your time Darren as you may never again get an opportunity to really build a BIG innings.

  • WILAD on December 5, 2013, 23:41 GMT

    I know WI hasn't look that good but WI supporters over reacting. Roach no.14 test bowler is out. Fidel 29 ranked is injured and Rampaul isn't fit. That's the whole attack right there. Team changes big time with those players. It's just bad luck. Roach has been taking 5fors like crazy and I don't think it would have been that different in India or NZ. Remember these are back up bowlers except Shilli. In recent time it's the bowling that has kept WI in games and the luxury is not there right now. Who has WI lost to recently? India in India. Australia got a drubbing there and playing NZ in NZ where England barely escape with a draw. Yes the batting can improve but WI hasn't done well away(except for bangladesh) for many years now. Take it easy.

  • __PK on December 5, 2013, 20:27 GMT

    Interesting match, that one in 2008/9 when NZ asked India to follow-on. Taylor and McCullum scored centuries in the first innings then, too. Appalling decision from Vettori to put India back in, though. India were 4/240 off 77 overs, so obviously batting conditions were OK, but then they lost 6/50 in 13 overs and Vettori misread the situation. Apart from those crazy 13 overs, India only lost 8 wickets in 250 overs.

  • Riddymon on December 5, 2013, 16:00 GMT

    @vivsobers Delboy is right..he didn't necessarily mean tests. His last two scores in India were 63* and 37*...if you include this last innings...that's 3.

  • Puffin on December 5, 2013, 15:46 GMT

    Many will be wondering what will things will be like once Chanderpaul retires.

  • on December 5, 2013, 15:24 GMT

    Anyone who is recommending Charles / Walton as a test keeper really haven't seen either play . At best 50/50 chances accepted/ dropped . If looking for a keeper , look at young keepers and develop them . Pooran? Under 19 team ?

  • CricketChat on December 5, 2013, 15:04 GMT

    Can WI push the match into 5th day? That would be some improvement given the dismal showing in tests in Ind.

  • abc_akram on December 5, 2013, 14:54 GMT

    I am really surprised by WICB'S selection policy. What's the rationale in not selecting experienced fast bowlers like Ravi Rampaul, Jerome Taylor and Fidel Edwards and Sunil Narine is also not playing, West Indies batsmen should also dig in and apply themselves. Lendl Simmons can be given some more chances. Shannon Gabriel is not bowling well but he is being persisted with, and moreover Tino Best and Gabriel are bowling too many shot pitched deliveries giving easy pickings for the kiwi batsmen. Probably the present Windies fast bowlers should watch more videos of Ambrose,Garner,Marshall,Walsh Holding Roberts.

  • on December 5, 2013, 14:22 GMT

    W.I will draw this match. They will shock us. Lil

  • on December 5, 2013, 12:35 GMT

    Even NZ will be embarrassed by the likely result of this game. The gulf between the 2 teams is palpable.

  • on December 5, 2013, 9:27 GMT

    west indies team making tour to enjoy' even after 5 yrs they can't learn anything.

  • Diaz54 on December 5, 2013, 9:22 GMT

    Report says Panesar bowled well in patches and loose in others. No evidence of this in his stats. He has done very well,again for somebody who gets discarded at will! Commons guys be fair in your assessment. In Dubai and anundhabi...he was outstanding. Apparently according to Strauss he is not a good tourist...take what you think from this.

  • StevieS on December 5, 2013, 8:44 GMT

    iceaxe England also couldn't produce the same amount of swing as Boult and Southee last season. I have said it before but Boult and Southee are up there with the best when the ball is doiing something. I read somewhere that over the last 3 years Southee has the 3rd best record behind Steyn and Phillander.

  • on December 5, 2013, 8:33 GMT

    @delboy Please quote correct(at worse near to correct) stats. Esp since every possible stat is available on this site!!! 9 15 8 1 0 112.50 7 caught 2 v Zimbabwe Roseau 20 Mar 2013 Test # 2083 16 26 19 4 0 84.21 7 caught 1 v India Kolkata 6 Nov 2013 Test # 2101 8 41 29 1 0 27.58 7 bowled 3 v India Kolkata 6 Nov 2013 Test # 2101 0 2 2 0 0 0.00 8 caught 1 v India Mumbai 14 Nov 2013 Test # 2102 1 5 8 0 0 12.50 9 lbw 3 v India Mumbai 14 Nov 2013 Test # 2102 27* 43 22 6 0 122.72 8 not out 2 v New Zealand Dunedin 3 Dec 2013 Test # 2104

  • Rally_Windies on December 5, 2013, 7:51 GMT

    I still want to know why Rampaul is not playing ....

    the pitches suit his bowling .....

    he might have taken 4 wickets ....

    and I will say it again....

    with Doenarine, bowling so well why do you need 2 offspinners ?

    Why can't Doenarine bowl 30 overs in a game ?

    His strike rate is better than Shillingford's ...

    and the quality of the wickets he takes are of a front line bowler ...

    Doenarine is no "part time" spinner ....

    He is better than Hooper and Richards ....

    and almost as good as Shilingford ...

    Deonarine is a wasted resource ....

  • on December 5, 2013, 7:15 GMT

    "New Zealand would believe, were extremely low against a West Indies batting line-up low on confidence in the longer format" says it all....west indies travel whole to gift things before christmas?? they gifted centuries and 5-wicket hauls to indians and now they are doing it here...are they really interested in playing test cricket??

  • on December 5, 2013, 7:11 GMT

    WI players are not changing with a non-playing captain. Lets change selectors now. dont understand why Ramdin is in the team. i really hate because of his non-performance. why cling in the team, please leave the team and let youngsters come in. pl help wi cricket by allowing youngsters to play

  • Mayaro_Man on December 5, 2013, 7:08 GMT

    @delboy, Sammy was not N.O in his last three innings. Did you not see his batting in India?

  • British_North_America on December 5, 2013, 7:04 GMT

    Ricardo Mitchell Deonaraine>Naraine

  • on December 5, 2013, 3:57 GMT

    Congrads Tiger-Paul....11,000 runs I think putting up with Gibson's rubbish was harder for him.

  • mngc1 on December 5, 2013, 3:53 GMT

    @rajesh. The only people that would pick Charles as keeper do not know that to date he missed about 45 % of chances.

  • on December 5, 2013, 2:11 GMT

    Ordinary WI team this. Wonder what is Sammy's role in this XI. if they want to be successful, they will have to play some of their trusted Lieutenants at least for 2 more years:

    Gayle, K Edwards, Samuels, C'Paul, Sarwan, Dwyane Bravo, Charles (W), Roach, Rampaul, Narine, F Edwards

  • delboy on December 5, 2013, 1:35 GMT

    Is no one going to get on Sammy's case for being not out in his last three innings?

  • iceaxe on December 5, 2013, 1:33 GMT

    Wow! WI shown up a lot here. Why couldn't they produce the same swing as NZ?

  • on December 5, 2013, 1:30 GMT

    What a disgrace! Why on earth these fools don't think. How can you not play Narine and play Deonarine? Ramdin should not be in the side. This shows lack of unity, pride, and self respect. Where is the next captain going to come from? where is the next crop of good fast bowlers going to come from? Oh my gosh.!!!!

  • on December 5, 2013, 0:16 GMT

    Congratulation Chanderpaul.....................very good batsmen................

  • on December 5, 2013, 0:10 GMT

    How is Chanderpaul not the captain when he's the leader of the side by a million miles?

  • on December 5, 2013, 0:01 GMT

    Congrats to Shiv Chanderpaul...top it off with a century now

  • Mayaro_Man on December 5, 2013, 0:01 GMT

    Congrats Shiv, the last of our world class players. What an impressive landmark and a testimony to your skill, professionalism and desire. May some of the spineless others try to learn from you.

  • darsh127 on December 4, 2013, 23:55 GMT

    One must truly feel for Chanderpaul for having to deal with such rubbish.

  • cyborg on December 4, 2013, 23:54 GMT

    im loving the commentary on this test so far , they are killing west indies in all parts of this game

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • cyborg on December 4, 2013, 23:54 GMT

    im loving the commentary on this test so far , they are killing west indies in all parts of this game

  • darsh127 on December 4, 2013, 23:55 GMT

    One must truly feel for Chanderpaul for having to deal with such rubbish.

  • Mayaro_Man on December 5, 2013, 0:01 GMT

    Congrats Shiv, the last of our world class players. What an impressive landmark and a testimony to your skill, professionalism and desire. May some of the spineless others try to learn from you.

  • on December 5, 2013, 0:01 GMT

    Congrats to Shiv Chanderpaul...top it off with a century now

  • on December 5, 2013, 0:10 GMT

    How is Chanderpaul not the captain when he's the leader of the side by a million miles?

  • on December 5, 2013, 0:16 GMT

    Congratulation Chanderpaul.....................very good batsmen................

  • on December 5, 2013, 1:30 GMT

    What a disgrace! Why on earth these fools don't think. How can you not play Narine and play Deonarine? Ramdin should not be in the side. This shows lack of unity, pride, and self respect. Where is the next captain going to come from? where is the next crop of good fast bowlers going to come from? Oh my gosh.!!!!

  • iceaxe on December 5, 2013, 1:33 GMT

    Wow! WI shown up a lot here. Why couldn't they produce the same swing as NZ?

  • delboy on December 5, 2013, 1:35 GMT

    Is no one going to get on Sammy's case for being not out in his last three innings?

  • on December 5, 2013, 2:11 GMT

    Ordinary WI team this. Wonder what is Sammy's role in this XI. if they want to be successful, they will have to play some of their trusted Lieutenants at least for 2 more years:

    Gayle, K Edwards, Samuels, C'Paul, Sarwan, Dwyane Bravo, Charles (W), Roach, Rampaul, Narine, F Edwards