ICC Combined XI v England XI, Tour match, Dubai January 6, 2012

Bresnan injury opens door for Finn

George Dobell
24

Success in sport is often attributed to discipline, dedication and determination but, so often, it's blind luck that makes the crucial contribution.

So it could prove for Steven Finn or Chris Tremlett. Both travelled to the UAE knowing they could well spend several weeks doing little more than providing net bowling for their colleagues. Yet, after Tim Bresnan was ruled out of the warm-up match against ICC Combined Associate and Affiliate XI, one of Finn or Tremlett has an excellent opportunity to stake a persuasive claim for a Test place.

It would be premature to completely discount Bresnan as a possibility for the first Test. Andrew Strauss declared himself "hopeful" that the Yorkshireman would be "ready for the second warm-up [match]." But, with only one three-day game to come before three back-to-back Tests, it would something of a gamble to select Bresnan as one of England's three pace bowlers.

That could well leave Finn and Tremlett competing for one place. While Tremlett has a fine record since his return to the Test side, there is a sense that Finn is the rising power within English cricket. Not only did he provide a rare beacon of joy amid England's limited-overs thrashing in India but, aged just 22, he's already the quickest bowler in the squad. He's raw, certainly, but has all the attributes to carve out a fine career at the top level.

Tremlett, meanwhile, is struggling with a sore eye. While Strauss dismissed that of "no great concern", it would be typical of Tremlett's ill-fortune if such an unavoidable incident should thwart him. He's previously been sidelined by a tendon cut in a freak washing-up accident and a lung punctured by a misplaced acupuncture needle. While the cynics have long criticised Tremlett's attitude and commitment, the truth is he's simply enjoyed little luck.

There's also an interesting sub-plot to this match. Among the opposition is the Ireland and Warwickshire fast bowler Boyd Rankin. After a domestic season in which Marcus Trescothick rated him the best fast bowler he faced, Rankin has forced his way into the England Lions squad and knows that a strong performance here will take him even closer to the Test squad. It's a prospect that will be viewed with bitter-sweet phlegmatism by Irish cricket lovers. In the longer-term, George Dockrell, a 19-year-old left-arm spinner with Somerset, is another who could follow the same route.

They are not the only ones with special incentive, however. The ICC side are itching to show the strength of Associate and Affiliate cricket and feel that a good game will maintain pressure on the ICC to provide greater opportunities for the non-Test nations. Rankin, for example, has argued this current experiment could be continued. "There is room for an Associate team playing Test cricket. A Combined ICC team is more than capable of playing against the best sides in the world," he said. It's an intriguing thought.

England, meanwhile, will be happy to return to competitive cricket after an unusually long break. With just two three-day games in which to prepare for the Test series - a far cry from the preparation they enjoyed going into the Ashes - they know they need to hit the ground running. In this match, each first innings will be limited to a maximum 100 overs and there will not be an opportunity to utilise batsmen or bowlers from outside the selected XI as is sometimes the case with these warm-up matches.

Much as England and Pakistan may wish to move on from the spot-fixing debacle, its shadow will linger over this tour. The trial of the former Essex seamer, Mervyn Westfield, who is accused of offences related to spot-fixing, begins on January 12 and will, inevitably, turn the focus of the cricketing world back towards the sport's grubby underbelly. The trial of Allen Stanford, currently scheduled to begin on January 23, may also revive memories some would rather forget.

Yet there will also be much to savour during this tour. It says much for the abundance of talent in Pakistan that, barely months after losing some of their brightest talents to the spot-fixing debacle, the team are seen as providing a serious threat to England's winning streak. Pakistan have won their last three series and lost just one of their last 12 Tests. World cricket needs a strong Pakistan and their recent progress is heartening.

Perhaps their record flatters to deceive, however. Two of those series wins have come against Bangladesh and Zimbabwe - currently the weakest Test sides - while the other came against a Sri Lankan side in a transitional state. England will provide a far stiffer challenge.

It is sometimes blithely stated that all England's success has come on green pitches favouring seam bowlers. It's not so, however. While England are certainly a daunting proposition in archetypal English conditions, they've also had success on run-filled surfaces. Think of Adelaide, Sydney, Brisbane, Edgbaston and The Oval. With the likes of Alastair Cook, Jonathan Trott and Graeme Swann in the team, England can 'do attrition' as well as anyone. Their opponents underestimate them at their peril.

Pakistan are progressing, but their fragile recovery could well be crushed under the heel of a very impressive England.

England XI (from) Andrew Strauss (capt), Alastair Cook, Jonathan Trott, Kevin Pietersen, Ian Bell, Eoin Morgan, Matt Prior (wk), Stuart Broad, Graeme Swann, Steven Finn, James Anderson, Ravi Bopara, Steven Davies (wk), Chris Tremlett, Monty Panesar

Combined AM XI (from) William Porterfield (capt), George Dockrell, Boyd Rankin, Paul Stirling (all Ireland), Saqib Ali (UAE), Kyle Coetzer, Majid Haq (both Scotland), Hamid Hassan, Mohammed Nabi, Mohammad Shahzad+ (all Afghanistan), Christi Viljoen, Craig Williams (both Namibia)

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • AlanHarrison on January 9, 2012, 11:54 GMT

    @Imran Awan; NZ beat Aus only in 1 test match, not in a series (the series was 1-1). However, I do accept your logic that Pakistan have done pretty well recently. Good luck for the series.

  • Dravid_Pujara_Gravitas on January 7, 2012, 16:27 GMT

    IPL isn't the reason for Bresnan's injury. Or is it? ;)

  • Front-Foot-Lunge on January 7, 2012, 16:08 GMT

    It seems so long ago now that England silenced the last of their critics who said they couldn't play on flat decks. A year or two on from that now comes a new phase: The UAE home to reputably the slowest lowest tracks in the world, where a 90 mph ball doesn't get above waist height. England continue to march on, cricket lovers around the world are looking forward to the forthcoming series.

  • SDHM on January 7, 2012, 16:06 GMT

    I think that an Associations XI as part of Test cricket is a fantastic idea, although the logistics maybe difficult to work out. In the meantime and to help it get off the ground, maybe touring sides to England could play a four day warm up game against an Associate side on every tour? I say that because England are the only team who plays consistently from May through to September, and with everyone else playing at similar times it'd be difficult to have them everywhere at once. It could also put them in the shop window for a county contract, which would help both player development and security no end. Look into it, ICC!

  • on January 7, 2012, 13:52 GMT

    Nice sentiments on spot fixing. However Mr Dobell forgets to mention the drawn series against SA in UAE who have as strong a bowling attack as any of the top sides. Furthermore, in UAE, it will not be the quality of the batsmen but the variety of a team's bowling unit that would win you a test. The balance tilts ever so slightly in the "home" side's favor. Either way it promises to be a most interesting duel. COME ON PAKISTAN!

  • AlanHarrison on January 7, 2012, 11:58 GMT

    A combined ICC associates team may be an 'intriguing thought', George, and has something to say for it rather than Rankin being lost to the English system (if Trescothick's rather surprising assessment comes to fruition), but after the weakness of the ICC XI during the "supertest" in 2005 I can't see it happening. I wonder if the effect of Bresnan's injury will be to prolong his record of playing only for winning test teams. These tests in UAE look a bit tricky, but if Bresnan misses these his next outing might be in Sri Lanka or against West Indies in early-season in England. It is strange how Bresnan seems to keep running into relatively easy opponents or being picked for games that turn out to be not even close. I think he's an OK player, but played 10, won 10, 6 or 7 innings victories makes him look a hell of a lot better still!

  • Stark62 on January 7, 2012, 11:47 GMT

    Well........

    That's the home advantage theory out of the window now!

  • on January 7, 2012, 9:41 GMT

    Pak beat NZ and NZ beat Aus. Pak beat Sri lanka and Sri lanka beat SA in seaming conditions. So we expect another solid performance from Misbah ul Haq. This man has changed the destiny of Pak cricket. Yes he is slow but he is the man who can perform under pressure, Well done skipper. You make nation proud in 2011 and hopes for best in 2012

    imran haripur hazara

  • on January 7, 2012, 9:39 GMT

    well played afghan batsmen shahzad against england. england bowlers couldnt restrict him from century.. and wish him a good luck'

  • yorkslanka on January 7, 2012, 8:27 GMT

    wow what a HUGE waste of time this game is...players talk about burn out and then play rubbish like this game...at least the IPL is only 20 overs with some competition...

  • AlanHarrison on January 9, 2012, 11:54 GMT

    @Imran Awan; NZ beat Aus only in 1 test match, not in a series (the series was 1-1). However, I do accept your logic that Pakistan have done pretty well recently. Good luck for the series.

  • Dravid_Pujara_Gravitas on January 7, 2012, 16:27 GMT

    IPL isn't the reason for Bresnan's injury. Or is it? ;)

  • Front-Foot-Lunge on January 7, 2012, 16:08 GMT

    It seems so long ago now that England silenced the last of their critics who said they couldn't play on flat decks. A year or two on from that now comes a new phase: The UAE home to reputably the slowest lowest tracks in the world, where a 90 mph ball doesn't get above waist height. England continue to march on, cricket lovers around the world are looking forward to the forthcoming series.

  • SDHM on January 7, 2012, 16:06 GMT

    I think that an Associations XI as part of Test cricket is a fantastic idea, although the logistics maybe difficult to work out. In the meantime and to help it get off the ground, maybe touring sides to England could play a four day warm up game against an Associate side on every tour? I say that because England are the only team who plays consistently from May through to September, and with everyone else playing at similar times it'd be difficult to have them everywhere at once. It could also put them in the shop window for a county contract, which would help both player development and security no end. Look into it, ICC!

  • on January 7, 2012, 13:52 GMT

    Nice sentiments on spot fixing. However Mr Dobell forgets to mention the drawn series against SA in UAE who have as strong a bowling attack as any of the top sides. Furthermore, in UAE, it will not be the quality of the batsmen but the variety of a team's bowling unit that would win you a test. The balance tilts ever so slightly in the "home" side's favor. Either way it promises to be a most interesting duel. COME ON PAKISTAN!

  • AlanHarrison on January 7, 2012, 11:58 GMT

    A combined ICC associates team may be an 'intriguing thought', George, and has something to say for it rather than Rankin being lost to the English system (if Trescothick's rather surprising assessment comes to fruition), but after the weakness of the ICC XI during the "supertest" in 2005 I can't see it happening. I wonder if the effect of Bresnan's injury will be to prolong his record of playing only for winning test teams. These tests in UAE look a bit tricky, but if Bresnan misses these his next outing might be in Sri Lanka or against West Indies in early-season in England. It is strange how Bresnan seems to keep running into relatively easy opponents or being picked for games that turn out to be not even close. I think he's an OK player, but played 10, won 10, 6 or 7 innings victories makes him look a hell of a lot better still!

  • Stark62 on January 7, 2012, 11:47 GMT

    Well........

    That's the home advantage theory out of the window now!

  • on January 7, 2012, 9:41 GMT

    Pak beat NZ and NZ beat Aus. Pak beat Sri lanka and Sri lanka beat SA in seaming conditions. So we expect another solid performance from Misbah ul Haq. This man has changed the destiny of Pak cricket. Yes he is slow but he is the man who can perform under pressure, Well done skipper. You make nation proud in 2011 and hopes for best in 2012

    imran haripur hazara

  • on January 7, 2012, 9:39 GMT

    well played afghan batsmen shahzad against england. england bowlers couldnt restrict him from century.. and wish him a good luck'

  • yorkslanka on January 7, 2012, 8:27 GMT

    wow what a HUGE waste of time this game is...players talk about burn out and then play rubbish like this game...at least the IPL is only 20 overs with some competition...

  • jonesy2 on January 7, 2012, 8:08 GMT

    that steve davies is england's back up keeper? oh my how does a side with such a lack of depth be number 1? food for thought

  • SamRoy on January 7, 2012, 7:24 GMT

    @Boyd Rankin and George Dockrell ought to be playing test cricket for Ireland. Terrible policies from ICC (only looks at money and not quality). Well this is getting disgusting beyond imagination. I still wonder why the English football team can't take players from Wales, Ireland, Northen Ireland and Scotland. They will never win the World Cup unless it's played at home and unless they start looking at foreign exports :).

  • jonesy2 on January 7, 2012, 6:30 GMT

    that is a pretty terrible combined team. if ryan ten doeshate and tom cooper were playing i would back it to beat england tom cooper being better than all of their batsmen and RTD being an allrounder that they dont have

  • on January 7, 2012, 6:17 GMT

    Real shame if Bresnan is injured, hope he's OK in time for the actual series, his style of bowling seems best suited to the conditions. Also a batting average of 45 is not to be sniffed at. Still should be an interesting warm up with players in both side with something to prove.

  • zenboomerang on January 7, 2012, 5:52 GMT

    I hope Bresnan recovers for the 1st Test... An exciting bowling allrounder who always gives good value for money whenever he plays... It should be a good test of both bowling units & seeing where Pakistan is at in an amazing rebuilding year... Lets hope for a close series...

  • zenboomerang on January 7, 2012, 5:51 GMT

    @George Dobell... The wickets at Adelaide, Sydney, Brisbane last summer were as close to English conditions as you will ever see these wkts - the wettest summer for decades, with rain & cloudy weather constant in all these Tests... You also came up against the weakest Oz team for 25 years... lol... doesn't really say much about where England was at, but how low Aust were - probably about 7th in Test ranking on form... You really need to get out more... lol...

  • DocBindra on January 7, 2012, 5:46 GMT

    The fragile England United squad is already starting to fall by the way side. How long has the United squad have to get healthy??... and here we go...LOL. Who will be next with a pulled groin or a "niggle"?

  • Dravid_Pujara_Gravitas on January 7, 2012, 1:39 GMT

    Is Bresnan an active player in IPL? ;)

  • Front-Foot-Lunge on January 6, 2012, 23:44 GMT

    One of the top 5 bowlers in the world is the strong Yorkshire lad: England'll miss him, but as England have proved time and time again, and silenced their critics and doubters time and time again, the strength and depth to the squad, as shown in players like Finn, means they're still very strong even if they don't play their first team!

  • on January 6, 2012, 20:31 GMT

    Will they play a 5th bowler with no Bres? Swanny, Jimmy, Tremmers/Finn, Panesar not the strongest tail in history :-)

  • KashifMuneer on January 6, 2012, 20:20 GMT

    Bresnan's loss would be crucial as it would almost wipe the batting advantage that England's tail have over Pakistan. While Finn or Tremlett are as good as Bresnan in the bowling department, they lack his batting skills. Broad and Swann are hit and miss with the bat and Finn and Anderson would create a tail only marginally stronger than Rehman, Ajmal, Gul and Wahab.

  • gunnerr4life on January 6, 2012, 20:11 GMT

    Doesn't make much difference because Finn is a quality bowler !

  • Lord_Dravid on January 6, 2012, 19:11 GMT

    england pacers are only good in their own conditions..remember your playing in sub continent conditions..this is not england or australia!

  • GreenTeam-Elite on January 6, 2012, 18:42 GMT

    Bresnan is a Good Wicket Taking Bowler!!! I Think England is Going to Miss him in whole Series!!!

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • GreenTeam-Elite on January 6, 2012, 18:42 GMT

    Bresnan is a Good Wicket Taking Bowler!!! I Think England is Going to Miss him in whole Series!!!

  • Lord_Dravid on January 6, 2012, 19:11 GMT

    england pacers are only good in their own conditions..remember your playing in sub continent conditions..this is not england or australia!

  • gunnerr4life on January 6, 2012, 20:11 GMT

    Doesn't make much difference because Finn is a quality bowler !

  • KashifMuneer on January 6, 2012, 20:20 GMT

    Bresnan's loss would be crucial as it would almost wipe the batting advantage that England's tail have over Pakistan. While Finn or Tremlett are as good as Bresnan in the bowling department, they lack his batting skills. Broad and Swann are hit and miss with the bat and Finn and Anderson would create a tail only marginally stronger than Rehman, Ajmal, Gul and Wahab.

  • on January 6, 2012, 20:31 GMT

    Will they play a 5th bowler with no Bres? Swanny, Jimmy, Tremmers/Finn, Panesar not the strongest tail in history :-)

  • Front-Foot-Lunge on January 6, 2012, 23:44 GMT

    One of the top 5 bowlers in the world is the strong Yorkshire lad: England'll miss him, but as England have proved time and time again, and silenced their critics and doubters time and time again, the strength and depth to the squad, as shown in players like Finn, means they're still very strong even if they don't play their first team!

  • Dravid_Pujara_Gravitas on January 7, 2012, 1:39 GMT

    Is Bresnan an active player in IPL? ;)

  • DocBindra on January 7, 2012, 5:46 GMT

    The fragile England United squad is already starting to fall by the way side. How long has the United squad have to get healthy??... and here we go...LOL. Who will be next with a pulled groin or a "niggle"?

  • zenboomerang on January 7, 2012, 5:51 GMT

    @George Dobell... The wickets at Adelaide, Sydney, Brisbane last summer were as close to English conditions as you will ever see these wkts - the wettest summer for decades, with rain & cloudy weather constant in all these Tests... You also came up against the weakest Oz team for 25 years... lol... doesn't really say much about where England was at, but how low Aust were - probably about 7th in Test ranking on form... You really need to get out more... lol...

  • zenboomerang on January 7, 2012, 5:52 GMT

    I hope Bresnan recovers for the 1st Test... An exciting bowling allrounder who always gives good value for money whenever he plays... It should be a good test of both bowling units & seeing where Pakistan is at in an amazing rebuilding year... Lets hope for a close series...