Pakistan v South Africa, 1st Test, Dubai, 3rd day November 14, 2010

South Africa in control after Morkel and Botha star

13

South Africa 380 and 139 for 2 (Amla 44*, Kallis, 32*) lead Pakistan 248 (Hafeez 60, Azhar 56, Morkel 5-54) by 271 runs
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

South Africa reasserted their control on the opening Test in Dubai with Johan Botha and Morne Morkel combining to run through Pakistan and earn their team a significant advantage which had been extended to 271 by the close. Botha took three wickets during the morning session in a teasing spell, then after lunch Morkel wrapped up the innings with the second new ball to finish with for 5 for 54 and leave South Africa well placed to push for victory.

Pakistan's second-day fightback had created the possibility of a close-fought match, but that chance receded as the batting subsided in familiar fashion after reaching a promising 176 for 2. Their demise - from Younis Khan's dismissal to when Saeed Ajmal gave Morkel his fifth wicket - was 8 for 72, almost identical to South Africa's own collapse of 8 for 73 on Saturday. However, South Africa had already been given a significant cushion by their top order and Pakistan's latest batting failure left them with an almost irretrievable situation, especially as they are down to one frontline quick bowler.

South Africa didn't set pulses racing as they added to the lead but were intent on setting a base for acceleration tomorrow. Alviro Petersen and Graeme Smith were both unlucky to be given lbw by Asoka de Silva, although Smith had lived dangerously against the spinners, but Hashim Amla and Jacques Kallis accumulated steadily during the final session without extending themselves too far. Occasionally the pair used their feet, but largely they were content to keep the ball along the ground.

After a wayward start in the first 10 overs of Pakistan's innings on Saturday, which allowed the openers a racing start, South Africa became increasingly impressive in the field. Smith led them intelligently, rotating his quick bowlers to keep them fresh and allowing Botha, whose offspin has added a useful dimension to the team, a long spell to work over the batsmen. Younis showed some early intent, but Morkel and Dale Steyn didn't offer many scoring opportunities which meant when wickets started to fall the scoreboard hadn't moved very far.

Following an initial burst from the pacemen, spin was introduced and Botha quickly settled onto a testing length. There was a clear plan to get Younis working to the leg side and the reward came when a chip shot was well caught at short midwicket while the ball noticeably dusted the surface. Not a good sign for Pakistan's hopes when batting last.

Misbah-ul-Haq, Pakistan's fourth Test captain of the year, tried to lead by example as he set himself for a long innings, but was removed by an outstanding catch at short leg by Amla. Botha got another delivery to grip and it took the glove as Misbah played forward and Amla dived low to his left to grasp the chance inches off the turf.

The less said about Umar Akmal's attempt to build a Test innings the better. Two flamboyant cover drives showed he was in no mood to hang around and then, 15 minutes before lunch, he tried to heave a delivery over the leg side and lost so much control of the bat it ended up in one hand. The ball sailed straight up and landed in Steyn's hands at backward point. Umar left admonishing himself, but it felt a hollow gesture because the outcome was so predictable.

In complete contrast to Umar's self-destructiveness, Azhar Ali largely remained cocooned in his own defensive mindset but his reckless colleague could learn a few things about putting a price on the wicket. Occasionally, though, Azhar came out of his shell, with one boundary carved over cover against Kallis, and a loft off Paul Harris just over a leaping mid-on. Azhar's next attempt at dominating the spin was more convincing as he cleanly struck Harris straight, and his fifty came, off 144 balls, shortly before lunch.

Adnan Akmal showed aggression runs all the way through the family by opening his Test account with a crunching sweep off Botha, but was soon taught a lesson about the highest level when he was worked over by a high-class spell from Steyn with the new ball. Steyn, who is getting better the more he bowls after an injury lay-off, curved the ball away from the right hander until Adnan couldn't resist a drive and edged to Mark Boucher.

Then it was over to Morkel, South Africa's in-form bowler from the one-day series, as Abdur Rehman fenced to third slip with South Africa now on a surge. Azhar's impressive 172-ball resistance ended amid the collapse, but his dismissal was far less batsman error and much more fielding excellence as Amla pulled off another superb grab from Azhar's well-timed flick.

Wahab Riaz wasn't interested in seeing how long he could survive with an injured side and top-edged a wild leg-side heave, and Umar Gul, who launched Botha over midwicket for six, was left stranded when Ajmal gloved down the leg side to complete Morkel's haul. It was a clinical example of how to close out an innings and left Pakistan with a long battle to save the Test.

Andrew McGlashan is an assistant editor at Cricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on November 15, 2010, 7:57 GMT

    I would prefer nothing else other then a humiliating defeat for the Pakistan team. They need to hit rock bottom so there's no way but up after that before i'll start hoping for a win rather then pleading!

    - A dedicated Pakistani fan

  • anver777 on November 15, 2010, 6:17 GMT

    SA must declare by tea on 4th day for a result...otherwise Paks will survive and will draw the match!!!!!!!!!

  • on November 15, 2010, 4:39 GMT

    Its not the blowers fires its Umpires who fires by given wrong decisions during the batting of Pakistan team and when Pakistan were blowing the third class umpires of were even not give the clearly plum outs how shame is this is for ICC and other umpires. i.e. the ball which Younis Khan got out that was clearly a no ball by john bota which have mentioned by Mich Haisman during the commentary i think at that time umpair was sleeping like jack. so many other decision are bad but i have no time to mention them all.

  • on November 14, 2010, 23:06 GMT

    No I dont think they deserve any kind of appreciation, this not the level of cricket we want to see because Pakistan team has always been a fighter team in the past but batting(test matches) is really bad now. if they continue like this they will lost every test series.

  • cric4world on November 14, 2010, 20:30 GMT

    who says its a poor performance by pakistan? half of the team is brand new to international cricket n none of new players has a regular experienced team mate to gain experience from.rest of the half of team members r making their come back.pak doesnt have a single regular test bowler in their team.still apart from umar akmal every batsman contributed some how n it was widely expected misbah wont perform at all.considering all the things happening all around pakistan team i think they r fighting hard n deserve appreciation. dont forget they r playing against the most organised and inform team of the world who r best in all departments of the game.this match should b over in 3 days n 1 session if u look at the difference between both teams.

  • on November 14, 2010, 19:53 GMT

    If the PCB had made logical decisions over the past couple of years and wasn't run by a clown the following would be the test and one day teams. Notice how the teams match the temperament for the format required and don't go on just talent. Also note how many of these players have not been offered consistent spots on the team roster or have been sidelined such as Asif, Amir, Butt and Haider. Large periods of time wasted for Yousuf and Younis due to drama.

    Test team - No Akmals here 1. Salman Butt 2. Taufeeq Umar 3. Younis Khan 4. Mhd Yousuf 5. Azhar Ali (solid as a rock) 6. Khurram Manzoor (showed discipline when he did come good) 7. zulqarnain haider (ideally suited for long format) 8. Mhd Asif 9. Mhd Ammir 10. Danish Kaneria 11. Umar Gul

    One day team - Put Akmals here. Akmals are senseless blasters!

    1. Kamran Akmal 2. Salman Butt 3. Younis Khan 4. Mhd Yousuf 5. Umar Akmal 6. Shahid Afridi 7. Abdul Razzaq 8. Mhd Amir 9 Umar Gul 10. Ajmal 11. Shoaib Akhtar

  • on November 14, 2010, 19:04 GMT

    When will SA learn that Harris is NOT a spinner of the ball. Give Robin Petersen a chance. He can at least bat too! If SA can't win the series 2-0 then it is a poor performance by SA because Pakistan are without Wahab Riaz & of course Asif & Aamir.

  • Umms on November 14, 2010, 17:50 GMT

    For Pakistan, its same old story. For SA, they may done well by taking handy lead, but keeping in mind of a weak opposition in all areas, SA performance is not that great. Pakistan playing test match with inexperienced bowlers except Gul and one got injured in due course and they could not even cross 400!!!!. Pakistan batsmen needs to understand the technique of staying at the crease by not blocking the balls. How come they find difficult to get singles!!!!

  • sharprider on November 14, 2010, 17:34 GMT

    Yet another pathetic display by the Pakistani batsmen, and that too after discovering that they have to bowl without one of their regular bowlers, The main culprit is Misbah himself followed by our so-called promising star, Umar and the supposed mainstay of our batting, Younus. These three are actually the BACKBONE of our batting and should have taken upon themselves to lay the foundation for a reasonable score. Anyway, the milk has been spilled and there is no point in crying over it now. Pakistan can only hope for the best but we fans have to be prepared for the worst.

  • khurramsch on November 14, 2010, 16:33 GMT

    poor display from pakistan. i think coming bck from this stage is almost imposible. with 1 bowler short & batting in 4th inings on a slower track will be very dificult for pakistan. it sems tht umar akmal has no more temprament for tests. hav seen him in 6 test during england tour & seen him today. he is going no where. he has already ben droped in oDIs for performance i think same could b done in tests.gv Asad shafiq a chanc. top 4 did get starts but failed to go longer. 2nd new ball proved deadly for pakistan & thy scored so slow tht thy were way behind..i think SA will dec near 400.

  • on November 15, 2010, 7:57 GMT

    I would prefer nothing else other then a humiliating defeat for the Pakistan team. They need to hit rock bottom so there's no way but up after that before i'll start hoping for a win rather then pleading!

    - A dedicated Pakistani fan

  • anver777 on November 15, 2010, 6:17 GMT

    SA must declare by tea on 4th day for a result...otherwise Paks will survive and will draw the match!!!!!!!!!

  • on November 15, 2010, 4:39 GMT

    Its not the blowers fires its Umpires who fires by given wrong decisions during the batting of Pakistan team and when Pakistan were blowing the third class umpires of were even not give the clearly plum outs how shame is this is for ICC and other umpires. i.e. the ball which Younis Khan got out that was clearly a no ball by john bota which have mentioned by Mich Haisman during the commentary i think at that time umpair was sleeping like jack. so many other decision are bad but i have no time to mention them all.

  • on November 14, 2010, 23:06 GMT

    No I dont think they deserve any kind of appreciation, this not the level of cricket we want to see because Pakistan team has always been a fighter team in the past but batting(test matches) is really bad now. if they continue like this they will lost every test series.

  • cric4world on November 14, 2010, 20:30 GMT

    who says its a poor performance by pakistan? half of the team is brand new to international cricket n none of new players has a regular experienced team mate to gain experience from.rest of the half of team members r making their come back.pak doesnt have a single regular test bowler in their team.still apart from umar akmal every batsman contributed some how n it was widely expected misbah wont perform at all.considering all the things happening all around pakistan team i think they r fighting hard n deserve appreciation. dont forget they r playing against the most organised and inform team of the world who r best in all departments of the game.this match should b over in 3 days n 1 session if u look at the difference between both teams.

  • on November 14, 2010, 19:53 GMT

    If the PCB had made logical decisions over the past couple of years and wasn't run by a clown the following would be the test and one day teams. Notice how the teams match the temperament for the format required and don't go on just talent. Also note how many of these players have not been offered consistent spots on the team roster or have been sidelined such as Asif, Amir, Butt and Haider. Large periods of time wasted for Yousuf and Younis due to drama.

    Test team - No Akmals here 1. Salman Butt 2. Taufeeq Umar 3. Younis Khan 4. Mhd Yousuf 5. Azhar Ali (solid as a rock) 6. Khurram Manzoor (showed discipline when he did come good) 7. zulqarnain haider (ideally suited for long format) 8. Mhd Asif 9. Mhd Ammir 10. Danish Kaneria 11. Umar Gul

    One day team - Put Akmals here. Akmals are senseless blasters!

    1. Kamran Akmal 2. Salman Butt 3. Younis Khan 4. Mhd Yousuf 5. Umar Akmal 6. Shahid Afridi 7. Abdul Razzaq 8. Mhd Amir 9 Umar Gul 10. Ajmal 11. Shoaib Akhtar

  • on November 14, 2010, 19:04 GMT

    When will SA learn that Harris is NOT a spinner of the ball. Give Robin Petersen a chance. He can at least bat too! If SA can't win the series 2-0 then it is a poor performance by SA because Pakistan are without Wahab Riaz & of course Asif & Aamir.

  • Umms on November 14, 2010, 17:50 GMT

    For Pakistan, its same old story. For SA, they may done well by taking handy lead, but keeping in mind of a weak opposition in all areas, SA performance is not that great. Pakistan playing test match with inexperienced bowlers except Gul and one got injured in due course and they could not even cross 400!!!!. Pakistan batsmen needs to understand the technique of staying at the crease by not blocking the balls. How come they find difficult to get singles!!!!

  • sharprider on November 14, 2010, 17:34 GMT

    Yet another pathetic display by the Pakistani batsmen, and that too after discovering that they have to bowl without one of their regular bowlers, The main culprit is Misbah himself followed by our so-called promising star, Umar and the supposed mainstay of our batting, Younus. These three are actually the BACKBONE of our batting and should have taken upon themselves to lay the foundation for a reasonable score. Anyway, the milk has been spilled and there is no point in crying over it now. Pakistan can only hope for the best but we fans have to be prepared for the worst.

  • khurramsch on November 14, 2010, 16:33 GMT

    poor display from pakistan. i think coming bck from this stage is almost imposible. with 1 bowler short & batting in 4th inings on a slower track will be very dificult for pakistan. it sems tht umar akmal has no more temprament for tests. hav seen him in 6 test during england tour & seen him today. he is going no where. he has already ben droped in oDIs for performance i think same could b done in tests.gv Asad shafiq a chanc. top 4 did get starts but failed to go longer. 2nd new ball proved deadly for pakistan & thy scored so slow tht thy were way behind..i think SA will dec near 400.

  • on November 14, 2010, 15:53 GMT

    I knew Pakistan will collapse, I was hoping they reach atleast 300 to save the match but the batsmen failed to score again. this match is over for almost over now..

  • smjr on November 14, 2010, 14:58 GMT

    The shot played by Umar Akmal is just un-acceptable. This 20 year old lad show glimpse of talent but he should not play at this level (Test match) unless he show form and temperament in domestic 4 day tournament. Misbah is out of sort and never look like delivering some thing special. I cant understand if Misbah is included in Test side having age of 36 years then why Asim Kamal having average of 39 and a proper test batsman not selected. We are not having back up talent to replace Younus and Yousaf in Test matches.There are good players in domestic cricket but not quality one to play at he highest level. We may try Fawad Alam in Test matches and not in one day, he has the capacity to play long innings. He has just played only 3 test matches.Another thing that Pakistan bating require is one or two batsman should scores quickly and have powers in their shots so that the scoring rate increases and put pressure on opposing team. Shahzaib could be tried in test in place of Umar Akmal.

  • smjr on November 14, 2010, 14:40 GMT

    In my earlier comment on this forum I have said that if Pakistan scores 400 plus then they are safe and have bright chance of winning the test match. South Africa will win this test match before tea on fifth day. I cant see Pakistani batsman surviving for a longer period. Since winning the T-20 World cup, in 30 test innings prior to this series Pakistan has crossed 400 plus in just two innings.They have lost 10 Tests and won only 02 tests. So batting is a very big problem for Pakistan. Ironically we have two bowling coaches but no batting coach. All batsman except Azhar Ali and Taufiq Umer lacks the temperament, concentration, application, stamina and patience which are the basic ingredients of a test batsman. In past we have players like Miandad, Zaheer, Salim Malik, Inzamam, Mudassar who plays longer innings and adjust to the conditions very well thats why we won more test and lost few. Our bowling is alright at resent or in past.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • smjr on November 14, 2010, 14:40 GMT

    In my earlier comment on this forum I have said that if Pakistan scores 400 plus then they are safe and have bright chance of winning the test match. South Africa will win this test match before tea on fifth day. I cant see Pakistani batsman surviving for a longer period. Since winning the T-20 World cup, in 30 test innings prior to this series Pakistan has crossed 400 plus in just two innings.They have lost 10 Tests and won only 02 tests. So batting is a very big problem for Pakistan. Ironically we have two bowling coaches but no batting coach. All batsman except Azhar Ali and Taufiq Umer lacks the temperament, concentration, application, stamina and patience which are the basic ingredients of a test batsman. In past we have players like Miandad, Zaheer, Salim Malik, Inzamam, Mudassar who plays longer innings and adjust to the conditions very well thats why we won more test and lost few. Our bowling is alright at resent or in past.

  • smjr on November 14, 2010, 14:58 GMT

    The shot played by Umar Akmal is just un-acceptable. This 20 year old lad show glimpse of talent but he should not play at this level (Test match) unless he show form and temperament in domestic 4 day tournament. Misbah is out of sort and never look like delivering some thing special. I cant understand if Misbah is included in Test side having age of 36 years then why Asim Kamal having average of 39 and a proper test batsman not selected. We are not having back up talent to replace Younus and Yousaf in Test matches.There are good players in domestic cricket but not quality one to play at he highest level. We may try Fawad Alam in Test matches and not in one day, he has the capacity to play long innings. He has just played only 3 test matches.Another thing that Pakistan bating require is one or two batsman should scores quickly and have powers in their shots so that the scoring rate increases and put pressure on opposing team. Shahzaib could be tried in test in place of Umar Akmal.

  • on November 14, 2010, 15:53 GMT

    I knew Pakistan will collapse, I was hoping they reach atleast 300 to save the match but the batsmen failed to score again. this match is over for almost over now..

  • khurramsch on November 14, 2010, 16:33 GMT

    poor display from pakistan. i think coming bck from this stage is almost imposible. with 1 bowler short & batting in 4th inings on a slower track will be very dificult for pakistan. it sems tht umar akmal has no more temprament for tests. hav seen him in 6 test during england tour & seen him today. he is going no where. he has already ben droped in oDIs for performance i think same could b done in tests.gv Asad shafiq a chanc. top 4 did get starts but failed to go longer. 2nd new ball proved deadly for pakistan & thy scored so slow tht thy were way behind..i think SA will dec near 400.

  • sharprider on November 14, 2010, 17:34 GMT

    Yet another pathetic display by the Pakistani batsmen, and that too after discovering that they have to bowl without one of their regular bowlers, The main culprit is Misbah himself followed by our so-called promising star, Umar and the supposed mainstay of our batting, Younus. These three are actually the BACKBONE of our batting and should have taken upon themselves to lay the foundation for a reasonable score. Anyway, the milk has been spilled and there is no point in crying over it now. Pakistan can only hope for the best but we fans have to be prepared for the worst.

  • Umms on November 14, 2010, 17:50 GMT

    For Pakistan, its same old story. For SA, they may done well by taking handy lead, but keeping in mind of a weak opposition in all areas, SA performance is not that great. Pakistan playing test match with inexperienced bowlers except Gul and one got injured in due course and they could not even cross 400!!!!. Pakistan batsmen needs to understand the technique of staying at the crease by not blocking the balls. How come they find difficult to get singles!!!!

  • on November 14, 2010, 19:04 GMT

    When will SA learn that Harris is NOT a spinner of the ball. Give Robin Petersen a chance. He can at least bat too! If SA can't win the series 2-0 then it is a poor performance by SA because Pakistan are without Wahab Riaz & of course Asif & Aamir.

  • on November 14, 2010, 19:53 GMT

    If the PCB had made logical decisions over the past couple of years and wasn't run by a clown the following would be the test and one day teams. Notice how the teams match the temperament for the format required and don't go on just talent. Also note how many of these players have not been offered consistent spots on the team roster or have been sidelined such as Asif, Amir, Butt and Haider. Large periods of time wasted for Yousuf and Younis due to drama.

    Test team - No Akmals here 1. Salman Butt 2. Taufeeq Umar 3. Younis Khan 4. Mhd Yousuf 5. Azhar Ali (solid as a rock) 6. Khurram Manzoor (showed discipline when he did come good) 7. zulqarnain haider (ideally suited for long format) 8. Mhd Asif 9. Mhd Ammir 10. Danish Kaneria 11. Umar Gul

    One day team - Put Akmals here. Akmals are senseless blasters!

    1. Kamran Akmal 2. Salman Butt 3. Younis Khan 4. Mhd Yousuf 5. Umar Akmal 6. Shahid Afridi 7. Abdul Razzaq 8. Mhd Amir 9 Umar Gul 10. Ajmal 11. Shoaib Akhtar

  • cric4world on November 14, 2010, 20:30 GMT

    who says its a poor performance by pakistan? half of the team is brand new to international cricket n none of new players has a regular experienced team mate to gain experience from.rest of the half of team members r making their come back.pak doesnt have a single regular test bowler in their team.still apart from umar akmal every batsman contributed some how n it was widely expected misbah wont perform at all.considering all the things happening all around pakistan team i think they r fighting hard n deserve appreciation. dont forget they r playing against the most organised and inform team of the world who r best in all departments of the game.this match should b over in 3 days n 1 session if u look at the difference between both teams.

  • on November 14, 2010, 23:06 GMT

    No I dont think they deserve any kind of appreciation, this not the level of cricket we want to see because Pakistan team has always been a fighter team in the past but batting(test matches) is really bad now. if they continue like this they will lost every test series.