World T20 2016 March 9, 2016

Why Pakistan's teams are not travelling to India yet

The ICC has shifted the India-Pakistan match to Kolkata because of security concerns in Dharamsala, but the PCB has reasons for not yet clearing the departure of its teams
78

Play 05:25
Ugra: Indian politics to blame for game moving

The PCB's decision to defer the departure of its men's and women's teams to the World T20 in India pending "an assurance against specific threats to the Pakistan team from various political parties and groups during the tour", is the end result of months of dissatisfaction over handling of India-Pakistan cricket ties in India.

The PCB's announcement came shortly after the ICC had conveyed its decision to shift the March 19 World T20 fixture between India and Pakistan from Dharamsala to Kolkata. The change of venue was expected to bring the controversy surrounding the match to an end; the PCB, however, said its teams would not travel unless they were given high-level assurances from India, following an adverse report by its security team which visited Dharamsala and New Delhi over the weekend. The three-man committee which assessed the security situation in Dharamsala described it as 'unsatisfactory.'

The delay of the Pakistani teams' departures is not a trigger-happy response by the PCB to events of the last 24 hours. It has built up over several months, and reached tipping point when a scheduled meeting in October between the PCB chairman Shaharyar Khan and BCCI officials was cancelled due to anti-Pakistan protests in the BCCI's Mumbai office. These talks had been arranged to discuss the possibility of a long overdue bilateral series, to be hosted by the PCB. Workers from the Shiv Sena, a regional political party, stormed into the BCCI office in Mumbai, shouting anti-Pakistan slogans. It led to an embarrassing departure for the Pakistani delegation led by Shahryar.

The incident led to the PCB losing confidence in BCCI's handling of what is always a delicate situation as well as public support against pushing for matches versus India. It made headlines in Pakistan, with the PCB being severely criticised by political and cricketing quarters. Taking note of the fiasco, the Pakistan government asked the PCB to adopt caution in travelling to India and to do so only after a favourable prior advisory from the centre. In the case of the World T20, neither India's central government in New Delhi nor the Himachal Pradesh state government were able to give any clear assurances about the security that would be put into place for the Pakistan teams.

The state government of Himachal Pradesh in fact categorically refused to assure full-fledged security to the Pakistan team in Dharamsala, citing protests by ex-servicemen's families following incidents along the border. Following that, the Pakistan security delegation's visit did not appear to be taken seriously by the Indian government either.

While the ICC had indirectly assured the PCB of full security, it was not accepted because the only direct word from any government in India had come from the chief minister of Himachal Pradesh, about being unable to protect the team. When the delegation got to Dharamsala, no security plan was presented to them and they had to insist on a meeting with the deputy police commissioner of the region. There, it is learnt, the delegation found that the deputy commissioner did not have any special instructions from the home minister around security for the Pakistan team.

In Delhi, no attempts appeared to have been made by the BCCI to arrange meetings with senior authorities in the central government. The Pakistan delegation spent two days in the Indian capital but were unsuccessful in attempting to establish contact with the Home Ministry to set up a meeting with the Home Minister.

These incidents have further soured cricketing relations between the two countries. The PCB's last two major dealings with the BCCI have been unsatisfactory and led to increasing mistrust. Towards the end of 2015, there was a lack of clarity over playing the bilateral series, with the series abandoned and the BCCI not responding to communiqués from the PCB. India's silent ditching of the bilaterial series, the PCB say had cost them US$40m.

The list of Pakistan's disenchantment over cricketing relations with India stretches back beyond cricket over almost a year. The Shiv Sena's protest in the BCCI office was preceded by the cancellation of concerts in India by two Pakistani singers, Atif Aslam and Ghulam Ali, in April and October 2015. A launch of a book written by former Pakistan foreign minister Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri, also in October, was disrupted by right-wing activists attacking one of the organisers with black ink. After more Shiv Sena protests, which occurred during South Africa's tour of India, Pakistani umpire Aleem Dar and commentators Shoaib Akhtar and Wasim Akram did not travel to Mumbai for an ODI and left the country instead.

All of these events have led the PCB to be more stringent about its security demands on the BCCI and the ICC about the World T20. In such a scenario, if these demands are not met, there is every possibility the PCB may consider pulling both squads out of the tournament.

Umar Farooq is ESPNcricinfo's Pakistan correspondent. @kalson

Comments have now been closed for this article

  •   Syed Shahid Ali on March 11, 2016, 8:32 GMT

    Hy I want cricket .so pray all my Pakistani fan that Pak beat India in their home

  •   Farhan Habib on March 11, 2016, 7:58 GMT

    Indian government issues 'public guarantee' of security for Pakistan teams.....The men's cricket team the women's team is expected to depart for India within the next 24 hours..... yaaaaaaaaaaaay!!!!!!

  • cortadella on March 11, 2016, 7:01 GMT

    Arun parsad you are right provide security so important

  • uncanny on March 11, 2016, 5:21 GMT

    Anyways PCB has already given a go, Pak team is already on its way. So its good for cricket

  •   Saif Rehman on March 11, 2016, 4:58 GMT

    PCB will not send until INDIA provide security insurance in written document ...its good decision and i do agree .... INDIA ashamed

  • Smily Khan on March 11, 2016, 4:04 GMT

    v well wriiten. based on whats been happening i think pcb is right but we will miss pak vs ind match

  •   Abbas Ihsan on March 10, 2016, 23:44 GMT

    Very well written and stating the facts very clearly.

  • Adeel Anjum Malik on March 10, 2016, 22:30 GMT

    I think Indian board should take it very serious either ask their govt to do something or deny the fact that they cannot provide security to Pakistani team

  • ozman750 on March 10, 2016, 21:38 GMT

    PCB is righr...pak team should not travel to india untill they receive secuirity assurance...pak team has direct threats from indian militants shev sena etc. players safety is most important

  • Arun Prasad on March 10, 2016, 20:54 GMT

    I am an Indian and I love India vs Pakistan encounter a lot . In my opinion India should give assurance ....regarding security issues . personally I felt it what himachal chief minister refusing to give proper protection for Pakistan cricket team ...and I believe Pakistan has the right to ask about full proof security . But all these actions ..may it be from pak ..or from India .....it is certainly bad for cricket lovers ....I am not taking anybodies side ...but cricket should be the ultimate winner. ....guys it is just cricket.......enjoy it. .... let there be no hatred between us .......just enjoy the match ....may the best team win .......Pakistan fans .....u guys support fort ur country .....let's support for India........

  • No featured comments at the moment.