Maharashtra v Uttar Pradesh, Ranji Trophy, Group B, Pune

Pune continues to produce lifeless pitches

If the BCCI pulls up state associations for preparing underprepared wickets, it's high time they start doing so with those who come up with paatas that have nothing in them for the bowlers

Amol Karhadkar in Pune

November 11, 2012

Comments: 4 | Text size: A | A

Kedar Jadhav on his way to a triple-century against Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra v Uttar Pradesh, Group B, Ranji Trophy, 2nd day, Pune, November 10, 2012
Despite the first three days witnessing a record triple hundred and three more three-digit scores, the national selectors will hardly be impressed © Mihir Karkhanis
Enlarge

The first three days of Maharashtra's Ranji Trophy opener against Uttar Pradesh in Pune have seen 1051 runs scored for the loss of just seven wickets in 265 overs. There are times when statistics don't really reveal the whole story. But such numbers, heavily stacked in favour of the batsmen, precisely reflect the quality of the 22-yard strip at the Subrata Roy Sahara Stadium. As a result, despite the first three days witnessing a record triple hundred and three more three-digit scores, the national selectors - whose chief Sandeep Patil is watching the game closely since day one - will hardly be impressed with any of the batting performances.

It doesn't come as a surprise that the wicket at the newly-built stadium on the outskirts of Pune has offered a featherbed this time. After all, Pune has traditionally been home for paatas - benign, flat surfaces which offer no help to bowlers. Situated in the heart of Pune, the Nehru Stadium, the city's premier cricket venue till it hosted its last first-class game in 2005, was considered to be a bane for bowlers and a boon for batsmen.

This resulted in very few of the talented Maharashtra batsmen being awarded the Test cap. While Hrishikesh Kanitkar was among the few lucky ones, stalwarts like Milind Gunjal, Shrikant Kalyani (who moved to Bengal later), Shantanu Sugwekar and Surendra Bhave were unfortunately tagged as "flat-wicket specialists". Despite scoring big all over India, none of these prolific batsmen ended up becoming international cricketers.

When the Maharashtra Cricket Association completed the ambitious project of coming up with an ultramodern stadium, it was expected they would buck the trend of producing featherbeds. While last season's Ranji Plate Group knockouts and the Indian Premier League that followed showed the square was far from settled, the first game of this season has ended up denting the expectation in a big way.

The pitch had a tinge of live grass, even on the third day. But neither has it assisted seam movement nor has it offered bounce and spin. All that a decent batsman is required to do is to get his eye in and then score runs at will. So what really has gone wrong with the pitch?

"Since it's the first game of the season, we seem to have missed the trick somewhere. But the good thing is that it has got the batsmen going," said Bhave, Maharashtra's chairman of selectors, who himself is used to preparing wickets. "Going forward, once the team returns after playing three away games, by then we should ensure that instead of a featherbed, we end up offering a sporting wicket. I am confident that will happen."

While the batsmen keep on improving their records on such tracks, bowlers just seem to add blots to theirs. Imtiaz Ahmed, the star of UP's outright victory against a star-studded Delhi line-up last week, went wicketless this game in 41 overs, which cost him 190 runs. No wonder UP coach Venkatesh Prasad, the former India bowler, was more concerned about the nature of domestic pitches than his bowlers' performance.

"I don't really want to go too deep into the performance of the bowlers," Prasad had said after the end of the second day's play. "Yes, I agree they haven't bowled as well as they should have but this is not the wicket for the bowlers to be judged on.

"If a team is getting wickets like this, which is 70-30 in favour of the batsmen, then I think we are just killing the game and it is not good for the sport at all. But anyway, I would not like to decide on this pitch as of now since there are still two more days to go. I will be in a much better position to comment on the pitch, the opposition and our players by the end of the game."

Daljit Singh, the chairman of the BCCI's grounds & pitches committee, said the surface needed attention. "I am a little bit worried about the Pune strip that has produced 700-plus scores," he told PTI. "We need to have a proper look at the pitch.

"The BCCI's directive regarding the wicket that would be prepared for the Ranji Trophy is pretty clear. It should be a sporting wicket where a standard first-innings score should be in the region of 550-plus and it shouldn't start turning square from the first day itself."

If the board pulls up state associations for preparing underprepared wickets, it's high time it starts doing so with those who come up with paatas that have nothing in them for the bowlers.

Amol Karhadkar is a correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Amol Karhadkar

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by alwayscricketfan_Sundu on (November 12, 2012, 5:20 GMT)

Another instance of poor curatorship.... i think as the noise gets louder to stop producing such stupid belters ..more are the no: of pitches prepared as such.... I think the quicker BCCI and ICC understand that a game becomes interesting only when there is an even contest b/w bat and bal. the better it is for Cricketl . V . Prasad's comments are spot on"I think we are just killing the game and it is not good for the sport at all"... Preparation of flat pitches in a domestic tournament may look like a small issue when we think of overall picture of where is Cricket heading too ... but such things in the long run may prove fatal to the game itself

Posted by   on (November 11, 2012, 19:43 GMT)

I don't understand why Raina is upset, after all, it is a well known fact that the Ranji trophy is essentially a battle of first innings.

However, I don't understand why good swing bowlers still don't succeed. It's mostly to do with atmospheric conditions and not the pitch, I would've though that the pitches in India would be producing bowlers who could perform on flat decks.

Posted by sweetspot on (November 11, 2012, 19:21 GMT)

Did Pune recruit some people from the Formula One track laying team? Good job!

Posted by Kohli_DaBest on (November 11, 2012, 16:29 GMT)

i dont mind some good batting tracks tbh. after all, cricket is a batsmen's game nowadays, people dont come to watch wickets tumbling, they come to watch fireworks with the bat. india have a rich history of superb batting lineups, if we want to continue the trend we have to make similar wickets and get batmen's confidence levels high. thats how we have won cricket.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Amol KarhadkarClose
Tournament Results
Mumbai v Saurashtra at Mumbai - Jan 26-28, 2013
Mumbai won by an innings and 125 runs
Services v Mumbai at Delhi - Jan 16-21, 2013
Match drawn (Mumbai won on 1st innings)
Saurashtra v Punjab at Rajkot - Jan 16-20, 2013
Saurashtra won by 229 runs
Jharkhand v Punjab at Jamshedpur - Jan 6-10, 2013
Match drawn (Punjab won on 1st innings)
Mumbai v Baroda at Mumbai - Jan 6-10, 2013
Match drawn (Mumbai won on 1st innings)
Saurashtra v Karnataka at Rajkot - Jan 6-10, 2013
Match drawn (Saurashtra won on 1st innings)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days
Sponsored Links

Why not you? Read and learn how!