Mumbai v Gujarat, Ranji Trophy, 9th round, 4th day

Mumbai abort chase, settle for a draw

Amol Karhadkar

January 1, 2013

Comments: 16 | Text size: A | A

Gujarat 244 (Parthiv 101, Chavan 3-54) and 337 (Juneja 98, Chavan 4-124) drew with Mumbai 447 (Jaffer 171, Kushang 3-79) and 65 for 1 (H Shah 42*)

Mumbai aborted a chase of 135 off a minimum of 41 overs and instead settled for three points for the first innings lead against Gujarat in their last Ranji Trophy Group A game at the Dr DY Patil Sports Stadium.

The Mumbai bowlers were made to toil for more than half the day's play, courtesy Manprit Juneja and Chirag Gandhi's attractive batting. So, Mumbai had to keep the scoreboard flowing in order to achieve the target that was not out of reach by any means, especially since the wicket was playing true even on the fourth day.

With Wasim Jaffer, who anchored the first innings with a trademark 171, having to rush to a hospital in the morning since his father suffered a cardiac arrest, Aditya Tare walked out to bat along with Kaustubh Pawar. But the duo showed little intent of going for the target. The only instance of Mumbai trying for six points came when Hiken Shah, replacing Tare who was caught behind the wicket in the eighth over, hit left-arm spinner Rakesh Dhurv for four boundaries in an over before tea.

However, the half an hour following the tea break saw neither Pawar nor Shah trying to up the ante, even when Parthiv Patel took his gloves off and rolled his arm over, making it evident they were settling for a draw. As a result, it did not come as a surprise when both the teams shook hands at the start of the mandatory overs.

"It wasn't really going to matter eventually - whether we went for the target or not. The fact is we have achieved the objective of qualifying for the semi-final. It doesn't really matter whether we qualify second or third since the line-up for second and third teams from top two groups is going to be decided by chits," Mumbai coach Sulakshan Kulkarni said.

Amol Karhadkar is a correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Amol Karhadkar

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 13:25 GMT)

Mumbai coach does not understand the difference between a draw and a win!

Posted by Vivek.Bhandari on (January 2, 2013, 13:11 GMT)

The Dominica 2012 instance will continue to haunt Indian cricket time and again.

Posted by   on (January 1, 2013, 19:47 GMT)

This kind of attitude towards winning and settling for a draw should concern BCCI. The same attitude will also prevail at international cricket and then we'll be settling for draws instead of developing the killer instinct to go for outright wins.

I hope teams get penalized when they play for a draw when they had a chance to win :/

Posted by   on (January 1, 2013, 16:53 GMT)

good news for Mumbai for sachin played. all those said unfair to MP & Gujarat, Mumbai played well in all the match

Posted by GoldenRed on (January 1, 2013, 14:42 GMT)

The point rules of Ranji Trophy is pathetic.. Mumbai has won only one match yet the qualify to knockout. That is unfair to Gujarat, Railways and MP

Posted by   on (January 1, 2013, 14:39 GMT)

Not sure how you can call return of a non-performing Sachin who just requires 2 straight, over-pitched balls above 125 KPH on his middle stump to lose his wicket.

In fact, I feel Sachin will become a problem for Agarkar - he will not score at any sensible pace, will insist on abusing the respect Indians have for him & bat at # 4, the most critical position in any batting line-up & do nothing of note.

Worse - Sachin will come in & occupy a slot that was traditionally assigned to someone who delivers. So Sachin being available is BAD NEWS for Mumbai.

Posted by   on (January 1, 2013, 14:14 GMT)

Fans might say pathetic attitude by Mumbai. But they had everything to loose had they went on to chase. Fixing the opponent is also out of question as indicated by Sulakshan Kulkarni. But for Mumbai, already Zaheer and Jaffer were out of batting lineup. Had there been a collapse, they would have been out of knockouts. Also Mumbai for whole season have preferred a bit more rest rather than chance of injuring a player in this packed schedule.

Posted by criccitizen on (January 1, 2013, 14:12 GMT)

Well done karnataka, but why the hell u people will always choose to bowl first even though you are performing well while batting first. check out the performance of this particular series itself.

Posted by   on (January 1, 2013, 13:39 GMT)

Well Done Karnataka..Do well In QF's..

Posted by suhasbalasubramanya on (January 1, 2013, 13:33 GMT)

What a fantastic last-minute squeeze by Karnataka! Amazing chase in the end after Maharashtra looked set to spoil K'taka's party with a stubborn second innings fightback. Perhaps the most closely fought league stage in recent years. The result of Delhi match also went in K'taka's favour. Augers well.

Posted by koushik56 on (January 1, 2013, 13:16 GMT)

this is not the first time that Mumbai has resorted to this sort of approach.In the name of professionalism they have done this many times in the past.It is only a ploy tofixd the opponent in the quarter final.Will the BCCI act or at least send out a warning to the Mumbai management.In the 70s when only the topper from each zone would qualify for the knock-out, rules were changed to accomodate Bombay when they came 2nd in west zone.Better nothing said about Players if they are loosing.Remember Agarkar's antics at Mysore when Karnataka almost beat them in the final.

Posted by anranga1 on (January 1, 2013, 13:05 GMT)

Great job by karnataka. They started very badly collapsing in many matches, finally pulled thro'. This is the first match for binny as captain? Wonder why Uthappa did not open in the second, was it ability or attitude?

Compare karnataka to Mumbai who did not chase 135 in 41, they should have chased even if it was 21

Posted by nirmalzz on (January 1, 2013, 12:52 GMT)

I think, zaheer had remembered Dhoni before thinking about win.. Hahaha, after watching Mumbai team's approach, I am thinking, how they had got supremecy in Ranji trophy in past yrs...

Posted by NYer on (January 1, 2013, 12:30 GMT)

Pathetic attitude indeed. Reminds me of the South Korean shuttlers at the Olympics.Hope BCCI learns from this and next time makes the number 3 team of group A play the number 2 team from group B, instead of chits

Posted by ashup on (January 1, 2013, 12:11 GMT)

agree ..this is really pathetic approach by mumbai .....bcci should take a not of such approach from Ranji Captains and penalise them . This approach is the death of cricket . In my opinion the match between MP and Mumbai was awesome and MP should go thru the qtrs at mumbai's expense because of the willingness to WIN was there. Mumbai Captain should be banned for 1 match for the dull approach.

Posted by   on (January 1, 2013, 11:51 GMT)

pathetic attitude, this will take india no-where

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Amol KarhadkarClose
Tournament Results
Mumbai v Saurashtra at Mumbai - Jan 26-28, 2013
Mumbai won by an innings and 125 runs
Services v Mumbai at Delhi - Jan 16-21, 2013
Match drawn (Mumbai won on 1st innings)
Saurashtra v Punjab at Rajkot - Jan 16-20, 2013
Saurashtra won by 229 runs
Jharkhand v Punjab at Jamshedpur - Jan 6-10, 2013
Match drawn (Punjab won on 1st innings)
Mumbai v Baroda at Mumbai - Jan 6-10, 2013
Match drawn (Mumbai won on 1st innings)
Saurashtra v Karnataka at Rajkot - Jan 6-10, 2013
Match drawn (Saurashtra won on 1st innings)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days