Mumbai v Tamil Nadu, 2nd semi-final, Ranji Trophy, 2nd day January 11, 2012

Balaji burst leaves Mumbai on the rocks

18

Mumbai 121 for 6 (Yadav 52, Hiken Shah 21*, Kulkarni 5*, Balaji 3-16) trail Tamil Nadu 359 (Prasanna 104, Mahesh 67, Sandhu 5-88) by 238 runs
Scorecard

Aggressive and accurate bowling helped Tamil Nadu flatten Mumbai on the second day at the Wankhede Stadium. Six of the hosts' batsmen were back in the dressing-room before the total could cross the three-figure mark. This after Tamil Nadu's lower order had added 220 runs for the last four wickets to frustrate Mumbai and take the visitors to 359 in their first innings. With two days to go Mumbai have only four wickets remaining and are still trailing by 238 runs.

Tamil Nadu had watched closely the mistakes their opponents had committed in the field over the first four-and-a-quarter sessions, and learned from them. Their captain L Balaji set the tone by deploying attacking fields for Mumbai's new opening pair of Kaustubh Pawar and Onkar Gurav. It was the seventh combination Mumbai had fielded this season due to injury and other constraints, and it did not work.

Pawar was nicely set up by Balaji, who had three slips and a gully for him initially, and then also brought in a short leg. Pawar grew defensive and poked at an outswinger away from his body to edge and give Dinesh Karthik an easy catch behind the stumps. The wicket came off the last ball of Balaji's third over. Off the first ball of his fourth, Balaji induced another edge, this time from Onkar Gurav, who was forced to play at a length ball that shaped away late and took the outside edge on its way to M Vijay at first slip.

Balaji made full use of the new ball, making the batsman play at every delivery. Wasim Jaffer, the Mumbai captain, survived the hat-trick delivery but three balls later was a victim of umpire K Hariharan's second poor lbw decision in two days. Jaffer moved in line with his off stump to defend a delivery that was fuller in length and straightened after pitching. An inside edge trickled onto the pad, just above the knee roll, and the ball went towards gully. Balaji appealed for an lbw but there were clearly two noises and the height was questionable too. What made the decision look even worse was the fact that K Vasudevadas, the gully fielder, who obviously knew there was an edge, had charged in and thrown himself forward in an attempt to take the catch. Jaffer was astonished and immediately showed his bat to the umpire, but the decision had been made and he was dismissed for a duck. Mumbai had lost three wickets in the space of six deliveries.

Earlier in the season Abhishek Nayar and Suryakumar Yadav had shown the patience and ability to stabilise innings after the top order had faltered. Both had scored double-centuries during the league stages, so Mumbai would have been hopeful of a comeback. Nayar brought up Mumbai's fifty with a push past point for four of J Kaushik, who shared the new ball with Balaji. In the next over, though, Nayar, who was returning after a two-match absence due to a finger injury, flirted with an unconventional stroke against the left-arm spin of Aushik Srinivas. Nayar tried to scoop Srinivas to the leg side but got a leading edge that went straight to Vasudevadas, who had moved from slip to leg slip before the delivery.

Yadav, too, fell to a loose shot. Having marched to a confident half-century, his fifth of the season, he let himself get distracted by a change in angle from Yo Mahesh, Tamil Nadu's third medium-pacer. Mahesh changed to bowling from over the wicket mid-over, and got the last ball of his over to move away off a length. Yadav tried to push hard without moving his feet and gave Karthik his second catch behind the stumps. Ankeet Chavan, who had scored his maiden first-class century in the quarter-final against Madhya Pradesh, lasted just 15 balls before edging to Vijay off Kaushik.

Mumbai were in an embarrassing situation at 98 for 6, and they had no-one but themselves to blame. A combination of defensive fields, the failure of Mumbai's bowlers to maintain probing lengths and bad luck allowed Tamil Nadu's overnight pair of Ramaswamy Prasanna and Mahesh to extend their match-turning partnership to 152 runs. The stand, along with a couple more contributions from the tail, helped the visitors leap from the depths of 139 for 6 at one stage on the first day to 359.

Prasanna started the day on 81 not out, and galloped to his third first-class century with four boundaries on the second morning. He was aided by Mumbai's medium-pacers Dhawal Kulkarni and Balwinder Sandhu who pitched on lengths that made it easy for him to score. What was baffling was Jaffer's decision to spread the field within the first hour when he could have crowded the batsmen with a ring of fielders.

The only saving grace for Mumbai was the performance of Kshemal Waingankar, their third medium-pacer, who bowled tireless spells of reverse-swing. Waingankar only picked up one wicket in the day but it was the pressure he exerted that finally broke the Prasanna-Mahesh partnership. Waingankar bowled his fourth delivery of the morning from close to the stumps. The ball started on middle and Prasanna, who thought the ball would swing into him, moved towards off. The ball, though, suddenly shaped away towards the shiny side, leaving Prasanna flummoxed.

Waingankar swung the ball in, bowled short and had the centurion Prasanna rattled. In the next over, Prasanna was tentative against the part-time medium-pace of Nayar, was beaten by reverse-swing once again and lost his off stump.

Mahesh added another 42 runs with Balaji for the eighth-wicket. He was the ninth batsman to be dismissed, giving Waingankar his first wicket when he was beaten by reverse and trapped lbw. It brought to an end a six-hour vigil at the wicket. Mumbai lost more than half their batting in half that time.

Nagraj Gollapudi is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • ssenthil on January 12, 2012, 13:01 GMT

    Tamil Nadu lead by 422 runs with 6 wickets remaining at the end of 3rd Day. That's all over for Mumbai. I hope TN don't declare and keep frustrate Mumbai they way they always do against their opponent for years. Give them a taste of their own medicine. Let them taste how bitter it is. Shut them out of this match completely and just give 1 Session for our bowlers to practice after Lunch. TN must be worried going in to final, with Abinav, Badri and DK are not in form. Yo Mahesh keep on doing above his potential with Bat. Hope this TN Fab 4 can get a well deserved Ranji trophy

  • satish619chandar on January 12, 2012, 11:55 GMT

    Hope TN declares and try to win than simply play out a irresponsible draw.. It might be effective for now but will put the developing cricketers in a very poor state of mind..

  • ssenthil on January 12, 2012, 5:31 GMT

    Finally TN dully have the upper hand over Mumbai. Great bowling performance by TN to bundle out for a cheap 157. Lead from the front by L Balaji and the Impressive Yo Mahesh who is having a stellar season this year with both Bat and Ball. Little surprised with TN not enforcing Follow-on despite having 202 runs lead. Mumbai have often done that. Bat the opposition out rather then going for a aggressive way to win. Mukund in search of his elusive Century against Mumbai despite having a great year with bat. If TN score another 150 runs that almost end's any Hope Mumbai having to make a come back. Today we will know which 2 teams going to meet in the Final since the other match is as well about to end with Haryana reeling at 57/5 needing another 128 runs to win. Seems to be Rajasthan vs TN final.

  • Sakthiivel on January 12, 2012, 5:31 GMT

    Bring it on Guys.. Ranji is our this time....

  • satish619chandar on January 12, 2012, 4:13 GMT

    Budding all rounders did it.. It is their match to lose now.. If they lose now, they can never ever win against Mumbai..

  • Tendulkars_Tennis_Elbow on January 12, 2012, 3:48 GMT

    Come on TN! well played Bala. finish them off this morning please.

  • on January 12, 2012, 3:24 GMT

    Come on Guys.Mumabi Needs their lower order again Come on Dhawal 1 more half century is required..come on boys you can do it. After all its Mumbai your home ground.Its not a big task apply yourseld and you can score the runss

  • on January 11, 2012, 23:54 GMT

    the reporter seems to be all praise for kshemal waingankar...all for 1 wicket... guess his mentor is a "waingankar" too!! mumbai cricket is living in its past glory and false ego for sure... sure the selectors will now have a valid reason zaheer khan's words about selectors pulling down mumbai cricket was not a stray remark for sure tamil nadu's long cherished dream of beating mumbai in mumbai in a ranji trophy knockout game is getting crystallized.. kudos to Tamil Nadu for grooming, nurturing and supporting cricketers from the grass root level..

  • gururajan23 on January 11, 2012, 23:48 GMT

    Win the game TN - its your best chance. Hope the Ranji is won this time

  • ashok16 on January 11, 2012, 21:45 GMT

    Never thought I'd say this: thank you BCCI.

    Now shut down all those unncessary India tours and get the stars to play in Ranji.

  • ssenthil on January 12, 2012, 13:01 GMT

    Tamil Nadu lead by 422 runs with 6 wickets remaining at the end of 3rd Day. That's all over for Mumbai. I hope TN don't declare and keep frustrate Mumbai they way they always do against their opponent for years. Give them a taste of their own medicine. Let them taste how bitter it is. Shut them out of this match completely and just give 1 Session for our bowlers to practice after Lunch. TN must be worried going in to final, with Abinav, Badri and DK are not in form. Yo Mahesh keep on doing above his potential with Bat. Hope this TN Fab 4 can get a well deserved Ranji trophy

  • satish619chandar on January 12, 2012, 11:55 GMT

    Hope TN declares and try to win than simply play out a irresponsible draw.. It might be effective for now but will put the developing cricketers in a very poor state of mind..

  • ssenthil on January 12, 2012, 5:31 GMT

    Finally TN dully have the upper hand over Mumbai. Great bowling performance by TN to bundle out for a cheap 157. Lead from the front by L Balaji and the Impressive Yo Mahesh who is having a stellar season this year with both Bat and Ball. Little surprised with TN not enforcing Follow-on despite having 202 runs lead. Mumbai have often done that. Bat the opposition out rather then going for a aggressive way to win. Mukund in search of his elusive Century against Mumbai despite having a great year with bat. If TN score another 150 runs that almost end's any Hope Mumbai having to make a come back. Today we will know which 2 teams going to meet in the Final since the other match is as well about to end with Haryana reeling at 57/5 needing another 128 runs to win. Seems to be Rajasthan vs TN final.

  • Sakthiivel on January 12, 2012, 5:31 GMT

    Bring it on Guys.. Ranji is our this time....

  • satish619chandar on January 12, 2012, 4:13 GMT

    Budding all rounders did it.. It is their match to lose now.. If they lose now, they can never ever win against Mumbai..

  • Tendulkars_Tennis_Elbow on January 12, 2012, 3:48 GMT

    Come on TN! well played Bala. finish them off this morning please.

  • on January 12, 2012, 3:24 GMT

    Come on Guys.Mumabi Needs their lower order again Come on Dhawal 1 more half century is required..come on boys you can do it. After all its Mumbai your home ground.Its not a big task apply yourseld and you can score the runss

  • on January 11, 2012, 23:54 GMT

    the reporter seems to be all praise for kshemal waingankar...all for 1 wicket... guess his mentor is a "waingankar" too!! mumbai cricket is living in its past glory and false ego for sure... sure the selectors will now have a valid reason zaheer khan's words about selectors pulling down mumbai cricket was not a stray remark for sure tamil nadu's long cherished dream of beating mumbai in mumbai in a ranji trophy knockout game is getting crystallized.. kudos to Tamil Nadu for grooming, nurturing and supporting cricketers from the grass root level..

  • gururajan23 on January 11, 2012, 23:48 GMT

    Win the game TN - its your best chance. Hope the Ranji is won this time

  • ashok16 on January 11, 2012, 21:45 GMT

    Never thought I'd say this: thank you BCCI.

    Now shut down all those unncessary India tours and get the stars to play in Ranji.

  • on January 11, 2012, 18:30 GMT

    Having watched the game live on bcci.tv till tea (1 AM my time), I would say this was awesome advertisement for Ranji Cricket. Both teams traded blows back and forth. Look at this though. TN 138 for 6 and had one last batter and one fast bowler bailing them out. Mumbai 121 for 6 and has one batter and one fast bowler at the crease. Hariharan gave LBW to TN's number 4 batter (DK) and Mumbai's number 4 (WJ). Top order from both the teams scored a fifty and a 40. Now what remains to be seen is how the last batter from Mumbai bats or how TN attacks (which WJ failed on second day morning) to finish Mumbai off. But it would be hard for me to forgive Hariharan, he called a no-ball to Powar's first ball when he landed well inside, gave two wrong LBWs. He is as useless as Vivek Razdan in commentary. Why no EX-Tn player was in the commentary to add some balanced views?

  • NairUSA on January 11, 2012, 17:03 GMT

    It is indeed glad to see medium pacers making an impact in a Ranji game. Even though most medium pacers were bowling in the 130 kph range, they seemed to understand the need for good lengths and reverse swing. Thanks to BCCI for telecasing the match in the streaming mode.

  • ssenthil on January 11, 2012, 16:55 GMT

    Finally TN in a position close to upper hand over Mumbai in a knock out match and this match is still not over and we all know how good the Mumbai tail always. TN can't be complacent and relax tomorrow morning. The way the match is heading it's all about who is going to get the First Innings lead. TN are favourite to get that but can't write off Mumbai yet. So a reverting 3rd Day ahead of us. Balaji bowled really a great first spell and as a captain he lead from the front and his bowling changes are just perfect. Lot of credit to be given to yo Mahesh for hanging in there for 259 balls for his 67. He now has 3 Fifties all in the last 3 matches incl this, also a great effort by Prasanna when the team was tottering at 139/6 without any more batsman left apart from him. Jaffer perhaps unlucky to go but that equals D karthik wicket given by the same umpire. Now this match is all about the 3 wickets of H Shah, Dhawal Kulkarni and Ramesh Power. At the moment TN has this match

  • venkateshmonika on January 11, 2012, 16:39 GMT

    Is this the chance for TN to beat Mumbai in Ranji Knock out ? GO TN go.. Hail Balaji...

  • Kishor_shinde on January 11, 2012, 16:27 GMT

    Hope mumbai's lower order clicks and manage sme sort of lead........:)

  • Kishor_shinde on January 11, 2012, 16:27 GMT

    Hope mumbai's lower order clicks and manage sme sort of lead........:)

  • androyuvi on January 11, 2012, 16:10 GMT

    TN has a very bright chance to grab the trophy this time.. hope it happens.! Go balaji.. Go TN..

  • Deepak on January 11, 2012, 15:58 GMT

    Hmmm....Mumbai team just played out the part that Indian team has been playing out in Australia (Same script, different actors) - defensive fields when opposition is down & impatience while batting (poking at balls and poor footwork). Looks like TN are headed for the Ranji Finals! Disappointing stuff from Mumbai...was really hoping for a Mumbai Vs. Rajasthan Final.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Deepak on January 11, 2012, 15:58 GMT

    Hmmm....Mumbai team just played out the part that Indian team has been playing out in Australia (Same script, different actors) - defensive fields when opposition is down & impatience while batting (poking at balls and poor footwork). Looks like TN are headed for the Ranji Finals! Disappointing stuff from Mumbai...was really hoping for a Mumbai Vs. Rajasthan Final.

  • androyuvi on January 11, 2012, 16:10 GMT

    TN has a very bright chance to grab the trophy this time.. hope it happens.! Go balaji.. Go TN..

  • Kishor_shinde on January 11, 2012, 16:27 GMT

    Hope mumbai's lower order clicks and manage sme sort of lead........:)

  • Kishor_shinde on January 11, 2012, 16:27 GMT

    Hope mumbai's lower order clicks and manage sme sort of lead........:)

  • venkateshmonika on January 11, 2012, 16:39 GMT

    Is this the chance for TN to beat Mumbai in Ranji Knock out ? GO TN go.. Hail Balaji...

  • ssenthil on January 11, 2012, 16:55 GMT

    Finally TN in a position close to upper hand over Mumbai in a knock out match and this match is still not over and we all know how good the Mumbai tail always. TN can't be complacent and relax tomorrow morning. The way the match is heading it's all about who is going to get the First Innings lead. TN are favourite to get that but can't write off Mumbai yet. So a reverting 3rd Day ahead of us. Balaji bowled really a great first spell and as a captain he lead from the front and his bowling changes are just perfect. Lot of credit to be given to yo Mahesh for hanging in there for 259 balls for his 67. He now has 3 Fifties all in the last 3 matches incl this, also a great effort by Prasanna when the team was tottering at 139/6 without any more batsman left apart from him. Jaffer perhaps unlucky to go but that equals D karthik wicket given by the same umpire. Now this match is all about the 3 wickets of H Shah, Dhawal Kulkarni and Ramesh Power. At the moment TN has this match

  • NairUSA on January 11, 2012, 17:03 GMT

    It is indeed glad to see medium pacers making an impact in a Ranji game. Even though most medium pacers were bowling in the 130 kph range, they seemed to understand the need for good lengths and reverse swing. Thanks to BCCI for telecasing the match in the streaming mode.

  • on January 11, 2012, 18:30 GMT

    Having watched the game live on bcci.tv till tea (1 AM my time), I would say this was awesome advertisement for Ranji Cricket. Both teams traded blows back and forth. Look at this though. TN 138 for 6 and had one last batter and one fast bowler bailing them out. Mumbai 121 for 6 and has one batter and one fast bowler at the crease. Hariharan gave LBW to TN's number 4 batter (DK) and Mumbai's number 4 (WJ). Top order from both the teams scored a fifty and a 40. Now what remains to be seen is how the last batter from Mumbai bats or how TN attacks (which WJ failed on second day morning) to finish Mumbai off. But it would be hard for me to forgive Hariharan, he called a no-ball to Powar's first ball when he landed well inside, gave two wrong LBWs. He is as useless as Vivek Razdan in commentary. Why no EX-Tn player was in the commentary to add some balanced views?

  • ashok16 on January 11, 2012, 21:45 GMT

    Never thought I'd say this: thank you BCCI.

    Now shut down all those unncessary India tours and get the stars to play in Ranji.

  • gururajan23 on January 11, 2012, 23:48 GMT

    Win the game TN - its your best chance. Hope the Ranji is won this time