2010 Review

Falling to earth

Their aura has been fading over the last couple of years, but in 2010 the harsh reality of their decline hit Australia hard

Peter English

January 5, 2011

Comments: 50 | Text size: A | A

Ricky Ponting leaves the field after being bowled by Tim Bresnan, Australia v England, 4th Test, Melbourne, 3rd day, December 28, 2010
Ricky Ponting: the man who lost the most © Getty Images
Related Links
Series/Tournaments: England tour of Australia
Teams: Australia

The SCG is usually a place for Australia to raise a trophy and wave to their supporters, signing off the year in style. This time they are playing there after experiencing 12 months to write off. The once mighty outfit has fallen so far that for the first time in 24 years England will leave with the Ashes. Not since the mid-1980s, a period in which Australia were beaten home and away by New Zealand, have the cricket followers in this country felt so bad.

And now to the most depressing aspect of the tumble from the top of the world: there is no quick fix. For years Australia have been pushing for a Test championship play-off as a way of adding prestige to the No. 1 spot. If the concept had been introduced in 2010, Australia may have failed to reach the tournament between the four top-ranked teams. The squad currently sits in the final qualifying spot, but spent time at No. 5.

Australia's senior players, such as Ricky Ponting, Michael Clarke and Michael Hussey, didn't think the outfit was as bad as the number suggested. They were. A year that began with a suspicious series success over Pakistan and a clean sweep of an under-strength New Zealand, unravelled swiftly when the better teams or swinging conditions had to be conquered.

From May, Australia lost the final of the World Twenty20 to England, another vital step in the old enemy's demystification process, and then drew a series with Pakistan. The rubber was played in England, with the conditions suiting Pakistan's swing and seam bowlers, but it was the first embarrassing result of the second half of a year filled with them. Australia were dismissed for 88 in Leeds after winning the toss, a score only slightly worse than the 98 at the MCG, which ultimately did for their chances of regaining the Ashes.

The loss at Headingley began a sequence of seven defeats in all competitions. Not since the late 1880s had Australia failed so badly for so long. Yet still the players felt the next corner would be the one that started the turnaround. As the year ended, the only international victories after the slump were an ODI against Sri Lanka, who had already won their first series here, and the Ashes Test in Perth. They were more like the flickers of a fire trying desperately to stay lit.

At the start of the Ashes, the most important contest for an Australian, so many mistakes were made that the hosts were acting like the England of the 1990s. Nasser Hussain, a victim here twice, said it best before the series started: "You've nicked Vodafone as a sponsor, you've picked 17 players in a squad and you lose games. You keep your batsmen [too long], and you rotate your bowlers - we used to do that for a while."

It was funny at the time but there was no laughing from the locals after England took a 1-0 lead after dominating the opening two Tests. Having planned since the 2009 Ashes defeat at The Oval to retain most of the same faces, Australia's selectors panicked. Instead of grooming players like Steven Smith, Phillip Hughes and a new spinner in preparation for this campaign, the panel lobbed them into the side at vital points. Marcus North and Nathan Hauritz were discarded, Mitchell Johnson was given a break, and Simon Katich suffered a serious heel injury.

The case of Hauritz was the strangest. One unheralded slow bowler, Xavier Doherty, and another unheard-of spinner, Michael Beer, were used instead. Meanwhile Hauritz collected domestic wickets for New South Wales and scored two centuries.

At the start of the Ashes, the most important contest for an Australian, so many mistakes were made that the hosts were acting like the England of the 1990s

By the fifth Test the side's average age was in the mid-20s instead of the low 30s, which shows some promising signs for the future. Ponting, who had struggled with the bat, had been forced out of the final Test with a broken finger, having possibly played his final Test the previous week in Melbourne. As he handed over to Michael Clarke for the SCG encounter, Australia were chasing new beginnings on many fronts.

New kid on the block
Ryan Harris was the pick of the 2010 batch of debutants, but his hardworking swing-bowling performances soon lost out to his body. After five Tests and 20 wickets his ankle became too stressed in the first innings at the MCG and the crack put him out of the World Cup. That was a great shame for the side because he had also been excellent in the one-day outfit, and had fought to recover from a career-threatening knee problem.

Fading star
Sadly the man who lost most was Ricky Ponting. He started the second Test of the year with a double-century against Pakistan in Hobart, having been dropped at fine leg from his first ball. His good fortune then ran out. With the bat he averaged 37 for the Test year, but only 113 runs came in four games against England. He says he doesn't want to retire, but the World Cup seems the most appropriate stage to depart.

High point
For two days at the WACA, Australia felt like a team on top of the world again. Mitchell Johnson's amazing spells of swing bowling recovered the hosts from their first-day 268, and as England were falling to a 267-run defeat the swagger and sledging returned. "We're back", they said with renewed confidence, but the revival lasted for only one match. Johnson followed his nine wickets with another below-par display at the MCG.

Low point
So many to choose from. Even though they lost seven in a row, the result against England was the worst. Not finishing a home Ashes series with the urn is the worst thing that can happen to a modern Australian team. There are cricket supporters in their early 20s who have never experienced this feeling. Ouch.

Peter English is the Australasia editor of Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: Peter English

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by   on (January 8, 2011, 0:04 GMT)

@ gopul & hutty. i don't think either of you there are giving england enough credit for their performance in south africa last year. in the one test south africa let their guard down england smashed them to pieces and in the other three, whilst we did get battered, we survived two of them. the pitches weren't as flat as the ones south africa and india have just played on either, which makes that 1-1 draw even more of an acheivement. your right though, india, south africa and sri lanka in sri lanka are the teams to beat, but then so were the aussies. hopefully its already one down, with three more to come :)

Posted by gilly007 on (January 7, 2011, 9:18 GMT)

Its funny to read the comments about how almost everyone in the world has written off Australia. Just a mere indication of how the Great Aus Team of the recent past thrashed the rest of the world ( literally and figuratively ). But come on. Hasn't all this been said before ( 2009 Ashes). And what happened next ?? England getting thrashed 6-1 and Australia winning the Champions Trophy by a mile. Ponting held the team together after 2006-07 ashes, with Glenn, Warne, Langer and martyn retiring. Something which would have crippled any other team. Ponting is an awesome captain and he will retire with the 2011 WC and ashes victory in England. Captain or otherwise

Posted by Pirran on (January 7, 2011, 3:29 GMT)

As a Half Cornish / Half Aussie hybrid, I don't think Australia has sunk quite as low as some think; rather, I think Australia in the glory days of the 90's and early noughties weren't as wonderful as most concluded. The key to their overwhelming success were two great (and extremely durable) bowlers and poor International competition.

In contrast, the assembly line of wonderful WIndian bowlers of the late 70's and 80's (Roberts, Marshall, Garner, Holding, Croft) were competing against other very good teams (Lillee, Thompson, Willis, Botham, Hadlee, Imran Khan and Kapil Dev for starters). They were a genuinely great team. Australia in the recent past were competing against a woeful England, a Windies populace that had switched to basketball and athletics as being more lucrative and Sub-Continental sides mired in factional in-fighting and corruption.

When Warne and McGrath retired, Australia was bound to slide. The International competition is still not great, just a little better.

Posted by   on (January 7, 2011, 2:52 GMT)

Good point Hutty, but its not as if they'll be retiring with Tendulkar and company also. Hence, the retirements and transition will be much smoother for India. Also, England's strength has to be gauged by how they play against tough teams. By that I mean India/SA anywhere and SL away. These matches are important to determine if they have the potential to become a great side. So far we only know that they're better than Pakistan, Bangladesh and Australia

Posted by Hutty86 on (January 6, 2011, 22:29 GMT)

@Gopal Krishna Sharma Nandyala: The decline for India may not be quite as severe (although this was a disgraceful series form-wise for Australia and may not be a complete indicator of the future).. but the guys you mention like Sehwag, Singh, etc; they are fantastic cricketers but they're hardly young guys themselves!! England look a wonderful side, but they have yet to win in SA/India and that's where the real test lies. We'll just have to wait and see I guess.

Posted by James_10 on (January 6, 2011, 22:28 GMT)

@Okakaboka, I would like to see you do better than Hughes,Hifenhaus, Smith, Doherty and North. o

Posted by   on (January 6, 2011, 20:12 GMT)

i'm an englishman - i'm not going to say ner ner or anything like that. i think it all went wrong for Australia when Nathan Hauritz wasn't selected. he is by far the best spinner you have and he can also bat. He has international fifties to his name and sheffield sheild tons. I'd have never dropped North or Bollinger either. He was a star performer in the 2009 Ashes. Whilst i'm delighted that England have finally got the monkey off our back, Austrlia aren't such a bad side, you've just had a really bad series (i know losing to us in Aus is unforgiveable for you guys, but still). Johnson has to go, get Bollinger, swap smith back for North, Hauritz for hilfenhaus and Khawaja for Ponting and there, problem solved :)

Posted by   on (January 6, 2011, 18:30 GMT)

Hands up who else thinks Mitchell Johnson is a better batsman than Phil Hughes? Maybe they should swap places in the Australian batting order. If you're going to bat like a tailender you may as well play there. Okay, Johnson got a first ball duck in the 2nd Innings but at least he wasn't involved in any inept run-outs.

Posted by Okakaboka on (January 6, 2011, 14:24 GMT)

@geraldf...sorry...most of us bloggers are NOT making excuses for our team being flogged. We are frustrated with the continual chances given to players who fail consistently and seem to be immune to being dropped. England absolutely smashed us in every respect....out batted, out bowled, out fielded, out wicketkeeped, out coached, out thought......& the big one: OUT SELECTED! Yep...England beat...NSW and a couple of others. Victoria smashed England in the one match at the MCG. This was against the trend of all other tour matches. And Hodge didn't play....If he did...it may not have been pretty. He is now the best batsman in the country by a mile and he doesn't even play the 4 day format anymore. WHY? Thanks Hilditch...good work. Why didn't this creep treat Clarke like he did Hodge? Because he isn't from good old NSW. We know Smith, Hughes, North, Doherty, Beer, Hilfenhaus should never have been selected to play. Even Australia A got smashed...Who picked this team?...Yep. Selectors 0/10

Posted by   on (January 6, 2011, 13:25 GMT)

@Flat_Pitch_Bully, completely agree. The more disappointing aspect, however is how they've always got away with such a pathetic behavior!! Had the officials been equal to all, this would've never happened

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Peter EnglishClose

More in 2010 review

  • And the winners are...

    Highs and Lows: Tis the season to give, so we're handing out awards for last year. Starring Shahrukh, Sachin, all in between, and lots of tweeting. By Osman Samiuddin
  • All hail England and Amla

    Stats: England won two big events in 2010, while Hashim Amla was the only batsman to top 1000 runs in both Tests and ODIs. By S Rajesh
  • The IPL has fallen, long live the IPL

    This was the year it all came crashing down for cricket's next big thing. But fundamentally hardly anything has changed. By Sharda Ugra
  • The travesty, the 'trick, the tape

    Staff picks: Part two of ESPNcricinfo's editors' selections of the best and worst in cricket in 2010. By Sambit Bal, Martin Williamson, Brydon Coverdale, Sharda Ugra and Dileep Premachandran
  • The Lord's sham, the Twenty20 scam

    Staff picks: Part one of ESPNcricinfo's editors' selections of the best and worst in cricket in 2010. By Peter English, Jayaditya Gupta, Andrew McGlashan and Sidharth Monga

    An all-round ODI giant

Numbers Game: Few players can boast the sort of numbers that Jacques Kallis achieved in ODIs

    Is being bowled out by Moeen embarrassing?

Polite Enquiries: Is Rahane India's Misbah? Should Rohit be dropped? Jarrod Kimber and George Dobell discuss

    'We were determined to prove we were not an average team'

Former South Africa wicketkeeper Dave Richardson remembers his favourite moment from the Lord's win in 1994

    'A test of Kohli's mental strength'

Bowl at Boycs: Geoffrey Boycott on Kohli's recent form, and Cook's captaincy

How does one 'lead by example'?

Alex Bowden: A captain needs to do enough as an individual to retain respect and control, but exceptional performances may not result in even greater influence

News | Features Last 3 days

The woeful world of Pankaj Singh

Pankaj Singh greeted his most expensive analysis in Test history with the words 'That is cricket'. It was admirable acceptance from an impressive man of a record he did not deserve

Ugly runs but still they swoon

Alastair Cook did not bat like a leading man but the crowd applauded him for simply not failing

Boycott floored by an Indian trundler

When Eknath Solkar got under the skin of Geoff Boycott, leading to a three-year self-imposed exile from Test cricket

Worst keepers, and honours at Lord's

Also, most keeping dismissals on debut, seven-for at HQ, and youngest ODI centurions

England's selection errors could lead to series defeat

Their decision to persist with Alastair Cook as captain, and to pick batsmen who can only score runs against weak attacks, will hurt them

News | Features Last 3 days