2012 Review

Highs and Lows

Hello KP, goodbye you other lot

Lots of Pietersen and SLC and plenty of fond farewells in our look at the top dogs and bottom feeders of the year gone by

Sidharth Monga

January 2, 2013

Comments: 35 | Text size: A | A

Michael Clarke and Shane Warne pose with the replica of the Ashes trophy, Australia v England, 3rd Test, Perth, December 18, 2006
No, not happening © Getty Images

The statistic
In the time it takes you to read this sentence, MS Dhoni makes about US$3. According to Forbes magazine, he made $26.5 million in the period from June 2011 to May 2012. That puts him ahead of not only all cricketers but also Usain Bolt and Novak Djokovic. That's $72,603 per day, and about 84 cents per second. Take that, suckers who think he uses deep point too often in Tests.

The intimidation
India playing four quicks in Perth. Horsemen of the Apocalypse. Pace like fire. Batsmen quaking in their boots. Err… David Warner 180 off 159. India beaten inside three days. MS Dhoni banned for poor over rate. It was all happening at the WACA.

The Sarfraz Nawaz award for raising a match-fixing stink
Hashan Tillakaratne. Except that nothing came of it. This is the last we heard of it: "I stand by my comments about match fixing but can't reveal names for my safety. I made the statement in good faith and I will reveal the names to the ICC."

The tweet
No tweet can be serious unless it is deleted soon after. After India had been knocked out of the World Twenty20 in Sri Lanka, Suresh Raina indulged in some schadenfreude at Pakistan's ouster, deleted the tweet immediately after, and then blamed it on his nephew. Last heard, it was the nephew who couldn't face the short ball.

The product placement
Adidas in Kevin Pietersen's apology video.

The retirements
Rahul Dravid, VVS Laxman, Mark Boucher, Tatenda Taibu, Brett Lee, Ricky Ponting, Andrew Strauss, Simon Taufel, Sachin Tendulkar (just ODIs), Michael Hussey.

Thankfully not Bill Lawry, who has said - amid speculation this could be his last summer as a commentator - that he has not made a decision yet. It won't all happen once he goes.

The retirement, part II
Test cricket in Sri Lanka. If SLC had its way, all Test cricket in every country would make way for ODIs with India, but thankfully there are some boards that still want their teams to play Tests. This year, Sri Lanka's Tests against India were converted to an ODI series (the horror, the horror), one Test was taken off the England tour, next year's Tests in the West Indies have been cancelled, and South Africa's Test tour of the island is headed towards becoming a tri-nation ODI series involving, yes, India.

The retirement, part III
Haroon Lorgat. Those press conferences at important cricketing occasions, where the ICC's CEO spoke a lot without saying anything, are not being missed at all.

The SLC award for poor administration
NZC can be proud. (Incidentally it all happened in Sri Lanka.) What really happened only John Buchanan, Mike Hesson and the suits know, but if you go by what Ross Taylor said, they were all lying. What Taylor said made sense too. If New Zealand indeed wanted to have Taylor remain the Test captain, they must have believed he was a better captain than Brendon McCullum, because you need a better captain in Tests. It didn't show in how they let him go.

The SLC award for being bad paymasters
The BPL.

The SLC award for being petty
To the SLC, for not letting the players spread share of their earnings among the lesser fortunate ground staff and other helpers.

The hoax
Mystery balls. Some people should realise they are not Shane Warne.

The press conference
Where Kris Srikkanth, then the chairman of Indian selectors, instructed a reporter, "Boss, you just shut up now." Those priceless words, now used to end all cricketing arguments, came in response to a question - repeated ad nauseam because Srikkanth wouldn't answer it - about why, if Virender Sehwag was unfit for a future tour, he was not being pulled out of an ongoing one.

The award
Kumar Dharmasena. Best umpire. It is not yet clear if that was what prompted Vernon Philander to tweet: "Great to be back in the mothercity. What a waste of 4days that was. Let's start on a positive note, seeing forward to training tom...#cobras"

The shot
Actually it's not a particular shot but the way Martin Guptill plays them. The eyes follow the ball only until it meets the bat. He doesn't look up to see where it has gone. The eyes are, as Richie Benaud succinctly puts it, where the ball used to be. He is yet to mis-hit one of them.

The comeback
Brad Hogg. At 41. Still sprightly. Still bowling a googly hard to pick in T20. Still the owner of flowing natural hair. No self-respecting postman, Newman from Seinfeld least of them, will approve of such efficiency.

The turnaround
Richard Levi began the year with a 117 not out against New Zealand. That T20 innings was superbly timed, in that it came just before the IPL auction. Following that, though, Levi has been sorted out so comprehensively that he has scored 106 in 11 innings. That includes a fifty against Zimbabwe. In South Africa's final T20 of the year, Levi was finally dropped.

The most pointless debate
Was the one around introducing lbws to balls pitched outside leg when the batsman is attempting a switch hit. Kevin Pietersen, the finest exponent of said shot, killed it off in one tweet, like only a man who knows the stroke inside out can. What Pietersen basically said was: I get outside the line of the stumps when I play the switch hit, and I am playing a shot, so how can you give me out? "It's a waste of a meeting," Pietersen concluded.

The timing
India had just lost the SCG Test. It was the end of a dream that had kept such greats as Sachin Tendulkar, Rahul Dravid and VVS Laxman going over the years. It was official then that the three would never win a Test series in Australia. Minutes later, the BCCI emailed the schedule of the IPL, which would go on for 53 days.

The declarations
Michael Clarke: once when he was on 329 in a match Australia won inside four days. Once when he was 259 in a match that could not have produced a result. Of the 26 declarations made in Tests this year, eight have come from Clarke. Australia might not be the best team in the world yet, but under Clarke they have shown the most intent.

PS: Clarke also became the first man in Test history to score four double-centuries in a year.

The MS Dhoni award for the most weird analogy
For the second year in a row, it is Salman Butt. "I had always asked him [Mohammad Amir] to have his hair cut, but he never listened to me. Then how was he ready to do such a big thing [at my behest]?" Butt wondered. Last year Butt wondered if professional wrestling could be popular despite being scripted, why not cricket.

Kevin Pietersen arrives back at Heathrow Airport after England's series win in India, London, December 18, 2012
Without Pietersen playing international cricket, this article would be shorter by a third © PA Photos

The most pointless match
In March, India travelled 6984 kilometres, from Mumbai to Johannesburg, with a 15-man squad plus support staff to play one Twenty20 international. It was the first international match out of 5551 played till then to be lost by a side that lost no wicket. We could have done without this match.

The extinct
Good old-fashioned, swinging, possessed yorker speared into the toes. Once upon a time fast bowlers used the delivery at the death. Now they bring fine leg and third man up and bowl slower balls on a length.

The note
By going from "Yea Viv talk nah" in Edgbaston to "Sweeter from behind" in Colombo, Denesh Ramdin proved his ability to come up with a line that got people talking was, just like his Test century, a one-off.

The boxers
It's easy to write them off as publicity seekers, but there are less brutal ways of staying in the limelight than taking up boxing. These two boys' own heroes have had their share of demons to fight, but they have also brought us immense joy on the cricket field. Whatever took Andrew Flintoff and Jesse Ryder into the ring, it has to be more than just the desire to see their names in circulation again. They both won their debut fights, and both want more. So when can we have Ryder v Flintoff?

The laboratory
ODI cricket. They are playing with the Powerplays again, and introducing more bouncers, and nobody - players included - actually knows what is going on.

Slyly, a bigger experiment was at work. Only 95 ODIs were played in the year, as opposed to 83 T20 internationals. The biggest consumer of ODIs, India, hosted just one such match - and that was on December 30, as part of an unscheduled series.

The blackout
Radio Sport discontinued its coverage of the Plunket Shield in New Zealand. SABC won't broadcast home Tests in South Africa. In a year in which South Africa became No. 1 in Tests. Heaven forbid if they won a World Cup.

The clashes
Test Match Special fought Test Match Sofa, everybody fought the BCCI, the BCCI fought the DRS, the DRS fought itself, Shah Rukh Khan fought the authorities at the Wankhede, New Road fought floods (again), Kirti Azad fought the IPL, Shahid Afridi fought reporters, Chris Cairns fought Lalit Modi…

The Hashim Amla award for the best bearded player
Monty Panesar. Six Tests, 33 wickets, four five-fors, one ten-wicket haul, all achieved in a joyous wide-eyed way. Not bad for somebody who is still a non-regular, eh?

The comeback, II
Left-arm spinners like Panesar. Rangana Herath was the leading wicket-taker of the year, Abdur Rehman provided Saeed Ajmal great support, Pragyan Ojha kept pitching it on a kerchief, and even Robin Peterson took wickets in his only Test.

The comeback, interrupted
Last year Zimbabwe returned to Tests, and gave New Zealand and Pakistan a scare. This year they played just one Test and three ODIs. One year forward, two back.

The threat
From Shane Warne, who went too far in his BBL publicity overdrive and said all it would take for him to come back to Tests was a phone call from his mate Michael Clarke. It is rumoured the Australian captain has taken Warne off his speed dial.

The Mahatma Gandhi award for seeing, hearing and speaking no evil
Duncan Fletcher.

The Shane Warne award for glorifying an IPL performance
Gautam Gambhir. The recipient of said praise being Yusuf Pathan, who was called "a magical player" by his Kolkata Knight Riders captain after he scored 40 off 21, his highest score in a 17-match season.

The debut
On Test debut, Abul Hasan scored a century from No. 10 to rescue Bangladesh from 193 for 8, but for the sheer character he showed in drawing the Adelaide Test with a century scored over close to eight hours, Faf du Plessis has to be the debutant of the year. The innings not only kept South Africa alive in the fight for No. 1, it also exhausted the best Australian bowlers so much they couldn't take field in the next Test.

The unlikeliest meeting of minds
Kevin Pietersen echoed Ravi Shastri's sentiment that England is jealous of the IPL.

The BlackBerry endorsement
From Pietersen, when he allegedly BBMed (that's a word nowadays) South African fast bowlers with tips on how to get Andrew Strauss out.

The worst century
It was more than a year in the making, it came in a loss against Bangladesh, and it involved slowing down during a Powerplay. The days when he let the 100th consume him - he blamed the media and fans for the pressure, but the fans didn't sign all those commercial deals on his behalf - were surely the worst phase of Sachin Tendulkar's career?

The celebration
It was just T20, and West Indies have gone back to their losing ways after that, but for that fortnight in the World Twenty20, West Indies showed us how to celebrate success. This interview, and not "Gangnam Style", ought to be the YouTube hit of the year.

The victim
Everybody blames it for Indian Test spinners' poor discipline, for Indian Test batsmen's lack of patience, for conflicts of interest, for calendar clashes, for tired players. Fall guy. Easy target. Straw man. Poor little victimised, helpless IPL. Go on, apologists, pull another one.

The VVS Laxman award for playing three scarcely believable and super-impactful Test innings in one year
Michael Clarke, Hashim Amla and Alastair Cook might fight for the tag of the best batsman of the year, but for sparkling innings don't look beyond Kevin Pietersen. At the P Sara Oval he demonstered spin for England and levelled the Sri Lanka series, at Headingley he danced down the wicket and hooked the best bowling attack in the world, and at the Wankhede he brutalised Indian spinners on a raging turner. (And there was a fair bit of left-arm spin that he took care of along the way.)

The word you shouldn't be using for a South African in 2012, unless he is Kevin Pietersen

The word you can use for a South African in 2012
Choke, after AB de Villiers, their captain at the World Twenty20, admitted that was just what his side did.

The Greg Ritchie-Rodney Hogg award for cringeworthiness
For the second year running, Star Cricket's promos before series against England. After the Andrew Peter series last year, the broadcaster continued to embarrass by straddling the line between jingoism and racism with these.

Composite: Andrew Flintoff and Jesse Ryder
Freddie and Jesse: match-up of 2013? © Getty Images

The cringeworthiness, part II
During the Champions League Twenty20, Ravi Shastri asked viewers to not go by the size of Quinton de Kock.

The next cricketing MP in a reality show in India
After Sanath Jayausuriya and Navjot Sidhu made appearances in Indian versions of Strictly Come Dancing and Big Brother respectively, coming up next: Sachin Tendulkar in Survivor.

The biggest embarrassment heaped upon the ICC
By its jury, which didn't nominate Saeed Ajmal for an ICC award.

The leak
John Buchanan might have gone across the ditch, but Australia keep finding a way to make public silly dossiers and documents. Try to get Graeme Smith lbw, sledge Hashim Amla, this one said. Amla laughed his way to two centuries and 377 runs despite the "psychological warfare".

The Javagal Srinath award for being a vegetarian fast bowler
Peter Siddle.

Most innovative use of Sachin Tendulkar's name to earn mileage
Julia Gillard, for announcing, when on a diplomatic visit of India, a fast-growing export market for Australia, that Tendulkar would be awarded the Order of Australia.

Sidharth Monga is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Sidharth Monga

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by JG2704 on (January 5, 2013, 19:31 GMT)

@ Nutcutlet on (January 05 2013, 12:58 PM GMT) Nice responses there bud. I can almost hear the cogs turning

Posted by JG2704 on (January 5, 2013, 19:31 GMT)

@ maddy20 on (January 05 2013, 05:23 AM GMT) re

"Yes India is on a downward slide now , but what did you expect at the fag end of the careers of 3 of our greatest, arguably the worlds best batsmen?(Sachin, Dravid, Laxman) "

- I seemed to remember your good self and many other like minded fans expecting , REVENGE , WHITEWASH,HUMILIATION etc over team England in the recent test series. I notice you went a little quiet towards the end. I wonder why that was?

Posted by JG2704 on (January 5, 2013, 19:31 GMT)

@ baghels.a on (January 02 2013, 18:39 PM GMT) re "A .does anyone ask how EPL has a detrimental effect on English national football team ?? - the correct answer is yes. It is a constant sorce of debate that so many foreign recruits is stifling the potential progress of young English players . And re your comms in general , Nutcutlet is making observations on where he thinks it's been going wrong in Indian cricket recently and please don't tell me that losing to a nation who is so much smaller and (your words) cricket is the 3rd sport - far far behind football. Football with England and cricket with India are very similar in that domestically both are very lucrative but the argument that reliance on overseas talent is affecting the national side is has many valid points

Posted by jay57870 on (January 5, 2013, 15:45 GMT)

All bashers of Indian cricket should read "India's Olympic Achievement: Indifference" by reputed English writer Theodore Dalrymple in The Wall Street Journal. He writes "It is no coincidence that, economically, India now dominates this most English of games. India has taken over cricket as its companies have taken over British companies." Yes, India lags behind in sports in general. Except chess - yes, it's a bonafide sport & was invented in India - where Viswanathan Anand is the undisputed World Champion since 2007! Let's turn to Gideon Haigh. He tried to make a "case" for John Howard to get a top ICC job. Thank God this "ultimate cricket tragic" never made it! Again Haigh toasted "Sir" Kerry Packer for his rebel WSC & his dubious business tactics & crass commercialism. OMG! Packer's Circus almost destroyed Test cricket with ODIs! And Haigh questioned BCCI's "governance"? How hypocritical! Where's his moral compass re: the mega-scandals caused by Rupert Murdoch's media empire?

Posted by Nutcutlet on (January 5, 2013, 12:58 GMT)

@Maddy20: For the England XI to look like 'an IPL side', it would have to contain a few retired cricketers from Oz, several 3rd string Indian bowlers (come to think of it, there are only a couple of 1st string ones) & be in the pocket of someone who is part of the inner sanctum of the BCCI. So, I must reject your assertion as being well wide of the mark! All players who represent England are qualified so to do; it's a level playing field with the rest of the world. And thank goodness India can provide its own players - with a pop of 1.3 billion that hardly counts as a boast! No, seriously, I have to ask you, are you happy with the direction in which Indian cricket is going? Do you think that the BCCI has got its priorities right? Do you think that the future is bright for Indian cricket? Are you proud of your team's performances in ALL forms since the WC win of 2011? I would like India to be competitive, show some fight, but I'm regularly disappointed. Cricket is b4 nationalism for me.

Posted by maddy20 on (January 5, 2013, 5:23 GMT)

@ Nutcutlet For a country whose test cricket team looks like an IPL side , need an Irishman to captain their T-20 side, you Englishmen do talk a lot. Not so long ago we were the No.1 test team and have won both 50 over worldcups played last(the other being U-19). What do you Englishmen have to show for ? Their most deserved No.1 ranking (laughs). Yes India is on a downward slide now , but what did you expect at the fag end of the careers of 3 of our greatest, arguably the worlds best batsmen?(Sachin, Dravid, Laxman). The last two years also saw the retirement of our best spinner(Kumble) and his support act is out of form and our of the team for a long time. It is gonna take a while before we recover from this and we are willing to support our team through these times. Whatever we win or lose, we do it with our own players. Can you say something like that? As for Gideon Haigh, he is just a perennial basher like you Poms. Did he atleast say congrats when we won the Worldcup? I think not!

Posted by jay57870 on (January 5, 2013, 2:58 GMT)

Sid - The "biggest embarrassment heaped upon CA" is by its national selector John Inverarity - for summarily booting out Ricky Ponting from ODIs over a cursory phone call early in 2012! Call it a "fond farewell" for a batsman considered Australia's "top dog" since the great Don? Never mind, the Punter's in good company: Winston Churchill won the war, but was defeated in the 1945 elections. He even remarked "They have a perfect right to kick me out. That is democracy"! And when offered the most noble British honour, he good-humouredly asked "Why should I accept the Order of the Garter, when the British people have just given me the Order of the Boot?"!! And just to think that, in this multi-polar world, the Little Master was recently bestowed the Order of Australia honour? Innovative use of Sachin's name? Diplomacy? Business? Really? Why then so many irate folks down under? Especially Matthew Hayden? This IPL mercenary fully deserves the "cringeworthiness, part III" award, Sid!!!

Posted by I-Like-Cricket on (January 5, 2013, 2:18 GMT)

@CricketMaan, Australia played around 12 test matches (just a rough guess) this year and declared in 8 of them. That's pretty consistent to me.

Posted by CricketMaan on (January 4, 2013, 14:07 GMT)

In the end only India and SA showed consistency albiet India in losing and SA in winning..lol. All other teams must learn how to play consistently..for e.g Eng lost, drew and won..now compare that with India's consistency of loss, loss and will loose..Also, worth mentioning that IPL secured the most expensive deal for title sponsor and BCCI signed a mamoth TV deal with ESPN..try to beat that you aussies and english..never i say!! what more we even now have mastered the art of losing in all 3 formats. talk about taking momentum from one format to another..None of you guys can be as proud as us Indian fans..First learn from us what is consistency all about..before you plan for 2013. We will show the world once again how consistent we are..even if it is in the art of losing

Posted by SamRoy on (January 4, 2013, 9:56 GMT)

@baghel.s Thing is India became No. 1 because Australia lost the dominant position, England had recently lost to SA and SA were not all that good at home apart from the fact at that time India were decent away and very good at home. When India became No. 1 it was as result of fallacies of other teams and by no means greatness of theirs. India's best team was in 2002 when India had Srinath, Zaheer, Harbhajan (in his prime) and Kumble in bowling; and Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Ganguly and Laxman doing the batting duties. The only weakness was a lack of a proper wicketkeeper batsman whose keeping was upto international standards.

Posted by 7477 on (January 3, 2013, 4:57 GMT)

it would have been nice if this article had a special mention under the caption "the worst stage performances of the year" this goes out again to SLC for bringing in ridiculous band wagon of Cheerleaders for the world T20...it was so hilarious to watch them dance.....the suckers at SLC will never ever learn...

Posted by   on (January 3, 2013, 1:06 GMT)

Dhoni is an overrated and overpaid "captain." He doesn't believe in test cricket and only has an eye on his bank account. Short-term thinking and lack of leadership is at the centre of India's test demise.

Posted by Andre2 on (January 2, 2013, 23:00 GMT)

Very good article, please continue in 2013 with the same !

Posted by Nutcutlet on (January 2, 2013, 20:14 GMT)

@baghels.a: Same old..Same old. Just read Gideon Haigh, please! BTW, England competes in many sports at the highest level (with varying degrees of success, admittedly) India, so far as the world knows, has but one sport! Cricket apart, what does India offer the sporting world? It's not difficult 'to make cricket popular' in India. It's like winning a one-horse race! & as for India holding #1 TC ranking, just recall that was before the IPL got underway in 2008. Now, nearly 5 yrs later, the full effect on the Indian sides (in all formats!) is beginning to kick in & the slide is evident. Eng's football team doesn't do very well for precisely the same reason as the IPL doesn't benefit India's T20 side. Both are populated with non-national stars (aka mercenaries) leaving the national players as a supporting cast. And the standard isn't that special in IPL anyway. Re earnings: not many footballers get what MSD 'earns'! I want India to do well; it's important, but BCCI don't give a damnn!

Posted by AndyZaltzmannsHair on (January 2, 2013, 19:39 GMT)

The RandyOZ award for forum trolling: Winner: RandyOZ (See his comment below, and hundreds like it.)

Posted by baghels.a on (January 2, 2013, 18:53 GMT)

@Nutcutlet,English are supposed to be custodians of test cricket but has it helped the popularity of the game among general masses and youth in particularin England, dosen't cricket lag behind football ang Rugby in popularity stakes.I can bet you even right now that after England's brilliant victory over India in test series most of the English won't be able to tell who Alistair Cook is but they will know what is Wayne Rooney's exact goal tally this season. Please kindly stick to England's cricketering matters and your beloved Ashes and leave the affairs of Indian cricket to us Indians.BCCI is not a perfect body and are driven by greed, power and arrogance but atleast they have made Cricket a popular and lucrative sport in India not some poor country cousin of football as it happens elswhere ....

Posted by baghels.a on (January 2, 2013, 18:39 GMT)

@Nutcutlet, this is exactly what i refered in my earlier comment that i sense from you pompous elitism and Victorian snobbery all the way that if you not interested in test cricket that you are not a true cricket fan .Didn't India had no .1 ranking in test after the advent of IPL ,won WC in 2011, u-19 WC in 2012, are you suggesting if India had won all test series it has lost recently and last year then IPL would have been lauded or BCCI were all of sudden intereted in test cricket ?? this is just cultural differrence between us sub-continental fans and you Anglo-saxons regarding which formats we prefer.Indian cricketers earning obscene amounts but it is not even 1/10th of what footballers earn in EPL/La Liga/Serie A .does anyone ask how EPL has a detrimental effect on English national football team ?? no your English media is happy promoting EPL as this best league, most watched league etc etc. English is supposed to be custodians of test cricket contd....

Posted by NikhilNair on (January 2, 2013, 18:29 GMT)

Good article! Enjoyed it :D

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 18:14 GMT)

not a single word about Pakistani team or any Pakistani player

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 18:13 GMT)

this is an article which shows the present state of cricket the way it is and i dont mean to say its bad...it has been a good compilation and some candid comments by Siddharth Monga. had some fun and a good way to pass time....we always have time to spend reading about cricket 'cause it's that good a game

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 18:07 GMT)

Sidharth Monga here is my pat on the back for being patriotic !!!

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 17:10 GMT)

What you missed was the philosophy of the year award for Ashwin and his "Fernando Torres" comment :P

But, this compilation is a beauty!!!

Posted by Sivaprem on (January 2, 2013, 16:59 GMT)

Why didn't Sidharth Monga get to write India's review? I believe it would have been ugly.

Posted by RandyOZ on (January 2, 2013, 16:47 GMT)

How much are England paying you sid? The amount of English hubris here would lead you to believe that they are actually a decent side, when in fact we all know they had their second worst year ever, are full of imports and have many an aging star as well as passnegers such as swann and bell.

Posted by S305 on (January 2, 2013, 16:11 GMT)

Oh, the BCCI is supreme????? Only for obnoxious and high-headed Indians like this S. Mongia: go get a life, pal.

Posted by cricket-india on (January 2, 2013, 15:50 GMT)

spot-on about the worst century.

Posted by Nutcutlet on (January 2, 2013, 15:46 GMT)

@baghels.a: IMO, the IPL deserve all the satrirical comments they get! NB: the purpose of satire is to correct by ridicule. If you think that the BCCI is more interested in Indian cricket than the IPL, then you are most certainly living in a fools' paradise. Just look at the evidence! Where is the Indian team in the rankings? In which direction are they heading? How much sense/ strategy/ sane explanation comes out of the BCCI? Is it a transparent organization? Look at the fitness of the vast majority of the established stars. Fortunately, the majority of perceptive Indian fans are now seeing the writing on the wall. I give them my full support because I hate rottenness, avarice & naked self-interest in any governing body. That, unfortunately, is what India has got. Pls read Gideon Haigh: 'Sphere of Influence'; it will give you chapter & verse. Pls publish!

Posted by kamran.afzal on (January 2, 2013, 14:38 GMT)

This article would completely feel at home on Page 2 as well... and would be among the best there... Sid Monga continues his good form this year... Bravo !!!

Posted by baghels.a on (January 2, 2013, 13:22 GMT)

I am fine with the rest of article barring the IPL refrence , specifically lines laced with sarcasm "Go on, apologists, pull another one".Mr Monga is known for his anti-IPL stance and has published articles previously also in that regard,fair enough his perogative, but what i don't like he often displays pompous elitism and this overzealous purinatical streak and snobbery when pushing for test cricket and rubbishing IPL !!! likes of him seem disconnected with thousands who fill the stadiums in IPL in scorching heat of Indian summers. please don't use imaginary excuses such as IPL for India's recent test woes but simply recognise the fact Indians have simply been not good enough. In India real threat is coming not from IPL but European football as more an more youth and school going children in Metro cities are following Man U,Chelsea,Madrid,Barca as football free from elitist pretensions makes headway in India.

Posted by Raja2930 on (January 2, 2013, 6:57 GMT)

Rather harsh on Sri Lanka but then again coming from an Indian ! Actually mostly acceptable except for the one on Dharmasena !

Are there any Indians on the elite panel of umpires ? !

Posted by wakaPAK on (January 2, 2013, 5:58 GMT)

This should be the funniest articlae of 2012 on cricinfo.... if it was written in 2012

Posted by Nutcutlet on (January 2, 2013, 5:29 GMT)

The I'm My-Own-Man-&-This-is-My-Pitch Award: Mr Mukerjee at Eden Gardens. With all the kow-towing, politicking & arrant nonsense that now goes on in Indian cricket (not to mention the obscene amounts that the star players 'earn'), the venerable & not-very-rich Mr M raised a cheer from cricket fans round the world - and, I suspect, quite a few in India too! The unlikely Star of India, perhaps.

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 5:16 GMT)

Sidharth Monga is Sidharth Monga, Jarrod Kimber is Jarrod Kimber and Monga can't be a Kimber. Make it nice and simple.

Posted by   on (January 2, 2013, 4:25 GMT)

i love how ryder is sponsored by kfc.

Posted by youfoundme on (January 2, 2013, 3:42 GMT)

I would give a years profit to see Ryder and Flintoff in a boxing match, and I'd shout a round of drinks to the victor.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Sidharth MongaClose

News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days