Never before has this vaunted middle order been so badly exposed. The numbers might have been poor on the tour of New Zealand in 2002-03, but both Rahul Dravid and Sachin Tendulkar played fine hands in the loss at Basin Reserve, and doughty cameos in a low-scoring thriller at Hamilton. There have been no such crumbs of comfort here, with indecision and uncertainly the leitmotifs of a dismal showing.
After five innings, Sourav Ganguly has 78 runs. Rahul Dravid has 80, and Sachin Tendulkar 81. VVS Laxman had been marginally better, aggregating 154 while being guilty of squandering starts in every innings. Once you take out Virender Sehwag (310 runs) and Gambhir (284), the runs column makes for sombre reading. A line-up that's made runs the world over in all conditions and every conceivable match situation now bats to the tune of Paul Simon's You Can Call Me Al ("Why am I soft in the middle, The rest of my life is so hard").
Between them, India's four most experienced batsmen have managed one half-century in 20 visits to the crease. Gambhir, Mr. Consistency on this tour, has managed three, while batting with a composure and fluency that has eluded more illustrious names. Till he was once again undone by Ajantha Mendis's wiles, Gambhir had played another superb knock, driving the ball with panache and using his feet decisively against the spinners.
He needed to do something special to justify his inclusion ahead of Wasim Jaffer, and he has certainly done that, scoring at terrific pace in tandem with Sehwag. Unfortunately for India, there has been no one to capitalise on those starts, and the travails of the middle order on the first day at this historic venue were entirely in keeping with how they've batted right through the series.
Tendulkar, Ganguly and Laxman have all enjoyed purple patches of late, and the real reason for India's batting being so rudderless in this series can be found in the decline of Dravid. Once as dependable as an Audi, he hasn't found the high gears for nearly two years now, with match-turning efforts like the 92 in Perth becoming the exception rather than the rule. The more he struggles, the more you wonder whether the old solidity will ever come back.
On India's last tour of the island, they ran into a young fast bowler playing his seventh Test. Dilhara Fernando wrecked their hopes of success in Galle with a spell of 5 for 18 in seven overs. This time, the relatively unknown wrecking ball was Dammika Prasad, who started off as a No.3 batsman in school. Though he was distinctly scattergun in his first spell, he generated enough pace to ask far more questions than Nuwan Kulasekara had managed over two Tests.
Movement away from the bat did for the in-form Sehwag, but there was no more than a hint of swing about the deliveries that accounted for Dravid and Tendulkar. In pre-umpiring-review days, both might have enjoyed the benefit of the doubt, but in a game that's otherwise terribly skewed in the batsmen's favour, we shouldn't begrudge bowlers this novelty of delayed justice.
The dismissals of Ganguly and Laxman were far more demoralising. Both had shown signs of being in fine touch, with Ganguly stepping out and clouting Murali to the sightscreen and Laxman executing one glorious flick through midwicket as he came round the wicket. But Ganguly was trapped in that halfway house between playing a shot and leaving the ball, while Laxman succumbed to the delivery that will forever be associated with this series - Mendis' wonder flick that behaves like a leg-cutter.
As well as he bowled though, the last-wicket partnership between Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma put what went before into harsh perspective. They defied Murali, Mendis and Prasad for 20.2 overs, adding 51 runs along the way. With the pitch expected to be even more batsmen-friendly on the second day, India will spend Friday night wondering just how they frittered away the advantage gained at the toss.
One of punk's pioneers, Johnny Rotten, once said: "Don't accept the old order. Get rid of it." It's perhaps too early for Indian cricket to start thinking on those drastic lines, but there were more than a few gusts of the wind of change at the P Sara this afternoon.
Dileep Premachandran is an associate editor at Cricinfo