Australia in South Africa 2011-12

Harris suggests South Africa play two spinners

Firdose Moonda in Cape Town

November 6, 2011

Comments: 31 | Text size: A | A

Paul Harris is delighted after removing Virender Sehwag, South Africa v India, 1st Test, Centurion, 3rd day, December 18, 2010
Paul Harris was part of South Africa's team for their last Test series, at home against India © Gallo Images
Related Links
Players/Officials: Paul Harris
Series/Tournaments: Australia tour of South Africa
Teams: South Africa

Paul Harris, the South Africa left-arm spinner, has suggested South Africa play two spinners against Australia in the first Test in Cape Town, a move that would be a radical departure from the usual make-up of the starting XI and something that South Africa has rarely done.

Harris and Imran Tahir, the Pakistani-born legspinner, are the two spinners in the 14-man squad and it is expected that the pair will not play together. Tahir, who is touted as South Africa's first attacking spinner since Paul Adams, has had a dizzying rise to prominence since becoming eligible to play for South Africa in January and debuting at the 2011 World Cup. His success was thought to signal the end of Harris' international career. Harris is no longer a CSA contracted player and said he did not think he was part of the side's future plans.

Now that he is in the squad, Harris hopes to work with Tahir, who is, essentially, his biggest competitor. "I didn't think I was going to be in the squad in the first place. It was a nice surprise," Harris said. "It's good having Imran here as well because he is an attacking option and he deserved his call-up. It would be nice to bowl with him."

Harris and Tahir spent three seasons playing together for the Titans franchise, in which time they won the SuperSport Series once. "We bowl well together, we know each other's games and we get on quite well, so it's something we can exploit in the future," Harris said. "To have two spinners in South African conditions will be quality."

Newlands is the venue of the first Test and Harris said it was one of the places where South Africa could consider playing two spinners. "This is one of the grounds where you can do it, it does turn here. If they can get the pitch prepared to turn, it's a very good option."

Harris has not seen the pitch yet but understands that much will depend on the weather, which is expected to be cool and rainy in the lead-up to the Test. He said if the rain stayed away and a track that suited spin was prepared it could provide South Africa with "an area that we can exploit," since Australia do not have the same spin weapon they once did in Shane Warne.

Playing two spinners, Harris said, would also lessen the load on Jacques Kallis, the 36-year-old allrounder who is reaching that stage of his career where being managed does not refer to appearing in television advertisements. "I think he will bowl less if we play two spinners. He shouldn't bowl as much as he used to and if you can get one spell, maybe one-and-a-half spells, out of Jacques every day, that's all you want from him."

While all Harris' reasons are fairly logical, the cynic may hear them as a desperate plea from a man who does not want to lose his spot in the national side. Harris has been South Africa's premier Test spinner since January 2007, when he took five wickets in his debut match against India. Despite dealing with heavy criticism throughout the last four years, Harris has not been dropped once. Test captain Graeme Smith has praised him for playing a key, containing role and has maintained that Harris is an essential part of South Africa's attack.

In the current domestic season, Harris is third in the list of wicket-takers in the SuperSport Series, with 14 wickets from three matches at an average of 15.78. He said that was enough to merit his inclusion in the Test team, along with Tahir, but was philosophical about being left out. "May the best man win," he said at the conclusion of his two-spinner theory.

The domestic statistics this season are in Harris' favour: Tahir has taken 10 wickets in two matches and sat out the third due to a fitness concern. He has been expensive, although he has played on pitches that have not suited his type of bowling. Importantly though, both Tahir and Harris have had match practice, something that players like Graeme Smith and AB de Villiers have missed out on because of injury.

South Africa appeared undercooked in the Twenty20 and ODI series against Australia, and Harris said the emphasis on preparation had been increased. "Most of the guys who haven't played any first-class cricket recently are the senior guys and they've been around for a while; hopefully they will be able to adjust quite quickly. The preparation hasn't been ideal but we've got three days now, and we'll prepare as best as we can. It would have been easier to prepare if we had the Tests first and the one-dayers second."

Like many fans, Harris also lamented the series being shortened to two Tests from the usual three. "It would be nice to play at least three Tests against Australia. Dale Steyn made a comment the other day that he was on holiday longer than the series is going to last, so it is a bit disappointing."

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

RSS Feeds: Firdose Moonda

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by RandyOZ on (November 8, 2011, 2:02 GMT)

@david, similar to how india ran through your popgun south african batting lineup?

Posted by Dale-force_winds_steyn_the_pitch on (November 7, 2011, 19:39 GMT)

@Rr1m2: No thanks, Lopsy over Harris any time!

Posted by r1m2 on (November 7, 2011, 17:19 GMT)

Well Harris does have a practical point. After Steyn and Morkel, SAfrica does not have a capable third fast man to back them up in Test cricket. Tsotsobe and Parnell have both shown good form in limited overs but not so much in Tests. The new guy Philander might be a better choice for that, but he's got no experience. So, it might be better for SAfrica to deploy both Harris and Tahir in this match, if as he says this ground will have turn. Harris can continue to play containing role which might come in handy if SAfrica is attacking with Steyn, Morkel and Tahir with Kallis as backup.

Posted by bumsonseats on (November 7, 2011, 13:49 GMT)

randy just thought id get it in before he runs thru u guys. u must not rate him or that would have been brought up. this guy will make SA into one of the best sides maybe 2nd to your 3rd/4th. dpk

Posted by heathrf1974 on (November 7, 2011, 13:27 GMT)

If it will a good test series. Australia are beginning a new era and SA are attempting to cement their status as no. 2 in the world. The Aussies seem to lift against SA. I think it could be a drawn series 1-1.

Posted by RandyOZ on (November 7, 2011, 8:00 GMT)

@Meety,I agree we can play spin very well. Yet another bandwagon comment from @whitesXI. If people actually cared to watch our players you would see Marsh, Punter, Pup, Hussey all brilliant against spin. I have no doubt Hughsey will also be sensational.

Posted by zenboomerang on (November 7, 2011, 7:16 GMT)

Only reason for 2 spinners is a turning wicket... SA rely on their pacemen (rightly so) so might even see a green-top... with Harris born in Zimbabwe & Tahir in Pakistan is SA becoming the 'Little Britain' of the south... :P ... seriously though, both SA & Aus need a good no.3 bowler that is a swing & cut bowler for Newlands... like a Terry Alderman... seems like the type of bowler that most teams lack these days... would have liked to see Butterworth play this match & also is a vg no.7 or 8 with the bat...

Posted by zenboomerang on (November 7, 2011, 7:07 GMT)

@ whitesXI & rajanator360... Aus not playing spin bowling is a myth... only on sub-continent when multiple spinners are used for long periods... law of averages mean spinners get more wickets... in SA, Eng, WI, NZ & Aus most Aus wickets are taken by fast & medium bowlers... We didn't do too bad in the recent SL Test series on their wickets & with unknown bowlers... Tahir is not someone that we expect to be any better than the SL spinnners...

Posted by stormy16 on (November 7, 2011, 6:48 GMT)

Playing two spinners at home for SA will be alien to say the least. Also if SA doesnt play Tahir at 32 now, then they may as well look for someone else. Also I dont understant why Botha is not part of this deal. There are few better containing spinners in the world that Botha and he has hardly got a chance in tests. Cant recall Harris ever winning SA a game and I dont think there is point in playing a guy to hold up one end.

Posted by Meety on (November 7, 2011, 6:37 GMT)

Oz "lack" of ability against spin is a fallacy. Oz play spin poorly in India & to a lessor extent Pakistan (that long ago who remembers?). Unless the pitch ends up being sub-continental in characteristics Oz will play the spinners well. The question for SA is will they use a seamer to bottle up an end or a spinner. A seamer means that Tahir would play (been kept hidden from Oz), bottle up using a spinner & its Harris come on down. I would be more worried about Saffas negative spinners than Tahir as Oz are more likely get out to containment against a spinner.

Posted by rajanator360 on (November 7, 2011, 5:49 GMT)

Tahir's legspin will certainly take the aussies by surprise as they have barely seen what talent he has with the ball. On the other hand, Harris should be taken care of rather easily.

Posted by   on (November 7, 2011, 2:06 GMT)

Hey change the link of Paul harris when i click on the name its taking me to indian domestic cricket scores.

Posted by whitesXI on (November 7, 2011, 1:26 GMT)

Given aus lack of ability to play spin, it might not be a bad idea. Sadly for Harris I can't see it happening in SA, sub-continent fair enough, but not playing at home

Posted by rob11 on (November 7, 2011, 1:07 GMT)

Bit surprised Botha is not in the squad really

Posted by   on (November 6, 2011, 23:50 GMT)

love to see SA banking on spin.... don't see it happening...

Posted by smudgeon on (November 6, 2011, 23:39 GMT)

Interesting idea. It does sound awfully like Harris is trying to keep his spot, but some of his reasons are food for thought. Kallis never seems to struggle with the allrounder's workload, and Tsotsobe hasn't really set the world alight yet, so it could be worth taking a chance. Australia haven't seen Tahir up close yet, and if Harris can play a containing role, it'll allow Tahir the opportunity to be the aggressor (like a leggie should be!). Could be a good shock tactic, although a lot will depends on a) whether the selectors are willing to take a punt on two spinners, and b) whether the pitch at Newlands will take as much spin as they're predicting. I reckon it'll be a fairly standard attack though, three quicks + Tahir. It's going to be a compelling series, shame it's only two tests long...

Posted by johnathonjosephs on (November 6, 2011, 23:17 GMT)

Harris just wants to continue to play cricket for South Africa. Tahir's domestic record more than edges him out and compared to other nation's spinners, Harris is supremely below par. Tahir is way better choice and there is no way SA goes with a 2-2 bowling attack . People talking about Tsotsobe in a negative way. He hasn't been good earlier, but in recent time he's been in form and I feel he will be the key in the Test Series

Posted by landl47 on (November 6, 2011, 23:09 GMT)

Harris has been steady for SA, but he isn't a match-winner. Tahir is 32 and has never played a test match. I can't see SA playing two spinners except in the subcontinent, so the question is whether SA play the known quantity in Harris, who will at least keep the scoring rate in check, or take a flyer on Tahir, who might get wickets but might also go for plenty. With Kallis not able to contribute as many overs these days, they might go for Harris and rely on Steyn and Morkel to get the wickets. Preparing a turning wicket when Steyn and Morkel are in the side seems to me like the height of lunacy and I can't imagine SA will do that.

Posted by RandyOZ on (November 6, 2011, 22:47 GMT)

@davidpk, nice try playing the import card. I'll let you know when I figure out whether we are actually playing the real SA or SA 2, aka England United XI. The first 6 players I looked at in the United XI are born SA!

Posted by RandyOZ on (November 6, 2011, 22:44 GMT)

Harris only wants two spinners so he can play. Let him play so we can add him to the list of SA bowlers being spanked to all parts.

Posted by HatsforBats on (November 6, 2011, 21:08 GMT)

The Aussies will be hoping Harris plays, he's not a real wicket-taking threat and I can't imagine him being able to contain any of the top 7 (even Johnson, as bad as he's been with the bat of late, may like his chances against Harris again). I would think Tahir is a certainty and doubt very much that SA would go in with 2 spinners.

Posted by   on (November 6, 2011, 20:06 GMT)

I Think Tahir is a good option as we have seen in the past that assuies do struggled against quality and attacking spin bowling and when we have to choose between HArris or Tahir then Tahir will surely be a good option as he is more attacking among two. As far as two test match series is concern well its not good for test cricket because the best teams like SA and AUS should play more games on pitches where result oriented games can be played this will help the ICC to keep the interest of the game and also to save the Test cricket........

Posted by zico123 on (November 6, 2011, 20:04 GMT)

Imran Tahir should play defnitely

Posted by   on (November 6, 2011, 19:53 GMT)

Let's hope the selectors do follow his advice. And with so many good spinners as well as a slow pitch likely, how can they not?

Posted by hhillbumper on (November 6, 2011, 19:50 GMT)

tsotsobe was the worst overseas player Essex have ever had.can't believe he is highly rated and having seen him bowl there must be a reason why he gets picked for national team but they aren't occuring to me

Posted by   on (November 6, 2011, 19:40 GMT)

I clicked 'Paul Harris' link in the article and it opened Mumbai vs Railways game!! :) On the article., I think SA are rushing a bit too much here, Harris is a ideal Test spinner and Tahir needs to be his shadow rather than the first choice spinner!

Posted by   on (November 6, 2011, 19:00 GMT)

should have been a five test series frankly. would have allowed SA to try all kinds of spin -pace combinations- 4-1/3-2/5-0/ maybe even 2-3!!!!

Posted by CricketisMyPassion on (November 6, 2011, 18:43 GMT)

Harris may be right. Steyn-Morkel-Tahir-Harris plus Kaliis may be the best option for SA given that Tsotsobe is not a compelling choice. It wd alos upset Austalian batting plans since except Clarke and to lesser extent Ponting and Hussey ozzies wont be able to play spin well.

The two Test series is a shame. There should be some standard norms reg. minimum number of Tests to be played in a Test series. The top four ranked teams should play 5 Test series and the rest can play 3 Test series. The entire calendar should worked around this norm. - CMP

Posted by bumsonseats on (November 6, 2011, 17:42 GMT)

hes not more than a run stopper very average, i would put even the Aussie spinners ahead of him. SA should play the Pakistani leg spinner who has been what SA have needed since (the frog in a blender) was discarded. i cannot see them playing 3 pace and 2 spinners thats not very SA. and i think very strange. dpk

Posted by teo. on (November 6, 2011, 17:38 GMT)

Yes, and his containing role is vital for the balance of the attack. It would be really nice to see Tahir's potential at international level though.

Posted by Robster1 on (November 6, 2011, 16:46 GMT)

Two tests agianst the Aussies are indeed a travesty; for the forseeable future Harris should absolutely be an integral part of South Africa's test squad. Tahir is quite untested at test level. Harris's figures at domestic four day level are constantly impressive.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Firdose MoondaClose
Tour Results
South Africa v Australia at Johannesburg - Nov 17-21, 2011
Australia won by 2 wickets
South Africa v Australia at Cape Town - Nov 9-11, 2011
South Africa won by 8 wickets
Sth Africa A v Australians at Potchefstroom - Nov 1-3, 2011
Australians won by 7 wickets
South Africa v Australia at Durban - Oct 28, 2011
Australia won by 3 wickets (with 15 balls remaining)
South Africa v Australia at Port Elizabeth - Oct 23, 2011
South Africa won by 80 runs
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days