South Africa v England, 4th Test, Centurion January 21, 2016

De Villiers talks up England weaknesses


Even though England have already won the series against South Africa, AB de Villiers has declared them "not unbeatable" in a feisty press conference ahead of the final Test.

De Villiers referred to cracks in England's batting, with three of the top five potentially playing for their places in Centurion. He also suggested that some of their bowlers "have lost pace" - a comment widely interpreted as an attack on James Anderson, England's attack leader who has so far only managed to take three wickets in two Tests.

"There's no hiding from the fact that they seem to know what they are doing. But there's also no doubt that there are weaknesses there, and we've exposed some of them - but not enough and not for long enough," de Villiers said. "Their batting is not 100% best-in-the-world material. The bowling line-up is very experienced but some have lost pace over the years but they're very smart and very skilled. They're not unbeatable."

With words like that, Alastair Cook warned that de Villiers may be asking for trouble from the England attack. "He's obviously trying to wind everything up and if Jimmy reads it he'll have a word," Cook said. "I actually think his speeds have been quite good in this series. It's a brave man to call Jimmy Anderson out but I guess it will spice up the match a little."

That does not bode well for South Africa's batsmen, who have had a torrid time of it in the last two months. They have managed only two scores over 300 and slumped to their two lowest totals since readmission - something de Villiers is not running away from. He admitted their performances were not good enough - "it's time for us to wake up a little bit now and start playing proper cricket" - but did not say whether much had changed behind the scenes to enable that to happen just yet.

For now, he offered fighting talk: "There are no dead rubbers in Test cricket. The game has got way too much tradition and culture and history for us just to rock up and think it doesn't mean anything. It's a huge game for us. We'd hate to lose 3-0. I think 2-1 sounds a lot better. It would be great to win a Test. We haven't won a Test for 12 months."

But in the near future, he hopes there will be more technical improvements, including the involvement of a batting coach. "We've been a bit naive in believing we can go on the way we have been," de Villiers said. "We need to get advice and help, not only from a batting coach - in a few other areas as well. That will be discussed after this series. There are a few names already in the hat."

One of those names might be former captain Graeme Smith, who was roped in to assist before the Newlands Test but could not commit more time than that because of his commentary commitments. Instead, Smith has been vocal in his criticism of the current set-up and he is not the only one. Other players including Barry Richards and Daryl Cullinan have also aired their views but the most noteworthy naysaying came from within.

Ashwell Prince, who is on the selection panel, questioned the wisdom of de Villiers' comment that "all hope is gone" after the Wanderers defeat, and said the captain needed to send out more positive messages to the youngsters. It seems de Villiers has heard that, even though it may have hurt him.

"It's funny, because when I used to play with these guys they would talk about past players criticising them, and [saying] they can't believe it and they'll never become like that. So it's pretty funny and it shows you how quickly things change," de Villiers said. "But I've got no one to blame. We haven't won for a while and we deserve a bit of criticism. It's disappointing, but there are no hard feelings. We've got to move on as a team and try and win games."

And de Villiers remained confident that they will start doing that again, even if it takes some time before they really turn things around. "Before our run of four or five very good years, just before that there was also a patch when Graeme was captaining when people were talking in exactly the same way about us. I'm hoping we can make that turn quicker than people are expecting us to do. I'm optimistic. I've seen a lot of talent come through. We just need to get some experience and to get a few smart heads involved, and I believe we will move forward as a cricket team."

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Master on January 22, 2016, 14:37 GMT

    DeVilliers has not started well as a Leader. His comments at the start of the series about workload were destabilising. He criticised his team publicly at the end of his first Test as captain. He goaded England's two senior bowlers in the build up to this match and almost inevitably he got a 2nd ball duck. Better learn quickly or this reign will end abruptly. He reminds me a little of KP. I don't think he is a skipper too self absorbed.

  • Ian on January 22, 2016, 12:08 GMT

    Brave enough words, but the bigger problem for SA cricket is that years of mismanagement and under investment are finally coming home to roost. Players like Smith, Kallis, Steyn, De Villiers and Amla have helped to paper over the cracks for a while now, but when you look at the players coming through it's obvious that there has been a significant drop in standards and that SA lacks the depth of talent to remain competitive on the international stage. Things are only going to get worse from here.

  • Sarang on January 22, 2016, 11:04 GMT

    Right, AB. Now that Finn is out, you call Eng attack down on pace. There was a time when AB used to talk up his team with some aggression in his press-conferences but this stuff is quite ordinary. First those demoralizing words and now this. Just shows SA don't have a clear plan and they are just talking. Anything more than a flat wicket and it could be 3-0.

  • Aqib on January 22, 2016, 8:48 GMT

    This is not in any way trash talk of engalnd. Blown completely out of proportion. What was he meant to say? You guys are acting like he's gonna say we are going to get outplayed again and lose 3-0. He has to talk up his teams chances and he is right to do so. They do have a chance to beat England.

  • Dave on January 22, 2016, 8:18 GMT

    "Some of England's bowlers have lost pace"......this implies plural, I wouldn't argue that Anderson has lost a bit of zip, but he was never about express pace anyway. But who else is he referring to? Broad? Seems a bit silly considering Broad got him for a duck last match and is bowling considerably quicker than he has done.

  • Russ on January 22, 2016, 7:44 GMT

    I've disliked DeVilliers ever since he tried to claim that dropped catch against Strauss. His batting and has been distinctly average this series and his recent whingeing has revealed much weakness . Give me Smith or Kallis any day.

  • Gueye on January 22, 2016, 7:22 GMT

    Brave of the captain to take pot shots at the bowling attack that knocked his side over for 83 in their last outing.

    The Proteas have been thoroughly underwhelming this series. They don't deserve better than 3-0 to be frank, and I fear that's exactly what they'll get.

  • FAN on January 22, 2016, 5:00 GMT

    Jimmy is very old now... He is the worst bowler in this series... Stuart broad just saved his career

  • Alex on January 22, 2016, 4:21 GMT

    Engalnd have ideal blueprint for test team. Infact they are not that good yet. But they covered leadership area well. As long as root is not next captain england will do fine. The day england appoint root captain , they will start to lose. Some are assasins, some are soldiers. You have to know who is good for certain role. With strauss in charge and whole england team knows what is their roles are. Players are thinking only their bit part. So its easier for players to manage. Winning makes that illusion and hide weaknesses of each player. Losses makes even make people question strength of players , forget weaknesses. ABD comes as man with too many thoughts in his mind and it does not come out in certain order. He has lot to say but its worthless in the perspective of winning this test. Coach domingo has to go. Mainly because he brought the mess of keeping duminy in the team. SA do not select young players like 20-24. Youth cures every disease plauging SA.

  • Tejas on January 22, 2016, 4:13 GMT

    I think AB's comments could easily backfire. SA had enough trouble against Broad alone. They cannot afford to wind-up Jimmy.

  • No featured comments at the moment.