South Africa v India, 2nd ODI, Johannesburg January 14, 2011

Miller the weakest link in middle order

  shares 21

"Can you imagine if we wrote Jacques Kallis off after his first 12 ODIs?" HD Ackerman, former South Africa Test batsman, asked. It would have meant aborting a career that has, so far, spanned 307 ODIs, seen over 11,000 runs, including 17 centuries, and boasts an average of 45.84.

It's unfathomable to think that such an illustrious career should have been cut short based on Kallis' first 12 ODIs; in those, he only managed 203 runs, at an average of 25.38, with one half-century. That's Ackerman's answer when he is asked if he thinks David Miller has done enough in his short time as a national cricketer to warrant a place in the South African team. Miller has played in 12 ODIs and averages 26.50, slightly more than Kallis did at the same stage, but has not set the stage alight as much as was expected.

In a shaky-looking middle to lower order, that consists of Miller, Johan Botha and the tail, it seems Miller is the weakest link. Ackerman has been one of Miller's strongest backers and said that in time, he can become the strongest member of the middle order. "The selectors and the fans are going to be have to patient with him. He is only 21-years old but he has massive potential to represent South Africa in all forms of the game."

Patience is not something South Africa can afford to have in abundance for the next few weeks, because the World Cup is looming. "People are going to ask questions about him [Miller] because of the World Cup. South Africa are desperate to win the World Cup, so they want the best side possible," Ackerman said. Miller's position, at No.6 or 7, will be a crucial one according to Ackerman, because it will require batsmen to be able "to play spin well."

Ackerman saw the two places being contested between Miller, Colin Ingram and Faf du Plessis, with du Plessis guaranteed a spot if Ackerman was the man choosing. "Faf hasn't played yet but he has the advantage of being able to bowl, which neither David or Colin do. He is also a fine fielder. The other two are also good fielders, but Faf is better than both of them."

Essentially, that means Miller and Ingram will fight it out for the remaining berth and Ackerman backed Miller to take it, saying his true batting style had not been allowed to come out at national level yet, but was lurking. "The David Miller I saw get out on Wednesday was not the David Miller I know. He is a good, clean hitter of the ball and he was trying to nudge and nurdle and he got out."

Miller made a name at the Dolphins for being a big hitter but Ackerman said that didn't mean Miller can't rotate the strike in the middle overs if needed. "When I say he is a big hitter, I mean that he gets the ball to the sweepers, the deep covers, the mid-offs. He doesn't just drop the ball and run, he hits it well and far. He can still take a single or a two off those shots." As for sticking to that skill and not getting bogged down into playing differently to what he is used to, Duncan Fletcher, the team's batting consultant, felt that ability would come with time. "All it needs is a little bit more experience I guess," he said.

Ingram, who has more of that experience at the domestic level and has fared better in his nine ODIs than Miller has in his 12, may be the more automatic choice in the subcontinent for that reason. Ingram is currently standing in for Kallis in No.3 position, and it may be a tricky task for him to move down the order, according to Ackerman. "For him to be taken to the World Cup and have to bat six could be difficult. The No.3 and No.6 roles are completely different and it will need a total change of mindset."

Kallis is not going to play any part in the ODI series, which means Ingram will probably stay at No.3 for the remaining four matches and not have any time lower down the order. Ackerman felt that experience was vital but added that the line-up may shift as South Africa get within sniffing distance of the ICC showpiece. "If South Africa go three-nil up in the series, then we will start seeing them use their game-plan that they want to carry into the World Cup." With conditions in South Africa very different to what they will experience in the subcontinent, they can't afford to experiment with their World Cup combinations before securing the series. Whatever happens, Ackerman hopes Miller will be part of it.

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on January 15, 2011, 20:03 GMT

    where is Albie morkel? i think they didnt even slected him in WC squad?

  • nzcricket174 on January 15, 2011, 17:41 GMT

    If you want a good clean striker of the ball batting at 7 Albie Morkel is your best choice.

  • on January 15, 2011, 16:49 GMT

    My dream team for south africa will be Smith,Amla,Kallis,De villears,C.Ingram,J.Duminy,A Morkel,j.Botha,M.Morkel,D.Steyn And LL Tsotsobe/WD Parnel 3 quality seamers and a gud sppiner with 2 class all rounders . There can be shuffle between Faf du Plesis and miller if d stage demands Please S A selectors give J.Morkel a chance he is a genuine allrounder

  • Robster1 on January 15, 2011, 14:02 GMT

    Am still amazed that Morne Van Wyk is not at the very least in the squad.

  • on January 15, 2011, 12:42 GMT

    ALBIE at seven with miller or ingram at 6 botha 8 steyn 9 morkel 10 tahir 11. with smith and amla to open after that kallis ab de villers and duminy.

    then theres the likes of tsotobe parnell theron bosman du plesiss and van de merwe and even langeveldt. with that starting team you can have the to main seamers along with albie and kallis plus the 2 spinners and duminy. if its a track for the fast bowlers bring in another seamer for one of the spinners. or even boucher or gibbs.........

  • on January 15, 2011, 10:50 GMT

    I agree that Graeme Smith is experiencing a slump in form. To call him the weakest link in the SA make-up is however a bit ridiculous. I am at the point where I'm taking it for granted that anybody who takes such an ill-informed position is clearly thinking with their emotions and not their heads.

  • on January 15, 2011, 10:17 GMT

    Come off it guys, some of your comments show just how little SA domestic cricket you have been watching. David is a fantastic hitter of the ball, and he is exactly what we need in the no. 6 batting position. To add to that he is a proper batsman as well, not a bowler who bats a bit or a batsman who bowls a bit. Lets be honest, Albie Morkel is not an all rounder, he is a bits and pieces player, and he would not be picked for the side for his batting or bowling alone, and neither would Faf du Plessis. The selectors have got it right with Hashim Amla when we all said it would not work as he bats too slowly, and they got it right with AB and JP as well, not to mention Parnell and Tsotsobe. The case of Kallis is just another reason why public opinion should be kept out of the selection process, he would never have played more than 20 tests or one-dayers if the public had been allowed to decide his fate. Lets sit back and enjoy the future, as both Colin and David mature into fine players

  • Proteas_Supporter on January 15, 2011, 9:11 GMT

    yes the weakest link in SA team is GC SMITH... he needs to show what hes capable of... the reason y he hasn't performed that well in the past 3 years is due to frequent freaking finger injuries... hope he hits form in the coming ODI's. about miller & ingram, they both look suspect agnst spin which will be crucial in WC. will be interesting who gets picked and who doesn't... miller, ingram, duminy, duplessis(if hes picked) all poor agnst spin. these 4 matches will say who gets the nod. and for ALBIE, hes way tooo inconsistent both with the bat & ball... he can perform in IPL though... albie won't make it to SA team anymore. hes finished...:(

  • on January 15, 2011, 7:04 GMT

    Rahul Dravid's stats in ODIs from start were as follows: 3,4,3,11,22,7,13,39.......and he ended up making more than 10000 runs at av of nearly 40........one must spot amount of talent in the player, later he will deliver........why India keep on investing in Vijay, Raina, Rohit because these guys have tonns of talent.......

  • prakashupad on January 15, 2011, 6:58 GMT

    My Team for the World Cup would be Smith,Amla,Kallis,De Villiers,Duminy,Faf Du Plessis,Albie Morkel,Steyn,Parnell/Botha,Morkel,Imran Tahir.....Du Plessis over Miller and Ingram because he is a batting allrounder and an xcellent fielder...Tahir over Botha because he has got loads of experience....

  • on January 15, 2011, 20:03 GMT

    where is Albie morkel? i think they didnt even slected him in WC squad?

  • nzcricket174 on January 15, 2011, 17:41 GMT

    If you want a good clean striker of the ball batting at 7 Albie Morkel is your best choice.

  • on January 15, 2011, 16:49 GMT

    My dream team for south africa will be Smith,Amla,Kallis,De villears,C.Ingram,J.Duminy,A Morkel,j.Botha,M.Morkel,D.Steyn And LL Tsotsobe/WD Parnel 3 quality seamers and a gud sppiner with 2 class all rounders . There can be shuffle between Faf du Plesis and miller if d stage demands Please S A selectors give J.Morkel a chance he is a genuine allrounder

  • Robster1 on January 15, 2011, 14:02 GMT

    Am still amazed that Morne Van Wyk is not at the very least in the squad.

  • on January 15, 2011, 12:42 GMT

    ALBIE at seven with miller or ingram at 6 botha 8 steyn 9 morkel 10 tahir 11. with smith and amla to open after that kallis ab de villers and duminy.

    then theres the likes of tsotobe parnell theron bosman du plesiss and van de merwe and even langeveldt. with that starting team you can have the to main seamers along with albie and kallis plus the 2 spinners and duminy. if its a track for the fast bowlers bring in another seamer for one of the spinners. or even boucher or gibbs.........

  • on January 15, 2011, 10:50 GMT

    I agree that Graeme Smith is experiencing a slump in form. To call him the weakest link in the SA make-up is however a bit ridiculous. I am at the point where I'm taking it for granted that anybody who takes such an ill-informed position is clearly thinking with their emotions and not their heads.

  • on January 15, 2011, 10:17 GMT

    Come off it guys, some of your comments show just how little SA domestic cricket you have been watching. David is a fantastic hitter of the ball, and he is exactly what we need in the no. 6 batting position. To add to that he is a proper batsman as well, not a bowler who bats a bit or a batsman who bowls a bit. Lets be honest, Albie Morkel is not an all rounder, he is a bits and pieces player, and he would not be picked for the side for his batting or bowling alone, and neither would Faf du Plessis. The selectors have got it right with Hashim Amla when we all said it would not work as he bats too slowly, and they got it right with AB and JP as well, not to mention Parnell and Tsotsobe. The case of Kallis is just another reason why public opinion should be kept out of the selection process, he would never have played more than 20 tests or one-dayers if the public had been allowed to decide his fate. Lets sit back and enjoy the future, as both Colin and David mature into fine players

  • Proteas_Supporter on January 15, 2011, 9:11 GMT

    yes the weakest link in SA team is GC SMITH... he needs to show what hes capable of... the reason y he hasn't performed that well in the past 3 years is due to frequent freaking finger injuries... hope he hits form in the coming ODI's. about miller & ingram, they both look suspect agnst spin which will be crucial in WC. will be interesting who gets picked and who doesn't... miller, ingram, duminy, duplessis(if hes picked) all poor agnst spin. these 4 matches will say who gets the nod. and for ALBIE, hes way tooo inconsistent both with the bat & ball... he can perform in IPL though... albie won't make it to SA team anymore. hes finished...:(

  • on January 15, 2011, 7:04 GMT

    Rahul Dravid's stats in ODIs from start were as follows: 3,4,3,11,22,7,13,39.......and he ended up making more than 10000 runs at av of nearly 40........one must spot amount of talent in the player, later he will deliver........why India keep on investing in Vijay, Raina, Rohit because these guys have tonns of talent.......

  • prakashupad on January 15, 2011, 6:58 GMT

    My Team for the World Cup would be Smith,Amla,Kallis,De Villiers,Duminy,Faf Du Plessis,Albie Morkel,Steyn,Parnell/Botha,Morkel,Imran Tahir.....Du Plessis over Miller and Ingram because he is a batting allrounder and an xcellent fielder...Tahir over Botha because he has got loads of experience....

  • venkatr_11 on January 15, 2011, 6:42 GMT

    Its glaring to note that SA have been omitting Albie Morkel. Being an all-rounder and having played a lot of IPL games, he has the experience to do the role of a 5th bowler and is a power hitter who can play match changing knocks. He needs to be backed up and given a lot of confidence. Smith can take a cue from MS Dhoni, his IPL Captain. Also, this will give them an option of playing Botha,Steyn, Morkel and Tahir as the bowlers with Kallis, Albie and Duminy filling in the 5th bowler slot! Simple and powerful thinking that maximizes their chances of winning the world cup. Unless Miller proves to be a success, ignoring Albie could be their doom! India will accept an all-rounder like Albie with both hands!

  • on January 15, 2011, 6:25 GMT

    This is my dream SA team for the worldcup

    GC Smith, HM Amla, JH Kallis, AB de Villiers, JP Duminy, CA Ingram/DA Miller, JA Morkel, J Botha, DW Steyn, M Morkel/J Theron, LL Tsotsobe/WD Parnell,

    In this way Kallis, Duminy and JA Morkel will have to ball the 5th Bowler's 10 overs. and I am sure they can do that. JA Morkel is because we need the fire power to finish the innings. I request the SA selection people to look seriously to this and select the team to win the worldcup

  • KunzMan on January 15, 2011, 5:05 GMT

    The two places should be between Faf / Miller / Albie. I am not sure Ingram can bat well at 6. And with regards to comments on Smith's form. Yes his consistency is a concern. But changing him as a captain as someone indirectly hinted would be like finding another groom for your daughter on the wedding eve.

  • Abhiramb on January 15, 2011, 2:49 GMT

    SA's weakest link could be right at the top of the batting order - Mr Smith. Look at what he has achieved as an opener in the past two years - two centuries Mar 2008 and Sep 2009 in 36 innings. He almost looks irresponsible when he bats and ends up putting a lot of pressure on the other batsmen. Look at the shot he played in the first match too. It will interesting to see how he performs in this series and in the world cup on turning pitches

  • on January 15, 2011, 0:40 GMT

    They should go with Albie or Du Plessis depending on the surface. With that player at 7, Botha at 8 the batting goes deep enough with enough bowling options, the team for the World Cup should go as follows

    Smith Amla Kallis De Villiers Duminy Ingram A. Morkel/Du Plessis 8. Botha 9. Parnell 10. Steyn 11. M. Morkel/Tahir

  • jessjess on January 14, 2011, 20:30 GMT

    FAF DU PLESSIS. he deserves a place in the world cup team. Im so happy he earned a contract with Chennai.

  • Fareen on January 14, 2011, 20:25 GMT

    I think Miller should continue to play there...but SA needs a good replacement in case he fails...If it Faf du plessis then he has to play 2-3 one-days in this series.You can throw a new guy in the WC.I guess the selectors have written off Albie Morkel And Ryan Mclaren.In this case,SA will miss a lower order hitter.Botha is not good enough for no.7.some allrounder has to bat there.and in sub-continent,you got to drop 1 bowler.To me,steyn and parnel should not be dropped as they are death bowlers.It's between Morne and lonwabo.

  • on January 14, 2011, 19:51 GMT

    As long as Graeme Smith is Captain, South Africa will not win the World Cup. It does not matter if Miller is in the team or not. Graeme Smith's thinking is very clear when his team is in a position of Strength. His thinking deteriorates and his vision is blurred when South Africa is under pressure. He takes that mind set and body language to the rest of the team. The real contenders for the World Cup are India, England, Sri-Lanka, Australia and Pakistan. If Australia can not find a good Spinner their chances would become less as well.

  • vsssarma on January 14, 2011, 19:33 GMT

    SA has plenty of bench strength with or without Miller who is of course a weak performer. Let us see the relative performances of SA's batsmen and bowlers during the last one year on a 0-1,000 point scale.

    HM Amla - 1,000; AB de Villiers - 914; JH Kallis - 663; LL Bosman - 640; JP Duminy - 527; CA Ingram - 386; GC Smith - 365; DA Miller - 221; J Botha - 170 - JA Morkel - 163; WD Parnell - 158; RE van der Merwe - 112; DW Steyn - 83; HH Gibbs - 81; R McLaren - 66; AN Petersen - 45; CK Langeveldt - 42; M Morkel - 31; J Theron - 23; RJ Peterson - 21; LL Tsotsobe - 10; MV Boucher - 5.

    SA's bowling strengths:

    RE van der Merwe - 1,000; J Theron - 999; LL Tsotsobe - 879; M Morkel - 826; RJ Peterson - 793; CK Langeveldt - 707; J Botha - 646; DW Steyn - 644; WD Parnell - 589; R McLaren - 531; JH Kallis - 439; JA Morkel - 380; JP Duminy - 84; Others - 0.

    SA has the problem of plenty now. Nothing to worry except for Captain's form.

  • on January 14, 2011, 19:21 GMT

    Where is Albie Morkel? He can bowl and bat too

  • skepticaloptimist on January 14, 2011, 19:16 GMT

    It's a slightly awkward time when CSA introduced Miller into the side. For subcontinental conditions, I'd say going to Albie would have been a better option. Nevertheless, Miller deserves his chances. He should perform in next 2-3 games to really cement his position for the World Cup side.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • skepticaloptimist on January 14, 2011, 19:16 GMT

    It's a slightly awkward time when CSA introduced Miller into the side. For subcontinental conditions, I'd say going to Albie would have been a better option. Nevertheless, Miller deserves his chances. He should perform in next 2-3 games to really cement his position for the World Cup side.

  • on January 14, 2011, 19:21 GMT

    Where is Albie Morkel? He can bowl and bat too

  • vsssarma on January 14, 2011, 19:33 GMT

    SA has plenty of bench strength with or without Miller who is of course a weak performer. Let us see the relative performances of SA's batsmen and bowlers during the last one year on a 0-1,000 point scale.

    HM Amla - 1,000; AB de Villiers - 914; JH Kallis - 663; LL Bosman - 640; JP Duminy - 527; CA Ingram - 386; GC Smith - 365; DA Miller - 221; J Botha - 170 - JA Morkel - 163; WD Parnell - 158; RE van der Merwe - 112; DW Steyn - 83; HH Gibbs - 81; R McLaren - 66; AN Petersen - 45; CK Langeveldt - 42; M Morkel - 31; J Theron - 23; RJ Peterson - 21; LL Tsotsobe - 10; MV Boucher - 5.

    SA's bowling strengths:

    RE van der Merwe - 1,000; J Theron - 999; LL Tsotsobe - 879; M Morkel - 826; RJ Peterson - 793; CK Langeveldt - 707; J Botha - 646; DW Steyn - 644; WD Parnell - 589; R McLaren - 531; JH Kallis - 439; JA Morkel - 380; JP Duminy - 84; Others - 0.

    SA has the problem of plenty now. Nothing to worry except for Captain's form.

  • on January 14, 2011, 19:51 GMT

    As long as Graeme Smith is Captain, South Africa will not win the World Cup. It does not matter if Miller is in the team or not. Graeme Smith's thinking is very clear when his team is in a position of Strength. His thinking deteriorates and his vision is blurred when South Africa is under pressure. He takes that mind set and body language to the rest of the team. The real contenders for the World Cup are India, England, Sri-Lanka, Australia and Pakistan. If Australia can not find a good Spinner their chances would become less as well.

  • Fareen on January 14, 2011, 20:25 GMT

    I think Miller should continue to play there...but SA needs a good replacement in case he fails...If it Faf du plessis then he has to play 2-3 one-days in this series.You can throw a new guy in the WC.I guess the selectors have written off Albie Morkel And Ryan Mclaren.In this case,SA will miss a lower order hitter.Botha is not good enough for no.7.some allrounder has to bat there.and in sub-continent,you got to drop 1 bowler.To me,steyn and parnel should not be dropped as they are death bowlers.It's between Morne and lonwabo.

  • jessjess on January 14, 2011, 20:30 GMT

    FAF DU PLESSIS. he deserves a place in the world cup team. Im so happy he earned a contract with Chennai.

  • on January 15, 2011, 0:40 GMT

    They should go with Albie or Du Plessis depending on the surface. With that player at 7, Botha at 8 the batting goes deep enough with enough bowling options, the team for the World Cup should go as follows

    Smith Amla Kallis De Villiers Duminy Ingram A. Morkel/Du Plessis 8. Botha 9. Parnell 10. Steyn 11. M. Morkel/Tahir

  • Abhiramb on January 15, 2011, 2:49 GMT

    SA's weakest link could be right at the top of the batting order - Mr Smith. Look at what he has achieved as an opener in the past two years - two centuries Mar 2008 and Sep 2009 in 36 innings. He almost looks irresponsible when he bats and ends up putting a lot of pressure on the other batsmen. Look at the shot he played in the first match too. It will interesting to see how he performs in this series and in the world cup on turning pitches

  • KunzMan on January 15, 2011, 5:05 GMT

    The two places should be between Faf / Miller / Albie. I am not sure Ingram can bat well at 6. And with regards to comments on Smith's form. Yes his consistency is a concern. But changing him as a captain as someone indirectly hinted would be like finding another groom for your daughter on the wedding eve.

  • on January 15, 2011, 6:25 GMT

    This is my dream SA team for the worldcup

    GC Smith, HM Amla, JH Kallis, AB de Villiers, JP Duminy, CA Ingram/DA Miller, JA Morkel, J Botha, DW Steyn, M Morkel/J Theron, LL Tsotsobe/WD Parnell,

    In this way Kallis, Duminy and JA Morkel will have to ball the 5th Bowler's 10 overs. and I am sure they can do that. JA Morkel is because we need the fire power to finish the innings. I request the SA selection people to look seriously to this and select the team to win the worldcup