South Africa v India, 2nd Test, Durban, 5th day

To turn it around and win a huge achievement - Smith

Firdose Moonda in Durban

December 30, 2013

Comments: 21 | Text size: A | A
Don't think we'll ever replace Jacques - Smith

Welcome back, Durban. You are part of South Africa again.

After being the scene of four straight defeats between 2009 and 2011, South Africa have turned their fortunes at the coastal city around. That Graeme Smith could lead his men out to sing their team song on its surface more than three and a half hours after they sealed the series victory was confirmation Kingsmead has returned to the fold of home turf.

"Protea fire" is the chorus of their song. The concept, featuring their nickname, the Proteas, is based on the germination of the country's national flower. It can only grow after a fire, because the seeds are cased in a hard shell which can remain closed for two decades. After the adversity of flame, it blooms.

Robin Peterson in his delivery stride, South Africa v India, 2nd Test, Durban, 4th day, December 29, 2013
Graeme Smith on Robin Peterson: "Robbie did well with the ball and with the bat last night. He brings a good balance to the team" © Getty Images

Smith believes his men lived up to their emblem because they overcome conditions and persistent clouds to ensure they were undefeated in a 14th consecutive series. Of those, they have won eight, including this one. "The wicket didn't make it easy for us. It's almost like we were back in India," he said. "The weather and the pitch made life a little more difficult. We had to work hard. To have the ability to turn it around and win like we did is a huge achievement."

The difference ended up being in the spin department, but not in the way anyone would have expected. Robin Peterson ended up as South Africa's leading wicket-taker in the second innings with four scalps. MS Dhoni and Ravindra Jadeja were two of them, having misjudged their shots against him.

Zaheer Khan was the other on the final day, adjudged lbw. Replays showed the ball would have missed legstump but the delivery Peterson bowled to achieve that wicket was a carrom ball, a skill many would have thought Peterson lacked. Add that to the 52-ball 61 he powered his way to with the bat and it was a good game for Peterson, who was under scrutiny after the way he bowled in Abu Dhabi against Pakistan.

South Africa still have unanswered questions in that department but Peterson went some way to reassuring them with this showing. "Both our spinners have faced challenging times," Smith said. "Robbie did well with the ball and with the bat last night. He brings a good balance to the team. The four wickets will be hugely rewarding. Without those four wickets, I don't think we would have come close to winning this Test match."

Peterson's ability as a lower-order allrounder may take the pressure off South Africa to find another seam-bowling two-in-one immediately following Kallis' Test retirement. There will be no easy polyfill for them, something MS Dhoni warned them of when he described Kallis as their "ultimate luxury" which India could have used.

"If we had a Kallis, we would have played two spinners and three seamers," Dhoni said. "But there's no point complaining about what we don't have. South Africa will have to find someone. They have players who can bat and bowl but they will have groom them further."

Smith acknowledged something similar but has already understood Kallis himself cannot be substituted. "I don't think we are ever going to replace Jacques. The sooner we face that, the better," he said. 'We'll need to get tactically smart. I don't think anyone who gets picked should be labeled as Jacques Kallis' replacement. What Jacques has left is huge. It's important that the next guy gets a fresh start."

South Africa have six weeks to ponder that before Australia arrive, a contest they are relishing despite the break to play domestic 20-overs cricket. "We're just hitting our straps and now we have another month off... I feel if we had a couple more [international] matches, we'd play really well," Smith said. "But it's setting up for an exciting series."

Until then, South Africa can soak in the success they've just achieved in beating the team ranked second, gaining two ranking points, winning a series against India for the first time since 2006. "The one team we haven't beaten over the last three years [is India]. At the Wanderers, we were behind the game for 90% of it and fought our way back to draw. This was an incredible win considering the weather and India's performance on the first day." Smith said. "This team conducts itself in ways that speak for itself."

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

RSS Feeds: Firdose Moonda

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Duidelik on (January 1, 2014, 11:18 GMT)

I may sound funny by saying this and attract huge criticism from my fellow SA countrymen, and no denying that Jacques Kallis is probably the greatest allrounder the world has ever seen (even better than Sobers, Khan and Hadlee!), but he has actually been a liability over the last 2 years in the team and has disturbed the balance due to the selectors not wanting to drop him out of respect. Yes, I know he did get a ton in his farewell test, and possibly engineered the win, but watch how the balance of the team improves againt the Aussies. The Aussies are not that hot at the moment, and they have won the Ashes against an England side on the downward slide. SA will actually defeat Australia far easier than they did against India. They don't have any proven stars. Our batters grew up against pace like Johnson & co. Our batters read finger spinners like Lyon better than wrist spinners. We will set traps for Warner. Watson is shot. We only fear Michael Clarke. He's a class act!

Posted by stormy16 on (December 31, 2013, 9:10 GMT)

Sure SA won but question marks remain! India were a young side and I expected SA to blow them away with the best bowling and batting line ups in the world. They conceeded a first innings lead in JHB and India were nearly 200/1 in the second test. Sure SA did well to draw and nearly win the first test and blow away India in the second test but I think SA were expected to win 2-0 and the wins to have been much easier. Take nothing away from SA they did really well against a plucky opponent who put them under presure, after all you dont be the number one team for nothing. My point is SA with all the guns up their sleeve should have won better.

Posted by sachin_vvsfan on (December 31, 2013, 8:11 GMT)

@KiwiRocker welcome back!! We missed you all these days. I thought you would disappear after Tendulkar's retirement. You weren't seen when India was dominating the game. So hows your pakistan team doing? I think their batsmen are doing fine job at the moment and hope you don't get carried away by calling your team world beaters. See you next year when India looses or when Sangakkara retires. Because he is the next on the debate list on his retirement after Lara vs Sachin, Ponting vs Sachin, Kallis vs Sachin debate.

Posted by   on (December 31, 2013, 6:14 GMT)

there comes kiwirocker and his passion on Indian cricket

Posted by sanjai007 on (December 31, 2013, 5:52 GMT)

Kallis cant b replaced, however the team have to move on, so Smith, Petersen, Amla, Faf, AB, JP, Parnell, Philander, Steyn, Morkel, Peterson(in fast pitches) / Tahir (in turners ).

Bring in dekock, roussow, harmer to th test arena,

Posted by   on (December 31, 2013, 5:09 GMT)

Congrats SA for series win. But beware of the upcoming series against Aussie.They are gelling well and seemed to be peaked the right form in the ongoing Ashes.Waiting for AUS-SA Test Series. Truly Kallis can't be replaced , But they have ABD who can achieve close to watch what kallis has achieved. Try to relieve him with keeping stuff with Q kock.

Posted by rezwan_83. on (December 31, 2013, 4:09 GMT)

Include Simon Harmer and Quinny as back up and groom them.Harmer is a good prospect and he is the right choice to lead the spinning department.Quinny can take number 4 position in SA test line up.

Posted by Mogudoom on (December 31, 2013, 4:08 GMT)

FAF can try at no 4 , and ABD at 5 and question mark is 6 and 7 th position .. i dont think JBD play that well recent days .. if he perform welll then we need a clean striker at no 7 with batting skill and little defense skill and 8,9,10 , 11 bowler whom little bit can able to bat

Posted by   on (December 31, 2013, 1:29 GMT)

Elgar??? No the ignored Albie Morkel for Kallis, Albie even has a great first class batting avg and is ideal to bat at 7. Du Plessis at 4, De V at 5, Duminy at 6. SAf will be more formidable now since Kallis was out of form the last 2 years. As for India, the Rohit-haters make no sense at all. They forget how unsuccessful Pujara's, Kohli's (the first 8 innings!), Rahane (flopped totally in Aus even against state sides) and Vijay's I(a flop in WI against WI) initial overseas test cricket was. And yet Dhawan & Rohit have done very well in overseas ODIs against quality attacks including some of the best fast bowlers in the world.

Posted by Guduji71 on (December 31, 2013, 0:42 GMT)

My analysis of the series is that India almost lost the first test I think SA should have gone for the win in the first test match and second test was won by SA almost by an innings. Ind lost both ODIs, badly. The results don't show that India did remarkably well.

Posted by KiwiRocker- on (December 31, 2013, 0:15 GMT)

SA is a well deserved No.1 ranked team and they have shown character. Something that Indian players lacked. India has failed at first hurdle. Dhoni and Co are as usual trying to hige behind hollow rankings that mean nothing. Pakistan beat SA in a test match that India could not manage on batsmen friendly tracks. Pakistan even managed to beat SA in SA in an ODI series and Pakistan is not supposed to be top ranked team. ICC rankings are flawed and they make as much sense as claims that Tendulkar was better than Kallis. In current form, SA, Australia and Pakistan are three top ranked test and ODI teams. India and England are behind the top.3. Status and results show that. The claims that difference was Steyn are also misleading. Indeed Steyn destroyed much hyped Indian batting in ODi and test series, but real difference was how SA batsmen stood up in second inning of first test and first inning of second test. That was difference SA batting. India's bowling failed but so did batting!

Posted by kbza86 on (December 30, 2013, 22:24 GMT)

yes we are all sad that Kallis has left the scene(very sad)..but we always new this day would come and it finally has.I'm sure there are plans post retirement..ill support any decision BIffy and Domingo take..but here is my suggestion: 1.Petersen, 2.Biff 3.Faf/elgar 4.Amla 5.ABD 6. JPD 7.Mclaren 8.Peterson 9. Big Vern 10.Steyn 11.Mornas

Simply because our strength has always been our seam and batting (ie:Donald, Pollock, Pollock, Pollock, Barry Richards, Eddie Barlow, fanie, goddard etc) we will always find another allrounder just a matter of time...just need someone to fill in till then...

Posted by StaalBurgher on (December 30, 2013, 22:24 GMT)

It should be QDK in for Kallis. Elgar, who is good, is an opener and not as talented as a batsmen as Quinton. If anything Petersen should be replaced by Elgar, Kallis by Quinton and ANYONE for Tahir/Peterson.

Posted by Shongololo on (December 30, 2013, 22:09 GMT)

Let's get real about Robbie P and his four wickets - the first was Faf's catch, the second we'll give him as it climbed on Dhoni and he spooned it to Alviro, the third was very poor cricket from Jadeja and the fourth was, well, not out. Why we bother having a so-called specialist spinner occupy a spot in the XI is beyond me. Our spinners are crap, leave the job to J-P and fill the vacant spot with talent.

Posted by haq33 on (December 30, 2013, 21:52 GMT)

Hello Firdose. Your usage of metaphor has become so predictable......predictably awesome. In some ways, it is reminiscent of the Philander style of bowling, constant line and length for the most part, one peculiar sentence that drifts away slightly, making the reader think ahh she is straying off course here talking about flowers, and then BANG, right back into him with the next one and by the time he realises he has been done in by a superb metaphor it is already too late to resist. See, that was me trying to use metaphor too. Didn't really work I know.

Posted by Zak- on (December 30, 2013, 21:31 GMT)

McLaren would be a great player to try out now. I don't want to wish physical harm on Robbie P, but I can't see any other way for him to be dropped, and it would be best for everyone if he didn't play. 4 lucky wickets and a pressure-free half century mean that he will sadly be picked for more matches. It's a terrible, horrible, awful situation.

Posted by StaalBurgher on (December 30, 2013, 21:06 GMT)

I believe SA deserve the win BUT the Peterson wickets were fortunate. Two slogs gone awry and one bad umpiring lbw decision. Peterson is not a good decision. He does not add balance. The SA spin berth is still a huge problem.

Posted by   on (December 30, 2013, 20:44 GMT)

If Chris Morris keeps developing, this will be a non-issue in a year's time. He's certainly no Kallis, but he has the skills to fill a Shaun Pollock type role in the lower middle order (although he's not in the same class as a bowler). Considering Philander can also hold a bat, that would mean SA would have decent batting strength down to at least 8, and possibly even 9 if Robbie plays instead of Tahir. Plus Steyn has a habit of contributing valuable runs under pressure. There are other potential permutations as well - though Kallis is obviously a massive loss, AB's success as a keeper means SA won't suffer as much as people might think (and his understudy is Quinton de Kock... 'nough said).

Posted by AB_DeVilliers on (December 30, 2013, 20:35 GMT)

Think with Robbie P and Vernon, don't think SA need to replace Kallis with a batsmen. They'll be better off with a bowling all-rounder, so for me Mclaren should come in. My team against Oz would be: Smith Petersen Amla Duminy De Villiers Du Plessis Mclaren Peterson Philander Steyn Morkel. I prefer Duminy at number 4, time for him to step-up and prove his worth.

Posted by android_user on (December 30, 2013, 20:31 GMT)

This is a great team, I believe their decision to draw the first test was the right one because they believe that they will always win the series. I am looking forward to Australian series because that will be the true acid test of how long they can be number 1 in tests. This is a brilliant victory considering the conditions that were against them. Protea fire all the way.

Posted by gimme-a-greentop on (December 30, 2013, 19:29 GMT)

I imagine it would be Elgar in for Kallis, which still leaves the batting pretty strong but 3 quicks instead of 4 and an extra part time spinner. Unless they go for an extra pace bowler in Abbott, drop the spinner and play Elgar and Duminy as the spinners. But I thought Robbie P far surpassed all expectations, including my own. That carrom ball was tricksy, even if the LBW was sliding down. His reverse slog sweep for 6 was also epic.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Firdose MoondaClose
Related Links
Players/Officials: Graeme Smith
Series/Tournaments: India tour of South Africa
Tour Results
South Africa v India at Durban - Dec 26-30, 2013
South Africa won by 10 wickets
South Africa v India at Johannesburg - Dec 18-22, 2013
Match drawn
SAf Invit XI v Indians at Benoni - Dec 13-14, 2013
Match abandoned without a ball bowled
South Africa v India at Centurion - Dec 11, 2013
No result
South Africa v India at Durban - Dec 8, 2013
South Africa won by 134 runs
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days