Current cricket in focus
RSS RSS

Broad's edge: to walk or not to walk

Stuart Broad's controversial decision to stick to the umpire's 'not out' call when he had clearly edged the ball to slip in the first Ashes Test created quite the stir on the third day at Trent Bridge

Producer: Arya Yuyutsu

July 13, 2013

Posted by   on (July 14, 2013, 21:57 GMT)

There is barely an Aussie cricketer alive who has the moral right to insist that Broad should have walked. Even Gilchrist who was a walker appealed vociferously for balls that he doubted were out and left it in the hands of the umpire. There is no moral difference between standing for a fine nick and a cover drive to point. Broad is no more a cheat than either Clarke or Haddin were for standing in the second innings. In fact, arguably, Broad is the more honest. At least he admits he got away with one whereas Clarke insists he didn't know. Anyone who has played the game at a decent level will tell you that EVERY batsman knows when they have nicked a ball except in the most exceptional circumstances. Clarke had every right to stand as did Broad, but he should at least be honest about it.

Posted by   on (July 13, 2013, 9:32 GMT)

why cant we give 2 reviews to umpire to take a action what happen to board if its a hard one.

Posted by ODI_BestFormOfCricket on (July 13, 2013, 9:28 GMT)

Clarke has no moral right to ask broad to walk or to talk about spirit. Had he walket when he edged in first test against india last series against ashwin?

Comments have now been closed for this article


Play Video
Who is to blame for crisis in the West Indies?

Oct 20, 2014 ESPNCricinfo's Alexis Nunes talks with Simon Crosskill about the administrative crisis in the West Indies and looks at the possible consequences over the decision to abandon the tour of India (02:23)

Play Video
'SA have put meticulous planning for WC'

Oct 20, 2014 The only change South Africa have made ahead of the ODI series in New Zealand to an otherwise stable squad is Vernon Philander, says Firdose Moonda (01:07)


Play Video
Ronchi combats collapse with 99

Highlights: New Zealand wicketkeeper-batsman Luke Ronchi rescued New Zealand by scoring 99 from 83 balls, including a 74-run 10th-wicket stand with Trent Boult, to take his side to 230 against South Africa in the first ODI at Mount Maunganui. (01:42) | Oct 21, 2014

Play Video
Highlights: Ronchi's rearguard takes NZ to 230

Highlights: Action from the first innings of the first ODI between New Zealand and South Africa, in Mount Maunganui. (03:30) | Oct 21, 2014

Play Video
de Kock's leg-side screamer

Highlights: South Africa wicketkeeper Quinton de Kock dives to his left for a one-handed catch to dismiss New Zealand batsman Nathan McCullum during the 1st ODI in Mount Maunganui. (00:21) | Oct 21, 2014