Current cricket in focus
RSS RSS

Broad's edge: to walk or not to walk

Stuart Broad's controversial decision to stick to the umpire's 'not out' call when he had clearly edged the ball to slip in the first Ashes Test created quite the stir on the third day at Trent Bridge

Producer: Arya Yuyutsu

July 13, 2013

Posted by   on (July 14, 2013, 21:57 GMT)

There is barely an Aussie cricketer alive who has the moral right to insist that Broad should have walked. Even Gilchrist who was a walker appealed vociferously for balls that he doubted were out and left it in the hands of the umpire. There is no moral difference between standing for a fine nick and a cover drive to point. Broad is no more a cheat than either Clarke or Haddin were for standing in the second innings. In fact, arguably, Broad is the more honest. At least he admits he got away with one whereas Clarke insists he didn't know. Anyone who has played the game at a decent level will tell you that EVERY batsman knows when they have nicked a ball except in the most exceptional circumstances. Clarke had every right to stand as did Broad, but he should at least be honest about it.

Posted by   on (July 13, 2013, 9:32 GMT)

why cant we give 2 reviews to umpire to take a action what happen to board if its a hard one.

Posted by ODI_BestFormOfCricket on (July 13, 2013, 9:28 GMT)

Clarke has no moral right to ask broad to walk or to talk about spirit. Had he walket when he edged in first test against india last series against ashwin?

Comments have now been closed for this article


Play Video
Middle order tussle for Proteas

Oct 22, 2014 South Africa may look to shake up the middle order for the second ODI against New Zealand (01:33)

Play Video
Is the West Indies World Cup under threat?

Oct 22, 2014 ESPNcricinfo senior correspondent George Dobell on the scenarios the West Indies could face if the ICC gets involved in the dispute between the BCCI and WICB (02:34)


Play Video
Almost got our World Cup team right - Amla

Press Conference: Ahead of the second ODI against New Zealand, Hashim Amla says South Africa have an almost settled team leading into the World Cup (02:50) | Oct 23, 2014

Play Video
Up to me to shoulder more responsibility - Maddinson

Interviews: New South Wales batsman Nic Maddinson looks ahead to his team's clash against Queensland (01:25) | Oct 23, 2014

Play Audio
'It's up to the WICB to win the players over'

Bowl at Boycs: Geoffrey Boycott talks about the troubles in West Indian cricket, Steven Smith's recent catch against Pakistan, and fast bowling in India (20:18) | Oct 23, 2014