West Indies hit and miss

Mark Donaldson and Ricardo Powell discuss the tri-series in the Caribbean while Stuart Clark gives his thoughts on Australia's Ashes chances

Producer: Jenni Rutherford

July 10, 2013

Posted by   on (July 11, 2013, 12:31 GMT)

I propose that the West Indies Board organize domestic T20/ODI/Test Preliminaries among three teams comprising of the best three squads that the West Indies have to offer. You could use the recent tri-series format and choose ONLY the best performers to play for the West Indies for the ensuing year. They can use a quiet period in the annual calendar for that purpose. Such a proposition would make more sense to West Indies Cricket than the CPL, we already have an IPL. In addition, when guys are selected for the West Indies final squads they should be compensated on the basis of their performance in the various matches. Each player should be given a reasonable target of performance given the conditions and situation of the said match. Your pay would be based on how well you delivered on those targets. If you delivered 50% then you get 50% of your match fee, after fines have been deducted.

Posted by   on (July 11, 2013, 1:13 GMT)

lok here until such time the people who is running w i cricket start to select people who is prepare to represent the w/i the way others players on other teams does we have nowhere to go as a cricket team where is the discipline amongs this team players none whatsever but they r still getting to play for the w/i u have so many of them who cannot play for no other team other than the w/i sometimes it makes wonder if these players have any intelligence at all u combine the amount of matches they have played and to see how they performed as against other players in other teams it is time we ask ourself what is the purpose of still playing them at all they r an embarassment to the entire west indies nations the have no pride at all in themselves because they know that they will be paid at the end of the day shine 1 r 2 innings and fail for the rest of the series and it is ok to my mind the only player in that team that gives 100 percent is darren sammy the rest just dont care if we l

Posted by   on (July 10, 2013, 21:02 GMT)

But Retour the ODI has turned into T20 games because of rain.

Posted by johnathonjosephs on (July 10, 2013, 20:43 GMT)

There is nothing really wrong with the Top 5 of the West Indian Batting lineup, but the problem lies within the lower order. As good as Sammy/Pollard/Dwayne Bravo may be in T20, ODI cricket is a different breed and these players are not consistent. Thats why West Indies does well when a top order batsman does good (Gayle/Charles/Bravo), but when those 3 fail, the consistency is gone. Would love to see Chanderpaul back in the side

Posted by Retour on (July 10, 2013, 17:56 GMT)

IMO, one issue with WI in ODIs is that it is playing too many T20 type of players in the 11. I am a fan of Pollard but it is hard for me to see him in the ODI line up unless he can bowl 7-8 overs consistently as he is very inconsistent with his batting. WI needs to pick 2 out of Bravo Sr, Sammy and Pollard. And give the open position to either a specialist batsman or bowler depending up on playing conditions.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Play Video
Rayudu seizes his chance

Jul 30, 2013 A coming of age, the world's oldest sport tournament, and the 2015 World Cup schedule: all in this edition of our news magazine show (06:50)

Play Video
'Domingo will have to start from scratch' - Moonda

Jul 17, 2013 ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent Firdose Moonda discusses how Russell Domingo will approach his first assignment as head coach for South Africa. (02:32)

Play Video
'I will be aggressive as a captain' - Finch

Press Conference: Aaron Finch, Australia's T20 captain, talks about his plans for the side before the one-off T20 against Pakistan in Dubai on Sunday (02:56) | Oct 1, 2014

Play Video
'We were 15 or 20 runs light' - Flynn

Interviews: Northern Knights captain Daniel Flynn says the Barbados Tridents bowling unit did well to restrict his side in the Knights' six-wicket loss in Bangalore (00:32) | Sep 30, 2014

Play Video
'Our top five are 21 years old or younger' - Langer

Press Conference: Perth Scorchers coach Justin Langer speaks about his side's inexperience playing in the Champions League Twenty20 (00:47) | Sep 30, 2014