West Indies v England, 1st ODI, Antigua

Missing players hamper Giles' audition

England will interview for a new head coach in April, and by then Ashley Giles could have cemented his position as favourite or be struggling to keep his head above water

George Dobell in Antigua

February 27, 2014

Comments: 4 | Text size: A | A
England and West Indies desperate for momentum


Is this a job interview? Ashley Giles chats with Paul Downton, the managing director of England cricket, North Sound, February 27, 2014
Is this a job interview? Ashley Giles chats with Paul Downton, the managing director of England cricket © Getty Images
Enlarge

Like arriving for a job interview with blood on your suit and stains on your CV, Ashley Giles knows that England's recent form can hardly have helped his case to be the team's next head coach.

Giles, England's limited-overs coach since the start of 2013, has made it clear he would like to be in charge in all formats of the game, but goes into the ODI series against West Indies, starting in Antigua on Friday, knowing his side have lost six of their last eight ODIs and five of their last six T20 internationals. It is not a record that does his case any favours.

The final of the Champions Trophy seems long ago. Then, in June, England appeared to be pretty much on track for the World Cup in 2015 as a team missing the injured Kevin Pietersen and Graeme Swann went within an ace of winning their first global ODI tournament.

But instead of building for the World Cup, the foundations appear to have crumbled. Swann and Pietersen have gone, Jonathan Trott is absent and the results in Australia - England won one and lost seven limited-overs matches - inspire little confidence.

Perhaps it is unfair to judge Giles on such statistics. He had, after all, something close to a B team with which to work in Australia and, with Andy Flower hardly the sort to release the reins, has never enjoyed the opportunity to select or coach a side exactly the way he would have liked.

That has not changed entirely even now. With their eye, reasonably enough, on the larger prize - the World T20 starts in Bangladesh in just over two weeks - England have arrived in Antigua with a team of T20 specialists, missing several of their key ODI players. As a result, Giles is risking going into the business stages of the application for the England role with a record that could make it hard for the ECB to give him the job.

Underlining the inexperience of this England team is the fact that Tuesday's warm-up match represented Stuart Broad's first experience of captaincy in 50-over cricket at any level in his entire career. If Eoin Morgan is forced to miss Friday's game with a knee injury sustained in the field on Tuesday, England may have two debutants (Moeen Ali and Alex Hales) in the top five as well, with Ben Stokes and Chris Jordan little more experienced. Ravi Bopara, going into his 100th ODI, has suddenly emerged as a senior player.

Broad lauds Bopara's contribution

  • Ravi Bopara has finally found his perfect role in the side, according to England captain, Stuart Broad. Bopara will become just the 18th man to play 100 ODIs for England if he appears in Antigua on Friday and, batting at No. 7, has demonstrated the experience, the freedom and the range of strokes to emerge as a key figure in this side.
  • "Playing 100 ODIs is a fantastic achievement," Broad said. "He's put in some really strong performances throughout those but now he's at the stage where he has experience of both winning games for England but also being on the wrong side of games that can help him in the future.

  • "He's found a good role for himself in the middle order. He is our finisher and, in the Champions Trophy, he played a couple of innings, such as one against Sri Lanka at the Oval where he took 25 or 30 off the last over, where he can really go.

  • "Things like that can take the pressure off the top four a bit. At seven he can come out and play his way. We know he's got the big shots but he can also work it around. It's obviously a huge achievement but he's hungry for a lot more success."

There are a couple of areas for optimism for England. For a start, West Indies' own form is little better. They have won just three of their last nine ODIs against Test-playing opposition and they are missing several of their best players - notably Chris Gayle, Kieron Pollard and Kemar Roach - through injury.

England also possess, especially if Morgan is fit, an exciting middle order. The Morgan-Buttler-Bopara spine has proved an effective accelerator in recent times, building on foundations laid by the likes of Ian Bell, Alastair Cook and Trott.

That has always been a controversial tactic. While some believe England's policy of accumulation has been their greatest strength, others feel it has held them back. So in this series, England will explore the possibilities of a more aggressive approach at the start of their innings.

Instead of Cook and Bell, England will have Luke Wright and Hales to face the new ball. And instead of Trott, they will have Stokes at No. 3. It could give them the fast start they require to take pressure off the middle-order. Or it could see them 30 for 3 and expose the middle-order.

"There will be a bit of a shift on how we play in England," Broad revealed. "You look at that Champions Trophy when we had a lot of success through, not being defensive, but stacking it up at the back end.

"But when you play abroad, as was evident in Australia, you can't be 130 after 30, you've got to look to be more like 160 so you're not as reliant on people like Morgs and Buttler to get us up towards 300.

"So I think there's a bit of change in mind set to push our score a bit beyond 130 after the first 30 to take a bit of pressure off the guys at the end. We've got world-class players there but you can't expect them to do it every time. The players are pretty excited about executing that."

Death bowling is another area requiring improvement. With Broad sometimes making the somewhat surprising decision to bowl his full allocation of overs before the end and James Anderson missing, England were sometimes badly exposed in Australia with a surfeit of slower balls failing to mask the lack of yorkers.

"We've got strong areas we need to improve on in ODI cricket," Broad said. "I think our death bowling is somewhere where we need our skills to improve. Of course that comes with yorkers and our change-ups and that will also help us in Bangladesh. The pitches there can be pretty good to bat on so getting up in the hole is important. The bowlers have been having a good focus on their yorker bowling."

England's training session was again hit by rain on Thursday, but without causing any meaningful disruption. While the change from Flower's influence to Giles' is not always obvious, it has become apparent that, at long last, the England coaches are ensuring that bowlers are not allowed to bowl no-balls in the nets or training sessions.

In a professional sport where attention to detail is advocated in all things, it has long been an absurdity that England's bowlers over-stepped in training but then expected to hit exact lengths and avoid no-balls in match situations. It is a small detail, but an important one and may yet make the difference between a win and a loss over the next few weeks.

George Dobell is a senior correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: George Dobell

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by BailsRgo on (March 1, 2014, 10:00 GMT)

Giles is not worthy of being England coach. He is part of the current problem not its solution. he has no experience of coaching other than over recent ODi/T20 matches. he is totally out of his depth even there!!!! Get Rid

Posted by Rally_Windies on (February 28, 2014, 17:34 GMT)

which missing players? hampered his audition ?

Roach, Pollard, Samuels and Gayle are missing ....

If anything the missing players have given him an easy 1st outing ~!

Posted by   on (February 28, 2014, 11:43 GMT)

That's not really true about Buttler, Benjamin. Here are his significant recent scores in his last eight innings (all v Australia), batting at number seven in a mostly losing England team:

75 from 65 balls out of 227; 65* from 48 out of 231; 42 from 37 out of 249; 34* from 24 out of 269; 49 from 36 out of 300; 71 from 43 out of 316.

That's six innings out of the last eight in which he's accelerated the innings under pressure. Nobody's saying he's a middle order Test batsman yet, but his improved one day batting and wicket keeping make him one of the only players in this side who undoubtedly deserves an improving reputation.

Posted by   on (February 27, 2014, 22:54 GMT)

The Morgan, Buttler, Bopara spine has not proved a effective accelerator in recent times. In fact in Australia there wasn't a single occasion when all three fired at once. In fact Morgan fired a couple of times, and Bopara once. Buttler, easily the most overrated English batsman since John Crawley has done made very few scores of any significance in recent matches. England may beat a poorly performing and injury-hit Windies side, but they still haven't got a hope in next year's World Cup.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
George DobellClose
Tour Results
West Indies v England at Bridgetown - Mar 13, 2014
England won by 5 runs
West Indies v England at Bridgetown - Mar 11, 2014
West Indies won by 5 wickets (with 7 balls remaining)
West Indies v England at Bridgetown - Mar 9, 2014
West Indies won by 27 runs
West Indies v England at North Sound - Mar 5, 2014
England won by 25 runs
West Indies v England at North Sound - Mar 2, 2014
England won by 3 wickets (with 31 balls remaining)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days