West Indies v England, 3rd ODI, Antigua

Spectators deserve a better pitch

The pitch in Antigua, which will be used for the third time, is doing the spectator few favours but all the players can do is take their chance. Ravi Bopara did that two days ago, winning a game he may not have done in the past

George Dobell in Antigua

March 4, 2014

Comments: 13 | Text size: A | A
Young guns need to step up for WI and England

Ravi Bopara bowls in training, North Sound, March 4, 2014
Ravi Bopara has not been needed much with the ball so far on surfaces where spin has dominated © Getty Images

Cricket's governing bodies are a curious bunch. Try to take a soft drink into a game in many places and you can be refused entry; wear a branded top in some places and you face the prospect of being accused of ambush marketing. During the 2007 World Cup, a fellow had his lunch taken from him because the baguette he carried was deemed to be a weapon.

But when it comes to the really important thing - the product that is the game of cricket - they, at best, do nothing.

Dull pitches represent a greater threat to the future of the game than drugs, spot-fixing, ambush marketing or websites seeking to celebrate and propagate cricket. Dull pitches will result in dull matches that risk losing the interest of spectators and failing to attract the next generation of supporters. And that was, of course, the original point of limited-overs cricket.

So it should come as a disappointment to learn that West Indies and England will contest the deciding ODI of their series in Antigua on the same begrudging surface that hosted the first two games. The same surface that yielded just nine fours in West Indies' innings in the second ODI. The same surface where part-time spinners have proved so effective in stifling the scoring. The same surface where where strokeplay and pace are punished and where patience and accumulation are rewarded. Where anti-cricket thrives. ODI cricket was not meant to be this way.

It is no coincidence and should be no surprise that attendances have declined in the Caribbean since such pitches became the norm. This ground has only been filled once. And that was when Kenny Rogers took his love to town.

There is, in this case at least, some mitigation. The conditions here are expected to be similar to those in Bangladesh where, in a couple of weeks, these two sides will be starting their World T20 campaign. But it is a shame that spectators have been asked to sit through - and pay for - a training session in desultory cricket.

That is not to say that both this sides are not desperate to win. They are like two old heavyweights slugging it out on the undercard; battling not so much for glory as to sustain an ebbing career. They craze confidence and momentum after chastening months and, quite rightly, see each other as opposition ripe for the taking. This has not been a high-quality series.

But both sides could be strengthened for this game. Marlon Samuels is not 100% but will be considered for selection by West Indies in the place of the horribly out of sorts Kirk Edwards, while Alex Hales and Eoin Morgan have now trained for three days in succession and are close to a return. Luke Wright looks most vulnerable. In a series typified by weak batting, all three would be welcome.

One man who can already take some confidence from this series is Ravi Bopara. His match-winning partnership with Stuart Broad in the second game might not, in the grand scheme of things, be remembered as one of the great innings - he scored 38 in 59 balls, after all - but in the context of his England career, it might prove quietly significant.

Must give Narine more runs - Dwayne Bravo

  • Dwyane Bravo has appealed to his batsmen to give Sunil Narine a chance to win games for West Indies. In Narine, West Indies believe they have the best spin bowler in the world, but the team's top-order batting has sometimes asked too much of him.
  • "Narine is a bowler that most teams struggle to play," Bravo said. "Not only England. Even India and Sri Lanka. They all struggle.

  • "He's a handful, and we're happy to have him in our squad. But at the same time, we can't leave it all up to him. It's a total team effort.

  • "If we don't have enough runs, then Narine is no value. We need to have runs on the board to give him the opportunity to deliver for us. We definitely need to bat better. If we can put a better total on the board, we can make a better game of it.

  • "England bowling spin at the start of our innings caught us by surprise. We were not able to counter-act it, or come up with a gameplan against it.

  • "We know England are going to do it again. So our batters need to give themselves the opportunity to be themselves, be flamboyant, play fearless and put England under some pressure. We have very good lower-order batting, but it's the start that has given us the problem."

As things stand, the defining moment of Bopara's career is the Champions Trophy final. With England on course for victory - they required 20 to win from 14 balls - Bopara, the last experienced batsman, pulled a long-hop from Ishant Sharma to square-leg. England lost by five runs and their long wait for that first global ODI trophy remains. It is a memory that might bother the whole team for the rest of their lives.

It is an uncomfortably accurate summation of Bopara's career, too, which has to date promised rather more than it has delivered. And certainly the memory of it bothers Bopara.

"We came so close in the Champions Trophy," he said. "We had a chance to win a global competition. That would have been amazing for the team. For all of us, really. Not winning was heartbreaking. It's right up there with the worst disappointment I've had.

"When you're out there, you don't think back. You don't think 'this is what happened in the Champions Trophy'. You just play the situation. You play the ball. But every now and then I'll be sitting watching TV and I'll think about the Champions Trophy final and think 'maybe I could have done this or that'."

He appears to have learned from the experience.

"When we needed three to win the other day, Darren Sammy came on as the top bowlers had bowled out," Bopara said. "He bowled me a short ball and I took the single and got up the other end, looked at square leg and thought 'You know what, I could easily have hit that straight at him.' If I'd just pulled it, it would have felt nice coming straight out of the middle of the bat, you think, alright that's going for four, but it goes straight to the bloke. That could easily have happened again.

Such episodes bode well for England. If Bopara, who says he has "never been more hungry" to return to Test cricket, can find the composure to complement his talent, he could yet win many games for England. Perhaps in all formats.

"I feel stronger and tougher," he said. "I don't question myself as much as I used to. I went through that that period when things weren't right with my life and I took my eye off the ball. I had a lot of time to think about what I want to do and why I'm here and why I started playing cricket. I realised that the most important thing in my life apart from my family is cricket. Finishing my career saying I've played 13 Tests and 100 ODIs; that doesn't satisfy me."

Winning this ODI series may not satisfy these teams, either. But it will provide something of a foundation stone at the start of a long rebuilding process.

George Dobell is a senior correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: George Dobell

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by SirViv1973 on (March 5, 2014, 18:00 GMT)

In the hey days of the WI most surfaces in the region provided plenty of pace & bounce. There were one or 2 exceptions notably the old rec at Antigua which was often pretty flat. However WI were criticized back then for producing pitches which were 2 much in favor of fast bowling. I didn't go along with that it was the WI attack that was generally too good for the opposition batsman & they proved this by the amount of series they won away from home. Since the demise of WI cricket there seems to have been a sea change in surfaces played on. As WI have produced fewer fast bowlers, pitches have got slower & slower. It's sad when you see such small crowds at games these days. If the pitches could be be quickened up i'm sure it would make for more exciting cricket & it may get fans back in the grounds. It may also help with the search for quality tall fast bowlers, something WI used to have in a abundance but something which has now been missing from the game for well over a decade.

Posted by   on (March 5, 2014, 11:25 GMT)

My issue with the pitch is not so much that it spins but that it offers such a lot to poor quality spin like Joe Root. England are better off bowling him than a specialist pace bowler. Spectators are not seeing proper bowlers trying to get out proper batmen they are see players who barely bowl in domestic cricket. International Cricket should be the best Vs the best, but England already ruined that by sending a very odd squad

These sort of pitches have there place as I wouldn't want to see 350 plays 340 every game but to play three in a row.

Posted by Nutcutlet on (March 5, 2014, 10:26 GMT)

I'll put my hand up, Cpt Meanster, but it's up to you as to whether you think my definition of a fair pitch shows 'an ounce of common sense' (I'd prefer to be showing an ounce of unbiassed cricketing appreciation, btw). A fair pitch is straw-coloured at the outset, perhaps with the merest hint of green. In session 1, the swing and seam bowlers can get a little movement through the air & off the pitch and keep the opposing top order honest - testing their skill against the moving ball; as the first day wears on, the green tinge disappears; the batsmen are able to increase the rate of scoring as the bowling is easier to play. The ball should come on to the bat and there should be a decent amount of lift possible for the quicks that put their backs into their work. Days 2 & 3 are the best for batting. Some time on day four spinners start to get some quick turn & reverse swing is also possible on the dry pitch. Dusting up on the last day creates more opps for spin. Fair: all skills tested!

Posted by jackiethepen on (March 5, 2014, 10:24 GMT)

What is a decent pitch? Wouldn't spin bowlers say that this is a decent pitch? Different batting skills are needed than batting on pitches that suit batsmen playing strokes and getting boundaries. Wouldn't it make for dull cricket to have the same sort of game on every pitch curated to so-called "entertain" the crowd - isn't struggle itself exciting? The phrase "low-scoring thriller" can apply to t20 as well as ODs - and ironically given the discussion - was used a number of times in the Big Bash. We don't want a lessening of skills, but more variety so that batsmen can cope on any pitch they encounter. That is surely a truer test than just performing on very good batting pitches. It's all part of this mantra approach to cricket - you play a certain kind of cricket on all surfaces - instead of that art form of Reading the Game. I thought Lumb showed he was a cut above the other batsmen. He challenged the fashion for saying we always need to attack - he sensibly rotated the strike.

Posted by Matt.au on (March 5, 2014, 6:16 GMT)

Posted by riverlime on It takes money-lots of it- to replace pitches. WICB has none.

Perhaps it's time the WICB pondered the fact they have no money. They have been around a long, long time.

WICB needs to take a very good look at themselves, their surroundings, their supporters (or lack there of), their sponsors (or lack there of) and do something, anything to start to get some sort of cash flow.

Perhaps they could enlist the many superstars of yesteryear that are still largely loved and respected. If the legends are used right they may be able to encourage youngsters to take up the game and in turn get their parents to take them to WI games.

Get the legends to the schools, to cricket training, on posters and T.V advertisements. Not just an ad here or there, saturate the airwaves.

The legends may well be repaid at a later date if player numbers go up as elite coaches, managers etc may be needed.

Boosting crowds at cricket games will boost cash flow and encourage sponsors.

Posted by Cpt.Meanster on (March 5, 2014, 2:57 GMT)

Can somebody with an ounce of common sense define to me what a 'fair' pitch is ? Cause, I am sick and tired of these same old stories surfacing up whenever England or any other non-Asian team plays. These teams make it a BIG deal about slow pitches because they know they ain't good enough to play on them. Not every geographical conditions around the world allows for pitches with green grass, pace and bounce. A good cricket team MUST win in all conditions. Otherwise, don't even bother convincing me. England are anything but a good team and the same can be said about most non-Asian teams. Live with it dear England. Caribbean pitches ain't getting quick any time soon. Besides, I love slow pitches and I think they test batsmen more than any other pitch type because of the self-generated pace the batsmen have to create in order to execute shots.

Posted by   on (March 4, 2014, 23:49 GMT)

Shouldn't moved away from the Recreation Ground. This new stadium is a shambles. Awful outfield, awful wickets, awful atmosphere

Posted by   on (March 4, 2014, 21:24 GMT)

Ravi really is England's answer to Watto! Perhaps with a decent run at it and an injury free run he could make it in all 3 formats, hard to say but I think England needs his experience right now.

Posted by FRpunk on (March 4, 2014, 20:54 GMT)

Absolutely agree . i think its about time Cricket Authorities show a little bit more Respect to the fans . Without us This Game won`t be the Same . I have been to the Eden Gardens a Few times and basically u can`t Carry anything apart from your Cell Phone there but its Understandable because there have been some instances of the crowd being rowdy and disrupting a match .

The Pitches are the Key to Entertainment . I want Bowler Friendly Pitches for Test Matches and Flat Tracks for the Limited overs Cricket . it Does`nt matters if Its a Green Top or a Rank Turner but as long as it is Producing Results its Great . Indian Pitches are Crticized the most but in the Last 10 Test matches in india has produced 9 Results which is great for Test Cricket .

Slow and Low Pitches are the most boring pitches . Where the Bowl neither Swings nor comes on to the Bat Nicely , Its Just Boring .

Posted by riverlime on (March 4, 2014, 20:27 GMT)

It takes money-lots of it- to replace pitches. WICB has none. So who will bell the cat?

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
George DobellClose
Related Links
Tour Results
West Indies v England at Bridgetown - Mar 13, 2014
England won by 5 runs
West Indies v England at Bridgetown - Mar 11, 2014
West Indies won by 5 wickets (with 7 balls remaining)
West Indies v England at Bridgetown - Mar 9, 2014
West Indies won by 27 runs
West Indies v England at North Sound - Mar 5, 2014
England won by 25 runs
West Indies v England at North Sound - Mar 2, 2014
England won by 3 wickets (with 31 balls remaining)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days