West Indies v India, 3rd Test, Dominica, 5th day July 10, 2011

Gutsy Chanderpaul denies India


West Indies 204 (Baugh 60, Bravo 50, Ishant 5-77) and 322 (Chanderpaul 116, K Edwards 110, Harbhajan 4-75) drew with India 347 (Dhoni 74, Abhinav 62, F Edwards 5-103) and 94 for 3 (Vijay 45, Dravid 34*)
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

India will have to wait until 2016 to win more than one Test in a series in the Caribbean - a feat they've never achieved and were denied this time due to a resistance led by their West Indian tormentor-in-chief Shivnarine Chanderpaul. He grafted his way to a 23rd Test century and was supported by Fidel Edwards in a decisive 37-over grind that made India rue their lack of effectiveness with the ball.

Even though Chanderpaul's partners failed to match his patience and eventually conceded their wickets to set a target of 180 in 47 overs, timely breakthroughs in the chase meant India's priorities switched from forcing a win to securing their 1-0 lead. A day that began with the visitors in complete control, ended with West Indies achieving parity thanks, fittingly, to a batsman who became their most-capped Test player in this match.

India's late inroads on the fourth day, the fortuitous wicket of Darren Sammy - caught at short leg off a deflection from his chest - on the fifth morning and the subsequent run-out of Ravi Rampaul boosted their chances of wrapping up the game quickly. But Chanderpaul blocked out one end completely. He saw off the seamers with ease, driving and clipping them away for runs early and displaying solid defence and farming the strike when Edwards joined him. Unshakeable at one end, he forced the Indian bowlers to turn their focus completely towards Edwards, whose vigil guided Chanderpaul through to another landmark.

Chanderpaul had been dropped on 25 by Rahul Dravid on the fourth day and offered another chance in his 90s - a brief phase where was troubled by the turn and Harbhajan Singh's round-the-wicket line. He edged Harbhajan a couple of times past slip, once very narrowly past Dravid but reached his century with a tickle off Ishant Sharma and celebrated with a ritual kiss to the Windsor Park surface, much to the joy of a raucous Sunday crowd in the venue's first ever Test.

India's seamers shone for much of the series, including the first innings where they kept probing away, but they faltered today in good batting conditions. They didn't vary their lengths, and bowled too short: Ishant had the better of Sammy thrice in this series by pitching the ball on a length, but rarely did that today; instead, in his very first over, he was slashed for two boundaries. Munaf Patel roughed up Edwards early in his innings, whacking him on the ear when he missed a hook, but the bowlers repeated the dose too often after the batsman had learnt his lesson. Spin was India's hope, with the ball spitting on the odd occasion and though it yielded success, it came long after India desired it.

While Chanderpaul weathered most of the bowling, Edwards, who arrived with the lead just 113, showed he was adept at handling the short-ball barrage, knocking them down off the back foot, swaying out of the way quickly and showing the full face to both the seamers and Harbhajan when they bowled fuller. When Praveen Kumar found a bit of reverse, he drove him through the line after getting to the pitch, and negotiated the turn and bounce despite a cluster of close-in fielders on the leg side. He offered India hope, however, with some needless extravagance. He smashed a slower one from Ishant over mid-off and swung another over midwicket. Having got away on a couple of occasions, he was third time unlucky when Suresh Raina forced another loose shot to mid-off. Devendra Bishoo edged a catch to slip shortly after, leaving Chanderpaul stranded when he'd have been hoping to frustrate India further.

Edwards' performance did fire him up however, and he bowled with fierce pace, and got dangerous swing with the new ball. Abhinav Mukund was trapped in front first ball, playing across the line and Dravid was unsettled by some scorchers that he erred by playing at. He survived a stormy first spell with M Vijay, who put India on course with fluent batting in conditions that considerably eased out after tea.

Singles were easy to come by, and the bad balls were comfortably dispatched. Vijay took Sammy for a couple of boundaries, including one that was off his favourite swing over midwicket, while Dravid punished Bishoo's half-tracker first up, prompting the bowler to switch to a round-the-wicket line outside leg stump. That had an effect on Vijay, who, after playing out five such deliveries in an over, felt the urge to employ a cross-batted heave off Ravi Rampaul's first ball of a new spell. He miscued it to mid-on, but the chase was still on with Raina promoted up the order. Though he infused the innings with some urgency, running smartly between the wickets, his stay, and India's hopes of a successful chase, ended when he scooped a catch back to Rampaul. The captains ended the game at the first opportunity just before the mandatory 15 overs began.

In the end, MS Dhoni was satisfied with a 1-0 result, but could India have rounded off with a stronger statement of intent ahead of a tougher assignment in England? For West Indies, too, this was a satisfactory end. The start of the season was marred by the spat between senior players, including Chris Gayle, and the board. But a Test win over Pakistan led by their under-pressure captain Sammy, two draws against India secured from positions of weakness, the rise of Rampaul, the successful return of Edwards, the impressive debut of Kirk Edwards and Chanderpaul's evergreen reliability were all welcome results.

Siddhartha Talya is a sub editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Mohamed on July 12, 2011, 11:03 GMT

    @m_ilind: "Dravid as usual, was intent on drawing the match" - i don't think he was in the intention to draw it until Raina left and Laxman came and informed the decision of Dhoni. Have u watched the match? Have u noted the way Dravid played along with Vijay (after their intial struggle)? Have u seen how he handled Bishoo and forced him to move to Around the side to bowl? and of course, have u watched the close-in fielders (on both sides of him) got hit by him and forced them back to move away to stop him? - Do u think all this is for a Draw. i don't think so.

    Also - "he dropped a sitter of Chanderpaul early on" - Its part of the game, for ex: If Sammy had taken Dravid on second inn. of First test, we won't even a lead of 1-0. And 11th wicket's (Bishoo) tough catch has been caught by Dravid on this match, otherwise it wouldn't have even finished at that stage (who knows they would have put on another 50 partnership) - Stop false encountering a Legend.

  • Mohsin on July 12, 2011, 1:34 GMT

    Does anyone know about indias bowling overrate in 3rd test?Dhoni was at the brink of being dropped on that basis in his next test. Secondly, this series reiterated the importance of udrs and its use in eyery test and odi. Even the umpire who replaced harper made mistakes and proved that dhoni and bcci s call for improvement of umpiring standards was the height of stupidity. Umpires are humans.

  • rashid on July 11, 2011, 21:33 GMT

    Same pitches, more or less same weather conditions and same opponent... Pak Vs WI: Test - Pak won 1 out of 2. ODI - Pak won 3 out of 5. Ind Vs WI: Test - Ind won 1 out of 3. ODI - Ind won 3 out of 5. Who is BETTER......

  • Milind on July 11, 2011, 20:27 GMT

    Had Vijay hung around longer, the match could have been interesting as he was showing positive intent. Dravid as usual, was intent on drawing the match. Moreover, he dropped a sitter of Chanderpaul early on, else the result could have been different. This spoilt all the good work put in by the team in the previous four days. Atleast, they are not blaming the weather this time!

  • Dummy4 on July 11, 2011, 18:43 GMT

    remove fletcher and dhoni if india want to be force again.not chasing the total does not justify India to be ranked number 1

  • Dummy4 on July 11, 2011, 18:32 GMT

    I do not know why India did not go for win or made an attempt at all. In this era of 20 20 not chasing 180 in 47 overs surprises me a lot. I am following Cricket from late 1970's.Three matches involving India against Pak and WI immediately comes into my mind. India was at the receiving end on all three matches. At Karachi Pakistan chased India's target of 165 in 33 overs in the last session of Match when everyone thought India will save the match without any fuss. In 1983 at Jamaica, when match was heading for draw, Andy Roberts cleaned up last 3 wkts of India in no time before tea.WI chased down the target of around 175 successfully in just 26/27 Overs through some lasty hitting from King Richards and everyone was hitting 6s with ease.On thinking about those matches, I cannot able to digest the way India gave up the chase so easily.It is not worth being no.1 without ominating your opponent.Dhoni is too defensive. There is no need to play 3 tests or 4 or 5 tests if you are not wish 2

  • Valavan on July 11, 2011, 16:38 GMT

    @flyingmachine, seems you ate more sour grapes, WICB or ICC never forced India to send 2nd strength team. BTW WI is ranked 7 and they were also dented by absence of Bravo,Taylor and Gayle. SO NO MORE ARGUMENTS. JUST INDIA is NOT WINDIES of 80s or OZ of 2000s. VERY VERY SIMPLE

  • Nikhil on July 11, 2011, 16:13 GMT

    Like every captain specifically, in India has a shelf life, seems this will trigger Dhoni's downtrend. It started with the 2007 20-20 win, consolidated for nxt 3 yrs with fresh emphatic wins & peaked with the WC win, he thinks that he can get away with the public/selectors, but this overconfidence will surely bring him back to earth, incase you lose in England. Already there must be a few heartburns appearing in the dressing room, on his over reliance on Raina, even though he does not disappoint. It seems so obvious now, need a bowling change, u see Raina! ( even though Kohli, etc have shown that they can also chance their decently), batting accleration - you see Raina! mid pitch discussions- Raina!...Lol...

  • Mathan on July 11, 2011, 15:54 GMT

    My wait for a ruthless, hungry indian team continues...It is not the first time team India has shyed away from modest challenge. It has happened under the helm of Azhar, Sachin, Dravid and Ganguly. Now it continues under Dhoni.

  • Manoj on July 11, 2011, 15:26 GMT

    Also consider that without rain, the score would be 3-0 in India's favour. Why risk a game which has been already delayed by rain. No need for heroics. Manoj

  • No featured comments at the moment.