Zimbabwe v Pakistan, 2nd Test, Harare September 9, 2013

Zimbabwe's last chance to convert promise

  shares 14

Match facts

September 10-14, 2013
Start time 1000 local (0800 GMT)

Big Picture

In March this year, Zimbabwe arrived in the West Indies absolutely undercooked. Their only internationals in the previous 12 months: two Twenty20s in Hambantota. The two Tests in Barbados and Dominica lasted five days in all. They barely avoided losing by an innings in the first, but succumbed to the ignominy in the second.

Six months later, in what has been a hectic year compared to the famine of 2012, they took a sizeable first-innings lead against Pakistan, and had them effectively 91 for 5 in the second. Then Younis Khan decided to restore order, and Zimbabwe went through one of their capitulations in the fourth innings. The first Test in Harare will become another addition to the long list of heavy Zimbabwe defeats, completely obfuscating their dominance over the initial three days. The scorecard of the Barbados Test says West Indies won by nine wickets but a closer look reveals Zimbabwe had a chance of taking the lead then too, having reduced the hosts to 151 for 6 in response to 211.

With utmost justification, Zimbabwe keep clamouring for more cricket. Amid a crippling monetary crisis, they have managed to squeeze in six Tests, 14 ODIs and six T20s this year. The numbers would have been higher had the shortage of funds not caused the postponement of Sri Lanka's visit. While there was the embarrassment of a 0-5 defeat against a second-string India side, there was also the ODI win over Pakistan, followed by the unexpectedly competitive performance in the first Test.

It is a hopeless situation to be in. Very few tours to high-ranked nations because they do not see much value in playing you. Few incoming trips because your board does not have the money to arrange more. How do you improve? A glance at the FTP provides little hope in the near future. The second Test against Pakistan will be Zimbabwe's last international match before the World Twenty20 in March. Can they make a final, bigger statement of promise?

It will not be easy. Pakistan were playing their first Test in more than six months last week. Misbah-ul-Haq warned after the game that his team could not afford to start slowly repeatedly. Complacency, if there was any among the new arrivals for the Tests, will not be there this time.

Form guide

Pakistan WLLLD (last five matches, most recent first)
Zimbabwe LLWLL

Watch out for

Zimbabwe lost 15 wickets to Saeed Ajmal and Abdur Rehman in the first Test. Their batsmen are not accustomed to facing high-quality spinners, and there is no shame in failing to tackle Ajmal when better sides have struggled to. But before this series, Zimbabwe were confounded by Amit Mishra. In West Indies, they lost 29 of 40 wickets to Shane Shillingford and Marlon Samuels.

It is only going to get tougher. The Harare square has taken such a battering this season there are concerns over how the pitch will behave, with Hamilton Masakadza expecting a lot more help for spin. Although it has been kept covered to try and retain whatever moisture there is, less than three days is hardly any time to prepare a Test surface, let alone on a ground which has seen so much cricket in recent months. Junaid Khan and Co can be counted on, but again, the real test for the Zimbabwe batsmen will be the Pakistan spinners.

Mohammad Hafeez averages 8.00 with the bat in Tests, all outside Asia, this year. He had two productive years after almost a decade of disappointment but questions are now being asked whether he fits in as opener in a format where he is not needed too much as a bowler. He remains important in limited-overs but he'll be 33 in October, and even if persisted with for a while, is certainly not a long-term option. Which also means he will have to come good quickly, and often.

Team news

The one change Pakistan could make is to bring in the quicker Wahab Riaz in place of Rahat Ali, who took 1 for 105 in the first Test. Mohammad Hafeez ran gingerly between the wickets last week, after straining his hamstring in the third ODI. However, Misbah has claimed that Pakistan's T20 captain is fit.

Pakistan (probable) 1 Mohammad Hafeez, 2 Khurram Manzoor, 3 Azhar Ali, 4 Younis Khan, 5 Misbah-ul-Haq (capt), 6 Asad Shafiq, 7 Adnan Akmal (wk), 8 Wahab Riaz/Rahat Ali, 9 Saeed Ajmal, 10 Junaid Khan, 11 Abdur Rehman

Brendan Taylor will return to lead Zimbabwe after missing the first Test to be with his fiancee and newborn son but has said he will not keep wicket. It is not often that Zimbabwe have to fret over who to leave out. Sikandar Raza was handed a Test debut after Taylor decided to sit out last week, and looks the most likely candidate to be omitted, although that is no justice for a man who made 60 and 24.

Zimbabwe will decide in the morning whether to play a second spinner. If they do, it will mean a Test debut for young legspinner Natsai M'shangwe but they will have a hard time deciding which fast bowler to leave out, as all performed manfully in the first Test. In fact, they carried such a heavy workload - 161.1 overs - that Hamilton Masakadza joked they needed "bed rest and maybe a drip". Brian Vitori could be called upon if one of them fails to recover.

Zimbabwe (probable) 1 Vusi Sibanda, 2 Tino Mawoyo, 3 Hamilton Masakadza, 4 Brendan Taylor (capt), 5 Malcolm Waller, 6 Elton Chigumbura, 7 Richmond Mutumbami (wk), 8 Prosper Utseya, 9,10 & 11 Three out of Tinashe Panyangara/Shingi Masakadza/Tendai Chatara/Natsai M'shangwe/Brian Vitori

Stats and trivia

  • Younis Khan is 48 short of becoming the fourth Pakistan batsman to reach 7000 Test runs, after Javed Miandad, Inzamam-ul-Haq and Mohammad Yousuf
  • This will be the 12th international game this year at Harare Sports Club, easily the most matches at a ground

Quotes

"We can learn from their mental awareness and the way they switched on and off at different times in the game. We were on top of them for three-and-half days but their two best performers made it tough for us. If we can just switch on at the right times, we could do better."
Brendan Taylor on what Zimbabwe can pick up from Pakistan

Abhishek Purohit is a sub-editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 15:20 GMT

    " The second Test against Pakistan will be Zimbabwe's last international match before the World Twenty20 in March." - This is really disappointing. No International Match Until next 5-6 months. If Zimbabwe are not given opportunities to play competitive cricket, how will they keep on improving. In this series, Zimbabwe have shown some glimpses of talent and skill in some players, but that skill needs to be honed, that won't happen until they a play a decent amount of international cricket. Players like S. Raza, M. Waller, T. Payangara, B. Vitori, T. Chatara have given quite impressive performance. Someone should do something for Zimbabwe Cricket.

  • POSTED BY android_user on | September 10, 2013, 6:42 GMT

    agreed with sudeep sarkar..

  • POSTED BY TeamSelector on | September 9, 2013, 23:07 GMT

    Hafeez & Rahat should be 'rested' & replaced by Faisal & Adil. Hafeez's bowling is not needed as Rehman is playing & Younis could be the fifth bowler if needed. Although Rahat did score some runs, his main job is as a bowler. Have Azhar open. 1-Manzoor 2-Azhar 3-Younis 4-Faisal 5-Misbah 6-Shafiq 7-Akmal 8-Rehman 9-Ajmal 10-Adil 11-Junaid

  • POSTED BY Chaudry_Cricket on | September 9, 2013, 22:18 GMT

    If anyone deserves a drop then it is 'NOTHING WRONG WITH MY TECHNIQUE' Hafeez, he failed to score and he did not contribute with the ball, he is a ordinary fielder drops dollies in slips at times. But Misbah and Whatmore have deemed him as the SAVIOUR of Pakistan cricket. I just fail to understand why he is undroppable. We have players who perform the same roles as him and are better than him (Sohaib Maqsood, Mohammad Nawaz etc) with consistant chances will be a better end product than Hafeez. But team managment believe Hafeez is the greatest player to grace the cricket world.

    Rahat deserves another go (see potential in him). We have to give him consistant chances for a while to see what he can do. I admit he was rubbish in the first test but he is young and with the right guidance and consistant chances he might prove to be a good bowler.

    My 11 would be: Shaan, Khurram, Azhar, Younis, Misbah, Asad, Adnan, Junaid, Rahat, Ajmal and Rehman.

  • POSTED BY abmughal on | September 9, 2013, 21:26 GMT

    y not PCB invite zim for short tour before WT20 in available window ?????

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 19:42 GMT

    The FTP's coming up short here, Zim deserve more games. I can understand the top echelon of Test nations see there's nothing in it for them, but is there no ICC funding to arrange tours against top associates? A few first class matches against Ireland, Scotland and the Netherlands would serve to help bring them on against decent sides

  • POSTED BY ammar7may on | September 9, 2013, 18:18 GMT

    South Africa and Australia gave citizenship to Pakistani spinners to get used to it. Zimbabwe have to do the same. They already have Sikander Raza. Haha...

  • POSTED BY sudeep_sarkar on | September 9, 2013, 18:03 GMT

    I personally think ICC should come in front and help Zim crisis.We are going to loose one good upcoming team very soon.What a a shame...Really feeling very sad and bad.Miss you Zim...All the best.. Sudeep Sarkar

  • POSTED BY Desihungama on | September 9, 2013, 17:58 GMT

    Wahab Riaz? Really? I thought this guy was done and dusted. Just what could he do to prove? I mean if PCB has an iota of far sightedness, would have gone with Ehsan Adil, Zia-ul-Haq. Any sane team would gradually ease their players into Test by playing them into shorter formats for longer period. (exactly how India and done and now reaping rewards) but not here. Rahat, Ehsan were all inserted into Test without being tested in shorter formats. Look at Rahat, he is no where close to a Test bowler. Is PCB charging these young lads to hand over a Test cap?

  • POSTED BY ZCFOutkast on | September 9, 2013, 17:43 GMT

    Only results count I'm afraid. Australia dominated Proteas with bat and ball for 13 out of 14 days and they lost the series. One would argue they dominated the Ashes with ball in hand, but like Zimbabwe their batting came up short.

    Both WI&Zim were rusty when we toured judging by the batting of Darren Bravo&Chanderpaul(who was not part of LOIs squads). Looking at the quality of the batting on display, I wouldn't say they were much better than Zim as a team. The difference was obviously Cremer's horible bowling, all the more reason why he should be nowhere near the team, and of course Shillingford bowled like a man possessed! WI should never have scored more than 250 at any point. Unfortunately Jarvis had a habit of fetching which severely negated his wickets, and the team felt it even more when he fetched but took few wickets.

    In all we've done as well as possible. We need to bat first&play for time to get a draw. Unfortunately Trevor "Misbah" Gripper's playing club cricket instead!

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 15:20 GMT

    " The second Test against Pakistan will be Zimbabwe's last international match before the World Twenty20 in March." - This is really disappointing. No International Match Until next 5-6 months. If Zimbabwe are not given opportunities to play competitive cricket, how will they keep on improving. In this series, Zimbabwe have shown some glimpses of talent and skill in some players, but that skill needs to be honed, that won't happen until they a play a decent amount of international cricket. Players like S. Raza, M. Waller, T. Payangara, B. Vitori, T. Chatara have given quite impressive performance. Someone should do something for Zimbabwe Cricket.

  • POSTED BY android_user on | September 10, 2013, 6:42 GMT

    agreed with sudeep sarkar..

  • POSTED BY TeamSelector on | September 9, 2013, 23:07 GMT

    Hafeez & Rahat should be 'rested' & replaced by Faisal & Adil. Hafeez's bowling is not needed as Rehman is playing & Younis could be the fifth bowler if needed. Although Rahat did score some runs, his main job is as a bowler. Have Azhar open. 1-Manzoor 2-Azhar 3-Younis 4-Faisal 5-Misbah 6-Shafiq 7-Akmal 8-Rehman 9-Ajmal 10-Adil 11-Junaid

  • POSTED BY Chaudry_Cricket on | September 9, 2013, 22:18 GMT

    If anyone deserves a drop then it is 'NOTHING WRONG WITH MY TECHNIQUE' Hafeez, he failed to score and he did not contribute with the ball, he is a ordinary fielder drops dollies in slips at times. But Misbah and Whatmore have deemed him as the SAVIOUR of Pakistan cricket. I just fail to understand why he is undroppable. We have players who perform the same roles as him and are better than him (Sohaib Maqsood, Mohammad Nawaz etc) with consistant chances will be a better end product than Hafeez. But team managment believe Hafeez is the greatest player to grace the cricket world.

    Rahat deserves another go (see potential in him). We have to give him consistant chances for a while to see what he can do. I admit he was rubbish in the first test but he is young and with the right guidance and consistant chances he might prove to be a good bowler.

    My 11 would be: Shaan, Khurram, Azhar, Younis, Misbah, Asad, Adnan, Junaid, Rahat, Ajmal and Rehman.

  • POSTED BY abmughal on | September 9, 2013, 21:26 GMT

    y not PCB invite zim for short tour before WT20 in available window ?????

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 19:42 GMT

    The FTP's coming up short here, Zim deserve more games. I can understand the top echelon of Test nations see there's nothing in it for them, but is there no ICC funding to arrange tours against top associates? A few first class matches against Ireland, Scotland and the Netherlands would serve to help bring them on against decent sides

  • POSTED BY ammar7may on | September 9, 2013, 18:18 GMT

    South Africa and Australia gave citizenship to Pakistani spinners to get used to it. Zimbabwe have to do the same. They already have Sikander Raza. Haha...

  • POSTED BY sudeep_sarkar on | September 9, 2013, 18:03 GMT

    I personally think ICC should come in front and help Zim crisis.We are going to loose one good upcoming team very soon.What a a shame...Really feeling very sad and bad.Miss you Zim...All the best.. Sudeep Sarkar

  • POSTED BY Desihungama on | September 9, 2013, 17:58 GMT

    Wahab Riaz? Really? I thought this guy was done and dusted. Just what could he do to prove? I mean if PCB has an iota of far sightedness, would have gone with Ehsan Adil, Zia-ul-Haq. Any sane team would gradually ease their players into Test by playing them into shorter formats for longer period. (exactly how India and done and now reaping rewards) but not here. Rahat, Ehsan were all inserted into Test without being tested in shorter formats. Look at Rahat, he is no where close to a Test bowler. Is PCB charging these young lads to hand over a Test cap?

  • POSTED BY ZCFOutkast on | September 9, 2013, 17:43 GMT

    Only results count I'm afraid. Australia dominated Proteas with bat and ball for 13 out of 14 days and they lost the series. One would argue they dominated the Ashes with ball in hand, but like Zimbabwe their batting came up short.

    Both WI&Zim were rusty when we toured judging by the batting of Darren Bravo&Chanderpaul(who was not part of LOIs squads). Looking at the quality of the batting on display, I wouldn't say they were much better than Zim as a team. The difference was obviously Cremer's horible bowling, all the more reason why he should be nowhere near the team, and of course Shillingford bowled like a man possessed! WI should never have scored more than 250 at any point. Unfortunately Jarvis had a habit of fetching which severely negated his wickets, and the team felt it even more when he fetched but took few wickets.

    In all we've done as well as possible. We need to bat first&play for time to get a draw. Unfortunately Trevor "Misbah" Gripper's playing club cricket instead!

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 16:11 GMT

    logically hafeez should be rested ( if you dont want to call it a draw ). He has been poor this year and in whole match he never bowled a single over( may be not fit ). But problem for misbah will be that if he drops him, the talks of politics between these 2 will come back like in SA series.

    he has had a poor test year. if he is not bowling then there should be no place for him in playing 11.

    Openers & asad shafiq will have to lift their game now. Next series is a big one and this is last chance to prove themselves.

  • POSTED BY ZCFOutkast on | September 9, 2013, 15:14 GMT

    Only results count I'm afraid. Australia dominated Proteas with bat and ball for 13 out of 14 days and they lost the series. One would argue they dominated the Ashes with ball in hand, but like Zimbabwe their batting came up short.

    Both WI&Zim were rusty when we toured judging by the batting of Darren Bravo&Chanderpaul(who was not part of LOIs squads). Looking at the quality of the batting on display, I wouldn't say they were much better than Zim as a team. The difference was obviously Cremer's horible bowling, all the more reason why he should be nowhere near the team, and of course Shillingford bowled like a man possessed! WI should never have scored more than 250 at any point. Unfortunately Jarvis had a habit of fetching which severely negated his wickets, and the team felt it even more when he fetched but took few wickets.

    In all we've done as well as possible. We need to bat first&play for time to get a draw. Unfortunately Trevor "Misbah" Gripper's playing club cricket instead!

  • POSTED BY AdilKhans on | September 9, 2013, 14:56 GMT

    Pakistan openers should perform in this test before sa series specially mohd hafeez, his technique against quality fast bowling is pathetic. K. Manzoor should be given a long run, he is capable of scoring big. Pak's middle order is looking strong now with the likes of ali, misbah, younis & shafiq, ppl are critisizing shafiq needlessly he is a good player and is just an innings away from finding form. It's really surprising pakistan's pace department is lacking firepower except junaid khan no other bowler looks promising enough, look at rahat, he's so inconsistent he has pace but lack's control ppl are calling for wahab riaz, who's a worst fast bowler to and have been given many opportunities but to no avail. IMO pak should look for someone who is in the mould of mcgrath, asif. These bowlers used to have immaculate control over their line and length even though they were not as quick as other but used to get wickets for their captains and that is what you need in test cricket- wicket taking bowlers.

  • POSTED BY abmughal on | September 9, 2013, 14:31 GMT

    best of luck zim.....y not pakistan tries asad shafiq to open the innings for pakistan ....as he was doing in the past for domestic teams .....or azher ali can open the inning as he is professionaly a openner ....hafiz should not open the inning.... that top opening spot should be given to other ...i know if only he is out from longer format he would not be able to continue performing in shorter formats of the game....best of luck to hafeez ... no doubt he is big player ..only the opening place is not the best place for him to bat.

  • POSTED BY abmughal on | September 9, 2013, 14:31 GMT

    best of luck zim.....y not pakistan tries asad shafiq to open the innings for pakistan ....as he was doing in the past for domestic teams .....or azher ali can open the inning as he is professionaly a openner ....hafiz should not open the inning.... that top opening spot should be given to other ...i know if only he is out from longer format he would not be able to continue performing in shorter formats of the game....best of luck to hafeez ... no doubt he is big player ..only the opening place is not the best place for him to bat.

  • POSTED BY AdilKhans on | September 9, 2013, 14:56 GMT

    Pakistan openers should perform in this test before sa series specially mohd hafeez, his technique against quality fast bowling is pathetic. K. Manzoor should be given a long run, he is capable of scoring big. Pak's middle order is looking strong now with the likes of ali, misbah, younis & shafiq, ppl are critisizing shafiq needlessly he is a good player and is just an innings away from finding form. It's really surprising pakistan's pace department is lacking firepower except junaid khan no other bowler looks promising enough, look at rahat, he's so inconsistent he has pace but lack's control ppl are calling for wahab riaz, who's a worst fast bowler to and have been given many opportunities but to no avail. IMO pak should look for someone who is in the mould of mcgrath, asif. These bowlers used to have immaculate control over their line and length even though they were not as quick as other but used to get wickets for their captains and that is what you need in test cricket- wicket taking bowlers.

  • POSTED BY ZCFOutkast on | September 9, 2013, 15:14 GMT

    Only results count I'm afraid. Australia dominated Proteas with bat and ball for 13 out of 14 days and they lost the series. One would argue they dominated the Ashes with ball in hand, but like Zimbabwe their batting came up short.

    Both WI&Zim were rusty when we toured judging by the batting of Darren Bravo&Chanderpaul(who was not part of LOIs squads). Looking at the quality of the batting on display, I wouldn't say they were much better than Zim as a team. The difference was obviously Cremer's horible bowling, all the more reason why he should be nowhere near the team, and of course Shillingford bowled like a man possessed! WI should never have scored more than 250 at any point. Unfortunately Jarvis had a habit of fetching which severely negated his wickets, and the team felt it even more when he fetched but took few wickets.

    In all we've done as well as possible. We need to bat first&play for time to get a draw. Unfortunately Trevor "Misbah" Gripper's playing club cricket instead!

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 16:11 GMT

    logically hafeez should be rested ( if you dont want to call it a draw ). He has been poor this year and in whole match he never bowled a single over( may be not fit ). But problem for misbah will be that if he drops him, the talks of politics between these 2 will come back like in SA series.

    he has had a poor test year. if he is not bowling then there should be no place for him in playing 11.

    Openers & asad shafiq will have to lift their game now. Next series is a big one and this is last chance to prove themselves.

  • POSTED BY ZCFOutkast on | September 9, 2013, 17:43 GMT

    Only results count I'm afraid. Australia dominated Proteas with bat and ball for 13 out of 14 days and they lost the series. One would argue they dominated the Ashes with ball in hand, but like Zimbabwe their batting came up short.

    Both WI&Zim were rusty when we toured judging by the batting of Darren Bravo&Chanderpaul(who was not part of LOIs squads). Looking at the quality of the batting on display, I wouldn't say they were much better than Zim as a team. The difference was obviously Cremer's horible bowling, all the more reason why he should be nowhere near the team, and of course Shillingford bowled like a man possessed! WI should never have scored more than 250 at any point. Unfortunately Jarvis had a habit of fetching which severely negated his wickets, and the team felt it even more when he fetched but took few wickets.

    In all we've done as well as possible. We need to bat first&play for time to get a draw. Unfortunately Trevor "Misbah" Gripper's playing club cricket instead!

  • POSTED BY Desihungama on | September 9, 2013, 17:58 GMT

    Wahab Riaz? Really? I thought this guy was done and dusted. Just what could he do to prove? I mean if PCB has an iota of far sightedness, would have gone with Ehsan Adil, Zia-ul-Haq. Any sane team would gradually ease their players into Test by playing them into shorter formats for longer period. (exactly how India and done and now reaping rewards) but not here. Rahat, Ehsan were all inserted into Test without being tested in shorter formats. Look at Rahat, he is no where close to a Test bowler. Is PCB charging these young lads to hand over a Test cap?

  • POSTED BY sudeep_sarkar on | September 9, 2013, 18:03 GMT

    I personally think ICC should come in front and help Zim crisis.We are going to loose one good upcoming team very soon.What a a shame...Really feeling very sad and bad.Miss you Zim...All the best.. Sudeep Sarkar

  • POSTED BY ammar7may on | September 9, 2013, 18:18 GMT

    South Africa and Australia gave citizenship to Pakistani spinners to get used to it. Zimbabwe have to do the same. They already have Sikander Raza. Haha...

  • POSTED BY on | September 9, 2013, 19:42 GMT

    The FTP's coming up short here, Zim deserve more games. I can understand the top echelon of Test nations see there's nothing in it for them, but is there no ICC funding to arrange tours against top associates? A few first class matches against Ireland, Scotland and the Netherlands would serve to help bring them on against decent sides

  • POSTED BY abmughal on | September 9, 2013, 21:26 GMT

    y not PCB invite zim for short tour before WT20 in available window ?????