To say that there is disappointment in Pakistan at
losing the Karachi Test match and with it the
series would be to convey the most polite of
sentiments. Only the Pakistan cricket team has the
genius to contrive a defeat from a seemingly
impregnable position. They won the toss and made
405.
Thanks to some very indifferent bowling and even
worse fielding, they allowed England to get within
17 runs of their first innings total. But they did
get a lead. The batting collapsed in the second
innings but England still needed to make 176 runs
in 44 overs at an asking-rate of 4 per over and
England got the runs.
From the start of the England innings, Pakistan
went on the defensive and blocked the boundaries.
Since the asking-rate was only 4 per over, England
decided to get the runs in singles, thus exposing
not only poor tactics but a poor knowledge of
arithmetic on the part of Pakistan. It's mindboggling.
In the end Pakistan was counting on the light
fading and did their share of time wasting,
earning a warning from Steve Bucknor. Here too
Pakistan did not realise that the light is offered
to the batsmen and when it was offered, they
decided, not surprisingly, to play on.
The sooner we forget this Test match and indeed
the Test series, the better. Unless we choose to
hear it as a wake-up call. Pakistan has lost four
consecutive home Test series. Clearly home
advantage does not suit us. One reason for this
could well be that we are ourselves not familiar
with home conditions. We set out to con the
England team that they would be playing on
spinning tracks.
In the process we conned ourselves as well. We
prepared what we thought were spinning tracks,
packed the team with spinners. We played with only
two seamers and the wickets were so dead, no pace,
no bounce, that we neutralised these two seamers
but gave no advantage to our spinners. We also
assumed that we had quality spinners and England
did not have any.
Historically, it has been Pakistan's fast bowlers
who have won Test matches for us, starting with
Fazal Mahmood, Khan Mohammad, Mahmood Hussain,
down to Imran Khan, Sarfaraz Nawaz and finally
Wasim Akram and Waqar Younis.
Pakistan has had only one quality spinner in its
cricket history. And that has been Abdul Qadir. It
is true that Tauseef Ahmed and Iqbal Qasim won us
the Bangalore Test match but that was on a mud
track that had been fiendishly under-prepared and
India fell in its own trap.
If England was vulnerable against spin, it was the
spin of Shane Warne. As it transpired it was
Ashley Giles who helped himself to some 16 wickets
in the series and played a crucial role in
England's win. Pakistani batsmen too seem
vulnerable against spin!
Eleven individuals, no matter how brilliant, do
not make a team. There has to be some element that
binds them, be it national or professional pride.
England got the better of the Test matches, apart,
of course from winning the last, because they
proved to be a better team though man for man we
might have been better. They came to Pakistan as
underdogs and were happy for it. It provided
greater motivation, it kept the players together
and as happens, they developed self-belief. Nor
for a moment was there an indication that there
may be problems in the team, any sort of friction
between the players and management. Whatever
differences they had, they left behind in their
hotel rooms.
The next two series, against New Zealand in New
Zealand and England in England will be very tough
ones. Pakistan needs to do its homework. They will
be playing on wickets where the ball will seam and
swing in the air. It will be cold and wet. Even on
the flat and docile wickets on which the series
against England was played, only two batsmen
performed consistently, Inzamam-ul-Haq and Yousuf
Youhana. We saw a splendid century from Abdur
Razzaq and Salim Elahi showed doggedness.
But, in totality, it looks like a brittle batting
side and we saw that in Pakistan's second innings
at Karachi. There was some atrocious shot
selection. I think Pakistan's think-tank needs to
put its thinking cap on. There should be a coldblooded review of England's tour of Pakistan and
pin-point the mistakes that were made. It may be a
cliche but it happens to be true that the road to
the temple of wisdom is how we can only learn from
our mistakes. I think too that we need a greater
element of trust between the constituent parts
that make up the team, The Management, the
selectors, the players.
I get the impression that they are often at odds
with each other and working at cross-purposes. As
I said, it is only an impression but the cricket
public too shares this impression, many have
mentioned it to me. The lost series could be a
blessing in disguise, if it helps to convert
highly gifted individuals into a team.
I agree that winning and losing is part of the
game but ask anyone, winning is better.